Surface Laptop 7 vs MacBook Air M3 - The ULTIMATE Battle
Summary
TLDRこのビデオでは、マイクロソフトの新しいSurface Laptop 7とAppleのMacBook Airの比較が行われています。両者はビルド品質、ポータビリティ、ディスプレイ、キーボード、トラックパッド、パフォーマンス、ファンノイズ、バッテリー寿命、スピーカー、接続性、外部ディスプレイサポート、Wi-Fi接続、安定性、価格、アップグレーダビリティを評価されました。最終的に、Surface Laptopは83ポイント、MacBook Airは80ポイントを獲得し、Surfaceが勝利しましたが、広告によるポイントの差し引き後、実際のニーズに応じてどちらを選ぶべきかはユーザー次第です。
Takeaways
- 💻 マイクロソフトの新しいSurface Laptop 7とAppleのMacBook Airが対決しました。
- 🏆 両チームはビルドクオリティと携帯性を比較し、Surface Laptopはよりスタイルがあり、MacBook Airはより持ちやすかったです。
- 🖥️ ディスプレイの比較では、Surface Laptopは120Hzの高速リフレッシュレートとタッチスクリーンを備えていますが、OLEDパネルは搭載されていません。
- ⌨️ キーボードの比較では、Surface Laptopのキーボードの方がより満足度が高いと感じられましたが、どちらもバックライト付きでした。
- 🖱️ トラックパッドの比較では、Surface Laptop 7はWindowsノートパソコンの中ではMacBookと同等の優れたハプティックトラックパッドを備えています。
- 🚀 パフォーマンス比較では、Surface Laptopはマルチコア性能でMacBook Airを上回りましたが、単コア性能では逆でした。
- 🔋 バッテリー寿命では、MacBook Airはより省エネルギーで冷却性能も優れており、Surface Laptopに比べてファンノイズも少なく、長持ちします。
- 🎮 グラフィック性能では、MacBook AirのM3の統合グラフィックがSurface LaptopのSnapdragon X Eliteチップを上回ります。
- 🔊 スピーカーの比較では、Surface Laptopの方が少し音が平たんでボリュームも大きいですが、個人の好みによります。
- 🔌 接続性では、Surface Laptopはより多くのポートを備えており、Wi-Fi 7もサポートしていますが、MacBook AirはWi-Fi 6Eのみです。
- 💰 価値比較では、Surface Laptopは価格とアップグレーダビリティの点でMacBook Airより優れており、MacBook Airは購入後はアップグレードできません。
- 🛠️ ステーブル性の比較では、MacBook Airは完璧でしたが、Surface Laptopは新しいARMアーキテクチャのためにいくつかの不安定さが見られました。
Q & A
マイクロソフトの新しいSurface Laptop 7とAppleのMacBook Airを比較する基準は何ですか?
-比較の基準は、ビルド品質と携帯性、ディスプレイ、キーボード、トラックパッド、パフォーマンス、ファンの騒音と熱、バッテリー寿命、スピーカー品質、接続性、外部ディスプレイサポート、Wi-Fi接続性、安定性、価格とアップグレーダビリティです。
Surface Laptop 7のスタイルとカラーについてどう思いますか?
-Surface Laptop 7は、特に青色のモデルでは、非常に新鮮でスタイルが良く、指紋をほとんど残さないという点で評価されています。
MacBook Airのディスプレイはどのような特徴がありますか?
-MacBook Airのディスプレイは、高解像度で224ピクセル/インチ、最大500ニートの明るさ、フルP3カラーギャムをカバーしていますが、タッチ画面やOLEDパネルは備えていません。
Surface Laptop 7のディスプレイはどのように評価されていますか?
-Surface Laptop 7のディスプレイは、200ピクセル/インチの解像度、最大600ニートの明るさ、120Hzの高速リフレッシュレート、タッチ画面を備えていますが、OLEDパネルは使用していません。
MacBook Airのキーボードはどのような評価を受けていますか?
-MacBook Airのキーボードは、タイプがあまり快適ではなく、キーストロークが少し短いと評価されています。
Surface Laptop 7のキーボードはどのような特徴がありますか?
-Surface Laptop 7のキーボードは、より満足いくつかの感触があり、キーボードのレイアウトはほぼ標準的ですが、右CtrlキーをCo-Pilotキーに置き換えています。
トラックパッドのパフォーマンスについて、どちらのラップトップが良いですか?
