Schindler's List (2/9) Movie CLIP - Commandant Amon Goeth (1993) HD

Summary

In a tense scene, a commander offers a job to a girl named Helen Hirsch at his villa, but then dismisses the idea. A construction foreman, Diana Reiter, a Jewish engineer, warns of a critical foundation error in the barracks, predicting subsidence and collapse. Despite her expertise, the commander, influenced by prejudice, orders her execution, highlighting the tragic intersection of bigotry and authority in a historical setting.

Takeaways

• 🏠 The script involves a conversation about a job opening at a new villa, suggesting an opportunity to escape manual labor.
• 👗 It is revealed that the person offering the job is looking for a maid without pre-existing habits, indicating a desire for control over the employee's behavior.
• 🗣️ A character named Helen Hirsch is introduced, who is asked to repeat her name due to being unheard, possibly due to a noisy environment or the speaker's dismissive attitude.
• 🚫 There is a clear directive to 'take it down', referring to a construction issue, suggesting a potential safety hazard.
• 🏢 The foundation of a barracks is mentioned as having been poured incorrectly, indicating a serious construction flaw that requires rectification.
• 👷‍♀️ Diana Reiter, a Jewish engineer, is portrayed as knowledgeable and assertive about the construction problem, despite the dangerous context.
• 🎓 Diana's educational background in Civil Engineering from the University of Milan is highlighted, adding credibility to her professional judgment.
• 🗣️ There is a derogatory reference to Karl Marx, drawing a comparison between the educated Jewish engineer and a well-known figure, which could imply prejudice.
• 🔫 A command to shoot Diana is given, reflecting the extreme and violent nature of the situation and the disregard for her expertise.
• 🤝 The sergeant's initial reluctance to follow the order without a reason suggests a potential conflict between duty and morality.
• 🏚️ The final line suggests that the barracks' structural issues are more significant than initially thought, hinting at a broader problem that may not be easily resolved.

Q & A

What is the context of the dialogue where a job opening is mentioned?

The dialogue takes place in a setting where a man is offering a job opportunity to a girl, presumably to work at his new villa, away from her current backbreaking work.

Why does the man change his mind about hiring someone else's maid?

The man decides against hiring someone else's maid because he does not want to deal with the annoying habits that he would have to correct.

What is Helen Hirsch's role in the script?

Helen Hirsch is a character who is present during the conversation about the job opportunity. Her name is mentioned when the man asks for her name.

What is the issue with the foundation of the barracks according to the script?

The foundation of the barracks has been poured incorrectly, and it needs to be torn down and repoured to prevent subsidence and potential collapse.

Who is Diana Reiter and what is her profession?

Diana Reiter is a character who identifies herself as a Civil Engineer, a graduate from the University of Milan, and she is the foreman of construction.

What is the man's initial reaction to Diana Reiter's professional advice?

The man dismisses Diana's professional advice and orders her to be shot, showing a disregard for her expertise and safety concerns.

What is the sergeant's role in the script and his reaction to the order?

The sergeant is a subordinate who is given the order to shoot Diana. His reaction is one of confusion and questioning, as indicated by his response 'What? Commander!'

Why does the man refer to Diana as an 'educated Jew' and compare her to Karl Marx?

The man uses the term 'educated Jew' derogatorily, comparing Diana to Karl Marx to mock her education and imply that he sees her as part of a stereotype rather than an individual.

What is the significance of the term 'Herr Kommandant' used in the script?

The term 'Herr Kommandant' is a German title used to address a high-ranking military officer, indicating the man's authority and possibly his role in a military or Nazi context.

What is the conflict between the man and Diana regarding the construction of the barracks?

The conflict arises from Diana's insistence on the need to correct the foundation of the barracks for safety reasons, while the man dismisses her concerns and orders her execution.

What can be inferred about the setting and time period of the script based on the dialogue?

The setting appears to be during a time of conflict or war, possibly World War II, given the military titles, the mention of a barracks, and the derogatory language used towards Diana.