Merrel Moab 3 Review: Budget Shoe or Better?
Summary
TLDRDans cette vidéo, Alan de dustyhackers.com teste la chaussure de randonnée Merrell Moab 3, souvent considérée comme un modèle économique. Il l'évalue sur des critères tels que la traction, la protection, la stabilité et le confort, la comparant à d'autres modèles plus chers. Bien qu'elle soit la moins chère des chaussures testées, à environ 100 dollars, elle offre un bon rapport qualité-prix avec des matériaux recyclés et une confortabilité satisfaisante. Cependant, il souligne que d'autres chaussures offrent une meilleure stabilité, protection et traction, mais reconnaît que pour une randonnée de jour ou pour les débutants, le Merrell Moab 3 est une option intéressante.
Takeaways
- 👟 La chaussure Merrell Moab 3 est souvent considérée comme une chaussure de randonnée à faible coût.
- 💰 Elle est la chaussure la moins chère testée, à environ cent dollars, tandis que les autres modèles coûtent 50 à 80 dollars de plus.
- 🏔️ L'auteur a testé cette année des chaussures de randonnée, en se concentrant sur la traction, la protection, la stabilité et le confort.
- 👍 L'un des points forts de la chaussure est son prix abordable, ce qui la rend attrayante même si d'autres modèles peuvent être seulement comparables.
- 🚀 La chaussure a toutes les caractéristiques attendues d'une chaussure de randonnée moderne, offrant un confort de marche sur de longues distances.
- 🌡️ Le design de la chaussure, combinant suède, étoffe et maille, conviendra à la plupart des gens et est adaptable à différentes conditions climatiques.
- 👣 La chaussure a une semelle Vibram TC5 Plus, qui essaie de faire tout, mais ne se distingue pas dans un domaine spécifique.
- 🔄 Certains points négatifs incluent la largeur de la chaussure, qui peut causer des plis au niveau du cou-de-pied et des lacets trop épais.
- 📊 En termes de stabilité, elle a obtenu la quatrième place sur cinq chaussures testées, ce qui ne signifie pas qu'elle est mauvaise, mais qu'il y a des modèles plus stables.
- ⛰️ Pour la traction, elle s'est classée à égalité avec deux autres modèles, mais deux autres ont offert une meilleure adhérence.
- 🛡️ En ce qui concerne la protection, bien que la semelle soit flexible, elle n'a pas offert la meilleure protection par rapport aux autres modèles testés.
- 👍 Le confort est un atout majeur de cette chaussure, offrant un bon rapport qualité-prix pour les randonneurs occasionnels ou débutants.
- 🌱 La chaussure contient beaucoup de matériaux recyclés, ce que l'auteur apprécie et encourage chez les autres fabricants de chaussures de randonnée.
Q & A
Le Merrell Moab 3 est-il juste une chaussure de randonnée à faible budget ou est-il une chaussure de randonnée adéquate capable de rivaliser avec d'autres chaussures de randonnée de qualité supérieure ?
-Le Merrell Moab 3 est considéré comme une chaussure de randonnée à faible budget, mais le testeur a intégré ce modèle dans son évaluation pour voir comment il se compare avec d'autres chaussures de randonnée plus chères. Bien que le Merrell Moab 3 soit le moins cher des modèles testés, il est équipé de fonctionnalités modernes et pourrait être une option adéquate pour de nombreuses personnes.
Combien coûte le Merrell Moab 3 par rapport aux autres chaussures de randonnée testées ?
-Le Merrell Moab 3 coûte environ cent dollars, tandis que les autres chaussures étaient au moins 50, 60, 70, voire 80 dollars de plus chères.
Quelles sont les catégories de critères utilisées pour évaluer les chaussures de randonnée dans le script ?
-Les critères utilisés pour évaluer les chaussures de randonnée sont la traction, la protection, la stabilité et le confort.
Quel est le principal avantage du Merrell Moab 3 mentionné dans le script ?
