The Economy of Communist China

Summary

The video script provides a historical narrative of China's economic transformation from 1949 onwards. It describes how China, once the wealthiest nation, fell behind due to modern industrialization and the impact of war. The establishment of the People's Republic of China under Mao Zedong led to a centralized economic model focused on heavy industry, with an initial period of prosperity followed by challenges due to the Great Leap Forward's flawed policies. The script highlights the struggle between ideology and practical economic strategies, which resulted in significant hardships for the population. It concludes with a teaser for the next video, which will explore China's rise to become the second most powerful nation on earth, following the economic reforms initiated by Deng Xiaoping after Mao's death.

Takeaways

• 🌏 In 1949, China was a nation recovering from years of war and exploitation by foreign powers, with a goal to rebuild and redefine its political and economic systems.
• 📉 Prior to the 20th century, China was the world's largest economic power, but it fell behind as other nations industrialized and modernized their economies.
• 🏭 Mao Zedong established the People's Republic of China and initiated a centralized, Soviet-style economic model focusing on heavy industry to drive economic development.
• 🔧 The Soviet Union assisted China by sending scientists, engineers, and developers to set up factories and infrastructure, which helped in its industrialization efforts.
• 🏗️ China's first five-year plan led to a period of prosperity with a focus on heavy industry, but it also resulted in a lag in agricultural production.
• 🚫 The Great Leap Forward was an economic plan that aimed for rapid growth in all sectors, but it was marred by poor economic direction and a lack of incentives for workers.
• 🛠️ The backyard furnace experiment, aimed at increasing agricultural production, led to disastrous consequences, including deforestation and a decline in food production.
• 🌾 Agricultural stagnation and the prioritization of heavy industry led to a decline in food production, which impacted the ability to feed the population.
• 🧐 There was internal disagreement within the Communist Party regarding incentives for high-achieving workers, with concerns about equality and the potential for political opposition.
• 📉 The Great Leap Forward's emphasis on hard work without proper planning or incentives led to economic stagnation and a decline in living conditions.
• 🛑 After Mao's death, Deng Xiaoping took over and began implementing policies that were more liberating for individual workers, marking the beginning of China's economic turnaround.

Q & A

What was the state of China in 1949?

In 1949, China was a nation ravaged by years of war and exploitation by its allies, struggling to feed itself and in need of significant economic and infrastructure rebuilding.

Why was China considered the wealthiest nation in the world for most of the last millennia?

China was the wealthiest nation due to its abundant manpower, good arable land, and a hard-working, productive populace, which supported a massive economy without reliance on modern technology or colonial rule.

How did the industrialization of other nations impact China's economic status in the early 20th century?

The industrialization of the United States, Europe, and Japan allowed these nations to catch up and surpass China as modern economic superpowers, as raw manpower could no longer compete with modern industry and mechanized warfare.

What was the primary goal of Mao Zedong's economic plan after establishing the People's Republic of China in 1949?

Mao Zedong's primary goal was to reestablish China as an economic powerhouse with a focus on heavy industry and modernization, adopting a centralized Soviet-style economic model.

How did the Soviet Union assist China in its initial industrialization efforts?

The Soviet Union sent scientists, engineers, and developers to China to help set up factories and capital-intensive infrastructure, which facilitated China's industrial development.

What was the Great Leap Forward and what was its main objective?

The Great Leap Forward was an economic plan initiated by Mao Zedong that aimed to rapidly transform China's economy by promoting collective effort and increasing production across all sectors, with a particular emphasis on heavy industry and agriculture.

What were the consequences of the backyard furnace experiment during the Great Leap Forward?

The backyard furnace experiment led to a significant diversion of manpower and resources from agriculture, deforestation, and the production of low-quality steel, which contributed to failed crops, famine, and a decline in living conditions.

Why was there disagreement within the Communist Party about incentivizing high-achieving workers?

There was disagreement because incentivizing high-achieving workers contradicted the principle of equality and collective work, and could potentially lead to the rise of class enemies, which Mao used as a tool to suppress political opposition.

How did Deng Xiaoping's policies differ from those of Mao Zedong, and what impact did they have on China's economy?

