This Makes Drawing Permissible in Islam

Summary

The video discusses Islamic perspectives on drawing and imagery, particularly the differing opinions among scholars. It highlights that while some hadiths prohibit creating images of living beings, there is no direct prohibition in the Quran. The four major Islamic schools of thought hold varying views, with some forbidding both 2D and 3D representations, while others permit them with restrictions. The video provides advice for artists on how to make drawings permissible in Islam and clarifies exceptions in cases of necessity. The creator emphasizes the importance of intention and following Islamic teachings closely.

Takeaways

• 😀 Different opinions exist among scholars regarding drawing in Islam, particularly on depictions of living beings.
• 📜 The Quran does not explicitly prohibit drawing, but hadiths do provide guidance on the topic, with warnings for image makers.
• 🎨 Some scholars believe drawing beings with souls (humans, animals) is strictly prohibited, while others think it is only forbidden when done with the intent of idol worship.
• 🕌 The four major Islamic schools of thought (Hanafi, Shafi’i, Hanbali, and Maliki) have different rulings on drawing, particularly regarding 3D vs 2D imagery.
• ⛔ All four imams agree that 3D art, such as sculptures, is prohibited as it closely resembles idol statues.
• 🖼️ 2D drawings are generally considered forbidden by the Hanafi, Shafi'i, and Hanbali schools, but Maliki views it as disliked (makruh) but not haram.
• ✂️ To make drawings permissible, one can omit the head or facial features like eyes, nose, or mouth.
• 👮 Exceptions to the rule are made in cases of necessity, such as creating criminal sketches for law enforcement.
• 📸 Photography of nature or non-living objects is permissible, but displaying pictures of living beings in the house is discouraged as angels do not enter homes with such images.
• 🙏 Wearing clothes with animated figures or celebrities is makruh during prayer, though the prayer remains valid.

Q & A

What is the Islamic ruling on drawing living beings according to the script?

The script explains that drawing living beings, particularly those with souls, is considered haram (forbidden) by most scholars, including Imam Hanbali, Imam Shafi’i, and Imam Hanafi. However, Imam Maliki considers it disliked (makruh) but not haram.

Are there any differences in rulings regarding 3D vs 2D images?

Yes, all four major Islamic scholars (imams) agree that 3D images, such as statues and sculptures, are prohibited because they resemble idol statues. For 2D images like drawings or paintings, most scholars also consider them haram, except Imam Maliki, who believes they are only disliked.

What is one way to make drawing a living being permissible?

One way to make drawing living beings permissible is by removing the head or covering key facial features such as the eyes, nose, or mouth. This removes the lifelike appearance, making it permissible in Islam.

How do scholars interpret the hadith about the punishment of image makers?

Some scholars believe the hadith refers specifically to those who create images for idol worship or other ideological purposes, associating it with shirk (polytheism). Other scholars interpret it as a general prohibition on creating lifelike images.

What are the rules regarding taking photos according to the script?

Taking photos is considered permissible, as capturing Allah's creation through photography is allowed. However, displaying pictures of animated beings in the home is discouraged, as angels of mercy do not enter homes where there are pictures of living beings.

Is it permissible to draw parts of the body, such as hands or feet?

Yes, drawing only parts of the body, like hands or feet, is permissible. The prohibition or dislike applies specifically to drawing the full body, especially when facial features are depicted.

Can you pray while wearing clothes with images or drawings of animated beings?

It is still valid to pray while wearing clothes with images of animated beings, but it is considered makruh (disliked). Wearing such clothes is not permissible in general, especially if the images include cartoons, celebrities, or other animated characters.

Do intentions matter when it comes to drawing in Islam?

Intentions are important in Islam, and good intentions can lead to rewards from Allah. However, good intentions do not make something haram permissible. For example, drawing for educational purposes is still not allowed unless under specific circumstances of necessity.

Are there exceptions where drawing or creating images becomes permissible?

Yes, exceptions are made in cases of necessity, such as when a police officer needs to create a sketch to help identify a criminal. In such cases, drawing becomes permissible if there is no alternative.

How do scholars advise Muslims to handle images in their homes?

Scholars advise Muslims to display images of nature or inanimate objects instead of pictures of living beings. Additionally, pictures of living beings should be collected in a book gallery rather than displayed prominently in the home.