-Le principal avantage du Merrell Moab 3 est son coût abordable, étant le moins cher des chaussures testées.
Quels sont les aspects de confort du Merrell Moab 3 mentionnés dans le script ?
-Le confort du Merrell Moab 3 est attribué à son[midsole](https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Midsole) agréable, à son insole confortable, et à la combinaison de cuir fauve et de tissu de maille qui le rendent confortable pour la marche sur de longues distances.
Quel matériau est utilisé pour le revêtement supérieur du Merrell Moab 3 et comment cela affecte-t-il la sensation portée ?
-Le revêtement supérieur du Merrell Moab 3 est fait d'un mélange de cuir fauve et de tissu de maille, ce qui le rend confortable pour la plupart de l'année, possiblement un peu chaud en été et un peu froid en hiver.
Quelle est la conception du semelle extérieure du Merrell Moab 3 et quel en est le compromis ?
-Le semelle extérieure est un semelle Vibram appelée Vibram TC5 Plus, qui essaie de faire tout, mais ne fait rien extrêmement bien. Cependant, pour cent dollars, elle conviendra à la plupart des gens dans la plupart des scénarios de randonnée.
Quels sont les points négatifs mentionnés concernant le Merrell Moab 3 ?
-Les points négatifs mentionnés incluent une largeur qui cause un pliage au niveau du cou-de-pied, des lacets trop épais, et un tongue gorgé qui forme des rides lorsqu'il est serré.
Comment le Merrell Moab 3 s'est-il classé en termes de stabilité par rapport aux autres chaussures testées ?
-Le Merrell Moab 3 a obtenu la quatrième place en termes de stabilité parmi les cinq chaussures testées.
Quel est le test spécifique utilisé pour évaluer la traction des chaussures de randonnée et où se situe le Merrell Moab 3 dans ce test ?
-Le test de traction implique de porter chaque chaussure et de grimper un terrain raid et débris, pour évaluer la traction. Le Merrell Moab 3 a obtenu une troisième place, lié à deux autres chaussures, mais il y avait deux chaussures qui ont mieux performé.
Quelle est l'évaluation de la protection du Merrell Moab 3 et comment cela se compare-t-il aux autres chaussures testées ?
-Le Merrell Moab 3 a été jugé comme offrant une protection moyenne, avec un capuchon de pied bien conçu mais qui a perdu face à toutes les quatre autres chaussures testées en termes de protection sous le pied.
Quel est le poids des chaussures Merrell Moab 3 et comment cela se compare-t-il aux autres modèles testés ?
-Le Merrell Moab 3 pèse 17,56 onces, soit un peu plus d'une livre. Bien qu'il soit lourd, il y a d'autres chaussures qui offrent de meilleures performances et sont significativement plus légères.
Quelle est l'appréciation du testeur pour le matériau recyclé utilisé dans le Merrell Moab 3 ?
-Le testeur apprécie l'utilisation de matériaux recyclés dans le Merrell Moab 3, incluant les lacets, le tissu et la sangle intérieure, ce qui est composé de 100% de matériaux recyclés.
Quelle est la conclusion finale du testeur sur le Merrell Moab 3 ?
-Le testeur considère que le Merrell Moab 3 est une bonne chaussure compte tenu de son prix, mais il existe d'autres chaussures sur le marché qui offrent de meilleures performances.
Outlines
🥾 Évaluation de la chaussure de randonnée Merrell Moab 3
Dans ce paragraphe, le narrateur introduit le sujet de la vidéo : une évaluation de la chaussure de randonnée Merrell Moab 3, souvent considérée comme une chaussure de randonnée à faible budget. Il pose la question de savoir si cette chaussure est vraiment juste une option économique ou si elle peut rivaliser avec d'autres chaussures de randonnée de qualité supérieure. Le narrateur explique que chaque année, il achète et teste plusieurs paires de chaussures de randonnée, choisit celle qui lui semble la meilleure et partage ses conclusions avec les téléspectateurs. Cette année, il a inclus la Merrell Moab 3 dans son processus d'évaluation, notant qu'elle était la moins chère des chaussures testées, avec un coût d'environ cent dollars, bien inférieur aux autres qui coûtaient au moins cinquante à quatre-vingt dollars de plus. Il se concentre sur quatre catégories principales : traction, protection, stabilité et confort, et il va discuter des résultats de ces tests.
