Economic Systems & the Labor Market: Crash Course Sociology #29

Summary

This script explores the evolution of economies, from the agrarian revolution to the industrial and information revolutions, highlighting the shift from self-sufficiency to complex economic sectors. It delves into capitalism and socialism, discussing their impacts on society, including economic inequality and the role of labor unions. The summary also touches on the current information revolution's effects on jobs and the global influence of corporations, setting the stage for ongoing economic changes.

Takeaways

• 🌐 The economy is a social institution that organizes production, consumption, and trade, and is fundamentally about people, not just numbers.
• 📈 Economies can be categorized into three sectors: primary (extracting raw materials), secondary (manufacturing), and tertiary (services).
• 🏛️ The agrarian revolution marked the first major economic shift, allowing for surplus production and leading to permanent settlements and trade networks.
• 🏭 The industrial revolution introduced new economic tools like steam engines and mass production, transforming work and increasing productivity but also creating economic inequality.
• 👷 Labor unions emerged to address the working conditions and economic disparities caused by the industrial revolution, advocating for minimum wages and worker protections.
• 💡 Capitalism is characterized by private ownership and profit-seeking competition, with the 'Invisible Hand' concept suggesting market self-regulation by consumers.
• 🏛️ Socialism emphasizes collective ownership and meeting basic needs over individual profit, with the government playing a significant role in production and distribution.
• 🌐 The information revolution represents the current economic shift, moving from a manufacturing-based economy to one focused on services and idea production.
• 📊 The primary and secondary labor markets differentiate jobs based on benefits, income, and job security, with the primary market offering more advantages.
• 📊 The service industry now dominates the US economy, with 85% of jobs falling under the tertiary sector, reflecting a post-industrial society.
• 🌐 Corporations, as legal entities with separate liabilities, are increasingly operating globally, indicating that future economic developments will be influenced by international factors.
• 🔮 While the future of economic models is uncertain, the current landscape is shaped by both capitalism and socialism, with technology and global corporations playing key roles.

Q & A

What is the primary sector in the economy?

The primary sector of the economy is responsible for extracting raw materials from natural environments, including activities like farming and mining.

How does the secondary sector differ from the primary sector?

The secondary sector takes the raw materials provided by the primary sector and transforms them into manufactured goods, unlike the primary sector which focuses on extraction.

What is the role of the tertiary sector in an economy?

The tertiary sector involves the provision of services rather than the production of goods, encompassing activities such as administration, education, and healthcare.

What was the significance of the agrarian revolution in economic history?

The agrarian revolution marked a shift to a more productive agricultural economy, allowing for the creation of surpluses, the development of permanent settlements, trade networks, and population growth.

What were the key innovations of the industrial revolution in the 1800s?

The industrial revolution introduced new economic tools such as steam engines, manufacturing processes, and mass production, which significantly changed the nature of work and increased overall productivity.

What problems did the industrial revolution create for workers?

The industrial revolution led to poor working conditions for many workers, including dangerous environments and low wages, particularly for women and children.

What is the role of labor unions in improving worker conditions?

Labor unions were formed to collectively bargain for better wages and working conditions, leading to the establishment of minimum wage laws, reasonable working hours, and workplace safety regulations.

How does capitalism differ from socialism in terms of ownership and economic goals?

Capitalism is characterized by private ownership of resources and production means, with an emphasis on profit and competition. Socialism, on the other hand, involves collective ownership and focuses on meeting basic needs and collective goals over individual profit.

What are the potential downsides of a purely capitalist economy?

A purely capitalist economy can lead to market failures such as monopolies, income inequality, and inefficient allocation of goods and services without government intervention.

What is the 'invisible hand' concept in capitalism as described by Adam Smith?

The 'invisible hand' concept suggests that in a capitalist economy, if left unregulated, consumers will naturally select goods and services that provide the best value, thereby regulating the market themselves.

How has the information revolution impacted the economy and labor market?

The information revolution has reduced the role of human labor in manufacturing and shifted the economy towards service work and the production of ideas. It has also led to automation of jobs and a decline in union membership.

What are the characteristics of jobs in the primary labor market?

Jobs in the primary labor market offer high incomes, job security, health insurance, and retirement packages, and are typically white-collar professions such as doctors, accountants, or engineers.

What is the current dominant sector in the US economy in terms of job composition?

The tertiary sector, or the service industry, makes up 85% of jobs in the US, indicating a shift from primary and secondary sectors to service-based occupations.

