⚡️ПЛОХИЕ новости для фанерщиков! ГОСДУМА готовит закон против ЗВЕЗДУНОВ! Михалков разнёс Бузову

Московский Папарацци

26 Jan 202406:37

Summary

TLDRThe video discusses the widespread use of pre-recorded backing tracks (phonograms) by Russian pop stars during live performances without informing fans. It covers a proposed 2013 Russian bill to fine promoters for not disclosing phonogram use and compensate ticket holders, which was rejected. The summary also notes famous director Nikita Mikhalkov's criticism of singer Olga Buzova lipsyncing to win a Russian music award despite lacking talent. Overall, the video advocates for transparency from performers using phonograms and reflects public frustration with Russia's music industry.

Takeaways

😤 The pervasive issue of lip-syncing ('фанерщик') in the Russian music industry has sparked significant public discontent.
🎤 Olga Buzova's win as 'Song of the Year' has raised eyebrows and contributed to the controversy surrounding authenticity in performances.
👀 Prominent filmmaker Nikita Mikhalkov has openly criticized Olga Buzova, highlighting a broader industry critique.
🚨 The Russian government and authorities have begun to address public grievances by considering official measures against lip-synced performances.
💡 There's a proposal for artists to clearly indicate when performances are lip-synced, including on tickets and promotional materials, to ensure audience transparency.
📉 Public demand for lower ticket prices for lip-synced shows reflects the expectation for pricing to match the authenticity of the performance.
🔍 Historical context: A legislative proposal in 2013 aimed at penalizing the use of lip-syncing without audience notification was rejected, but recent events have reignited interest in such measures.
📢 Dmitry Pevtsov, a senior figure in the State Duma, indicated readiness to revisit legislation on lip-syncing, signaling potential legal action.
🎭 Nikita Mikhalkov's critique extends beyond Buzova, suggesting a systemic issue with the lack of live singing in performances.
📚 The ongoing debate and potential legislative action reflect a broader cultural and ethical discussion about authenticity and artist-audience trust in the Russian entertainment industry.

Q & A

What is the main concern expressed in the script about the Russian show business?
-The main concern is the widespread use of lip-syncing (performing to a pre-recorded track) in live performances, which is seen as deceptive to audiences.
Who won the 'Song of the Year' award, causing controversy?
-Olga Buzova won the 'Song of the Year' award, sparking controversy.
What was Nikita Sergeyevich Mikhalkov's reaction to the current state of the music industry?
-Nikita Sergeyevich Mikhalkov expressed strong criticism towards Olga Buzova and the trend of lip-syncing in the music industry.
How have the Russian authorities responded to public dissatisfaction with lip-syncing artists?
-Russian authorities have officially raised the issue, showing they are listening to the public's dissatisfaction with lip-syncing artists.
What legislative initiative is mentioned regarding lip-syncing in concerts?
-The script mentions a potential return to considering a law against lip-syncing in concerts, which would penalize organizers who don't inform audiences about the use of pre-recorded tracks.
What did Dmitry Pevtsov say about the issue of lip-syncing?
-Dmitry Pevtsov stated that the State Duma might revisit the legislation concerning lip-syncing if the initiative is proposed again.
What happened to the legislative proposal about lip-syncing in 2013?
-The legislative proposal introduced in 2013 to impose fines for using lip-syncing without informing the audience was rejected.
What are the proposed measures for informing the public about lip-syncing in performances?
-Proposed measures include notifying the audience through all promotional materials if a performance will involve lip-syncing, with penalties for providing misleading information about live performances.
How does the script suggest ticket prices should be adjusted for lip-synced performances?
-The script suggests that ticket prices for lip-synced performances should be lower than those for live performances, reflecting the reduced artistic effort.
What analogy is used to describe the ease of performing to a pre-recorded track compared to live singing?
-The script compares performing to a pre-recorded track to lip-syncing on TikTok, implying it requires less skill than live singing.

