Snapdragon X Elite vs M3 Pro MBP - How is THIS Possible?!

Max Tech
25 Jun 202426:54

Summary

TLDRこのビデオスクリプトでは、Surface Laptop 7とMacBook Proの比較が行われています。両者のスペック、デザイン、キーボード、トラックパッド、スピーカー、ウェブカメラ、タッチID、ディスプレイ、バッテリー寿命、そして特にパフォーマンスをテストしました。X EliteとM3 ProのCPU、GPU、SSD、ベンチマーク、実際の使用状況でのパフォーマンスを比較し、MacBook Proが創造的タスクやグラフィックタスクにおいて優れていることが明らかになりました。しかし、Surface Laptop 7も優れたバッテリー寿命と価値を提供しており、日常的なオフィスタスクには適しています。

Takeaways

  • 💻 スクリプトでは、Surface Laptop 7とMacBook Proの比較が行われ、両者のパフォーマンスと機能が評価されています。
  • 🔌 Surface Laptop 7は、磁性のSurfaceコネクタで充電が可能で、MacBook ProはUSB-Cを使用しています。
  • 💰 MacBook Proは価格が高価ですが、Surface Laptop 7はAmazonで低い価格で入手可能です。
  • 📐 両者のサイズと設計は非常に似ており、Surface Laptop 7の方がわずかに軽いとされています。
  • 🔌 MacBook ProはThunderboltポートを備えるのに対して、Surface Laptop 7はUSB 4を備えています。
  • ⌨️ 両者ともにキーボードとトラックパッドの質は高く、特にSurface Laptop 7のトラックパッドはWindowsラップトップの中では最高評価されています。
  • 🔊 MacBook ProのスピーカーシステムはSurface Laptop 7を上回るが、後者のスピーカーも優れているとされています。
  • 🖥️ MacBook ProはTouch IDを備えているのに対し、Surface Laptop 7はWindows Helloを使用しています。
  • 🖼️ 両者のディスプレイは鮮明で鮮明ですが、MacBook ProのディスプレイはHDRコンテンツでのハイライトとコントラストが優れています。
  • 🔋 バッテリー寿命の比較では、MacBook ProがSurface Laptop 7よりも優れていることがわかります。
  • 🚀 パフォーマンステストでは、MacBook ProのM3 ProチップがSurface Laptop 7のX Eliteを上回る傾向にありますが、特定のテストでは非常に近いスコアを得ています。
  • 🎨 クリエイティブタスクやグラフィックパフォーマンスでは、MacBook Proが大幅に優れていることが示されています。
  • 🔧 特定のアプリケーションでは、MacBook Proの最適化されていないアプリでもパフォーマンスが高く、Surface Laptop 7では遅くなることが確認されています。

Q & A

  • Surface Laptop 7とMacBook Proの比較において、どちらのスピーカーが優れていると比較されましたか?

    -Surface Laptop 7のスピーカーは13インチのMacBookに比べて優れていると比較されましたが、14インチのMacBook Proに比べると明らかに劣ります。

  • Surface Laptop 7の充電方法にはどのような特徴がありますか?

    -Surface Laptop 7にはマグネット式のサーフェスコネクタがあり、MacSafeと同様に便利で安全です。また、USB-Cでも充電が可能です。

  • MacBook ProとSurface Laptop 7の価格差はどれくらいですか?

    -MacBook Proは約2000ドルですが、Surface Laptop 7はAmazonで現在16.99ドルで購入できます。

  • Surface Laptop 7とMacBook Proのキーボードとトラックパッドの質はどのように評価されていますか?

    -両者ともに非常に良いキーボードとトラックパッドを持っており、特にSurface Laptop 7のトラックパッドはWindowsラップトップの中では最高のものです。

  • Surface Laptop 7とMacBook Proのウェブカメラの比較では、どちらが優れていると述べられていますか?

    -Surface Laptop 7のウェブカメラはより広角で、画面の上にマイクロフォンが2つあることが特徴です。MacBook Proのウェブカメラは1080pで、スタジオ品質のマイクロフォンが搭載されています。

  • MacBook Proのディスプレイ技術について、Surface Laptop 7と比較してどのような利点がありますか?

    -MacBook ProはProMotion技術とmini-LEDディスプレイを備えており、HDRコンテンツの再生やコントラストの表現において優れています。

  • Surface Laptop 7のバッテリー寿命はどの程度ですか?

    -比較テストの途中でSurface Laptop 7のバッテリーは89%に低下していますが、具体的なバッテリー寿命はスクリプトに記載されていません。

  • MacBook ProのSSDのパフォーマンスはSurface Laptop 7と比較してどうですか?

    -MacBook ProのSSDはSurface Laptop 7と比較して64%高速で、84%のパフォーマンス差があると評価されています。

  • Surface Laptop 7のX EliteプロセッサはMacBook ProのM3 Proと比較してどの程度のパフォーマンスを示しましたか?

