[Podcast] Resensi Buku Fiksi & Non Fiksi - Nadyamara & Zahra Fathimi XI MIPA 7

Summary

In this engaging video, Zara Kartini and Nadia provide insightful reviews of two books. The first, *Habibie dan Ainun*, is an autobiographical account of B.J. Habibie’s deep love for his wife, Ainun, and their shared journey through triumphs and hardships in Indonesia. The second book, *William*, by Risa Saraswati, explores the melancholic life of a young boy named William, who moves to Batavia and faces isolation, later experiencing the afterlife as a spirit. Both reviews discuss the emotional depth and narrative strengths, while acknowledging their weaknesses, offering viewers a thoughtful reflection on these impactful stories.

Takeaways

• 😀 The speakers introduce themselves as Zara Kartini and Nadia, and apologize for wearing masks due to illness.
• 😀 Zara reviews the book *Habibie and Ainun*, an autobiographical work by B.J. Habibie, published in 2010, about his life and his deep love for his wife, Ainun.
• 😀 The book is categorized as non-fiction and contains 323 pages, focusing on Habibie's personal experiences and his love story with Ainun.
• 😀 Habibie was a prominent Indonesian figure, known for his intelligence and contributions to aerospace, as well as his leadership as the third president of Indonesia.
• 😀 The book tells the love story between Habibie and Ainun, starting from their reunion in 1962, following a long separation, and their eventual marriage.
• 😀 Despite early struggles in their marriage, especially financial difficulties, Ainun remained supportive, helping Habibie excel in his career.
• 😀 Habibie was later called back to Indonesia, where he continued to contribute to the nation, including leading a major aircraft project.
• 😀 The book also highlights the unwavering support Ainun gave Habibie during his presidency and her untimely death from cancer in 2010.
• 😀 A key theme in the book is Habibie's immense love for Ainun, describing her as his perfect match and the source of his strength.
• 😀 The speakers discuss both the strengths and weaknesses of the book, noting its emotional depth and inspiration, but also pointing out issues with confusing sentence structures and inconsistent narrative flow.
• 😀 Zara then reviews *William* by Risa Saraswati, a 2017 book about a boy named William, who moves from the Netherlands to Indonesia, struggles with loneliness, and later becomes an arwah (spirit).
• 😀 The *William* novel is praised for its vivid descriptions of historical Indonesia during the colonial era, though it is criticized for its idealized character depictions and occasional use of inappropriate language for younger readers.

Q & A

What is the main focus of the book *Habibie dan Ainun* by B.J. Habibie?

The book *Habibie dan Ainun* focuses on the love story between B.J. Habibie and his wife, Ainun, as well as their shared life journey. It also delves into Habibie's personal reflections and contributions to Indonesia, especially in the context of his work on aircraft design and his presidency.

Why did B.J. Habibie write *Habibie dan Ainun*?

B.J. Habibie wrote *Habibie dan Ainun* as a form of therapy to cope with the grief of losing his wife. The book allowed him to express his deep feelings of love and loss, helping him deal with his emotions after Ainun’s passing.

What is the genre of *Habibie dan Ainun*?

The genre of *Habibie dan Ainun* is autobiographical non-fiction. It is a personal memoir that recounts the life of B.J. Habibie and his relationship with his wife, Ainun.

How does *Habibie dan Ainun* inspire readers in terms of national pride?

The book highlights B.J. Habibie’s contributions to Indonesia, particularly his work on aircraft design and his role in the country’s development. This inspires national pride by showcasing his dedication to his country and the support he received from his wife throughout his journey.

What are some criticisms of *Habibie dan Ainun*?

Some criticisms of *Habibie dan Ainun* include the lack of a clear narrative flow, with some events recounted out of chronological order. Additionally, the book's title might mislead readers into expecting a more balanced focus on both Habibie and Ainun, when it primarily centers on Habibie’s perspective.

What is the main plot of *William* by Risa Saraswati?

The novel *William* follows the life of a boy named William Van Canon, who moves from the Netherlands to Batavia (Jakarta) and faces feelings of isolation and loneliness. The story explores his strained relationship with his parents, particularly his harsh mother, and his journey toward understanding himself, which continues after his death as a spirit (arwah).

How does *William* portray the historical setting of colonial Indonesia?

The book vividly describes the colonial era in Indonesia, allowing readers to experience the environment of Batavia during that time. The detailed setting helps bring the historical context to life, making the period feel immersive and real.

What is the relationship between William and his parents in the book?

William’s relationship with his parents is strained. His mother, Maria, is portrayed as harsh and critical, while his father, Johan, is more caring but unable to stop his wife’s behavior. William finds comfort and affection from his grandfather, who teaches him important life lessons.

What supernatural element is present in *William*?

The supernatural element in *William* occurs after William’s death. He becomes an 'arwah' (spirit) and gains a new perspective on life, finding peace and connection with other spirits, including his friends.

What are some strengths and weaknesses of *William* as identified in the review?

Strengths of *William* include its vivid descriptions of the historical setting and well-defined characters. However, a weakness is that some characters are portrayed as too perfect, making them feel unrealistic. Additionally, some of the language used may not be appropriate for younger readers.