【PLA系９種頂上決戦】コスパ最強フィラメントはどれだ!? 白の色味 印刷品質 強度も検証！

Summary

The video script discusses a comprehensive comparison of nine different white PLA filaments, highlighting variations in print quality and strength despite being the same material. The reviewer shares insights on color, transparency, and ease of use, evaluating each filament's performance based on print clarity, adhesion, and dimensional accuracy. The summary also mentions the unexpected strength of certain brands and the significant cost-performance ratio, guiding viewers to make informed choices for their 3D printing needs.

Takeaways

• 😀 The video script discusses a comparison of 9 different white PLA filaments purchased to evaluate print quality and strength variations.
• 🔍 There is a significant difference in strength among the tested PLA filaments, with some showing a strength difference of up to double, despite being the same material.
• 💡 The comparison was initiated due to a stock shortage of a standard white filament on amon, which led to exploring alternative materials.
• 🛍️ The script suggests looking for filaments that are easily available on platforms like Amazon, are affordable, and have good support for 3D printing without additional hassle.
• 🎨 The importance of color preference is highlighted, with a preference for white filaments that are not too transparent and have a clear, blue-white hue.
• 🏗️ The script mentions using the Clarity K1MA 3D printer and its proprietary slicing software for the tests, noting that some filaments print cleaner than others.
• ⚙️ Printing conditions, including hotend temperatures set to the maximum usage temperature of the material, are discussed to ensure strength and prevent printing defects.
• 📏 The script provides an analysis of color, infill visibility, and print quality, comparing the filaments based on these aspects.
• 📉 The video includes a detailed examination of the filaments' dimensional accuracy and mentions that some filaments resulted in larger deviations in certain measurements.
• 💪 A strength test is conducted, revealing that despite being the same material (PLA), there is a considerable variance in strength among different brands.
• 📊 The script concludes with a summary of the filaments' performance, cost-effectiveness, and overall quality, with a surprise finding that a less-known brand, Timony, performed exceptionally well in various tests.

Q & A

What is the main topic of the video script?

The main topic of the video script is a comparison of different types of white PLA filaments, their printing quality, and strength.

Why did the author start comparing different PLA filaments?

The author started comparing different PLA filaments because their standard white filament from a specific company became unavailable for purchase and was limited in stock, prompting them to look for alternatives.

What was the initial condition that led to the author's search for alternative materials?

The initial condition was the stock shortage of the author's standard white filament from a specific company, which was not being restocked as expected.

What criteria did the author consider when looking for alternative filaments?

The author considered criteria such as availability on Amazon, affordability, compatibility with their 3D printer, and ease of use without additional effort like ring attachments.

What are some of the specific attributes the author was looking for in a white filament?

The author was looking for attributes such as transparency for easy infill visibility, a preference for a cool white or blue-white color over yellowish tones, and a good balance of cost and quality.

What was the author's printing condition for testing the filaments?

The author used a K1MA from Clarity for printing, with the Clarity's original slicing software, and set the hotend temperature to the maximum recommended for the material to test for strength and print quality at higher temperatures.

How did the author evaluate the color and transparency of the filaments?

The author evaluated the color and transparency by visually comparing the filaments side by side, noting differences in their white tones and transparency, especially in the infill visibility.

What was the author's observation regarding the strength of different PLA filaments from the same company?

The author observed that even within the same PLA material, there could be a significant difference in strength, with some filaments being twice as strong as others.

What was the author's conclusion on the best white filament based on their tests?

The author concluded that the white filament from 'Tinmoni' was the best overall, considering color preference, print quality, and strength, despite it being from a lesser-known manufacturer.

What insights did the author provide on the cost-performance ratio of the tested filaments?

The author provided insights that filaments with a higher price tended to have greater strength, but there were also good cost-performance options like 'Elego' and 'E3' that offered good quality at a lower price.

What additional tests or considerations does the author suggest for future evaluations?

The author suggests additional tests to verify if the color of the filament affects its strength, as well as considering the availability and ease of obtaining the filaments for future use.