    -Geekbench 6のテストでは、Surface Laptop 7のX EliteはM3 Proに非常に近いスコアを獲得しましたが、シングルコアではMacの方が約200ポイント高いと評価されています。

  • Surface Laptop 7のタッチスクリーンはどのような利点がありますか?

    -Surface Laptop 7のタッチスクリーンはタッチのみでの操作を好むユーザーにとって利点で、MacBook Proにはこの機能は搭載されていません。

  • MacBook ProのグラフィックパフォーマンスはSurface Laptop 7と比較してどうですか?

    -3D Markのテストでは、MacBook ProのグラフィックパフォーマンスがSurface Laptop 7の2.6倍以上と評価されています。

  • MacBook ProとSurface Laptop 7のバッテリー効率と実際の使用時間の違いは何ですか?

    -MacBook Proはより効率的で、実際の使用時間もSurface Laptop 7よりも長く、特に高負荷の状況下ではMacBookのバッテリー寿命が優れていると評価されています。

Outlines

00:00

💻 サーフェースラップトップ7とMacBook Proの比較

ビデオスクリプトでは、Surface Laptop 7とMacBook Proの比較が行われています。両者のスペック、デザイン、価格、およびパフォーマンスが詳細に比較されています。Surface Laptop 7は、X Eliteプロセッサを搭載しており、MacBook ProのM3 Proと多くのタスクで比較されています。スクリプトでは、両者のポート、キーボード、トラックパッド、スピーカー、ウェブカメラ、およびタッチスクリーン機能についても触れられています。

05:03

🔍 ディスプレイとストレージの性能比較

この段落では、Surface Laptop 7とMacBook Proのディスプレイとストレージの性能が比較されています。MacBook Proのmini LEDディスプレイはHDRコンテンツで明暗のコントラストが優れており、Surface Laptop 7のLCDスクリーンと遼か不同的是ています。また、ストレージの性能比較では、MacBook ProのSSDが高速であることが明らかになりました。

10:05

🤖 パフォーマンステストとグラフィックス比較

パフォーマンステストでは、Surface Laptop 7とMacBook ProのCPUとGPUの性能が比較されています。3D Mark Wildlife Extreme UnlimitedとSteel Nomad Lightのテストでは、MacBook ProのM3 Proが大幅に優れていることがわかります。Cinebenchのテストでは、MacBook Proがわずかにリードしていますが、Surface Laptop 7も良好なパフォーマンスを示しています。

15:05

🔥 グラフィックスとエンコード能力の比較

この段落では、Surface Laptop 7とMacBook Proのグラフィックスとエンコード能力が詳細に比較されています。BlenderのBMWテストやAdobe Lightroom Classicでの画像編集、DaVinci Resolveでの4Kビデオ編集とエンコードのテストでは、MacBook ProのM3 Proが圧倒的に高速であることが示されています。

20:08

🔋 バッテリー寿命とプラグイン時のパフォーマンス

Surface Laptop 7とMacBook Proのバッテリー寿命が比較され、MacBook Proがより効率的であることがわかります。また、プラグイン時のパフォーマンステストでは、MacBook Proが引き続き高速であることが確認されています。

25:09

🏆 総括と結論

最後の段落では、Surface Laptop 7とMacBook Proの比較の総括が行われています。MacBook Proはスピーカー、ディスプレイ、ポート、バッテリー寿命、および特にクリエイティブタスクやグラフィックタスクにおいて優れていることが強調されています。Surface Laptop 7はWindowsシステムで優れたバリューを提供しているが、クリエイティブ分野ではMacBook Proが引き続きトップクラスであると結論付けられています。

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Surface Laptop 7

これはマイクロソフトが開発したノートパソコンで、ビデオの主題であるパソコンの比較の中心に位置づけられています。Surface Laptop 7は、そのスペックやパフォーマンス、特にX Eliteプロセッサ搭載モデルが比較対象となっています。ビデオでは、このラップトップのスペックや設計、さらには他のモデルと比較したパフォーマンステストの結果が詳細に説明されています。

💡M3 Pro

M3 Proは、Apple社が開発したプロセッサのモデルで、ビデオではSurface Laptop 7と比較されるメインの競合モデルです。M3 Proは、パフォーマンスやグラフィック処理能力、さらにはバッテリー寿命において優れていると評価されています。ビデオの比較では、M3 Pro搭載のMacBook Proのさまざまな性能テスト結果が紹介されています。

💡パフォーマンステスト

パフォーマンステストとは、コンピュータの処理能力や応答速度を測定するためのテストであり、ビデオの中心的なテーマの一つです。ビデオでは、Surface Laptop 7とM3 Pro搭載のMacBook Proをスペック比較だけでなく、実際のパフォーマンス比較も行っており、ベンチマークテストやリアルワールドテストの結果が示されています。

