Article Review on Forget developing poor countries, it's time to de-develop rich countries.
Summary
TLDRIn 'Forget Developing Poor Countries, It's Time to Develop Rich Countries' by Jason Hickel, the article challenges the conventional narrative that growth is the solution and instead suggests that rich countries should reduce their development levels. Hickel argues for learning from societies with low consumption but high happiness and longevity, promoting a more sustainable and appropriate development model. The article calls for a new understanding of progress that doesn't rely on endless growth, encouraging rich nations to justify their existence and consider a more balanced approach to global development.
Takeaways
- đ The article challenges the notion that growth is the only solution and suggests a reevaluation of development strategies.
- đ It critiques the idea of perpetuating growth as a means for poorer countries to catch up with richer ones, viewing it as outdated propaganda.
- đ The author, Jason Hickel, proposes a shift in perspective to consider 'catching down' as a viable alternative to the traditional 'catching up' approach.
- đïž The article highlights societies where people live long and happy lives despite lower levels of income and consumption, suggesting these as models for efficient living.
- đ± It emphasizes the need to learn from cultures that have achieved a good quality of life without excessive consumption or wealth.
- đ± The concept of 'appropriate development' is introduced, where countries are not seen as underdeveloped but as optimally developed for their context.
- đ Hickel calls for rich countries to justify their levels of development and consumption, implying a need for global equity and sustainability.
- đż The article aligns with the United Nations' Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), which aim to end poverty through sustainable means rather than endless growth.
- đĄ It encourages a higher level of consciousness and understanding, advocating for a world that values quality of life over material wealth.
- đ The article suggests a middle ground where both rich and poor countries can develop in a balanced way, meeting at a point of sustainable and equitable living standards.
Q & A
What is the main argument presented in Jason Hickel's article?
-The main argument is that growth is no longer a viable option and that instead of focusing on developing poor countries to catch up with rich ones, we should consider bringing rich countries down to more appropriate levels of development.
Who is Jason Hickel and what is his background?
-Jason Hickel is an anthropologist with a strong economic perspective. He is known for his critiques of development and economic growth.
What is the significance of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) mentioned in the article?
-The SDGs are a set of goals established by the United Nations to end poverty, protect the planet, and ensure prosperity for all. The article critiques the reliance on economic growth as a means to achieve these goals.
Who is Peter Edward, and what does he argue in the article?
-Peter Edward is an economist mentioned in the article who argues against the idea of pushing poorer countries to catch up with richer ones. Instead, he suggests that rich countries should aim for a more appropriate level of development.
What does the article suggest we should learn from societies with low income and consumption?
-The article suggests that we should learn from societies where people live long and happy lives despite relatively low income and consumption levels, as these represent efficient ways of living.
How does the article define 'appropriate development'?
-The article defines 'appropriate development' as a state where countries are not overdeveloped but have reached a level of development that allows for long and happy lives with lower levels of income and consumption.
What is the author's stance on the concept of 'developing' poor countries?
-The author argues against the traditional notion of developing poor countries to match the levels of rich ones, suggesting instead that rich countries should adjust their development to more sustainable levels.
What is the intended audience for this article?
-The intended audience is adults who are concerned about the state of the world and are open to rethinking conventional economic development models.
What is the main takeaway from the article according to the reviewer?
-The main takeaway is the importance of reevaluating our understanding of development and growth, and learning from societies that prioritize happiness and longevity over material wealth.
What is the reviewer's critique of the article's suggestion to stop developing poor countries?
-The reviewer points out that the article's suggestion to stop developing poor countries might be misinterpreted; they believe that poor countries should still be allowed to develop while rich countries adjust their development strategies.
Why does the reviewer recommend the article to others?
-The reviewer recommends the article because it challenges conventional economic wisdom and encourages readers to consider alternative models of development that prioritize well-being over material wealth.
Outlines
đ Rethinking Development: Rich Countries' Role
The article by Jason Michael Heikel challenges the conventional notion of economic growth, suggesting that the focus should shift from developing poor countries to reevaluating the development models of rich ones. It critiques the idea of continuous growth as a government propaganda tool and proposes that rich countries should reduce their development levels to more sustainable ones. The article advocates learning from societies with lower incomes and consumption, where people live long and happy lives, as a model for an efficient lifestyle. It also discusses the United Nations' Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) and the need for a new perspective on what constitutes 'appropriate' development. The author encourages rich countries to justify their existence and consumption levels, aiming for a higher level of global consciousness for a better world.
