JANGAN MENGAKU DEMOKRASI, TAPI MEMUPUK DINASTI!!
Summary
TLDRThe transcript discusses the rise of an individual from obscurity to the presidency due to democracy and reform, exemplified by 'Pak Jokowi.' It highlights the pride in the democratic process that allows a non-elite to lead. However, it also addresses concerns about the potential erosion of meritocracy and the influence of political engineering through surveys, which may undermine the integrity of democracy. The speaker criticizes the use of surveys for political gain and calls for academia to focus on preserving the moral and ethical foundations of democracy, rather than being swayed by partisan interests or surveys that may not reflect the true will of the people.
Takeaways
- đ The speaker reflects on the rise of Jokowi from obscurity to the presidency, highlighting the power of democracy and reform.
- đ The pride of the nation is emphasized due to the fact that someone who was not a general's child or a prominent figure could become president, a testament to the success of democracy and reform.
- đ€ Concerns are raised about Jokowi's handling of the Mahkamah Konstitusi case, which some believe undermines democracy by prioritizing his children over meritocracy.
- đïž The speaker criticizes the long-standing party leaders who are suddenly removed from the opportunity to run for higher office, suggesting a loss of meritocracy.
- đ The role of surveys as tools of political engineering is discussed, questioning the independence and funding sources of survey organizations.
- đ« The speaker calls for universities not to be disregarded or belittled in their role in expressing ideas and preserving democracy and moral integrity.
- đ The speaker expresses skepticism about the death of expertise and surveys, suggesting that academics are not trusted if their views do not align with certain beliefs.
- đ« There is a plea for universities to not be responsive to electoral pressures but to focus on saving democracy and moral integrity in Indonesia.
- đ€ The speaker recalls defending Jokowi in the past when there were no such controversies and expresses disappointment in the current situation.
- đŁïž The importance of academics focusing on ensuring that democracy runs fairly and ethically, as per the legal and ethical corridors, is emphasized.
Q & A
Who is being discussed as someone who rose from obscurity to become President?
-The person being discussed is Pak Jokowi, who was not well-known before 2014 but became the President of Indonesia.
What is the significance of Jokowi's rise to the presidency?
-Jokowi's rise to the presidency is significant as it represents the success of democracy and reform in Indonesia, allowing someone without a prominent background to become a leader.
What is the concern raised about Jokowi's leadership in relation to the Mahkamah Konstitusi case?
-The concern is that Jokowi's actions in the Mahkamah Konstitusi case might undermine democracy by prioritizing his offspring over meritocracy.
What is the issue with the political party leaders mentioned in the script?
-The issue is that long-serving party leaders are being replaced, potentially due to political engineering, which could be influenced by the President's children.
What is the role of surveys in the political context discussed in the script?
-Surveys are being used as a tool of political engineering, and there are concerns about their independence and the transparency of their funding.
Why is the integrity of experts and surveys being questioned in the script?
-The integrity is being questioned because experts and surveys are not always trusted if their findings do not align with certain political beliefs.
What is the concern about the influence of academic institutions on the electoral process?
-The concern is that academic institutions might be influencing the electoral process by not being neutral and potentially favoring certain political groups.
What is the call to action for academic institutions regarding democracy and morality?
-The call to action is for academic institutions to focus on ensuring that democracy runs fairly and ethically, rather than engaging in partisan politics.
What is the issue with the interference in campus activities as mentioned in the script?
-The issue is that there is interference and disruption when individuals or groups on campus try to express their opinions or make declarations, which is seen as a violation of free speech.
How does the script suggest that the academic community should respond to political pressures?
-The script suggests that the academic community should not be swayed by political pressures and should continue to express ideas that are crucial for preserving democracy and ethical standards.