🤔 Analyse des performances de la Merrell Moab 3
Dans ce second paragraphe, le narrateur poursuit son analyse de la Merrell Moab 3 en se concentrant sur les aspects de stabilité, traction, protection et confort. Il a marché environ trente miles avec chaque paire de chaussures dans le cadre de son test, notant la performance sur des terrains plats et irréguliers. Il mentionne que la chaussure a obtenu la quatrième place sur cinq pour la stabilité, ce qui indique qu'il y a trois autres chaussures qui se sont mieux exécutées dans cette catégorie. Il discute également de la traction, où la Merrell Moab 3 a obtenu une troisième place partagée avec deux autres chaussures, mais il y a deux autres qui ont mieux performé. Le narrateur encourage les téléspectateurs à consulter une autre vidéo sur son canal pour découvrir les chaussures gagnantes. Il insiste sur le fait que, malgré son prix abordable, la chaussure offre un bon rapport qualité-prix et qu'elle est faite de matériaux recyclés, ce qui est apprécié. Cependant, il note que d'autres chaussures offrent une meilleure performance en termes de protection et de confort, et il conclut que, bien que la Merrell Moab 3 soit un excellent choix économique, d'autres options sur le marché pourraient être préférables pour des randonneurs plus expérimentés ou pour des voyages de randonnée plus longs et exigeants.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Merrell Moab 3
💡chaussure de randonnée
💡budget
💡traction
💡protection
💡stabilité
💡confort
💡Vibram
💡recycled material
💡évaluation comparative
Highlights
Alan from dustyhackers.com discusses the Merrell Moab 3, a shoe often considered a budget hiking option.
The Merrell Moab 3 was the cheapest shoe tested, priced at about a hundred dollars, compared to others costing 50-80 dollars more.
Alan has included the Merrell Moab 3 in his annual hiking shoe comparison, having previously tested other Merrell models.
The evaluation focused on four categories: traction, protection, stability, and comfort.
The Merrell Moab 3 is noted for its low cost, which is a significant selling point.
The shoe features modern elements such as a nice midsole, insole, and a mix of suede straps with a mesh underlay.
The Merrell Moab 3 is described as comfortable for long-distance walking.
The shoe's design is expected to satisfy many people, with a forgiving last that fits a variety of foot types.
The shoe has a Vibram TC5 Plus outsole, which attempts to offer versatility but doesn't excel in any one area.
Some design criticisms include the shoe's width, leading to buckling at the front when tightened.
Thick laces and a gusseted tongue that forms wrinkles when tightened are mentioned as design drawbacks.
In stability testing, the Merrell Moab 3 ranked fourth among the five shoes tested.
Merrell's air cushion design is intended for both comfort and stability but doesn't outperform more expensive options.
Traction testing showed the Merrell Moab 3 tied for third place, with two other shoes outperforming it.
Protection testing revealed the shoe's flexible Vibram sole and semi-soft toe cap, but it lost to other shoes in direct comparison.
Comfort and weight are praised, with the shoe being very comfortable but not the lightest option at 17.56 ounces.
The Merrell Moab 3 contains a significant amount of recycled material, which is commended.
Despite its lower price, there are other shoes that perform better in various categories.
