Mark Kermode reviews Dune: Part Two - Kermode and Mayo's Take

Film Reviews | Kermode and Mayo's Take

29 Feb 202411:11

Summary

TLDRThe script discusses the Dune film franchise, praising Denis Villeneuve's ability to adapt the complex source material into a clear and compelling story in Dune: Part One. It analyzes themes of religion, prophecy, and the consequences of messianic figures like Paul Atreides. Visually spectacular with memorable scenes, it sets up the tragic arc to come in Dune: Part Two. While most performances are strong, a quibble is made about Christopher Walken seeming out of place. Overall an impressive adaptation, it captures the essence of Dune while engaging all the senses.

Takeaways

😊 Deni Vov's Dune part 1 had great clarity in storytelling which continues in part 2 despite increased complexity
👍 Seeing Dune part 1 is essential before watching part 2
🌟 Visual splendor in Dune part 2 never obscures the importance of the story
🔥 The worm riding sequences are breathtaking
🤔 The story explores complex themes like the messaging of religion being poisoned by dogma
😮‍💨 Timothy Chalamat's Paul Atreides has a reluctant messiah element like in Monty Python's Life of Brian
🎼 The music apparently uses electric guitars to mimic bagpipes
🤩 Zendaya and Austin Butler give strong lead performances
😕 Christopher Walken feels out of place, playing himself rather than the character
👍🏻 Overall an impressive, transportive cinematic experience

Q & A

What are the key themes explored in the Dune series?
-The Dune series explores complex philosophical themes like prophecy, religion, politics, ecology, and the consequences of messianic figures and religious movements.
How does the visual spectacle in the Dune films serve the storytelling?
-The visual effects create an immersive otherworldly experience but never obscure the storytelling, which remains clear and character-driven.
What techniques did cinematographer Greig Fraser use to achieve the visual look of Dune?
-He shot digitally on IMAX-approved cameras, then transferred to 35mm film and back again, blending modern crispness with nostalgic film texture.
How does Zendaya's performance contribute to the success of the new Dune film?
-As Chani, Zendaya anchors the emotional drama and carries the weight of this complex story impressively.
Why does the Christopher Walken casting feel jarring?
-Walken seems to just be playing his familiar persona rather than inhabiting the character fully within the world of Dune.
What story is set up for the planned Dune sequel?
-The sequel will explore the tragic, messianic arc of Paul Atreides as his movement turns toxic and war breaks out over the interpretations of his teachings.
How does the documentary Jodorowsky's Dune relate to the newer films?
-It shows the endless difficulties in adapting Dune, making Denis Villeneuve's coherent vision even more impressive.
What key events lead to the darker plot turn in the second half of Dune?
-After becoming the leader of the Fremen people, Paul loses his father, sets off a violent rebellion, and fulfills a dangerous prophecy.
How important is it to see the first Dune film before the sequel?
-Seeing the first film is essential, as the sequel will pick up threads without recap or explanation for new viewers.
What format does the speaker recommend for the optimal viewing experience of Dune?
-The speaker insists that to fully appreciate the scale and visuals, Dune should be watched in the biggest, most immersive format possible.