Deng Xiaoping's policies were more liberal towards individual workers, allowing for greater incentives and personal motivation, which marked the beginning of the Chinese economic miracle and the transformation of China into a global economic powerhouse.

What was the significance of the Marshall Plan and the reconstruction of the Pacific in the context of post-war economic recovery?

The Marshall Plan and the reconstruction of the Pacific were significant as they provided foreign aid and support to help countries like Japan and Germany rebuild their economies and become modern economic powerhouses after World War II.

How did the United States' stance on communism affect its willingness to provide aid to China post-World War II?

The United States was less inclined to extend aid to China due to the communist ideology of the newly established People's Republic of China, leading to China having to rely more on its own resources for recovery and development.

Outlines

00:00

😀 Post-War China and the Birth of the PRC

The first paragraph describes the state of China in 1949, a nation that had been severely affected by war and exploitation by allies, such as the United States and the Soviet Union. Once the wealthiest nation, it was now struggling economically. The political climate led to the establishment of the People's Republic of China under Mao Zedong, who aimed to rebuild China as a socialist economic powerhouse. The focus was on heavy industry to drive development, with the Soviet Union assisting by sending experts to set up factories and infrastructure. However, the U.S. was reluctant to aid China due to its communist regime, leaving China to rebuild independently.

05:02

🏭 The Central Planning and the Great Leap Forward

The second paragraph discusses China's shift towards central planning, with an emphasis on heavy industry. It covers the nationalization of private enterprises and the prosperous period that followed, despite the lag in agricultural growth. The Great Leap Forward, an economic initiative aimed at rapid industrialization and modernization, is also detailed. It highlights the misguided policy of having the population work harder without proper incentives or modern techniques, leading to economic stagnation and a decline in living conditions. The disastrous backyard furnace experiment, which attempted to produce steel using household items and led to further economic and environmental problems, is also mentioned.

10:02

🌾 The Consequences of Mao's Policies and the Rise of Deng Xiaoping

The third paragraph reflects on the negative outcomes of Mao Zedong's economic policies, which led to widespread suffering and a decline in the nation's ability to sustain its population. It discusses the conflict between ideology and effective economic strategies and the impact on China's agricultural and industrial sectors. The narrative then shifts to Deng Xiaoping, who, after Mao's death, introduced policies that were more liberating for individual workers, marking the beginning of China's economic turnaround. The video concludes with a teaser for the next part of the series, which will explore China's transformation into a global economic power.

Keywords

💡Industrialization

Industrialization refers to the process where a country shifts from a predominantly agrarian economy to one dominated by manufacturing and the use of advanced technology. In the video, it is a key concept as China, after the establishment of the People's Republic of China in 1949, sought to industrialize to prevent foreign invasions and to modernize its economy, which is a central theme of the video.

💡Mao Zedong

Mao Zedong was the founding father of the People's Republic of China and a key figure in the establishment of its political and economic systems. The video discusses his role in shaping China's economy post-1949, particularly through the implementation of the Great Leap Forward and other policies aimed at industrialization and modernization.

💡Great Leap Forward

The Great Leap Forward was an economic and social campaign by the Communist Party of China from 1958 to 1962, aiming for rapid industrialization and collectivization. The video describes it as a pivotal but flawed strategy that led to significant economic and social challenges, including the backyard furnace experiment and its disastrous effects on agriculture and the environment.

💡Soviet Union

The Soviet Union played a significant role in the early years of the People's Republic of China, as it was a major ally and influence on China's economic policies. The video mentions the Soviet Union's initial exploitation of China's industrial resources and later assistance in setting up factories and infrastructure, which was crucial for China's industrial development.

💡Backyard Furnace Experiment

The backyard furnace experiment was a part of the Great Leap Forward where local steel furnaces were set up to increase steel production. The video explains that this initiative led to a diversion of resources and labor from agriculture, causing significant ecological damage and contributing to economic hardship and famine.

💡Deng Xiaoping

Deng Xiaoping was a major Chinese leader who succeeded Mao Zedong and is credited with initiating the economic reforms that led to China's rapid economic growth. The video suggests that his policies marked a turning point from the previous economic strategies, moving towards a more liberal approach that allowed for individual incentives and productivity.

