How To Write A Creative Brief? Example Chrysler, Planet Fitness & Moneyball

Summary

In this video, Julian Cole and Charlie Quark emphasize the importance of a clear problem statement in crafting a creative brief. They illustrate the significance through the movie 'Moneyball,' where Brad Pitt's character, Billy Beane, redefines the team's problem from merely replacing players to addressing the inherent unfairness in baseball's financial structure. The video uses examples from Chrysler's 'Imported from Detroit' campaign and Planet Fitness's approach to gym intimidation to demonstrate how identifying and articulating a meaningful problem can lead to breakthrough marketing strategies. A checklist for writing effective problem statements is provided, highlighting the need for external focus, clarity, emotional resonance, and the potential for positive change.

Takeaways

• 📝 A strong problem statement is crucial for a creative brief, as emphasized by Julian Cole and Charlie Quark.
• 🕒 Albert Einstein's quote underscores the importance of spending significant time understanding the problem before seeking solutions.
• 🎬 The Moneyball scene illustrates the difference between a good and bad problem statement, highlighting the need for clarity and depth.
• 🤔 Good problem statements should focus on broader, external issues rather than internal, trivial details.
• 🌟 Effective problem statements evoke emotional responses and feel meaningful, as seen in the arguments made by Billy Beane in Moneyball.
• 🚗 The 'Imported from Detroit' campaign by Chrysler addressed a significant problem perception in the US car market.
• 💪 Planet Fitness identified and solved the problem of gym intimidation, a barrier for potential gym-goers.
• 📋 A checklist for writing problem statements includes being externally focused, clear, evocative, and meaningful.
• 🔍 The video provides a framework for distinguishing between effective and ineffective problem statements in creative briefs.
• 💡 The script encourages viewers to subscribe for more content on strategy and creative brief writing.

Q & A

What is the significance of a problem statement in a creative brief?

A problem statement in a creative brief is crucial as it defines the unfavorable conditions that prevent the goal or objective from being achieved. It helps focus creativity, resources, and time effectively towards solving a real issue rather than wasting them on vague or trivial problems.

How did Albert Einstein's approach to problem-solving relate to the discussion on problem statements?

Albert Einstein's approach to spend the majority of time understanding the problem before seeking a solution emphasizes the importance of a clear and well-thought-out problem statement. It suggests that a deep understanding of the problem is essential before moving on to finding a creative solution.

What is the key takeaway from the Moneyball scene in relation to problem statements?

The key takeaway from the Moneyball scene is that a good problem statement should be externally focused, evoke an emotional response, be clear, and feel meaningful. It should not just focus on immediate, trivial details but should address the broader, underlying issue.

Why did the scouts' arguments in the Moneyball scene not make a good problem statement?

The scouts' arguments were not good problem statements because they were focused on trivial details and did not address the broader, systemic issue of talent assessment in baseball. They failed to evoke a sense of gravity or emotional response necessary for a compelling problem statement.

What elements made Billy Beane's argument in the Moneyball scene more engaging?

Billy Beane's argument was more engaging because it was externally focused, it evoked an emotional response by highlighting the unfairness of the game, it was crystal clear in stating the problem, and it felt meaningful as it addressed the core issue of team performance relative to financial resources.

How did Chrysler's 'Imported from Detroit' campaign address the problem statement?

Chrysler's 'Imported from Detroit' campaign addressed the problem statement by challenging the perception that imported cars were superior. It reframed the problem as one of quality and heritage, arguing that Detroit-made cars were worth buying, thus shifting the focus from the origin to the value and craftsmanship.

What was the problem statement that Planet Fitness identified in the gym category?

Planet Fitness identified the problem statement in the gym category as 'gym timidation,' which refers to the self-consciousness and intimidation that people feel in gym environments, leading to a reluctance to join or continue going to the gym.

Why is it important for a problem statement to evoke an emotional response?

A problem statement that evokes an emotional response is important because it engages stakeholders more deeply, making the problem feel more real and urgent. This emotional connection can drive more effective and creative solutions.

What are the characteristics of a good problem statement according to the script?