Outlines
đ The Rise and Challenges of Jokowi's Presidency
This paragraph discusses the meteoric rise of Joko Widodo, commonly known as Jokowi, from an obscure figure to the President of Indonesia. It highlights the democratic process and the reforms that enabled someone without a prominent background to ascend to the presidency, which is seen as a source of national pride. However, the paragraph also points out the challenges Jokowi faces, particularly in relation to the Mahkamah Konstitusi case, which some perceive as undermining democracy and meritocracy. The paragraph raises concerns about the influence of political dynasties and the potential erosion of democratic values, as well as the role of surveys and political engineering in shaping public opinion and electoral outcomes.
đ Academic Perspectives on Democracy and Surveys
The second paragraph delves into the role of academics and their views on the state of democracy and the use of surveys as tools for political engineering. It touches on the skepticism towards surveys conducted by certain groups, particularly when they are not independent or when their findings do not align with the convictions of the academic community. The paragraph emphasizes the importance of maintaining the integrity of democracy and the moral standards expected from political actors. It also addresses the challenges faced by academics in expressing their opinions and the accusations of partisanship that can arise from their involvement in political discourse.
Mindmap
Keywords
đĄDemocracy
đĄReformasi
đĄMeritocracy
đĄPolitical Engineering
đĄSurvey
đĄMoralitas
đĄExpertise
đĄAcademic Freedom
đĄElectorate
đĄDynasty
đĄAcademics
Highlights
The rise of an individual from obscurity to the presidency due to democracy and reforms.
The pride of having a president who was not born into prominence or power.
The impact of democracy on allowing individuals from humble beginnings to achieve high office.
The role of political parties and the challenges they face in the democratic process.
Concerns about the prioritization of family members over meritocracy in political appointments.
The moral implications of political dynasties and their effects on democracy.
The use of surveys as tools for political engineering and their potential biases.
The importance of transparency in the funding and conduct of political surveys.
The decline of expertise and the distrust of experts who do not align with certain beliefs.
The death of surveys as a reliable tool due to manipulation and lack of trust.
The role of academia in preserving democracy and ethical standards.
The call for a fair and just democratic process in accordance with legal and ethical corridors.
The criticism of political interference in academic freedom and the expression of opinions.
The challenge of maintaining non-partisanship in a politically charged environment.
The potential for political bias in the representation of academic views and opinions.
The importance of academic freedom and the right to express dissenting views.
The need for a democratic process that is not influenced by political dynasties or favoritism.
Transcripts
[Musik]
orang yang dibesarkan oleh
demokrasi dari orang yang nothing
menjadi something menjadi presiden itu
kan pak
Jokowi Pak Jokowi itu siapa sih yang
kenal sebelum tahun
2014 enggak ada yang kenal tapi dia
kemudian atau Katakanlah sebelum tahun
2014 ya sebelum dia jadi Walikota
mungkin sangat sedikit orang kenal Pak
Jokowi tapi kemudian jadi walikota
itu kan karena demokrasi karena hasil
reformasi jadi
gubernur kita semua bangga bangga betul
bahwa ada orang yang dulunya tidak
dikenal bukan anak Jenderal bukan anak
tokoh besar bisa jadi presiden itu
kebanggaan itu hasil reformasi dan
demokrasi tapi kemudian
dia dinilai oleh banyak orang sekarang
dengan kasus Mahkamah Konstitusi itu
mencederai demokrasi dia