-両方のラップトップのトラックパッドは素晴らしいパフォーマンスを持ち、特にSurface Laptop 7はWindowsラップトップの中では初めてMacBookと競うことができると評価されています。
パフォーマンスにおいて、Surface Laptop 7とMacBook Airの主な違いは何ですか?
-Surface Laptop 7はマルチコアパフォーマンスでMacBook Airを上回りますが、単コアパフォーマンスではMacBook Airの方が若干スナップピアな印象を与えます。
Surface Laptop 7のファン騒音と熱の問題についてどう思いますか?
-Surface Laptop 7はパフォーマンスタスクでファン騒音が聞こえ、非常に温かく感じます。MacBook Airはファンがなく、静かです。
バッテリー寿命において、どちらのラップトップが良いですか?
-MacBook Airはパフォーマンスタスクにおいてはより信頼性があり、Surface Laptop 7は高負荷時のバッテリー寿命が短いと評価されています。
スピーカーの品質について、どちらのラップトップが良いですか?
-両方のラップトップのスピーカーは良好で、比較的フラットな音と少しだけ大きい音量を持っていますが、特に強い好みは見られません。
Wi-Fi接続性において、どちらのラップトップが良いですか?
-Surface Laptop 7はWi-Fi 7をサポートしており、MacBook AirのWi-Fi 6Eよりも優れていると評価されています。
安定性において、どちらのラップトップが良いですか?
-MacBook Airは安定しており、Surface Laptop 7は新しいARMアーキテクチャを使用しており、いくつかの不安定さが見られます。
価格とアップグレーダビリティにおいて、どちらのラップトップが良いですか?
-Surface Laptop 7は価格とアップグレーダビリティにおいて優れており、MacBook Airは購入後にはアップグレードできません。
全体的な評価では、どちらのラップトップが良いですか?
-全体的な評価ではSurface Laptop 7が83点、MacBook Airは80点を獲得しましたが、Surface Laptop 7は広告による評価の低下を考慮に入れて1ポイント差し引いて、実際にはほぼ同等と言えます。
最終的な推奨はどのようなラップトップですか?
-アプリケーションがネイティブで動作するか、軽いタスクに使われる場合、Surface Laptop 7を推奨します。一方で、多くのプロフェッショナルアプリケーションを使用し、熱やファンの騒音を少なくする必要がある場合は、MacBook Airが良いでしょう。
Outlines
💻 ラップトップ比較のエントリー
ビデオスクリプトでは、マイクロソフトのSurface Laptop 7とAppleのMacBook Airの比較が行われています。それぞれのモデルのスペックや外観、持ち運びやすさ、ディスプレイ、キーボード、トラックパッド、パフォーマンス、ファンの騒音、熱状況、バッテリー寿命、スピーカー、接続性、外部ディスプレイのサポート、Wi-Fi接続、安定性、価格、アップグレーダビリティなどを評価し、最終的な勝者を決定します。
🔍 パフォーマンスと熱状況の詳細比較
Surface Laptop 7とMacBook Airのパフォーマンス、ファンの騒音、熱状況を比較しています。Surface Laptopはより多くのCPUコアを備えており、より高速なグラフィックを提供していますが、パフォーマンスタスクでは熱くなり、ファンの騒音も大きくなる傾向があります。一方、MacBook Airはパフォーマンスタスクでも冷静に保ち、ファンの騒音も小さいと評価されています。また、Surface LaptopはWi-Fi 7をサポートしているのに対し、MacBook AirはWi-Fi 6Eをサポートしています。
🏆 総評と推奨
最終的にSurface Laptop 7は83点、MacBook Airは80点を獲得し、Surface Laptopが勝利しましたが、その差は小さいと評価されています。ビデオでは、Surface Laptopの価格やアップグレーダビリティの利点に触れていますが、ソフトウェアの互換性や安定性の問題も指摘されています。視聴者は自分のニーズに応じてどちらのモデルを選ぶかを決定するよう促されています。また、Surface Laptopの13インチX Eliteモデルの価値についても議論されており、X+モデルの方がバッテリー寿命が長く、価格も安価であることが示されています。
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Surface Laptop 7s
💡MacBook Air
💡ビルドクオリティ
💡ポータビリティ
💡ディスプレイ
💡キーボード
💡トラックパッド
💡パフォーマンス
💡ファンノイズ
💡バッテリー寿命
💡スピーカー
💡接続性
💡Wi-Fi接続性
💡安定性
💡アップグレーダビリティ
💡価格
Highlights
The Surface Laptop 7 and MacBook Air are compared in terms of build quality, portability, and other features.