💡バッテリー寿命

バッテリー寿命とは、デバイスが一度の充電で使用できる時間を指し、ビデオの比較において重要な要素です。ビデオでは、Surface Laptop 7とMacBook Proのバッテリー寿命を比較しており、テストの過程でそれぞれのバッテリー残量がどのように変化したかが追跡されています。

💡タッチスクリーン

タッチスクリーンは、ディスプレイ上で直接タッチ操作ができる機能で、Surface Laptop 7の特徴の一つです。ビデオでは、タッチスクリーンがユーザーインターフェースや操作性に与える影響について触れられており、特にタッチのみでの操作を好むユーザーにとって魅力的なポイントとされています。

💡スピーカー

スピーカーの品質は、ビデオで比較されるラップトップの重要なユーザエクスペリエンス要因です。ビデオでは、Surface Laptop 7とMacBook Proのスピーカー品質を比較し、MacBook Proのスピーカーシステムがより豊かで低音の強さを持ち、より優れた音質を提供していることが評価されています。

💡Webcam

Webcamは、ビデオ会議や遠隔操作に使われるビデオカメラであり、ビデオの比較においても重要な要素です。ビデオでは、Surface Laptop 7とMacBook ProのWebcamの画質や機能を比較しており、MacBook Proは1080pのWebcamとスタジオ品質のマイクを持っており、Surface Laptop 7にも同様のWebcamが搭載されていることが示されています。

💡グラフィックパフォーマンス

グラフィックパフォーマンスは、ビデオの主題であるラップトップ比較において重要なポイントで、特に3Dゲームやビデオ編集などのグラフィックズームなタスクにおいて重要です。ビデオでは、Surface Laptop 7とMacBook Proのグラフィックパフォーマンスを比較しており、M3 Pro搭載のMacBook Proが優れていることが明らかになります。

💡SSD

SSDとは、ソリッドステートドライブの略で、コンピュータのストレージデバイスです。ビデオでは、Surface Laptop 7とMacBook ProのSSDのパフォーマンスを比較しており、MacBook ProのSSDが非常に高速であることが示されています。

💡Geekbench

Geekbenchは、コンピュータのCPUやGPUのベンチマークテストを行うアプリケーションで、ビデオではこのツールを使ってSurface Laptop 7とMacBook Proのプロセッサ性能を比較しています。ビデオではGeekbenchのスコアに基づいて、どちらのラップトップがより優れた処理能力を持っているかが評価されています。

Highlights

Introduction of the Surface Laptop 7 with the X Elite, which outperforms the M3 in many tasks.

Detailed comparison of Surface Laptop 7 and M3 Pro, including displays, speakers, and performance tests.

Both laptops are at 100% battery life at the start of the comparison.

Surface Laptop 7 has a magnetic charging connector similar to MagSafe and USB-C on both laptops.

MacBook's Thunderbolt ports offer more capabilities like daisy chaining and better dock support.

Surface Laptop 7 features a USB Type-A port and fast USB 4.

Comparison of keyboard and trackpad quality, noting both have excellent keyboards but different trackpad designs.

Speaker comparison reveals the MacBook's six-speaker system offers fuller, richer sound with deep bass.

Webcam comparison shows Surface Laptop 7 provides a wider image with dual microphones.

MacBook's display has higher resolution and mini LED technology, offering better contrast and brightness.

Surface Laptop 7 includes a touchscreen display, which the MacBook does not have.

Battery life update shows MacBook at 94% and Surface Laptop 7 at 89% after initial tests.

MacBook's SSD performance significantly outpaces that of the Surface Laptop 7.

Geekbench 6 results show Surface Laptop 7 slightly outperforms the MacBook in multicore performance.

Surface Laptop 7's performance in real-world tests, such as Figma and Adobe Lightroom, is slower compared to MacBook.