mendahulukan anaknya sehingga lalu
menghilangkan yang namanya meritokrasi
coba berapa ketua partai politik yang
sudah itu sudah berapa tahun ketua
partai politik itu pada ingin jadi
capres atau cawapres tiba-tiba hilang
kesempatan termasuk surveinya Bang
kodari sebentar ini belum selesai
artinya orang-orang yang sebenarnya
meniti karir begitu lama itu dikalahkan
dengan karena anak Jokowi
itu yang kemudian menjadi persoalan
moralitas gitu loh Nah tetapi
survei-survei tadi survei juga menjadi
tool of political engineering terutama
kalau pelaku surveinya itu Tim Sukses
konsultan makanya harus jelas ini harus
diklarifikasi sebenarnya ini mereka ini
tim-tim independen dibayar oleh siapa
independen atau tidak Makanya sekarang
ini kalau di erast itu The Death of
expertise matinya para pakar kami-kami
ini kadang-kadang enggak dipercaya kalau
enggak sesuai dengan keyakinan mereka
sekarang juga terjadi in the death of
survey Kalau tidak ada masalah saya
yakin orang kampus juga tidak akan cari
masalah tidak akan menyampaikan seperti
itu Jadi tolong kampus ini jangan
eh direspon secara make signal ya di
satu sisi diremehkan suaranya enggak
terlalu penting terhadap elektoral malah
menurunkan kelompok elektoral tert
enggak ada urusan kalangan akademisi
tidak ada urusan dengan mau turun mau
naik itu yang dilakukan oleh mereka
hanya menyampaikan gagasan yang terkait
dengan menyelamatkan demokrasi dan
Indonesia dan kemudian juga
menyelamatkan moralitas demokrasi ini
jangan mengaku demokrasi tapi ternyata
adalah tadi memupuk dinasti dan
sebagainya itu nah sebentar Pak Prof
kalau misalnya ini interupsi aja biar
agak sebentar saya itu sudah terbiasa
untuk Anda interupsi dari dulu jadi
tolong sekalian ini jangan menginterupsi
saya kalau kalau dulu Anda kalau dulu
saya membela Pak Jokowi ketika belum ada
kasus-kasus seperti ini belakang makanya
dulu Pak Jokowi enggak pernah
ditertawakan tapi ketika sekarang anda
membela Pak Jokowi sekarang Pak Jokowi
jadi bahan tertahwaan di man B bang
Fadli lupa bahwa beliau ini pernah
dirjen di
kominfo ya gini gini pertanyaan saya itu
sederhana aja kalau misalnya ternyata
surveinya tuh yang lebih tinggi itu 03
atau 01 kira-kira akan ada enggak itu
tidak terus ter Kalau kami akademisi
sekarang ini tidak peduli dengan
persoalan survei biarlah yang kami
pedulikan adalah supaya demokrasi itu
bisa berjalan jujur dan adil itu saja
dan berlangsung sesuai dengan koridor
hukum maupun Etika itu yang kita minta
dari belasan tahun yang lalu Iya Ya
sudah kalau begitu Dar belasan tahun
lalu itu B saya menyuarakan kritik
ini anda saya bicara tadi dari anda
bicara tadi Saya enggak enggak ngomong
loh ya ya gini kalau memang kampus itu
dianggap seperti anda gak ada masalah
kenapa masih ada banyak kampus-kampus
itu juga diganggu ketika mau melakukan
deklarasi di kampus saya diganggu terus
terang di kampus saya diganggu
teman-teman saya itu mau mau apa mau
melakukan menyampaikan pendapat supaya
ada Katakanlah teguran moral atau etika
eh kami dikatakan sebagai ada yang
mengatakan langsung itu ada dan itu
Junior saya mengatakan kami partisan itu
ada yang partisan menuduh partisan belum
seperti itu belum selesai tiba-tiba ada
kelompok lain muncul yang diperbolehkan
juga ternyata dari grendra di di kampus
kami itu benar bukan orang kampus bukan
akademisi dalam artian sebagai warta
sebagai apa dosen dia hanya alumni yang
kebetulan juga satu partai dengan
anda dan menyuarakan hal yang berbeda
dengan
[Musik]
kami
Voir Plus de Vidéos Connexes
VICTORIA CIUDADANA GANĂ, PERO SE COMPORTĂ COMO LOS PARTIDOS TRADICIONALES - ÂżSon diferentes?
Arvind Kejriwal Jailed! | DICTATORSHIP Confirmed? |Â Dhruv Rathee
Presiden Joko Widodo...
KWN 8
Magisterial Lectures | Carmel V Abao PhD - Is Democracy the Solution or the Problem?
Topic 1.2 Types of Democracy AP Government OLD
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)