Both laptops have high build quality, but the Surface Laptop's chassis is slightly more rigid.
The Surface Laptop 7 has some build issues, such as not sitting flush on the desk for one model.
The Surface Laptop 7 is praised for its stylish design, especially in the blue color.
MacBook Airs have improved coating to resist fingerprints, especially the darker color models.
Surface Laptop 7 displays support higher refresh rates (120Hz) and touchscreens, but lack OLED panels.
MacBook Airs have higher resolution displays (224 PPI) but are limited to 60Hz refresh rates and are not touchscreens.
Surface Laptop 7's keyboards are more satisfying to type on compared to MacBook Airs, but have a non-standard layout.
Trackpads on both laptops are excellent, with Surface Laptop 7 using a haptic trackpad that competes with MacBook Air's trackpad.
Surface Laptop 7's X Elite processor outperforms MacBook Air's M3 in multi-core performance but not in single-core tasks.
MacBook Airs are significantly more power-efficient and have better battery life, especially during high-performance tasks.
Surface Laptop 7 has some stability issues with crashes and software compatibility, while MacBook Airs are more reliable.
Surface Laptop 7 supports Wi-Fi 7 and has better port placement and external display support compared to MacBook Air.
Surface Laptop 7 offers better value with lower prices and upgradeable storage compared to MacBook Airs.
Overall, the Surface Laptop 7 scores higher (82 points) compared to MacBook Air (80 points) but has issues with stability and advertising.
Transcripts
today we have an epic battle for you
Microsoft's new Surface laptop 7s versus
Apple's MacBook airs representing team
Microsoft we have the service laptop
13-in with the X+ chip and one with the
X Elite chip and we also have the 15in
with the X Elite chip too representing
team Apple we have the 13in and 15-in
air with M3 we're going to score each
part of the laptop separately and then
at the end We'll add up the scores and
declare an ultimate winner let's start
with their build quality and portability
both the MacBook airs and the surface
laptops feel very premium the surface is
chassis is slightly more rigid than the
airs but when you look closely the
surface isn't quite as well built our
surface laptop 713 with the xelite
processor does not sit flush on the desk
if you tap on the bottom right corner
you can clearly hear that there is a
gap this didn't happen by the way on our
other two models despite this the
surface laptop it looks more stylish
especially in the blue color that color
it just looks so refreshing the MACC
Air's darker color does have an improved
coating with the M3 version so they no
longer pick up fingerprints quite as
horribly as before we don't have the
darker colored surface but I can tell
you this about the blue one it does not
pick up fingerprints at all finally all
their screens can be opened with one
hand when it comes to portability the
MacBook airs have a slight lead they're
about a banana lighter overall in this
category the surface wins in looks and
the airwis in portability so we're going
to give both of these laptops a score of
9 out of 10 let's talk about their
displays the air comes with either a
13.6 or 15.3 in panel both have high
resolutions hitting 224 pixels per in we
measured over 500 nits of brightness
making the airs suitable for brighter
environments like using them next to a
window they also cover the full P3 color
gamut the main downsides though are that
they only refresh at 60 HZ they aren't
touch screens and they don't deliver the
increased contrast that an OLED display
would the surfaces laptops displays
measure 13.8 or 15 in they have a
slightly lower pixel density of 200
pixels per in when it comes to
brightness we measured around 600 nits
the surface also gives you a fast
refresh rate at 120 HZ this will make
content moving on screen look smooth
they also support a variable refresh
rate down to 24 Hertz which will help
with battery life plus the surfaces have
touch screens the only thing that is
really missing is that they aren't using
OLED panels with that said we're
awarding a 9 to the surface laptops and
a seven to the airs when it comes to the
keyboards all these laptops have good
high quality ones that are backlit the
MacBook a isn't the most comfortable to
type on though as it feels a bit low
travel the surfaces keyboard does feel
more satisfying but it's still not in
the upper echelons of comfortable
keyboards when it comes to layout the
airs have a standard layout which means
that you won't mispress Keys the
surfaces is almost standard Microsoft
has introduced a co-pilot key to replace
the right control key with that said the
surface laptops get a score of 7 out of
10 and the a get a score of six the
trackpads are both fantastic MacBooks
have always always had the best
trackpads in the industry the surface
laptop 7 though is the first Windows
laptop that I feel can compete it uses
an excellent haptic trackpad that does
not have the Palm rejection issues of
the other haptic ones that we've tried
in Windows laptops both the surface and