Transcripts

play00:00

you guys asked for it and we are

play00:02

delivering this is the surface laptop 7

play00:05

with the X Elite that beat out the M3 in

play00:08

a lot of tasks so we are comparing it to

play00:10

the M3 Pro just like you guys asked and

play00:13

not only we're going to compare the

play00:15

actual laptops the displays speakers

play00:18

everything about them but we're going to

play00:19

do a lot of performance tests both

play00:21

benchmarks and real world tests and both

play00:25

of these are at 100% battery life so we

play00:28

are going to compare that as well so now

play00:30

let's go ahead and unplug both of them

play00:33

and I have to say I love that we have

play00:34

that surface connector for charging its

play00:37

magnetic just like mac safe and of

play00:39

course you could still use the USBC on

play00:41

both of them now here are the full specs

play00:44

of each laptop and you can see how great

play00:47

of a value this surface laptop 7 is

play00:50

matching up the specs now the MacBook is

play00:54

two grand but you can pick it up right

play00:55

now on Amazon for

play00:57

$16.99 we'll link it down below that is

play01:00

a killer value but we'll see how they

play01:03

compare in the real world now in terms

play01:05

of the quality and the design both are

play01:07

made out of solid really nice aluminum

play01:11

this surface laptop is really good

play01:14

size-wise they are very similar and as

play01:17

far as thickness at the rear portion of

play01:20

the surface it's slightly thicker but

play01:22

because of its wedge shape just like the

play01:24

old school MacBooks it's thinner at the

play01:26

front the surface is lighter at 3 lb

play01:29

compared to 3.5 both of these do have

play01:32

fans buil in and as far as the ports the

play01:36

surface has a USB type a port which is

play01:39

nice both have dual USB C's on the leand

play01:43

side but the MacBook does have

play01:45

Thunderbolt so has a little bit more

play01:46

capabilities like daisy chaining and

play01:49

having better dock support but the

play01:52

surface does have fast USB 4 but the

play01:54

MacBook does have some extras on the

play01:57

right hand side we have a fast HDM my we

play02:00

have another Thunderbolt and an SD card

play02:03

reader which is so nice to have built in

play02:05

now as far as the keyboards both of

play02:07

these are really nice the magic

play02:09

keyboards are great the surface also

play02:12

feels great it has a nice tactile feel

play02:15

but I prefer the slightly concave Keys

play02:17

both are excellent though and in terms

play02:19

of the trackpads the Mac has a slightly

play02:22

larger one but the surface is also

play02:25

magnetic so it's not a diving board

play02:28

design and this is the best track

play02:29

backpad on any Windows laptop it is

play02:33

excellent now on the Mac you can see

play02:35

speaker grills on the left and right

play02:37

side of the keyboard whereas they are

play02:39

hidden on the surface now the surface

play02:42

beat out the 13-in MacBook here in terms

play02:44

of speakers so let's go ahead and

play02:46

compare it to the 14-in that has a six

play02:50

speaker

play02:53

system Normal Heart Break pain killer

play02:57

take me somewhere un

play03:00

bring me back to where we

play03:08

started

play03:16

out all right you guys heard that for

play03:19

yourselves the Mac in the 14in size is

play03:23

amazing it's full it's rich and the base

play03:26

hits so deep because of dedicated wers

play03:29

so if you willing to spend a little bit

play03:30

more money on the 14in pro Max I mean

play03:34

they are amazing now as far as webcams

play03:36

this is the 1080p webcam on the 14-in

play03:40

MacBook Pro along with their studio

play03:42

quality microphones like apple likes to

play03:45

name them and this is the 1080p webcam

play03:48

on the surface laptop 7 the first thing

play03:51

it stands out is that it does give you a

play03:53

wider image and I also can see dual

play03:57

microphones right on top of that screen

play03:59

so you guys let me know which one looks

play04:01

better and which one sounds better down

play04:03

in the comment section below now the

play04:05

MacBook has Touch ID to log in whereas

play04:09

the surface has Windows

play04:14

hello right there it sees me it logs me

play04:17

in and even though the lid thickness is

play04:19

the same Microsoft managed to put

play04:21

Windows hello into this but apple with a

play04:24

notch did not there's no excuse for not

play04:27

adding it in now as far as the bezels

play04:30

nice all around of course we don't have

play04:32

that Notch here and comparing the

play04:34

displays the MacBook does have more

play04:37

resolution it's a little bit higher but

play04:40

you can't really tell looking at them

play04:41

both look nice and sharp and the MacBook

play04:45

does have

play04:46

promotion and the surface also has their

play04:49

own version it goes up to 120 htz it

play04:51

could drop down to as low as 24 Herz to

play04:54

save battery power so both are very nice

play04:58

now one thing the surface has that the

play05:00

Mac doesn't is a touchscreen display so

play05:03

if you like to interact with touch only

play05:05

the surface can do that now both these

play05:07

displays are rated at 600 nits native

play05:10

but when you're watching HDR footage the

play05:13

MacBook can go up to

play05:14

1,600 so looking back at this 4K HDR

play05:18

video the highlights pop a lot more in

play05:21

some of these scenes than what you get

play05:23

on the surface now I'm also seeing much

play05:26

better contrast as well because the Mac