Outlines

00:00

🌐 The Economic Impact on Society

This paragraph delves into the significance of the economy as a social institution, emphasizing its human aspect beyond mere numbers. It explains the economy's role in organizing production, consumption, and trade, and introduces different economic systems like capitalism and socialism. The paragraph outlines the three sectors of an economy: primary (raw material extraction), secondary (manufacturing), and tertiary (services). It also touches on the historical progression from agrarian to industrial economies, highlighting the agrarian revolution's introduction of farming, surpluses, and societal developments, as well as the industrial revolution's impact on work, productivity, and economic inequality. The discussion of economic revolutions leads to the mention of labor unions and their influence on modern labor laws and protections.

05:03

🏭 Economic Models and the Information Revolution

The second paragraph explores the contrasting economic models of capitalism and socialism, detailing their principles, historical context, and practical implications. Capitalism is characterized by private ownership and profit-driven competition, with Adam Smith's 'Invisible Hand' theory explained. The paragraph points out the need for government intervention to prevent market failures like monopolies. Socialism, with collective ownership and a focus on meeting basic needs, is contrasted with capitalism's income inequality. The discussion includes the historical performance of socialist and capitalist countries and the role of labor unions in shaping economic policies. The paragraph concludes with the ongoing information revolution, describing its effects on labor, job displacement due to technology, and the shift towards a service and idea-based economy. It also provides an overview of the current economic landscape, with a focus on the tertiary sector, and discusses the primary and secondary labor markets, concluding with the global influence of corporations on economies.

Keywords

💡Economy

The economy is the social institution that organizes all production, consumption, and trade of goods in a society. It is central to the video's theme as it discusses how economies have evolved and their impact on society. The script mentions different economic systems such as capitalism and socialism, and how they influence the way people live.

💡Production Sectors

Production sectors refer to the primary, secondary, and tertiary sectors of an economy. The primary sector extracts raw materials, the secondary sector transforms these materials into manufactured goods, and the tertiary sector involves services. These sectors are key to understanding the economic structure discussed in the video.

💡Agrarian Revolution

The agrarian revolution marked the shift from hunter-gatherer societies to agricultural economies. It is a significant historical event mentioned in the script that led to the development of surpluses, permanent settlements, and trade networks, laying the foundation for more complex economic systems.

💡Industrial Revolution

The industrial revolution is the second major economic revolution discussed in the script, characterized by the rise of industry, steam engines, manufacturing, and mass production. It transformed work from home-based to factory-based labor, leading to increased productivity and new economic challenges.

💡Capitalism

Capitalism is an economic system where natural resources and means of production are privately owned, emphasizing profit-seeking and competition. The script explains how capitalism operates on the 'Invisible Hand' principle, where market forces drive efficiency, but also notes its potential for market failures and economic inequality.

💡Socialism

Socialism is presented as an alternative economic model to capitalism, where the means of production are under collective ownership and the focus is on collective goals and meeting basic needs. The script contrasts socialism with capitalism, discussing its emphasis on equality and the historical challenges of implementing socialist principles.

💡Labor Unions

Labor unions are organizations of workers that seek to improve wages and working conditions through collective action. The script discusses how unions formed in response to the harsh conditions of the industrial revolution and contributed to the establishment of minimum wage laws and workplace safety regulations.

💡Information Revolution

The information revolution is the current economic revolution, characterized by the shift from a manufacturing-based economy to one based on service work and the production of ideas. The script highlights how technology has reduced the role of human labor and reshaped the job market.

💡Primary Labor Market

The primary labor market consists of jobs that offer high incomes, job security, and benefits such as health insurance and retirement packages. The script uses this concept to differentiate between types of jobs based on social status and compensation within the tertiary sector.

💡Secondary Labor Market

The secondary labor market includes lower-skilled jobs and lower-level service sector jobs that offer fewer benefits, lower pay, and less job security. The script contrasts this with the primary labor market to illustrate the disparities in job quality and worker benefits.

💡Corporations

Corporations are legal entities with liabilities separate from their members, operating across national boundaries. The script suggests that corporations play a key role in the global economic landscape, indicating the international scale on which future economies will operate.

Highlights

The economy is a social institution that organizes production, consumption, and trade, and is fundamentally made up of people.

Economic systems like capitalism and socialism shape the way people live their lives.

Economies are divided into three sectors: primary (extraction of raw materials), secondary (manufacturing), and tertiary (services).

The agrarian revolution marked the first major economic change, leading to surpluses and societal developments like permanent settlements and trade networks.

The industrial revolution introduced new economic tools and mass production, significantly changing work dynamics and living standards.

Economic revolutions often come with casualties, such as poor working conditions and economic inequality during the industrial revolution.

Labor unions emerged to address economic inequality and improve working conditions through collective action.

Capitalism is characterized by private ownership and profit-seeking, with competition driving efficiency.

Socialism emphasizes collective ownership and meeting basic needs over individual profit, with the government playing a significant role.

Market failures, such as monopolies, can lead to inefficient economic allocations and may require government intervention.