airs are therefore getting full marks of
10 out of 10 all right let's now talk
performance the surface laptop 13 can be
configured with either an X+ or X Elite
processor the 15 is only available with
the X Elite compared to the plus the X
Elite has two extra CPU cores and can
run its course around 10% faster it also
has slightly better integrated graphics
on the MacBook Air side there are also
two processor options available but in
this case the only difference is that
the cheaper model has two less GPU cores
the cpu's performance itself it should
be identical in geekbench which tests a
variety of common performance tasks the
surface laptops beat the airs that is in
overall multi-core performance in
cinebench which test the laptops running
at Max performance it's the same thing
the surface laptops are fast
substantially so however since the
MacBook airs are faster in single core
performance some applications and tasks
will still feel snappier on the Mac now
one interesting observation is that
these processors do perform better in
the larger versions of these laptops
likely due to their better calling when
it comes to the MacBook Air the
difference is minimal and can only be
seen when we ran cine bench on a loop
for 10 minutes the a5's performance drop
is less than the 13s however this
difference is far more significant with
the surface the same ex Elite processor
in the 15-in surface significantly
outperforms the one in the 13 Even in a
single run of cinebench when we look at
Power draw between the airs and the
surfaces the difference is massive in
favor of the airs under Max load the
surface 13 draws an average of 34 WS the
MacBook Air on the other hand draws only
eight for the 13-in model the MacBook
Air is just much more power efficient
than the surface and this plays a big
role in how much better the air is in
terms of Heat fan noise and battery life
so let's get into those topics the air
is dead silent in performance tasks as
it does not need a fan to call its
processor the fan noise of the surface
laptop was better than other Intel
laptops but of course not as good as the
air in light tasks it was dead silent
but in performance tasks you could hear
it going in a quiet room when it comes
to the heat you feel in light tasks
neither laptop got warm but when their
performance is maxed out both measured
around the same in terms of warmth
however I want to say something
important when actually using these
laptops any performance tasks on any of
the surface models made them feel very
warm for example joining a zoom call the
airs on the other hand remain cool for
those same tasks now when it comes to
integrated graphics performance it is a
bit of the opposite of what we just saw
with General CPU performance the
integrated Graphics of the M3s in the
MacBook airs are simply more powerful
this is just going to make them better
for tasks like video editing or gaming
simple games and video projects only
though none of these laptops are
powerful enough for more when it comes
to AI task though the mpu of the
Snapdragon X processor destroys Apple's
M3s look you may not use AI tasks all
that much right now but these are the
results we're going to give a score of 8
out of 10 for performance to the
surfaces and a score of six to the airs
however for Heen fan noise we're going
to give a win to the air with a score of
nine and a score of seven to the surface
when on battery the surface's laptop's
performance was around the same as when
they were plugged in that being said we
did see some variance this is likely due
to how sensitive these laptops are to
heat in terms of their overall
performance as I said before they do get
very warm the airs on the other hand
were far more reliable now when
unplugged doing high performance tasks
the surface laptops don't last that long
on battery this is because these
Qualcomm Snapdragon processors are not
that power efficient when run at higher
wattage I've talked about this
extensively in another video which I
will link below as you can see when
running high performance tasks these
service laptops last around the same as
competing Intel laptops and they are way
behind the MacBook airs when doing light
tasks though like streaming a movie over
Wi-Fi the surfice laptops do perform
well but still not quite as good as the
airs with all this in mind we're going
to give a score of nine for battery life
to the airs and seven to the surface to
test speakers Ethan Sierra and I listen
to several tracks on each of these
laptops the surfaces have a flatter
sound and are ever so slightly louder I
prefer them more the airs sound more
Dynamic and Sierra and Ethan prefer them
more
[Music]
that being said none of us had a strong
preference and compared to the MacBook
Pro 14 which has the best speakers of
any 14-in laptop these are both nowhere
near as good so overall a six for the
surfaces and a six for the airs when it
comes to connectivity all these laptops
have two fast USB 4 ports a headphone
mic combo Jack and a separate
proprietory charging port but the
surface also has a traditional USB a
port and the 15in has a micro Wy card
slot the port placement on the surface