play05:28

has a mini LED display with a bunch of

play05:31

zones where the back lighting could be

play05:33

turned off giving us nice deep blacks

play05:36

and compared to the surface where the

play05:38

blacks look a little bit gray even

play05:40

though it has really good

play05:41

anti-reflective Coatings now if you're

play05:44

watching something at night particularly

play05:46

if you have a lot of contrast there the

play05:48

difference is massive the macbook's

play05:51

highlights still pop like crazy but you

play05:54

get those deep blacks whereas with the

play05:56

LCD screen on the surface all the blacks

play05:59

look look gray you don't have the same

play06:02

super bright highlights so the

play06:04

experience doesn't really even compare

play06:07

the macbook's display is so nice but the

play06:09

only downside is if you're looking off

play06:11

access or with crazy high contrast you

play06:14

do notice some blooming now it's also

play06:16

crazy to see the difference in

play06:18

antireflectivity Coatings the surface is

play06:20

a lot more reflective even though it

play06:23

beat out the regular M3 MacBook Air the

play06:27

14in MacBook Pro has really really good

play06:29

antireflectivity Coatings so that's

play06:32

going to be great for using it outdoors

play06:34

and of course you can get the app that

play06:35

kicks up the brightness even more and I

play06:38

want to remind you guys that we do have

play06:39

a big price difference here but if you

play06:41

don't need the M3 Pro for 1,400 bucks

play06:44

you can get the regular M3 in this

play06:45

machine and have this amazing display

play06:48

and now as we get into performance I

play06:49

want to give you an update on the

play06:51

battery life before we start hitting it

play06:53

hard the MacBook is at

play06:55

94% while we're doing all that shooting

play06:58

whereas the surface is already already

play06:59

at 89% so it is a little bit lower but

play07:03

now we're going to start pushing them

play07:05

and we'll see what happens and now let's

play07:07

go ahead and compare the performance of

play07:10

the ssds like I mentioned both of these

play07:12

have 512 GB ssds so it's an even playing

play07:16

field all right guys look at this

play07:18

difference the MacBook Pro with the M3

play07:21

Pro is so fast we have 64% difference in

play07:26

terms of performance almost 6,000 here

play07:29

now the surface is not bad and in the

play07:31

right speeds we have 4,600 compared to

play07:34

2500 that is an

play07:36

84% difference so the ssds are clearly

play07:39

faster with this Mac and now I have

play07:42

geekbench 6 opened up you guys see we

play07:44

have 18 gigs compared to 16 and we have

play07:47

a big difference in core counts we have

play07:49

a 12 core compared to an 11 core because

play07:52

this M3 Pro is the bend version but only

play07:55

five of those are performance cores with

play07:58

six efficiency where on the X Elite all

play08:01

12 are actually performance cores and we

play08:04

have higher frequencies too let's head

play08:06

run on both of these and I want to point

play08:09

out that the X Elite in the surface

play08:11

laptop 7 is an 80 skew which is not the

play08:15

highest but out of all of the xelite

play08:18

laptops we tested it is actually the

play08:20

fastest on battery power so Props to

play08:24

Microsoft for giving us good performance

play08:26

whether we're plugged in or unplugged

play08:28

compared to other manufacturers that

play08:30

will limit it and we do have this set to

play08:32

the best performance because that's what

play08:34

we're doing all right and here are the

play08:36

results and it is so close even though

play08:40

this is the 80 skew it beat out the M3

play08:44

Pro in multie we have just under 14,000

play08:48

compared to

play08:49

14,260 and if we look at the single core

play08:53

the Mac is faster by about 200 points

play08:56

it's about a 6% difference but the

play08:59

performance you're getting for the money

play09:01

with the surface laptop 7 on battery

play09:04

power is excellent and I have

play09:06

speedometer 3.0 opened up here both

play09:09

using Chrome and this is going to give

play09:11

us um an image of just how quick and

play09:14

snappy the web browsing performances and

play09:17

look at that we have 37.7 compared to

play09:20

28.4 28.4 is very fast but we have a

play09:24

difference of 33% in favor of the M3 Pro

play09:28

and now I have have the figma app opened

play09:30

up here for web design we'll see how it

play09:33

Compares this project right here is

play09:36

brought To Us by 500 designs one of the

play09:38

best design studios in

play09:40

California and I'm going just start out

play09:42

by testing out the smoothness so let's

play09:45

go right over here we have these high

play09:46

resolution images and that is loaded up

play09:51

very quick very Snappy let's try another

play09:54

one right over here so we have couple

play09:57

seconds here bam it loaded up now let's

play10:01

try it on the surface and this is a

play10:04

touchcreen so here I can select let me

play10:07

just zoom in this way I'm going to go to

play10:09

that same exact

play10:10

spot right here that loaded up super

play10:13

quick and the little image lower is

play10:17

higher resolution so let's zoom in

play10:19

here wow so that loaded up even quicker

play10:22

than it did on the Mac and now I have 12

play10:25

high resolution layers selected here

play10:28

we're going to export all of these and

play10:30

see how quick it is all right guys we

play10:32

are done and I want to mention that

play10:34