💡Five-Year Plans

Five-Year Plans are centralized economic planning models used by socialist countries to manage and direct their economic development. The video discusses China's adoption of this model, initially inspired by the Soviet Union, to focus on heavy industry and nationalize industries, which was a critical strategy in the early years of the People's Republic of China.

💡

💡Class Enemy

In the context of the video, a 'class enemy' refers to individuals who were seen as opposing the communist ideology and were often subject to persecution. The concept was used as a tool by Mao Zedong to suppress political opposition and maintain control, which had a chilling effect on individual incentives and productivity within the workforce.

💡Agricultural Collectivization

Agricultural collectivization is the process where individual land holdings are combined into larger, collective farms. The video mentions that China relied on farming collectives, which were groups of workers farming in a traditional manner. This approach did not embrace modern farming techniques and contributed to the lagging agricultural productivity.

💡Economic Stimulus

An economic stimulus refers to government policies or programs designed to boost economic activity. The video describes the Great Leap Forward as a form of economic stimulus that aimed to rapidly accelerate industrial and agricultural production through increased work effort and the adoption of new technologies.

💡Communism

Communism is a social, political, and economic ideology that seeks to establish a classless society where the means of production are owned and controlled by the community as a whole. The video discusses the establishment of a one-party communist state in China and its impact on the country's economic policies and development strategies.

Highlights

China in 1949 was a nation recovering from years of war and exploitation by allies, facing economic and infrastructure challenges.

China was once the wealthiest nation in the world, boasting a majority of global economic power for centuries.

The nation's wealth was based on its abundant manpower, arable land, and a hard-working populace.

The early 20th century saw China fall behind as modern industrial powers like the US and Europe surpassed it.

The Second World War exposed China's vulnerability due to its lack of industrial and military power.

Mao Zedong established the People's Republic of China in 1949, aiming to rebuild China as a modern socialist nation.

China's first task was to rebuild its infrastructure and address the dire state of its economy post-war.

The US was unwilling to provide aid to China due to ideological differences, leaving China to rebuild independently.

China adopted a centralized Soviet-style economic model focusing on heavy industry to drive economic development.

The Soviet Union assisted China by sending scientists, engineers, and developers to establish factories and infrastructure.

By 1956, all private enterprises were nationalized, with owners offered government positions in exchange.

The period following nationalization was prosperous as China embraced heavy industry and increased its productive capacity.

Agricultural growth lagged behind industrial growth, with farming techniques not yet modernized.

The Great Leap Forward was an economic plan aiming for ambitious goals across all sectors through increased work effort.

The plan led to disastrous outcomes, such as the backyard furnace experiment, which wasted resources and led to crop failures.

Deng Xiaoping's advocacy for incentives for high-achieving workers was initially rejected due to ideological conflicts.

The Great Leap Forward's failure led to a period of suffering for the Chinese population and economic stagnation.

Deng Xiaoping's eventual rise to power and the implementation of more liberal policies marked a turning point for China's economy.

The video series aims to explore how China transformed from a failing state to the second most powerful nation on earth.

Transcripts

[Music]