A good problem statement is externally focused, clear, evocative, and meaningful. It should address a problem of the world, not just an individual's or company's, and should be compelling enough to drive positive change.

How can the checklist for writing problem statements help in creative brief writing?

The checklist for writing problem statements helps in creative brief writing by providing a framework to ensure that the problem being addressed is well-defined, relevant, and impactful. It guides the writer to focus on the broader context and emotional resonance of the problem, leading to more effective and creative solutions.

Outlines

00:00

📝 The Essence of a Problem Statement in Creative Briefs

This paragraph emphasizes the critical role of a well-defined problem statement in crafting a creative brief. It introduces the concept with a quote from Albert Einstein, highlighting the importance of understanding the problem before seeking solutions. Julian Cole and Charlie Quark are mentioned as guides to illustrate the significance of a clear problem statement using examples from Chrysler and Planet Fitness. The paragraph discusses how a problem statement should not just identify challenges but also be externally focused, emotionally evocative, and meaningful to drive positive change. A scene from the movie 'Moneyball' is referenced to differentiate between a good and bad problem statement, where the character Billy Beane's argument is analyzed for its effectiveness in addressing the broader issue of team replacement in baseball, rather than focusing on trivial details.

Keywords

💡Creative Brief

A creative brief is a document that outlines the objectives, target audience, and other essential elements of a marketing or advertising campaign. It serves as a roadmap for creative teams to develop ideas and solutions. In the video, the creative brief is emphasized as a critical tool for ensuring that a project's challenges are clearly defined and addressed, which can save resources and time.

💡Problem Statement

A problem statement is a concise description of the issue that needs to be solved. It is a fundamental part of a creative brief, focusing on the unfavorable conditions that prevent the achievement of a goal or objective. The video underscores the importance of a clear problem statement as a key to effective creative work, using examples from Chrysler and Planet Fitness to illustrate how a well-defined problem statement can lead to breakthrough campaigns.

💡Albert Einstein

Albert Einstein is referenced in the video to highlight the importance of spending time understanding a problem before seeking solutions. The quote attributed to him emphasizes the need for deep reflection on the nature of the problem, which is a crucial step in the creative process. This aligns with the video's theme of the problem statement's role in creative work.

💡Moneyball

The movie 'Moneyball' is used as a context to illustrate the difference between a good and a bad problem statement. In the video, a scene from the movie is analyzed to show how Brad Pitt's character, Billy Beane, identifies the core issue of the team's situation, which is not just about replacing players but understanding the underlying unfairness in the game of baseball. This example is used to demonstrate the power of a clear and meaningful problem statement.

💡Externally Focused

An externally focused problem statement looks beyond the immediate circumstances and considers the broader context or market conditions. In the video, it is mentioned as a quality of a good problem statement, which helps in identifying the real challenges that a brand or product faces in the external world, rather than just internal concerns.

💡Evocative

An evocative problem statement is one that stirs emotions and resonates with the audience. The video explains that a good problem statement should not just be clear and concise but also emotionally engaging. This helps in creating a connection with the audience and motivates them to take action.

💡Meaningful

A meaningful problem statement is one that has significance and can lead to positive change. The video emphasizes that a problem statement should not only identify the issue but also suggest the potential for creating a meaningful impact, which can inspire creativity and drive the development of effective solutions.

💡Chrysler's 'Imported from Detroit' Campaign

Chrysler's 'Imported from Detroit' campaign is mentioned as an example of a successful marketing strategy that stemmed from a clear understanding of the problem. The campaign addressed the perception that imported cars were superior, by highlighting the quality and heritage of American-made cars, thus turning a negative perception into a positive brand message.

💡Planet Fitness

Planet Fitness is used as an example to show how understanding the real problem (gym intimidation) led to a successful marketing strategy. Instead of focusing on motivating people to go to the gym, Planet Fitness addressed the fear and self-consciousness that many potential gym-goers feel, which is a more nuanced and effective approach to the problem.

💡Checklist

A checklist in the context of the video refers to a set of criteria or guidelines that help in crafting an effective problem statement. The video provides a checklist for writing problem statements, which includes being externally focused, clear, evocative, and meaningful. This checklist serves as a tool for ensuring that the problem statement is well-crafted and sets the stage for a successful creative project.

