Callido Argument Mapping Extension

Callido Learning

22 Apr 202003:04

Summary

TLDRThis video tutorial introduces the Argument Mapping Extension from Caldo, a tool for visualizing arguments. It explains the components of an argument map, including conclusions, premises, factual evidence, and opposing claims. The video demonstrates how to use the browser extension to create an argument map by gathering supporting and opposing evidence from various online sources, highlighting the tool's ability to automatically record the source and access date, and to synthesize information to understand relationships between different pieces of evidence.

Takeaways

📊 Argument Mapping is a method to visually organize and understand arguments, with a conclusion, premises, evidence, and opposing claims.
📝 The green box in an argument map represents the conclusion, which is the main point or thesis being argued.
🔵 Blue boxes are used for premises, which are the supporting statements leading to the conclusion.
🔲 Gray boxes contain factual evidence that backs up the premises.
🟠 Orange elements represent opposing claims, which challenge the main argument presented.
🌐 Blue dashed lines indicate unstated or hidden premises that are not explicitly mentioned but are assumed in the argument.
🛠️ The browser extension allows users to create and label their own argument maps, helping to organize thoughts and research.
🔍 Users can add supporting premises to their map by selecting text from sources that agree with their conclusion, along with the source and date of access.
📌 Hidden premises can be added by right-clicking and noting them as assumptions within the argument map.
🔄 Similarly, opposing claims can be added from different sources, providing a counterpoint to the argument and including source and access date.
🔗 The tool's benefit lies in its ability to synthesize information from various sources, helping users to see how different pieces of information relate to one another.

Q & A

What is an argument map according to the video?
-An argument map is a visual tool used to represent and organize the structure of an argument, including conclusions, premises, factual evidence, opposing claims, and hidden premises.
What color represents the conclusion in an argument map?
-The conclusion in an argument map is represented by a green box.
What are the blue boxes in an argument map used for?
-The blue boxes in an argument map are used to represent the premises that support the conclusion of the argument.
What information does the gray box in an argument map contain?
-The gray box in an argument map contains factual evidence that supports the premises of the argument.
What is indicated by the orange elements in an argument map?
-The orange elements in an argument map represent opposing claims, which are arguments that counter the main view presented.
What do the blue dashed lines signify in the argument map?
-The blue dashed lines in an argument map signify unstated or hidden premises that are not explicitly mentioned but are assumed in the argument.
How does the browser extension help in creating an argument map?
-The browser extension allows users to label and organize their argument maps, add supporting premises, hidden assumptions, and opposing claims from various online sources directly into the map.
What is the benefit of using the browser extension for argument mapping?
-The browser extension helps in automatically recording the source and date of access for each piece of information added to the argument map, facilitating the synthesis and organization of arguments.
Can the browser extension be used to add information from any online source?
-Yes, the browser extension can be used to add information from any online source by snipping text and adding it as a supporting premise, hidden assumption, or opposing claim in the argument map.
How does the extension handle the information once it is added to the argument map?
-Once information is added to the argument map using the extension, it captures the text snippet, the source of the information, and the date it was accessed, organizing it under the appropriate category in the map.
What is an example of a conclusion presented in the video script for an argument map?
-An example of a conclusion in the video script is that dating apps may see a revenue spike during economic distress.
What is the example topic discussed in the video for creating an argument map using the browser extension?
-The example topic discussed in the video is how technology can be used to improve contact tracing and slow down the pandemic.

Outlines

00:00

📊 Argument Mapping Extension Overview

This paragraph introduces the concept of an argument map, a tool for visualizing arguments, using an example about industries experiencing revenue growth during an economic recession. The argument map consists of a conclusion, premises, factual evidence, and opposing claims. The speaker explains the use of a browser extension from 'caldo' to create an argument map, emphasizing the ability to label and organize information from various sources into supporting premises, hidden premises, and opposing claims. The extension automatically records the source and date of access, facilitating the synthesis of arguments.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Argument Mapping

Argument mapping is a visual method used to organize and understand the structure of an argument. In the video, it is used to break down the components of a claim, such as premises and conclusions, and to visually represent how they connect. The process involves creating a map with boxes for different parts of the argument and lines to indicate the logical flow between them.

💡Conclusion

In the context of argument mapping, a conclusion is the main point or the final statement that the person making the argument is trying to prove. In the video, the conclusion is about the potential for dating apps to see a revenue spike during economic distress, serving as the central claim that the premises aim to support.

💡Premises

Premises are the statements or facts that lead to the conclusion in an argument. They are the reasons or evidence that support the conclusion. In the video, the premises are the blue boxes that provide the foundation for the conclusion about the increase in revenue for dating apps during a recession.

💡Factual Evidence

Factual evidence refers to information or data that can be verified and is used to support the premises of an argument. In the video, the gray boxes represent factual evidence that backs up the premises, such as statistics or research findings that support the argument about technology improving contact tracing.

💡Opposing Claim

An opposing claim is a statement that challenges or contradicts the main argument. It presents an alternative view or evidence that may weaken the argument. In the video, the orange elements represent opposing claims that counter the argument about the benefits of using technology for contact tracing during a pandemic.

💡Unstated or Hidden Premises

Unstated or hidden premises are assumptions that are not explicitly stated but are necessary for the argument to hold. They are implicit beliefs or facts that support the premises. In the video, the blue dashed lines represent these hidden premises, which are noted as assumptions that the user adds to the argument map.

💡Browser Extension

A browser extension is a software component that adds functionality to a web browser. In the video, the browser extension is used to create and manage argument maps. It allows users to label and organize their arguments, add supporting evidence, and note hidden premises directly from web sources.

💡Supporting Premise

A supporting premise is a piece of evidence or reasoning that directly backs up the main argument. In the video, the user finds a snippet of text that supports the claim about technology improving contact tracing and adds it to the argument map as a supporting premise, which includes the source and date of access.

💡Contact Tracing

Contact tracing is a public health procedure used to track and monitor people who may have been exposed to a contagious disease. In the video, the user's argument is focused on how technology can be adapted to improve this process and slow down the spread of a pandemic.

💡Pandemic

A pandemic refers to an outbreak of a disease that occurs over a wide geographic area and affects an exceptionally high proportion of the population. In the video, the context of the argument is set within a pandemic scenario, where the use of technology for contact tracing is discussed as a means to mitigate the spread of the disease.

💡Synthesis

Synthesis in the context of argument mapping refers to the process of combining different pieces of information to form a coherent understanding. The video describes how the browser extension tool helps users synthesize arguments by organizing and relating different snippets of information from various sources to build a comprehensive view of the topic.

Highlights

Introduction to the argument mapping extension from Caldo.

Explanation of what an argument map is and its purpose.

Visual representation of an argument with different colored boxes for various components.

Identification of the green box as the conclusion in an argument map.

Description of blue boxes as premises that lead to the conclusion.

Mention of gray boxes containing factual evidence supporting premises.

Orange elements representing opposing claims against the main argument.

Blue dashed lines indicating unstated or hidden premises.

Demonstration of how to use the browser extension to build an argument map.

Creating a new map and labeling it for a specific topic.

Searching the internet for sources to back up a claim in the argument map.

Adding supporting premises from snippets found in sources.

Automatic capture of text, source, and date when adding to the map.

Adding hidden premises by right-clicking and noting them in the map.

Incorporating opposing claims from different sources into the argument map.

The benefit of synthesizing arguments and seeing how information relates.

Overview of the tool's utility in reading and organizing information from various sources.