this is China in 1949 he was a nation

ravaged by years and years of war and

Exploited by its allies at the time

namely America and the Soviet Union this

nation was once the wealthiest in the

world and now it was struggling to feed

itself it was these kinds of conditions

that gave rise to the political system

that would go on to define China in the

later half of the 20th century this is

the second part of a three-part series

on the economy of China if you have not

already seen the first part I would

encourage you to watch that either

before or after you watch this video and

I'm not saying that exclusively for a

shameless plug but also because it is

important to understand where China had

come from up until the start of the 20th

century China was the largest economic

power in the world the nation boasted

this wealth for a majority of the last

millennia only ever trading places with

India another nation that flies under

the radar in recorded history it even

achieved and maintained a level of

wealth beyond the typical colonial

powers like England France and the

Netherlands that we typically associate

with world domination in this period and

it did this through a good old-fashioned

grunt China wasn't the wealthiest nation

in the world because it had embraced

modern technology or ruled over a

portfolio of foreign colonies it was

home to the world's biggest economy

because it had a lot of manpower good

arable land and a hard-working and

productive populace this all started to

slip in the early 20th century when

nations like the United States and then

later Europe and Japan caught up and

acceded China as the world's modern

economic superpowers the time had come

where raw manpower alone couldn't keep

up with modern industry steam power had

been replaced with electrical grids in

gasoline and the textile mills had been

replaced with production lines and all

of this meant that raw manpower alone

was not enough to keep up this was not

ignored in China and a lot of the

leadership at the time had seen the

power of an industrial nation to improve

the wealth of its citizens what is more

is that industry now meant military

power in the age of mechanized

warfare having the ability to produce

tanks and planes and ships was hugely

influential this became extremely

evident in the Second World War when

Japan a nation with a smaller population

less resources and less desirable

geographic position invaded and

subsequently decimated mainland China

the invasion of Nanjing was one of the

most horrendous atrocities in the Second

World War and this was a war marred by

horrendous atrocities but what it meant

for the economy was a huge desire to

industrialize to stop something like

this ever happening again in 1949 this

man Mao Zedong established a one-party

nation as the People's Republic of China

and got straight to work establishing

China as the economic powerhouse it was

destined to be it had fallen behind in

previous years but it was time again for

it to become a modern powerful socialist

nation the first task was cleaning up

the nation and it was in bad shape years

of war meant that a lot of the

infrastructure had been destroyed this

was made worse by Soviet troops

dismantling what was left of a lot of

industrial machinery and shipping it

back to the Soviet Union when they were

finished deployment not cool comrades on

top of this food production had suffered

because a lot of farmers were forced to

flee their farms during the war so even

food production

the one thing that China had been really

really good at up until this point had

started to suffer now a lot of nations

that were impacted by the war during

this period started receiving foreign

aid particularly from the United States

we have already explored how the

Marshall Plan and the reconstruction of

the Pacific got Japan and Germany off

the ground to go on and become the

modern economic powerhouses they are

today but America was a whole lot less

keen to extend that charity to China

because of the whole communism thing so

they were kind of on their own now this

whole cleanup thing took about three

years and from then they set out on the

first of their five-year economic plans

this called for a centralized Soviet

style economic model where all inputs

and outputs and allocations of resources

were handled by a central administration

in particular China was very keen to

focus on building heavy industry to

drive their economic development

remember how the Soviet soldiers kind of

dogged their comrade China by stealing

all their machinery at the end of the

war well by this point the Soviet Union

realized that they needed all the

friends that they could get so they

repaid this debt by sending Soviet

scientists engineers and developers over

to set up factories and capital

intensive infrastructure to make

industrial development possible this

central planning model also called for

the nationalization of existing

industries China at this point still had

private enterprises but the Communist

Party wanted to take control of this the

government offered to buy private

enterprises in exchange for prestigious

government positions and this was kind

of a carrot and stick deal take this

generous offer or you know get branded a

class enemy and we'll just take your

factory anyway

needless to say by 1956 no privately

owned firms remained in China now this

period was actually really prosperous

the nation embraced heavy industry for

the first time and they did reap the

rewards of their new productive capacity

that being said though it wasn't like

they were starting at a great level to

improve from furthermore farming the

once foundational industry started to

lag behind the nation had not yet

properly embraced modern farming

techniques and instead relied on farming

collectives of workers who were more or

less growing food the same way that they

had always done but now with more of an

emphasis on this food being

redistributed toward the industrial

workers in the cities

before they even got to the end of their

first five-year plan the growing

imbalance between industrial and

agricultural growth dissatisfaction with

efficiency and lack of flexibility in

the decision-making process convinced

the nation's leaders particularly Mao

Zedong that the Soviet way of doing