Highlights

A clear problem statement is crucial for a creative brief.

Albert Einstein's quote emphasizes the importance of understanding the problem before seeking solutions.

Julian Cole and Charlie Quark demonstrate the significance of a problem statement with examples from Chrysler and Planet Fitness.

A problem statement should describe the conditions preventing the achievement of a goal or objective.

A scene from the movie 'Moneyball' illustrates the difference between a good and bad problem statement.

Billy Beane's character in 'Moneyball' highlights the need to address the unfairness in baseball talent assessment.

The scouts in 'Moneyball' focus on trivial details, whereas Beane sees the bigger picture.

A good problem statement should be externally focused, evoking an emotional response and be meaningful.

Chrysler's 'Imported from Detroit' campaign addresses the problem of perception about domestic cars.

Planet Fitness identified the problem of gym intimidation rather than laziness as a barrier to gym attendance.

The 'No Lunges' campaign by Planet Fitness addresses the self-consciousness people feel in gym environments.

A checklist for writing problem statements includes being externally focused, clear, evocative, and meaningful.

Overcoming a problem statement should lead to positive change in the world.

The video offers a checklist for writing effective problem statements.

Julian Cole invites viewers to subscribe for more on strategy.

Charlie Quark suggests watching another video for a breakdown on creative brief writing.

Transcripts

one of the most important elements in

writing a creative brief is a rock-solid

problem statement Albert Einstein

famously said if I had an hour to solve

a problem I'd spend 55 minutes thinking

about the problem and five minutes

thinking about the solution hi I'm

Julian Cole and along with Charlie quark

we want to show you how clear problem

statement is a key to a creative brief

with examples from Chrysler and Planet

Fitness without bringing rigor to codify

your key challenges a project can waste

a lot of creativity money and most

importantly time a problem statement

describes the unfavorable conditions

that prevent the goal or objective from

being achieved today we'll look at how a

scene from the movie Moneyball can help

us distinguish a good problem statement

from a bad one for context this is the

scene where Brad Pitt's character Billy

Beane is meeting with the team scouting

staff to discuss how to replace players

that have left for other teams look

Billy we all understand what the problem

is we have to perfectly what's the

problem the problem is we have to

replace three key players and are no I

know what's the problem Sam has ever

been we've got to replace these guys

with what we have exist know what's the

problem Barry we need 38 home runs 120

RBIs and 40 the problem we're trying to

solve is that there are rich teams and

there are poor teams then there's 50

feet of crap and then there's us it's an

unfair game what might be an argument so

effective how did he bring a sense of

gravity to the task of assessing

baseball talent first let's consider the

arguments of the other Scouts in the

same

while each scout described a real

challenge they were focused only on the

trivial details of their own situation

beans argument contains several elements

that made it more engaging it was

externally focused it evoked an

emotional response it was crystal clear

and a felt meaningful taking this model

to the ad world some of the best

campaigns have broken through by playing

off worthwhile problems for the US car

category they thought the problem was

that people preferred imported cars

because they were cheap Chrysler's

imported from Detroit campaign came in

response to the strategy understanding

the problem that people thinking that

anything comes from Detroit is not worth

buying at hard work - fiction and the

know-how that runs generations deep

every last one of us

[Music]

that's for the gym category a lot of

marketers assume that the problem for

gyms was that people are too lazy to go

to gyms they needed to motivate them

however Planet Fitness understood that

people feel self-conscious about the

environments of gym which led to the

problem of gym timid ation repels those

who can benefit from going to the gym

the most well Jessica we're not a gym no

gym timid ation no lungs unlimited

fitness training just ten dollars a

month we're not a gym her plan of

fitness

we hope this was helpful in helping you

identify and solve meaty creative

problems here's a checklist for writing

problem statements a good problem

statement is externally focused a

problem of the world not yours alone

it's clear it cuts through the

extraneous evocative it evokes an

emotional response meaningful over

coming out will create positive change

in the world if you're interested in

learning more about strategy subscribe

to my channel if you're interested in

more on creative brief writing you can

check out the video where I break down

the brief for seamless