laptops is also better too as they can
all be charged from either side of the
laptop this means that your charging
cable won't get in your way if your
outlet is on the right side of the
laptop now let's talk about the external
display support that these laptops can
drive on the surface laptop 7 we were
able to get three external monitors
going as well as the laptop's internal
display on the air on the other hand you
can only get two and that is with the
laptop's display turned off but it's not
quite that simple you see we found the
surface could drive all three at only 4K
30 HZ or at 1440 60 HZ or if we went
down to just two monitors we could get
one at 4K 60 and one at 14460 plus the
internal display the air on the other
hand can drive both external monitors at
very high resolution at 60 HZ when it
comes to Wi-Fi connectivity the surface
supports Wi-Fi 7 whereas the air only
supports Wi-Fi 6E with the clear wind
and connectivity going to the surface
we're going to give it a score of eight
whereas the air we're going to give a
score of four let's talk about stability
the MacBook Air was perfect the surface
laptop 7 was not it uses a new arm
architecture and because of this we
notice several instabilities for example
during a web conference call Via slack
our surface laptop completely crashed
and Switched Off and while writing the
script for this very video the surface
laptop 15's keyboard it completely
stopped working plus both our surface
laptop 13s occasionally just wouldn't
charge when they were plugged into the
wall software compatibility General was
hit or miss take League of Legends a
game I personally play it didn't work at
all I know this sounds odd but right now
you're going to have an easier time
finding working software on a Mac than
one of these new windows arm laptops
that other video of ours that I did
mention earlier also goes through
application compatibility and since it
is likely to improve over time we do
have an article on our website which we
will keep up to date so right now we do
have to give the surface a 5 out of 10
for stability and the air a 10 finally
let's talk about the over value
including pricing and upgradeability for
a configuration with 16 gig of memory
and 512 gig of storage which I would
recommend for most people here are the
prices the surface laptop 13 with the X+
processor cost $1,200 and the xelite
1,400 the surface laptop 15 is 1,500 the
MacBook airs are more expensive the
13-in model cost 1,500 and the 15in
1,700 value is a big win for the surface
and add to that that the MacBook a is
completely non- upgradable after you
purchase it the surface laptop storage
can be upgraded so we're only going to
give the air a score of four for value
and the surface laptop a score of seven
finally drum roll please let's add up
the scores to declare a winner the
surface laptops have come out on top
with a total score of 83 points the airs
surprisingly are not too far behind with
a score of 80 but we're going to deduct
a point from the surfaces because of
Microsoft's constant advertisements it
is a Grace that for a device that cost
well north of $1,000 that you're paying
for they feel that they have the right
to advertise to you on with that said
congratulations to Microsoft and
Qualcomm for taking this win the surface
it is a great device but as you've seen
it is not a clear Victory it really
depends on what's important to you as to
which you should buy overall my
recommendation is to buy the surface if
you know that your applications will run
natively or you're sticking to light
tasks Microsoft Office email web
browsing that sort of thing those
applications work really well that being
said in my specific use case I would
actually get the air you see I use a
variety of professional applications and
I want to know for sure that they work
also I value as little heat and fan
noise as possible and the air gives me
that and I'm not that sensitive to price
but I stick by the results of this video
there are many people who will prefer
the surface more final note as you
probably saw in our graphs there isn't
much point in buying the surface laptop
top 13 with the X Elite processor it
doesn't deliver the full performance of
The X Elite its battery life is worse
than the plus variant and it cost $200
more so stick to the X+ if you're buying
the 13in I'm going to cover this in a
full video which you won't want to miss
so make sure you're subscribed with the
notification Bell on for that well
that's all we got for you our website is
the place to go for all the laptops that
we recommend for various types of users
and where to go to get the best deals on
them till next time go to something
awesome with your day and I will catch
you later
Voir Plus de Vidéos Connexes
Snapdragon X Elite vs M3 Pro MBP - How is THIS Possible?!
Did Snapdragon X Elite Just END Intel's Career? (TESTED)
Sonos Ace HONEST Review and Comparison to AirPods Max!
Longest lasting laptop and MOAR TESTS! | Surface Laptop
【 WR-V vs ヤリスクロス 】最強ライバル対決! そもそも裏テーマは「ヴェゼルから奪われた客を取り戻せ」だった
これが結論。AirPods Pro 2とBose QuietComfort Earbuds IIを比較した結果
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)