figma is actually native for arm so it

play10:38

is not being emulated so we are getting

play10:40

full performance the Mac took a minute

play10:42

and 20 whereas the excelite surface took

play10:45

a minute and 51 seconds so the surface

play10:48

took 38% longer than our M3 Pro MacBook

play10:52

and now let's take a look at graphics

play10:55

performance once again this is the bend

play10:58

M3 Pro and I have 3D Mark Wildlife

play11:00

extreme unlimited opened up we are going

play11:02

to run this and this game test is really

play11:06

optimized for these kinds of arm chips

play11:09

and for mobile devices all right guys

play11:11

wow what a difference here we have

play11:15

72.4 compared to

play11:20

38.158900 per higher on the M3 Pro even

play11:24

the bin version that is crazy but now I

play11:28

want to go and test the brand new steel

play11:31

Nomad light this is more of a AAA game

play11:35

title as far as performance testing so

play11:38

let's run this and look at this right

play11:41

here my goodness we have 37.6 compared

play11:44

to

play11:46

4.44 that is 2.6 times better frames per

play11:50

second on the max so if you're going to

play11:53

be trying to play some games I mean the

play11:56

M3 Pro even the bend is so much faster

play11:59

and now let's really push these chips to

play12:02

their limits with cin bench I'm going to

play12:04

start the 10minute throttling test and

play12:08

on the Mac we're able to see all our

play12:10

information so right here we're going

play12:12

just above 20 watts 22 right there I saw

play12:15

at the peak unfortunately with the X

play12:18

Elite we don't have a lot of information

play12:20

we have some temps and frequencies so we

play12:22

saw a peak of 4,000 MHz 4 GHz but it's

play12:26

only on two cores and right now that we

play12:30

got started we're running at about 3 GHz

play12:33

compared to

play12:34

3.58 so this is clocking faster now in

play12:38

terms of the temps it did shoot up

play12:40

pretty quick as well and of course the

play12:43

fan it's going to spin up on here on the

play12:46

Mac right now we're averaging 88 um 95

play12:50

was the highest we hit but of course the

play12:52

fans are speeding up and as far as we

play12:54

know the actual wattage running this

play12:57

test should be roughly the same around

play13:00

23 WTS for the system so it's going to

play13:03

be a very interesting comparison now one

play13:05

thing that's really stood out testing

play13:07

these chips is that now they're running

play13:09

at 2500 MHz across all of the cores 27

play13:14

and sometimes it even gets as low as

play13:17

2,200 even though the temperatures are

play13:20

fairly low I hear um the cooling system

play13:24

running right now and it seems almost as

play13:27

if the chip is just just being limited

play13:30

by the amount of power that it can have

play13:32

and because it doesn't get enough

play13:34

wattage the clock speeds have to drop

play13:37

and that is just so weird compared to

play13:39

Intel systems and other Macs where

play13:41

typically were limited by heat and this

play13:44

is likely because this chip was

play13:46

originally designed for servers at much

play13:49

higher wattages than cooling but they

play13:51

able to they were able to package it

play13:53

down into an efficient underclocked

play13:57

mobile chip and now it's been around 5

play13:59

and 1/2 minutes the fans are all sped up

play14:02

everything's stabilized and the surface

play14:05

laptop 7 is running a little bit cooler

play14:08

than the MacBook but also a little bit

play14:10

louder the MacBook has a hum just

play14:13

slightly above ambient and now I have my

play14:16

thermal cam here so let's take a look

play14:19

we're getting 39° or so the hottest part

play14:23

of the M3 MacBook Pro you guys could see

play14:26

the Dual fans right over there and let's

play14:29

take a look at the surface

play14:31

46 they're at the hottest part and then

play14:35

we have the Heat going to one corner I

play14:37

think this thing has just a single fan

play14:39

but we've noticed that um these laptops

play14:42

the chip itself is consistently pretty

play14:45

dang hot even with fans and as this is

play14:48

finishing up I want to mention that even

play14:50

though the fan is louder on the surface

play14:53

with all of these exite laptops none of

play14:55

them are crazy loud and you never have a

play14:57

thing where you open up a web browser

play14:59

browser or you're starting up your

play15:01

machine or maybe installing an app and

play15:02

the fans are just ramping up and down so

play15:05

they've been designed really well and

play15:07

with this kind of a characteristic it's

play15:09

much more like a Mac and it seems like

play15:12

they're okay with the chip maybe getting

play15:13

a little bit hotter uh or um more based

play15:17

off of chassis temperature and keeping

play15:19

the fans from going crazy and blaring

play15:22

like you would get on Intel laptops and

play15:24

that just gets really annoying so this

play15:26

is much more like a Macbook all right

play15:29

guys we have our scores and we have 881

play15:32

for the bend M3 Pro and

play15:34

836 for this x Elite so that's only a

play15:38

difference of about 6% between the two

play15:41

machines and now I have blender opened

play15:44

up right here we're going to do the

play15:45

classic BMW test and right here on the

play15:48

exite in the settings I want to show you

play15:49

guys that none of these Technologies are

play15:53

supported for the X Elite so we're going

play15:56

to have to do the basic um CPU r

play15:58

rendering whereas on the Mac you have