The information revolution is the current economic shift, moving from a manufacturing-based to a service and idea-based economy.

Technological advancements have reduced the role of human labor and impacted job landscapes, with a decline in union membership.

The service industry now dominates the US economy, comprising 85% of jobs and including a diverse range of professions.

Sociological distinctions are made between the primary and secondary labor markets based on social status, compensation, and job security.

Corporations, as legal entities with separate liabilities, increasingly operate across national boundaries, impacting global economic landscapes.

The future of economies, including the US, will be influenced by global dynamics and the evolving role of corporations.

Crash Course Sociology is made possible by a team of contributors and the support of patrons on Patreon.

Transcripts

A social institution that has one of the biggest impacts on society is the economy.

And you might think of the economy in terms of numbers – unemployment numbers, GDPs, or whatever the stock market is doing today.

But while we often talk about it in numerical terms, the economy is really made of people!

It’s the social institution that organizes all production, consumption, and trade of goods in a society.

And there are lots of different ways in which stuff can be made, exchanged, and used.

Think capitalism, or socialism.

These economic systems – and the economic revolutions that created them – shape the way that people live their lives.

[Theme Music]

Economies can vary a lot from one society to the next, but in any given economy, you can typically see production split into three sectors.

The primary sector extracts raw materials from natural environments – so, workers like farmers or miners would fit well here.

The secondary sector takes raw materials and transforms them into manufactured goods.

So, someone in the primary sector may extract oil from the earth, but someone in the secondary sector refines the petroleum into gasoline.

And then the tertiary sector is the part of the economy that involves services rather than goods.

You know, doing things, rather than making things.

But, this system is actually pretty complicated.

Or at least, more sophisticated than the way things used to be for much of human history.

So, how did we get from a world where people worked to produce just what they needed for their families, to one with all these sectors that have to work together?

To understand that, we need to back up a little – about 12,000 years.

The first big economic change was the agrarian revolution.

When people first learned how to domesticate plants and animals,

it ushered in a new agricultural economy that was much more productive than hunter-gatherer societies were.

Farming helped societies build surpluses, which meant not everyone had to spend their time producing food.

This, in turn, led to major developments like permanent settlements, trade networks, and population growth.

Now, let’s go to the Thought Bubble to discuss the second major economic revolution: the industrial revolution of the 1800s.

With the rise of industry came new economic tools, like steam engines, manufacturing, and mass production.

Factories popped up, changing how work functioned.

Now, instead of working at home, where people worked for their family by making things from start to finish,

they began working as wage laborers and becoming more specialized in their skills.

Overall productivity went up, standards of living rose, and people had access to a wider variety of goods thanks to mass production – all good things.

But every economic revolution comes with economic casualties.

The workers in the factories – who were mainly poor women and children – worked in dangerous conditions for low wages.

There’s a reason that the industrialists of the 19th century were known as robber barons:

with more productivity came greater wealth, but also greater economic inequality.

So, in the late 19th century, labor unions began to form.

These organizations of workers sought to improve wages and working conditions through collective action, strikes, and negotiations.

Inspired by Marxist principles, labor unions are partly to thank for us now having things like minimum wage laws,

reasonable working hours, and regulations to protect the safety of workers.

Thanks Thought Bubble.

So, the industrial revolution was an incredibly big deal, when it came to the changes that it brought to both economies and societies.

And there’s a third revolution we should talk about too – one that’s happening right now.

But before we get to that, we should pause and explore two competing economic models that sprung up around the time of the industrial revolution,

as economic capital became more and more important to the production of goods.

Pretty sure you’ve heard of them!

And possibly have strong opinions about them!

They’re capitalism and socialism.

Capitalism is a system in which all natural resources and means of production are privately owned.

And it emphasizes profit-seeking and competition as the main drivers of efficiency.

If you own a business, you need to out-perform your competitors if you're going to succeed.

So you’re incentivized to be more efficient – by improving the quality of your product, and reducing your prices.

This is what economist Adam Smith in the 1770s called the “Invisible Hand” of the market.

The idea is that if you just leave a capitalist economy alone, consumers will regulate things themselves, by selecting goods and services that provide the best value.

But, in practice, an economy doesn’t work very well if it’s left completely on auto-pilot.

There are lots of sectors where a hands-off approach can lead to what economists call “market failures,”

where an unregulated market ends up allocating goods and services inefficiently.

A monopoly, for example, is a kind of market failure.

When a company has no competition for customers, it can charge higher prices without worrying about losing customers.

That, as economic allocations go, is really inefficient, at least on the consumer end.

So, in situations like these, a government might step in and force the company to break up into smaller companies to increase competition.

Market failures like this are why most countries, the United States included, are not purely capitalist societies.

For example, the US federal and state governments own and operate a number of businesses, like schools, the Postal Service, and the military.

