Kultum Sebelum Shalat Tarawih Bid’ah? - Syaikh Sulaiman bin Salimullah Ar-Ruhaily

Summary

The speaker discusses the permissibility of holding lessons before Isha prayer during Ramadan. They clarify that if an imam or sheikh views these gatherings as an opportunity to bring people together, there is no issue with holding such lessons. However, if these lessons are mistakenly regarded as part of Ramadan rituals, especially between the Taraweeh prayers, then it becomes problematic. The key distinction is that gathering people for educational purposes is allowed, but incorporating it into religious rituals as a custom is not permissible.

Takeaways

• 😀 The question is about the ruling on the lessons held by mosque imams before Isha prayer in Ramadan.
• 😀 The speaker highlights that these lessons are permissible if the imam sees it as an opportunity for people to gather.
• 😀 The gathering of people is more frequent during Ramadan, making these lessons a valuable opportunity for communal engagement.
• 😀 The lessons are not considered an innovation (Bid'ah) as long as they serve the purpose of bringing people together and are not seen as a formal part of Ramadan rituals.
• 😀 Some people mistakenly consider the lesson between Taraweeh prayers as a mandatory part of the Ramadan tradition, which is not correct.
• 😀 If the lessons are given with the intention of gathering the people for a beneficial purpose, there is no harm in holding them.
• 😀 The distinction is made between lessons that serve a practical purpose and those mistakenly viewed as obligatory rituals.
• 😀 Lessons during Ramadan should not be seen as part of the Taraweeh ritual, but as an optional opportunity for learning and gathering.
• 😀 The speaker emphasizes the importance of intentions behind holding such lessons, ensuring they are not perceived as innovations in the religious practice.
• 😀 In summary, the practice of holding lessons before Isha prayer during Ramadan is allowed, provided it is not mistaken for a religious obligation or innovation.

Q & A

What is the main topic discussed in the transcript?

The main topic discussed is the ruling on holding lessons or lectures in mosques before the Isha prayer during Ramadan, and whether it is considered an innovation (bid'ah).

Does the speaker consider lessons before Isha prayer in Ramadan as an innovation?

The speaker does not consider the lessons before Isha prayer an innovation if the purpose is to gather people for beneficial purposes, such as education or community bonding.

What is the reason for holding lessons in Ramadan before Isha prayer according to the speaker?

The speaker explains that Ramadan is a time when people gather more frequently than usual, making it a good opportunity for social and educational gatherings.

Is it permissible to hold a lesson before Isha prayer if it is seen as part of Ramadan's rituals?

No, the speaker mentions that it would not be permissible if people believe it to be a specific ritual or part of the practices of Ramadan, such as the belief that a lesson between the Tarawih prayers is a required practice.

What is the speaker's stance on lessons being held between Tarawih prayers?

The speaker believes that holding a lesson between the Tarawih prayers is not allowed, as some people wrongly view it as a part of the Tarawih ritual.

Can lessons be conducted for the purpose of gathering people in Ramadan?

Yes, the speaker allows for lessons if they are intended to gather people for beneficial purposes, not as part of a ritual or innovation in the Ramadan practices.

How does the speaker distinguish between permissible and impermissible lessons in Ramadan?

The speaker distinguishes between permissible lessons, which are meant for gathering and education, and impermissible lessons, which are mistakenly viewed as part of Ramadan rituals.

What is the implication of treating lessons before Isha as part of Ramadan's rituals?

Treating lessons before Isha as part of Ramadan's rituals would be problematic because it could lead to introducing innovations (bid'ah) into religious practices, which is not allowed.

Does the speaker allow flexibility in holding lessons before Isha in Ramadan?

Yes, the speaker allows flexibility if the lessons are intended to gather people and offer beneficial discussions, not for establishing new rituals.

Why is Ramadan considered a special time for gatherings and lessons?

Ramadan is considered special because it is a time when people gather more frequently, providing an opportunity to engage in beneficial activities like educational lessons.