play16:01

metal and it does work really quickly so

play16:04

now let's go ahead and render this all

play16:07

right guys we have our times here the

play16:10

MacBook took 21 seconds compared to get

play16:15

this 4 minutes and 41 seconds for the X

play16:20

Elite now of course we're not able to

play16:23

use graphics for a compute it's not

play16:26

supported and that time with CPU is not

play16:28

quick and the Mac on the other hand it

play16:30

even has rate tracing built in the chip

play16:32

which the ex Elite does not so it flies

play16:34

through 3D rendering so this machine is

play16:37

definitely not for that and just to

play16:39

prove the point I went ahead and I ran

play16:42

the same render using CPU only on the

play16:44

MacBooks we're not using Graphics or

play16:46

rate tracing and it took 2 minutes and

play16:48

42 seconds compared to that

play16:51

441 so the X Elite it was faster in

play16:55

geekbench it was almost as fast in cin

play16:57

bench but here instead of having 6%

play17:00

difference in cine bench we have a

play17:02

difference of 73% it took 73% longer

play17:06

than the Mac so that is just crazy um

play17:10

now of course this is also emulated

play17:12

running blender here but typically we

play17:14

saw like a 10% uh hit in performance for

play17:17

emulated applications but this just

play17:19

shows you the real world scenarios where

play17:21

you can run an app that might not be

play17:23

optimized and then the chip doesn't do a

play17:26

great job for this specific task as well

play17:28

you can have a big difference in

play17:29

performance and now let's get into some

play17:31

other creative apps I have Adobe

play17:34

Lightroom classic opened up right here

play17:36

we've tested it a couple times in

play17:38

previous videos and it actually works

play17:39

quite fast even though it's emulated now

play17:42

before we export these 50 edited high

play17:44

resolution images I want to do a couple

play17:46

things that a lot of people are using

play17:48

and this is what's going to use that npu

play17:52

um so we have uh let's go with the sky

play17:55

first I'm going to click it at the same

play17:56

time

play18:01

so right there on the Mac definitely a

play18:03

lot quicker probably twice as fast or

play18:05

three times faster let's go ahead and

play18:09

add another one

play18:11

here we'll use that AI to select the

play18:15

subject bam done on the Mac almost

play18:18

instantly here it is looking bam once

play18:22

again that is roughly three times

play18:24

quicker almost instant compared to

play18:26

sitting and waiting now I'm going to

play18:28

just flip through through some of these

play18:29

images here and switching through is

play18:33

still pretty quick even though this does

play18:36

have to use emulation now regular

play18:38

Lightroom the mobile web kind of based

play18:42

one for cloud that is optimized it's

play18:45

written for arm but some of these other

play18:46

programs if you like to use classic like

play18:48

a lot of professional photographers like

play18:50

well there it is going to be a little

play18:52

bit of a weight for all these apps to

play18:54

get optimized uh and set up and now

play18:57

let's go ahead and Export all all 50 of

play18:59

these so the MacBook took 43 seconds to

play19:02

do this whereas the X Elite took a

play19:05

minute and 38 seconds it took more than

play19:07

twice as long now in Lightroom the

play19:11

mobile version like I said it is quicker

play19:13

but it is still nowhere near the speed

play19:16

of the MacBook Pro and now let's test

play19:19

something that is fully optimized this

play19:22

is devinci resolve and we have the new

play19:25

version released for Windows arm this

play19:27

can actually use the G GPU to its full

play19:29

capability so there's no excuses here

play19:32

and this is a a 4K Blackmagic raw file

play19:37

with d noising so we're going to test

play19:39

out the compute performance of the

play19:42

graphics and let's just go ahead and run

play19:45

this it is really tough it's going to

play19:46

give us a frame rate and we'll see what

play19:49

this thing can handle now on the MacBook

play19:52

it's already playing we're getting 9 to

play19:54

10 frames per second so um that is

play19:58

pretty good good for this Bend chip and

play20:00

on The XLE it was glitching up and now

play20:04

started running we're getting 0 one two

play20:07

frames per second back to one frame per

play20:10

second back to two so as far as the

play20:13

graphics Compu performance this is 5X

play20:16

the performance on the MacBook that is

play20:20

crazy you could see right there the

play20:22

graphics is at 98

play20:25

99% 100 it is fully optimized but that's

play20:29

the performance we're getting all right

play20:31

let's try some playback here's some

play20:33

black magic raw footage uh with a l

play20:36

applied and we're just going to see how

play20:38

smoothly this plays on the Mac perfectly

play20:42

smooth

play20:58

optimized I'm not seeing really the

play21:00

frame rate I can go into the color tab

play21:03

here and it'll give me an actual frame

play21:04

rate for it so we're playing back at 12

play21:07

frames per second instead of 24 so this

play21:11

thing's maxed out and it looks like our

play21:13

energy saver just kicked in so we got

play21:16

low enough that it decided hey let's cut

play21:19

down the performance that's at

play21:22

19% interesting let's go ahead and turn

play21:27

this off and you guys can see our

play21:29

Graphics is pretty much maxed out here

play21:32

and we're not getting good performance

play21:34