Mindmap
Keywords
đĄDeveloping Countries
đĄRich Countries
đĄSustainable Development Goals (SDGs)
đĄGrowth Propaganda
đĄAppropriate Development
đĄQuality of Life
đĄPeter Edward
đĄJason Michael Heikel
đĄVoluntary Misery
đĄHigher Level of Understanding and Consciousness
Highlights
The article challenges the notion that growth is the only solution and suggests a reevaluation of development strategies.
It argues for a shift in focus from developing poor countries to reining in the development of rich ones.
The article suggests learning from societies with long, happy lives at lower levels of income and consumption.
The author, Jason Hickel, is an anthropologist with a strong economic perspective.
The article references the United Nations' Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) and their focus on ending poverty.
Economist Peter Edward is cited, advocating for a different approach to global economic development.
The article proposes viewing certain countries not as underdeveloped but as appropriately developed.
It calls for rich countries to justify their existence and development levels.
The objective is not to impose limits on human potential but to enhance global understanding and consciousness.
The article encourages looking at alternative ways of living that prioritize happiness and longevity over material wealth.
It critiques the idea of continuous development as a means to meet in the middle between rich and poor countries.
The article is recommended for readers seeking a new perspective on global development and sustainability.
The article suggests that development should not be a one-size-fits-all approach but tailored to societal needs and values.
It discusses the importance of redefining what it means to be developed in a global context.
The article emphasizes the need for a higher level of consciousness for a better world.
It questions the traditional narrative of development and growth as the ultimate goals for all countries.
The article provides a thought-provoking perspective on the limitations of current economic models.
Transcripts
foreign
[Music]
and we are here to do an article review
on forget developing poor countries it's
time to develop rich countries by Jason
heikel
[Music]
this article is intended for adults that
are concerned about the status of the
world
the purpose of this article is to inform
the masses that growth is not an option
anymore and it is just a mere propaganda
of the government to still continue
doing their business
moreover instead of pushing poorer
countries to catch up with the rich ones
the article says that we should be
thinking ways to bring rich countries to
catch down to a more appropriate levels
of development
we should look and learn from societies
where people live long and happy at a
relatively low levels of income and
consumption as an example of efficient
way of living
this is the first time that you have
seen the article and we don't have any
idea until we read the title as the
titles did forget developing work
address it's time to develop which
countries
we basically had the idea that this
about world politics and Earth overall
well-being
to why do we need to stop developing our
countries
and instead we need to develop the rich
coins
the author and the central figure of
this article is Jason Michael he has a
renewed a top anthropologies and now to
have a very strong economic option
the event mentioned his article is
signing on of UNS means sustainable
development goals
sdgs that may mean good figure attend
stated that the overall objective of
this event is to end probability by the
use of growth which is 70 years ago was
proven
there is this economics
mentioned in the article named Peter
Edward argues esteemed a pushing poorer
countries to catch up with Rich once we
should be thinking of ways to get rich
countries
to catch down to more appropriate level
of development
we should look at sociality where people
live long and happy at relative low
levels of income and consumption as an
example of
[Music]
in light of this Jason stated that we
should regard such countries not as
undeveloped but rather as appropriate
developed and we need to start calling
on the rich countries to justify their
existence
the objective of this article is not
about giving anything up and it's
certainly not about living a life of
voluntary misery or imposing harsh
limits on the human potential on the
contrary it's about reaching a higher
level of understanding and Consciousness
for a better world
the part that we like them
in the article is when the author is
imposing that you should learn from
other societies where people live long
and happy
at a relatively low income and makes it
out as an efficient way of living
the lesson here is that do not take
things for granted
the main drawback of this article is
that when it says to stop developing
poor countries for us we can still
develop rich countries while the poor
countries can continue to develop until
the two meets at the middle
we will gladly recommend this article
for everyone to read and understand the
message that the article has
[Music]
Voir Plus de Vidéos Connexes
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)