things may not be super appropriate for

China

they weren't abandoning communism or

even central planning altogether but

they decided that China was best run

through its industrial provinces this

way provinces with a high density of

Industry could focus on industry

management and provinces made up of

farms could focus on agriculture they

decided to scrap the five-year plans in

favor of a rebranded economic stimulus

called the Great Leap Forward this was

an economic plan that called for all

industries agriculture manufacturing and

even the military to take a will up

great leap forward and achieve ambitious

goals set by the central government the

plan to achieve this you know opening up

new trade agreements embracing new

technologies modern farming methods no

no just work harder now this sounds dumb

it would barely be acceptable for the

acting manager of a KFC but the command

to just work harder was just really

awful economic direction from the

central government of what used to be

the most powerful economy in the world

just 60 years prior but it wasn't

necessarily without reason

Chairman Mao and a lot of the leadership

had become obsessed with the idea of

slack labor particularly in the

industrial sector the idea was that

workers were not performing to their

maximum potential because they were lazy

and there was no individual incentive to

work harder than the absolute bare

minimum on top of this Communist China

was very uncool to people that were

working harder than their peers workers

were terrified of being branded as class

enemies which basically meant people who

were trying to be better than everyone

else which in communist China carried

harsh punishments this did not bode well

when they are now trying to turn around

and ask these workers to work as hard as

they can to meet these new economic

goals there was actually a lot of

disagreement between communist

party leadership about this equality at

all cost business the lack of incentives

to work harder and on top of these

punishment for people that work too hard

did stifle economic growth and by

extension living conditions major party

figures like Deng Xiaoping now eventual

successor advocated for some kind of

recognition for high achieving workers

to incentivize stronger output figures

now eventually shut this idea down for a

few reasons one it went against the

fundamental message of the nation that

all men are equal and we are working

collectively but the second reason may

have been more important

Chairman Mao was a ruthless dictator

that ruled over an authoritarian state

labeling someone as a class enemy was a

really really effective way to ice any

political opponents so he was probably

keen to keep that whole system in place

the kerfuffle that was the Great Leap

Forward was kind of typifies in the

nightmare that was the backyard furnace

experiment

Chairman Mao decided that farm machinery

was a good solution to increasing the

struggling crop here which was actually

a great idea when producing anything you

have to consider the factors of

production land labor and capital in

that sense producing potatoes is no

different than producing cars now China

had plenty of Labor and plenty of land

but it did not yet embrace capital or

machinery intensive farming techniques

Mao decided that farmers should set up

backyard furnaces to produce steel and

that could be used to make this

machinery these furnaces were small they

took a lot of manpower away from the

farms to maintain and operate and

required a lot of fuel to produce steel

this fuel came from doors and furnitures

and any tree that could be found around

these farms which caused issues trees

are super important to the irrigation of

farmland and lopping down every last one

of them to throw into your furnace is

going to cause irrigation problems and

failed crops to make things worse the

metal used to produce this steel came

from pig iron ore from knives and forks

and plates and pots and pans and really

any

metal that the population could get

their hands on and it should probably go

without saying that the metal that this

produced was absolute garbage like

totally useless for anything clumps of

nothing so yeah there you go

the backyard furnace experiment left a

large population of overworked peasant

farmers without doors or furniture pots

or pans sitting in mud with no food

because it had all been washed away

which when you think about it was

probably a metaphor for China as a whole

during this period

China under the rule of Mao Zedong was

perhaps a period of best intentions

executed terribly the conflict of

ideologies and good economic policy

conflicted to the point that the

population suffered greatly the nation

was mired by poorly planned economic

strategies that continued to backfire

and started to impact the nation's

ability to feed itself the nation had

once been so powerful simply because of

its ability to feed and maintain a large

population but even that was failing

heavy industry is not a golden ticket to

success productive industry that

facilitates the efforts of motivated

workers is what made nations like the

United States as wealthy as they are

today and China certainly missed this

distinction

remember this guy Deng Xiaoping who

basically said that we should cool it

with the killing off above-average

workers well he eventually took over the

reins of the nation after Mao's death

and started enacting policies that were

slightly more liberating to individual

workers this was the beginning of the

turning point that would lead to the

economy we see today the Chinese miracle

is truly a fascinating economic case

study and so in the next video we will

explore how China went from being a

failing state with poor crop yields and

stagnating growth to the second most

powerful nation on earth until then I

hope you enjoyed this video I want to

give a big shout out to our new patrons

over on patreon thank you for your

support guys you continue to make these

videos possible otherwise if you did

enjoy please consider liking and

subscribing I will be answering

questions for an hour after this video

goes live on our discord server or our

YouTube live stream over on the second

channel feel free to jump on there if

you want to ask any questions or

interact with the audience otherwise

thanks for watching guys bye