Eps 991 | BONGKAR JARINGAN BUZZER ISRAEL DI INDONESIA : DARI ABU JANDA, GUS YAHYA SAMPAI GUSDUR ?

Summary

In this video, Guru Gembul discusses allegations of paid influencers, referred to as 'bazers,' who promote pro-Israel narratives online, highlighting recruitment, payment structures, and subtle propaganda techniques. The speaker examines ideological support for Israel, distinguishing between those who are financially incentivized and those who support Israel based on historical, theological, or diplomatic reasoning. He also contextualizes the complex relationship between Jews and Muslims historically, referencing religious texts and figures like Gus Dur. The video concludes with reflections on global politics, Muslim unity, and geopolitical dynamics, urging viewers to critically assess influences and motivations behind public narratives on Israel and Palestine.

Takeaways

• 😀 Israel has been hiring 'bazzers' worldwide since 2017 to manage its online propaganda and improve its image, with a high salary for social media posts.
• 😀 The job for a bazzar involves posting 25 to 30 times a month on social media for $6,000 to $7,000 per post, depending on the frequency.
• 😀 Israel has historically spent millions of dollars on media propaganda but faced challenges with traditional media, leading to a shift towards using influencers and online figures.
• 😀 Influencers and bazzers are paid to spread messages that portray Israel as a victim and its adversaries, particularly Palestinians, as terrorists or anti-Semitic.
• 😀 Some key tactics used by bazzers include portraying Israel as a nation under constant attack and justifying its defense actions.
• 😀 Israel has also created apps, like AK Il and Hasbara, to promote their propaganda, but these have been discontinued due to poor results.
• 😀 High-profile figures in Indonesia, like Abu Janda, have been linked to Israel's propaganda efforts due to their public support for Israel and alignment with its narrative.
• 😀 Bazzers often operate under strict secrecy, with covert travel arrangements and the signing of non-disclosure agreements to protect their identities and activities.
• 😀 In Indonesia, some individuals have been suspected of being paid bazzers, but due to the covert nature of the operations, accusations remain unverified.
• 😀 The discussion also touches on the religious and historical justifications for Israel's existence, referencing Quranic verses that confirm the legitimacy of the Jewish people in the Promised Land.
• 😀 The script argues that Muslims' opposition to Zionism should be based on political rather than religious grounds, and the global Muslim community faces divisions on how to respond to Israel and its actions.

Q & A

What is the main topic discussed in the video script?

The main topic revolves around Israel's use of paid propagandists, known as 'bazer,' who spread pro-Israel narratives online. The speaker critiques these efforts, highlights the global scope of the campaign, and discusses the ideological and political motivations behind them.

How much are 'bazer' paid for their online posts, according to the script?

According to the script, 'bazer' are paid between $6,000 and $7,000 per post, with a requirement to post 25 to 30 times a month, resulting in a potential monthly income of up to $210,000 if they meet the target.

What role do 'bazer' play in Israel's propaganda efforts?

The 'bazer' serve as influencers who help spread pro-Israel content and narratives, particularly on social media. Their job is to shape public opinion by portraying Israel as a victim of aggression and to discredit Palestinian support as antisemitic or terrorist-driven.

Why did Israel shift from using mass media to social media for propaganda?

Israel shifted from using traditional mass media to social media because paying for media outlets became increasingly difficult, and social media allowed for more targeted and influential methods, particularly through influencers or 'bazer' who are more flexible and less regulated.

How are the activities of 'bazer' kept secret?

The activities of 'bazer' are kept secret through multiple layers of security and discretion. For example, when they travel to Israel, their routes and connections are carefully obscured, and they are bound by contracts that threaten large fines and blacklisting if they reveal any information about their work.

Can you name any individuals suspected of being 'bazer' in the script?

The script mentions several individuals suspected of being 'bazer,' including Abu Janda, Luthfi Sukani, and even Gus Yahya, though the speaker acknowledges that these accusations are not confirmed and that these individuals often deny the claims.

What is the ideological motivation for some individuals to support Israel, according to the script?

Some individuals, particularly in Indonesia, support Israel due to ideological or theological reasons. The script mentions that figures like Gus Dur defended Israel, citing religious justifications from both the Qur'an and the Torah, suggesting that the land of Israel was divinely promised to the Jewish people.

What is the historical relationship between Jews and Muslims before the rise of Zionism?

Before the rise of Zionism, Jews and Muslims coexisted relatively peacefully, with Jews finding refuge in Muslim-majority regions like the Abbasid Caliphate. Muslims and Jews shared common religious practices, and Jews were integrated into society, holding various roles including business owners, scholars, and even government officials.

What are the key religious references made in the script regarding Israel's legitimacy?

The script cites two Qur'anic verses as evidence that the land of Israel is divinely promised to the Jewish people: Surah Al-Maidah (5:20), where God instructs the Jewish people to enter the land, and Surah Al-Isra (17:104), which discusses the eventual gathering of the Jewish people to their promised land.

What are the main criticisms of individuals suspected of being 'bazer' in Indonesia?

The main criticisms are that these individuals spread pro-Israel narratives, label Palestinians and their supporters as terrorists or antisemitic, and use their influence to push Israel's political agenda. Some are also accused of being ideologically aligned with Israel or having been directly invited to Israel by its government.