priv
Summary
TLDRIn this educational script, a class discussion on Newton's method for solving nonlinear equations unfolds, with a student, Ben Campbell, intriguingly suggesting that Joseph Raphson, not Newton, was the true inventor. The narrative pivots to a game show scenario, where Ben applies statistical reasoning to increase his chances of winning a car by switching doors, highlighting the importance of variable change in decision-making. The script concludes with a lesson on overcoming emotional biases and trusting in math, as Ben secures the car over a goat.
Takeaways
- đ Newton's method is a technique used to solve nonlinear equations by iteratively approximating the root of a function.
- đ”ïžââïž Joseph Raphson, not Isaac Newton, is credited by some as the original author of the method, but Newton's name is more widely recognized due to better publicity.
- đ Newton's method can fail if the initial guess is too far from the actual root, highlighting the importance of choosing a good starting point.
- đ The script humorously suggests that after 1700, little is known about Raphson, except for his discovery of the cabala, which is a playful jab at historical obscurity.
- đ The 'game show host problem' is a classic probability puzzle that illustrates the concept of conditional probability and the value of changing one's initial choice based on new information.
- đ§ Ben Campbell, a student in the script, correctly applies statistical reasoning to the game show problem, demonstrating the power of logic over intuition.
- đ The concept of 'variable change' is introduced as a key factor in decision-making, emphasizing the need to reassess situations when new information becomes available.
- đ After the game show host opens a door, the probability of winning the car changes from 33.3% to 66.7% if one decides to switch doors, showcasing the impact of conditional probability.
- đ Ben's decision to switch doors is rewarded with a new car, symbolizing the triumph of rational analysis over emotional decision-making.
- đ The script ends with a reminder to students to pick up their graded papers, tying back to the educational setting of the conversation.
Q & A
What is Newton's method and how is it used?
-Newton's method is a numerical technique used to find the roots of a real-valued function. It is particularly useful for solving nonlinear equations.
Who is credited with discovering Newton's method?
-Isaac Newton is commonly credited with the method, but Joseph Raphson also published the same method 50 years earlier.
Why didn't Joseph Raphson get credit for Newton's method?
-Raphson did not get as much credit as Newton possibly due to Newton having a better publicist and because after 1700, very little is known about Raphson's life and work.
What is a drawback of Newton's method?
-If the starting value is too far from the true zero, Newton's method can fail to converge to the correct solution.
What is the 'game show host problem' mentioned in the script?
-The 'game show host problem' is a hypothetical scenario where a contestant on a game show must choose between three doors, with one hiding a car and the others goats. The host, knowing what's behind the doors, opens one with a goat and offers the contestant a chance to switch their choice.
Why should Ben switch his choice of doors in the 'game show host problem'?
-Ben should switch his choice because after the host opens a door with a goat, the probability of the car being behind one of the remaining doors changes. If Ben initially chose a door with a 33.3% chance of having the car, switching would give him a 66.7% chance of winning the car.
What is the significance of the Monty Hall problem in the script?
-The Monty Hall problem illustrates the importance of understanding probability and variable change. It demonstrates that making decisions based on statistical reasoning can lead to better outcomes than relying on intuition or fear.
What does the script suggest about the role of emotions in decision-making?
-The script suggests that emotions like paranoia and fear can cloud judgment and lead to suboptimal decisions. It encourages using logic and mathematical reasoning to make better choices.
How does the script use humor to discuss serious mathematical concepts?
-The script uses humor by comparing the historical credit for Newton's method to modern public relations and by joking about Raphson's discovery of the Kabbalah before Madonna.
What lesson does the script offer about the importance of considering variable change?
-The script emphasizes that accounting for changes in variables, as in the Monty Hall problem, can significantly impact the outcome of a decision and lead to more favorable results.