whereas on the Mac right now we're at

play21:36

47% Graphics usage with perfect playback

play21:40

46% right there you basically have 4X

play21:45

the performance in terms of Graphics

play21:47

compute 5x wow this is standard 4K

play21:50

footage with a little bit of effects

play21:53

applied and this should be pretty easy

play21:56

because you have Hardware decoders we're

play21:57

going to have Hardware encoders this is

play22:00

like the optimal scenario as you guys

play22:02

see they are both playing back perfectly

play22:04

so it is handling your basic simple

play22:07

footage um so that part of it at least

play22:10

is good you're not going to be able to

play22:12

stack a ton of effects or do some real

play22:14

serious work but for basic 4K it is

play22:17

playing it back and now let's render

play22:19

this 5 minute project and this is going

play22:23

to test out the speed of the built-in

play22:26

encoders Apple they have an up updated

play22:28

it from the M1 the M2 and now the M3

play22:31

this is the new ex Elite and it looks

play22:34

like we're running at about

play22:36

29.5 about 30 FPS compared to about 90

play22:42

on the MacBook with really old encoders

play22:45

I believe for the M4 they finally have

play22:48

updated it once M4 Max launch but let's

play22:51

see how long this takes the macbook's

play22:53

been done for a while here and looking

play22:56

at the xlite our Graphics is Mac maxed

play22:58

out the 3D engine is roughly half or so

play23:01

for the effects but the decode is what

play23:04

is maxing this out right here all right

play23:08

guys we have a minute and 21 compared to

play23:10

4 minutes and 12 seconds so the MacBook

play23:14

is 3 times faster in these very simple

play23:18

uh 4K video tasks and up to six times

play23:22

faster for more complex things that is a

play23:26

crazy difference that I was not EXP

play23:28

expecting now I want to do a quick test

play23:30

on this plugged in just to see if we

play23:33

have a difference but first I want to go

play23:35

ahead and take a look at our battery

play23:37

life we turned off that energy mode as

play23:39

soon as it kicked on when we were doing

play23:41

the previous test so our MacBook here is

play23:44

at 25% battery life remaining we've been

play23:47

shooting for hours and hours doing all

play23:49

of these tests and the surface is at

play23:54

7% battery life so this is still good as

play23:58

far as if you're comparing to the older

play24:00

Intel based systems but the MacBook is

play24:04

ahead uh in terms of overall efficiency

play24:08

speed in the real world and battery life

play24:11

when you're pushing it let's go ahead

play24:13

and plug in this system and as you guys

play24:16

can see it's showing 4 minutes 5 Seconds

play24:19

4 3 it usually jumps up and down so

play24:22

that's showing us that it's still going

play24:24

to take the same time we were not

play24:27

limited by any any sort of um on battery

play24:30

performance any sort of caps um or even

play24:33

the battery life being low that is just

play24:36

the performance that you get so what is

play24:38

our main conclusion what did we find in

play24:41

these tests you guys wanted the X Elite

play24:44

against the M3 Pro we did it and we saw

play24:47

that in pretty much everything the 14in

play24:51

with the bend weaker M3 Pro ended up

play24:54

beating it out the only thing it didn't

play24:56

is multicore in geekbench six but that

play24:59

was literally a 1% difference but in all

play25:02

the real world tasks optim unoptimized

play25:04

or optimized the 14in is a better

play25:08

machine now if you're willing to spend a

play25:11

little bit more money than this surface

play25:14

um laptop 7 you are getting a better

play25:17

machine you're getting the speakers the

play25:18

mini LED display you're getting the

play25:20

better ports you're getting better

play25:22

battery life and in terms of real world

play25:25

performance especially for Creative

play25:27

tasks especially for graphics and

play25:30

Graphics tasks for compute performance

play25:33

the difference is really big and with

play25:35

that said with the regular M3 in this

play25:39

machine even though some of the

play25:41

benchmarks would have been lower the

play25:42

real world performance tasks would have

play25:44

still beat it out in terms of you know

play25:47

blender in terms of the figma in terms

play25:50

of video editing it is still faster on

play25:55

that so we still really like the surface

play25:58

lap 7 with the X Elite if you need a

play26:00

Windows system we love this machine it

play26:02

is a great value you get way better

play26:05

battery life than you did with Intel um

play26:08

it's nice it's a good machine and if you

play26:11

use it for regular office tasks you know

play26:13

use it for web browsing emails CPU

play26:16

related tasks you want a nice screen

play26:19

webcam it is a good machine but it is

play26:22

not a Powerhouse for creatives or for

play26:25

graphics the MacBook still wins andk

play26:28

thankfully with those killer sales you

play26:30

can pick one up for a great price but

play26:33

you guys let me know what you thought

play26:35

down in the comment section below go

play26:37

ahead and click that Circle above cuz we

play26:38

still have some great videos coming out

play26:41

check out one of those videos right over

play26:42

there this has been Max and I'll see you

play26:44

in the next one

play26:46

[Music]

play26:52

[Music]

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Related Tags
Surface LaptopMacBook Proパフォーマンスバッテリーカメラ比較スピーカータッチ画面X EliteM3 Proレビュー技術比較
Do you need a summary in English?