Governments also set minimum wages, create workplace safety laws, and provide social support programs like unemployment benefits and food stamps.

Government plays an even larger role, however, in socialism.

In a socialist system, the means of production are under collective ownership.

Socialism rejects capitalism’s private-property and hands-off approaches.

Instead, here, property is owned by the government and allocated to all citizens, not just those with the money to afford it.

Socialism emphasizes collective goals, expecting everyone to work for the common good, and placing a higher value on meeting everyone’s basic needs than on individual profit.

When Karl Marx first wrote about socialism, he viewed it as a stepping stone toward communism,

a political and economic system in which all members of a society are socially equal.

But of course, in practice, this hasn’t played out in the countries that have modelled their economies on socialism, like Cuba, North Korea, China, and the former USSR.

Why?

Well, Marx hoped that, as economic differences vanished in communist society, the government would simply wither away and disappear.

But, that never happened.

If anything, the opposite did.

Rather than freeing the proletariat from inequality, the massive power of the government in these

states gave enormous wealth, power, and privilege to political elites, retrenching inequalities along political – rather than strictly economic – lines.

At the same time, capitalist countries economically out-performed their socialist counterparts,

contributing to the unrest that eventually led to the downfall of the USSR.

Before the fall of the Soviet Union, the average output in capitalist countries was about $13,500 per person, which was almost three times that in the Soviet countries.

But there are downsides to capitalism, too – namely greater income inequality.

A study of European capitalist countries and socialist countries in the 1970s

found that the income ratio between the top 5% and the bottom 5% in capitalist countries was about 10:1, whereas in socialist countries it was 5:1.

We could fill whole episodes about the merits of each economic model – and in fact, we did in Crash Course World History.

There are many more questions we could answer about how societies build their economic systems.

But in any case, those two models aren’t the end of the story.

Because: we’re living in the middle of the economic revolution that followed the industrial revolution.

Ours is the time of the information revolution.

Technology has reduced the role of human labor, and shifted it from a manufacturing-based economy

to one based on service work and the production of ideas rather than goods.

And this has had a lot of residual effects on our economy.

Computers and other technologies are beginning to replace many jobs, by making it easier to either automate them or send them offshore.

And we’ve also seen a decline in union membership.

Nowadays, most unions are for public sector jobs, like teachers.

So what do jobs in a post-industrial society look like?

Well, agricultural jobs, which once were a massive part of the American labor force, have fallen drastically over the last century.

While 40% of the labor force was involved in the agricultural sector in 1900, only about 2% of workers today work in farming.

Similarly, manufacturing jobs, which were the lifeblood of the US economy for much of the 20th century, have also declined in the last 30 years.

So, the US economy began with many workers serving in either the primary and secondary economic sectors,

but now, much of the US economy is centered on the tertiary sector, or the service industry.

The service industry makes up 85% of jobs in the US,

including everything from administrative assistants to nurses to teachers to lawyers to everyone who made this Crash Course video for you.

Now, that’s a really big and diverse group.

That’s because the tertiary sector – like all the economic sectors we’ve been discussing

– is defined mainly by what it produces, rather than what kinds of jobs it includes.

So, sociologists have a way of distinguishing between types of jobs, based more on the social status and compensation that come with them:

There’s the primary labor market and the secondary labor market.

The primary labor market includes jobs that provide lots of benefits to workers, like high incomes, job security, health insurance and retirement packages.

These are white collar professions, like doctors or accountants or engineers.

Secondary labor market jobs provide fewer benefits and include lower-skilled jobs and lower-level service sector jobs.

They tend to pay less, have more unpredictable schedules, and typically don’t offer benefits like health insurance.

They also tend to have less job security.

So what’s next for capitalism, or socialism?

Well, no one knows what the next economic revolution is going to look like.

But I can tell you that, nowadays, a key part of both our economic and political landscape is corporations.

Corporations are defined as organizations that exist as legal entities and have liabilities that are separate from its members.

So, they’re their own things.

And more and more these days, corporations are operating across national boundaries,

which means that the future of the US economy – and most countries’ economies – will play out on a global scale.

Today we discussed how economies can be broken down into the primary, secondary, and tertiary sectors.

We discussed the three stages of economic revolution that brought us to the modern post-industrial era.

And in the middle there, we talked about two types of economic models: capitalism and socialism.

Crash Course Sociology is filmed in the Dr. Cheryl C. Kinney Studio in Missoula, MT, and it’s made with the help of all of these nice people.

Our animation team is Thought Cafe and Crash Course is made with Adobe Creative Cloud.

If you'd like to keep Crash Course free for everyone, forever, you can support the series at Patreon, a crowdfunding platform that allows you to support the content you love.

Thank you to all of our patrons for making Crash Course possible with their continued support.