Outlines
𧟠Newton's Method and the Game Show Problem
The script begins with a discussion on Newton's method, a mathematical technique for solving nonlinear equations. The instructor expresses admiration for the method, particularly in the context of their class on nonlinear equations. A student, Ben Campbell, corrects the instructor by pointing out that Joseph Raphson, not Newton, was the original author of the method. The instructor acknowledges this and segues into a game show scenario to illustrate the concept of variable change. In this hypothetical game show, Ben is given a choice between three doors, one hiding a car and two with goats. After the host, knowing the contents, opens one door with a goat, Ben is asked if he wants to switch his choice. Ben decides to switch, explaining that the probability of winning the car increases from 33.3% to 66.7% by doing so. The instructor praises Ben's statistical reasoning over emotional decision-making, highlighting the importance of accounting for variable change in decision-making.
Mindmap
Keywords
đĄNewton's Method
đĄNonlinear Equations
đĄStart Value
đĄPublicist
đĄCabala
đĄGame Show Host Problem
đĄVariable Change
đĄParanoia
đĄStatistics
đĄExtra Credit
Highlights
Newton's method is used to solve nonlinear equations.
Newton's method is also known as the Newton-Raphson method.
Joseph Raphson published the method 50 years before Newton.
Newton had better publicity, overshadowing Raphson's contribution.
After 1700, little is known about Raphson except his discovery of the cabala.
The method may fail if the starting value is too far from the true zero.
Ben Campbell suggests Joseph Raphson as the original author of the method.
The Game Show Host Problem is introduced as an extra credit challenge.
In the game show scenario, choosing a door initially gives a 33.3% chance of winning.
After the host reveals a goat, the probability of winning by switching doors increases to 66.7%.
Ben Campbell chooses to switch doors for a higher chance of winning.
The importance of accounting for variable change in decision-making is emphasized.
Most people might not switch due to paranoia or fear, but math suggests it's beneficial.
Ben Campbell's decision to switch doors is based on statistical probability.
The lesson is to let math guide decisions rather than emotions.
The class concludes with the distribution of graded papers.
Transcripts
all right now who can explain Newton's
method and how you use it uh you can use
it to solve nonlinear
equations that's impressive uh that's
that's really good I mean I'm very
impressed by that especially since my
class is called nonlinear
equations all right now somebody tell me
something I don't already know anyone
buer anyone
fer um Newton Stolle it
I'm sorry Newton stole
it Joseph rafson published the same
method 50 years
earlier if the start value is too far
remove from true zero then it fails I'm
sorry what's your name uh Ben Ben
Campbell Ben so Ben Campbell suggests
that Joseph rafson was the original
author of this method well if that's the
case then why didn't he get any credit
well for one thing Newton had a better
publicist and for another after 1700 we
know very little about rapson other than
the fact that he discovered the cabala
about 300 years before
Madonna all right now let's give Ben a
chance for some extra credit shall we
we're going to call this um the game
show host problem all right Ben suppose
you're on a game show and you are given
a chance to choose from three different
doors all right now behind one of the
doors is a new car behind the other two
goats which door would you choose
Ben um door number one door number
number one Ben chooses door number one
all right now the game show host who by
the way knows what's behind all the
other doors decides to open another door
let's say he chooses door number three
behind which sits a goat now then game
show host comes up to you he says Ben do
you want to stay with door number one or
go with door number two now is it in
your interest to switch your choice yeah
well wait remember the host knows where
the car is so how do you know he's not
playing a trick on you trying to use
reverse psychology to get you to pick a
goat well I wouldn't really care I mean
my answer is based on statistics based
on variable
change variable change would you just
asked you a simple question yeah which
just changed
everything Enlighten us well when I was
originally asked to choose a door I had
a
33.3% chance of choosing right but after
he opens one of the doors and then re
offers me the choice it's now
66.7% if I choose to switch so yeah I'll
take door number two and thank you for
the extra
33.3% exactly people remember if you
don't know which door to open always
account for variable change now see most
people wouldn't take the switch out of
paranoia fear emotions but Mr Campbell
he kept motions aside and let simple
math
get his ass into a brand new
car which is better than that goat
you've been driving on campus all right
everybody that's the end of the day
thank you very much your graded papers
are down here at the end you can pick
them up on your way out
[Music]
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)