REPORT: Arizona State APPEALING Loss to Texas After TERRIBLE Call, College Football Playoff Alive

Summary

In this episode, the host tackles a range of college football topics, including the controversial Arizona State vs. Texas Peach Bowl outcome, the overhyped SEC dominance, and the rumors surrounding BYU allegedly tampering with Utah players. The host critiques sports media, calling out misinformation and emphasizing the lack of evidence behind various claims. With a mix of humor and passion, the speaker defends the integrity of college football, urging fans to avoid clickbait and baseless accusations. The episode offers a candid and entertaining breakdown of current football issues in the Big 12 and beyond.

Takeaways

• 😀 The controversy involves an analyst claiming that BYU is tampering with Utah players by offering them NIL deals that aren't fulfilled once they arrive.
• 😀 The host of the podcast, JT Wierstill, is not responsible for the analyst's claims and did not endorse the statements made.
• 😀 JT Wierstill, as the host, made a conscious decision to leave the analyst's comments in the podcast, even though they were controversial, as they were the analyst's opinions, not the host's.
• 😀 The claim about BYU offering higher NIL amounts than actually delivered is unsubstantiated, with no evidence to support this serious accusation.
• 😀 Despite the claims, there has not been a mass exodus of BYU players entering the transfer portal, which raises questions about the validity of the accusations.
• 😀 The accusation of tampering is based on very limited and questionable evidence, including a handshake between BYU's coach Kalani Sitake and players after a game.
• 😀 The rivalry between BYU and Utah is intensifying, especially since BYU's recent success, with Utah fans becoming more vocal about potential unethical actions by BYU.
• 😀 The discussion points out that while these accusations have been publicized, there’s no major evidence supporting tampering, and players continue to join BYU, not leave.
• 😀 The debate about tampering is being fueled by fan paranoia and hearsay, with accusations being made without clear proof or substantial backing.
• 😀 The rivalry between BYU and Utah is described as one of the loudest and most contentious, with each side regularly accusing the other of unethical behavior, making it difficult to find common ground.

Q & A

What is the primary issue being discussed in the transcript?

The main issue revolves around accusations of tampering, rivalry tensions, and over-promising of NIL (Name, Image, and Likeness) deals in college football, specifically between BYU and Utah. There's controversy over alleged false claims about these practices and the public reactions to them.

How does the host react to the analyst's statements about BYU tampering with players?

The host, Drake Tol, expresses disapproval of the analyst’s claims about BYU tampering with players. He believes these accusations lack evidence and calls them 'insane.' He also defends JT Wier, the Lockdown Utes host, stating that JT didn't intend to support such claims.

What evidence is mentioned that suggests BYU might be involved in tampering or over-promising NIL deals?

The only evidence mentioned are two instances: 1) Kalani Sitake shaking hands with Utah players after a game, which is a common practice, and 2) an analyst claiming that BYU is promising high amounts of money to recruits, but then failing to deliver those amounts once they arrive at the university.

How does the host respond to the claim that BYU is offering NIL deals and then under-delivering?

The host, Drake Tol, argues that there is no concrete evidence to support these claims. He points out the lack of any major transfer portal activity among BYU players, suggesting that if these accusations were true, players would be leaving BYU in large numbers, which is not happening.

What is the significance of the rivalry between BYU and Utah, according to the host?

The rivalry between BYU and Utah is presented as particularly intense and chaotic. The host compares it to children arguing in the backseat of a car, with both fanbases making wild accusations. This rivalry is seen as unique within the Big 12, having even more tension than the Texas vs. Oklahoma rivalry.

How does the host compare the current rivalry to the Texas vs. Oklahoma rivalry?

The host suggests that the BYU vs. Utah rivalry is more intense and heated than the Texas vs. Oklahoma rivalry, calling it even 'louder' and more chaotic. He implies that the Big 12 has never seen a rivalry like the one between these two teams.

What does the host think about the role of the podcast host in managing controversial opinions from guests?

The host believes that it is not necessarily the responsibility of the podcast host (JT Wier) to edit out a guest’s controversial or outrageous opinions. He defends JT Wier's decision to leave the analyst’s statement in the podcast, stating that the guest’s opinion was their own and not representative of the show.

What is the role of NIL (Name, Image, and Likeness) in the discussion about recruiting?

NIL plays a central role in the discussion, with accusations suggesting that BYU is using NIL deals to recruit players, but allegedly not delivering on the promises made to recruits. However, the host argues that there is no clear evidence to support these accusations and questions why no players are leaving BYU if the promises were indeed broken.

What point does the host make about the absence of a mass exodus of BYU players?

The host emphasizes that if BYU were truly under-delivering on NIL promises, there would be a mass exodus of players transferring out of BYU. The lack of such an exodus calls into question the legitimacy of the accusations being made about tampering and false promises.

How does the host feel about the accusations of defamation and slander towards BYU?

The host dismisses the accusations of defamation and slander against BYU as being baseless. He believes these claims are exaggerated and argues that the supposed evidence is flimsy, pointing to the lack of concrete proof and the chaotic nature of fan reactions.