Outlines

00:00

😑 Unhappy with fake performers using backing tracks

The paragraph expresses dissatisfaction with Russian singers using pre-recorded backing tracks during live performances instead of singing live. It mentions pop stars like Olga Buzova lip-syncing to backing tracks. There is hope that new legislation banning the use of phonograms could help address this issue.

05:01

😠 Critical of Olga Buzova winning song of the year

The paragraph criticizes Olga Buzova for winning song of the year 2023 despite lacking singing talent. Nikita Mikhalkov also disapproves and suggests legislation banning backing tracks could impact Buzova's career. He previously mocked her singing ambitions.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡phonogram

A phonogram refers to a pre-recorded audio track that is lip synced or mimed to during a live performance. The video discusses the widespread use of phonograms in Russian show business and pop music. For example, it mentions performers who simply open their mouths silently while a studio recording plays during concerts. The video is critical of this practice as a form of fraud or deception of audience members who assume the performance is live.

💡Olga Buzova

Olga Buzova is a Russian pop singer and media personality who is referenced several times in the video. She won the 2023 Song of the Year award despite lacking strong vocal abilities, which sparked controversy. The video uses her as an example of an artist who relies heavily on phonograms during performances.

💡Nikita Mikhalkov

Nikita Mikhalkov is a famous Russian filmmaker who is quoted in the video criticizing Olga Buzova's singing abilities and phonogram use. His YouTube channel was recently blocked, which the video notes as potential censorship. Mikhalkov is presented as an authoritative cultural figure who shares the video creator's stance against phonograms.

💡live singing

Live singing refers to vocal performances without any backing tracks or lip syncing to recordings. The video advocates for artists transparently identifying when phonograms are used so the audience knows when they are not hearing live singing. It argues live singing deserves higher ticket prices than reliance on phonograms.

💡deception

Deception is a theme in the video regarding phonogram use in Russian pop music. The creator argues that relying on phonograms without informing audiences is deceptive. The proposed 2013 law would have required concert organizers to disclose phonogram use to prevent deceiving ticket buyers.

💡censorship

Censorship comes up in the video in relation to the blocking of Nikita Mikhalkov's YouTube channel. This is presented as potential political censorship, given Mikhalkov's critical stances toward elements of Russian society and culture. The video creator implies censorship could be behind the 2013 rejection of the anti-phonogram law.

💡lip syncing

Lip syncing refers to the practice of mouthing along to a backing vocal track, creating the illusion of a live performance. The video critically associates lip syncing with the use of phonograms in Russian pop concerts. It compares pop stars who lip sync to ordinary social media users who do it with recordings.

💡public outrage

The video describes growing public outrage in Russia against the phonogram use and perceived inauthenticity of popular music performers. It suggests this public pressure led lawmakers to revisit banning phonograms. Outrage over Buzova's singing award is also mentioned.

💡transparency

Greater transparency is proposed as the solution to phony performances using phonograms. The video advocates for laws requiring concert promoters and stars to openly disclose any phonogram use on all publicity materials so fans are not deceived.

💡live atmosphere

The video argues the atmosphere of a live concert makes it a distinct experience from just listening to a studio recording at home. However, it questions whether the atmosphere is authentic if the singer is just lip syncing with a phonogram.

Highlights

В Госдуме задумались над проблемой фонограммы в российском шоу-бизнесе

Госдума может вернуться к рассмотрению закона о пении под фонограмму

В 2013 году в Госдуму вносили законопроект о штрафах за использование фонограммы

Фонограмма - это чистейший воды мошенническая схема

Артист присутствует на сцене не полностью, а только своим внешним видом, но не голосом

Никита Сергеевич Михалков высказал отношение к фанерщикам и Ольге Бузовой

Ольга Бузова выигрывает премию Песня года, не имея ни голоса, ни слуха

Михалков предложил Бузовой начать с чего-то попроще, например с нянечки

Канал Никиты Сергеевича на YouTube заблокировали

На YouTube есть цензура, подписывайтесь на другие соцсети

В Telegram канале можно найти актуальную повестку и пообщаться в чате

Поставьте лайк, если согласны с законом против фонограммы

Напишите в комментариях, что думаете о фанерщках

Спасибо за просмотр!