Transcripts
hey welcome back to the channel Alan
here with dustyhackers.com today I'm
going to talk about a shoe that a lot of
people characterize as a budget hiking
shoe but is the Merrell Moab 3 actually
just a budget hiking shoe or is it a
proper hiking shoe that stands up
against the competition from other
really really good hiking shoes if
you're not new to the channel you know
that every year I buy a bunch of hiking
shoes and then I test those hiking shoes
against each other and pick the one that
I think is the best and then I share
that information with you all so this
year I included the Merrell Moab 3 in
that round of testing it was by far the
cheapest shoe that I purchased coming in
at about a hundred dollars the other
shoes were at least 50 60 70 even 80
dollars more expensive than this shoe
and so my question is is this 100 hiking
platform as good as those the Merrell
Moab 3 is a shoe that I've been
interested in testing for a long time in
the last two years that I've done this
it was a Merrell shoe that actually
wound up taking first place and so I was
excited to see how the flagship of
Merrell would stand up against some
other comparable shoes as in years past
this year I focused on basically four
different categories traction protection
stability and comfort and so I'm going
to go over the test results with you
right now and then talk about this shoe
and what it brings to the table and what
maybe it could do better obviously one
of the big selling points of the shoe is
the low cost it's only about a hundred
dollars and probably in the future this
price will come down even more and I
would say that is worth looking at this
shoe just for the price because you
could spend uh eighty dollars more and
get something that might even just be
comparable to this another thing I
really like about this shoe is that it
has all of the features that you would
expect in a modern low hiking shoe like
this does fairly well for Comfort it's
got a nice midsole it's got a nice
insole in it and so it's a shoe that
you're going to feel comfortable in
Walking for quite a long distance I also
like the uppers with the so they mix
this suede mat they mix this suede
straps with a mesh underlay and so it's
a shoe that's going to feel fine
probably hiking most of the year it
might be a little bit hot in the summer
but and then probably be too cold in the
winter but for the most part I think the
design on the shoe is going to satisfy a
lot of people another thing that I like
is that it's fairly forgiving uh last or
the the type of foot that is designed to
fit in the shoe I think a lot of people
are going to be able to wear this shoe
it has a Vibram outsole it's called the
Vibram tc5 plus it's an outsole that
kind of tries to do everything and so
consequently it doesn't do anything
extremely well but again for a hundred
dollars it's it's going to work for most
people in most hiking scenarios just a
couple things that I did not like about
this shoe one is that because it is
quite wide when you cinch down the shoe
like I have to you do get some kind of
buckling here in on top of the front of
the foot another thing that I didn't
really like is the laces are I feel like
are just too thick and then also the
gusseted tongue when you when you cinch
it down up here there's some like
wrinkles that will sort of form around
the tongue area I have a pretty normal
foot so I think that the shoe runs
pretty wide given the fact that I have
to cinch it down so much okay so how
does this shoe compare to the other
shoes on stability traction protection
and comfort so for stability uh with all
of the shoes I hiked about 30 miles in
the shoes here in Tuscany and and then I
just for stability I just kind of took
notes on how the shoe performs hiking on
flat even ground and also kind of
scampering off Trail and seeing how it
performs when you're going over uneven
terrain whether the shoe kind of has a
tendency to kind of torque on you which
for me means that my heel might kind of
be partially slipping out of the back of
the of the shoe this shoe of the five
shoes that I tested it got fourth place
for stability again that doesn't mean
that it's horrible at stability it just
means that there were three other shoes
that I tested that that performed better
are at stability and so if you want to
find out what you actually won my
competition this year go and check out
the video it's on my channel and that's
probably the shoe that if you want to
spend about fifty dollars more that's
the shoe that I would get Merrell's
design choice for stability is this
thing called Merrell air cushion which
is kind of supposed to be a thing for
comfort and also for stability again I
don't think that uh for a hundred
dollars you're going to be disappointed
but again there are shoes that are more
stable the next thing that I did in
testing was traction so for traction
again it was just time spent on trail
taking notes comparing the shoe to the
other shoes but I also put I did a test
a head-to-head test where I did 10
iterations of this or permutations where
I put a one shoe on one foot and then a
different shoe on the other and then I
scampered up this Steep Hill that was
dirt and debris and then just tried to
feel which shoe gave me more purchase
and more traction as I'm trying to claw
my way up this hill the murals didn't do
too bad they basically basically tied
for third place with two other shoes so
there were two shoes that actually
performed much better on traction than
this shoe again if you want to figure
out which shoes those are go and check
out that video where I test all five
shoes in and pick the winner it's like
best hiking shoes of of the Year hey
you're already halfway through this
video and so you've outperformed most
people that come to this video if you
want to help my channel out if you're
finding something interesting the best
thing that you could do for me right now
is to hit subscribe it takes you like
one second I am so close to a thousand
subscribers I can taste it the other
thing that you could do is just hit like
on the video if you're finding something
useful leave a comment down below did
you did you buy the Merrell Moab three
and if you did did you like it uh do you
think it's worth a hundred dollars maybe
it's not even worth a hundred dollars or
maybe it's uh maybe it is just a budget
hiking shoe and if you're really serious
about hiking you should buy something
else so let me know in the comments
below finally I have this shoe Linked In
the description so if you want to check
out the pricing that's another way that
you can help my channel is to go and get
it I purchase all of these shoes with my
own money and do all of this testing for
you so if you want to give something
back to me that would be a way to do
that finally I have a Blog
dustyhikers.com so if you want to go
check out more information on the shoe
and other shoes that I've tested you can
go check that as as well okay next up
for protection again this this Vibram
sole kind of tries to do it all which
means that it doesn't do anything
extremely well I would say that it is
very very flexible which for me is I I
prefer flexible over super rigid in a
hiking platform but for protection what
I did was again hiking in the shoe and I
just felt like whether you know this
shoe was going to be good enough in the
uppers to provide enough protection it
does have a very nice toe cap that's
semi-soft but it's quite thick and then
finally the other thing that I did for
protection was I did another round of
head to head to head testing where I put
one shoe on each foot and then I stepped
on a stone to see which shoe transferred
less of the shape of that stone to the
bottom of my foot these shoes performed
okay I would say in general but they did
lose to all four other shoes and again I
think that's just a function of the fact
that this Vibram sole is quite soft and
it also doesn't I don't think it has as
much of a stack as the other shoes did
so again the shoe is going to work for a
lot of people I'm not saying that it is
not providing enough protection but
there are shoes out there that in my
estimation provide better protection
especially for protection underfoot okay
final category is comfort and weight
these shoes are quite comfortable so for
a hundred dollars you're going to get a
very very comfortable hiking platform I
would say you know if you're just a day
hiker or just interested in getting into
hiking and you want something other than
your sneakers I think this would be a
great way to go if I were going on a
five-day backpacking trip this would not
be the chew the shoe that I would choose
just for everything that I've stated
before it's not the most stable it
doesn't provide
enough protection underfoot for me
especially if you're carrying a backpack
and
um it doesn't have amazing traction all
of the padding and stuff that they've
added into the upper really adds a lot
of weight so this shoe comes in at 17.56
ounces or just over a pound which is
fine but there are other shoes that I
tested that perform better than this and
that are significantly lighter but again
it's only a hundred dollars so the
quality of the price ratio is is very
very good
okay final thoughts
um this shoe has a lot of recycled
material in it which is something that I
really appreciate from Merrell so the
laces
this mesh here and also the webbing on
the inside is all 100 recycled material
so hats off to you Meryl
um and I'm so glad that you're doing
this continue to do this and I think
that will be a great thing for the for
the hiking Footwear industry if other
companies follow your lead all right
that's it for the Merrell Moab three
again I think this is a great shoe given
its price but there are other shoes out
there that perform better I will see you
guys in the next one
Ver Más Videos Relacionados
Fixed price VS Agile (time material) approach
Pourquoi Personne ne Comprend le Prix du Pétrole ? [ Didier Darcet ]
Apple in 2024: dit kan je verwachten (HIJ KOMT 🥽)
EXCLU Essai nouvelle Tesla Model 3 (2024) : plus douce et plus sage !
Comment FILMER une INTERVIEW professionnelle
Une avocate au Barreau de Toulon nous parle du droit des animaux
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)