University of San Diego professor on applied mathematics and faith | Satyan Devadoss

The Veritas Forum
19 Dec 201923:48

Summary

TLDRSafi and Devdas, a professor of mathematics and computer science at the University of San Diego, explores the beauty of shapes and patterns in mathematics. He delves into how 'applied mathematics' has evolved, impacting various fields like encryption and data analysis. He also discusses the significance of topology in understanding complex data sets, such as identifying diabetes types. Devdas emphasizes the importance of not letting mathematics overshadow reality and the complexity of human experiences, advocating for a balanced appreciation of all disciplines and the physical world over mere data and quantification.

Takeaways

  • 📚 Safi and Devdas is a professor of mathematics and computer science at the University of San Diego, focusing on the study of shapes and their applications.
  • 🔍 Mathematics, to him, is about understanding patterns and structures in numbers, functions, and images.
  • 🌐 The term 'applied mathematics' has evolved from its 20th-century meaning of aiding engineering and science to encompass all areas of mathematics in the 21st century.
  • 🔑 Number theory, for example, has become crucial for data encryption and is widely used by organizations like the NSA.
  • 🎰 The concepts of probability and chance are fundamental to prediction analysis in business, dealing with large volumes of data.
  • 🧠 Topological data analysis, a field pioneered by Gunnar Carlsson, allows for understanding the shape of data in a fuzzy setting, which is beneficial for noisy real-world data.
  • 🍺 An example of applied mathematics is discerning patterns in beer characteristics, which can be analyzed to create a 'family tree' of different beers.
  • 👨‍🔬 Mathematics is not meant to overshadow reality but to partner with it, offering alternative perspectives and methods for understanding complex issues.
  • 🌟 The speaker believes that all disciplines, from mathematics to the arts, are valuable and should be viewed as a collective tapestry of human knowledge.
  • 🚀 The speaker is intrigued by the idea of what mathematics will be like in a perfect world, such as the new heaven and earth, and how it will continue to apply to a physical world.
  • ✅ Art and mathematics can intersect to create physical representations of mathematical concepts, like the dodecahedron sculpture that was taken to Burning Man, symbolizing deeper questions about humanity and the universe.

Q & A

  • What is the primary focus of Safi and Devdas' work as a professor?

    -Safi and Devdas' work focuses on studying shape, including how it can be framed, measured, looked at, and understood.

  • How does Safi and Devdas define mathematics?

    -Safi and Devdas defines mathematics as being about making sense of patterns and structures of things, such as numbers, functions, and pictures.

  • What is the significance of the term 'applied mathematics' in the 21st century according to the professor?

    -In the 21st century, 'applied mathematics' is not limited to traditional subjects like differential equations or calculus. Instead, every mathematical idea can be considered applied because it can be used to solve real-world problems across various disciplines.

  • How does the professor relate mathematics to everyday activities like using a credit card?

    -The professor relates mathematics to everyday activities by explaining that mathematical concepts, such as number theory, are used in data encryption, which is involved when swiping a credit card.

  • What is the role of topological data analysis in understanding complex data?

    -Topological data analysis allows for understanding the overall shape of complex data in a fuzzy setting, which is helpful because most real-world data contains noise and imperfections.

  • How did Safi and Devdas apply mathematical concepts to the study of beer?

    -Safi and Devdas applied mathematical concepts to the study of beer by analyzing 15 to 25 characteristics of different beers to create a 'family tree' that shows how they are related to one another.

  • What is the professor's view on the relationship between mathematics and reality?

    -The professor believes that mathematics should partner with the world to provide a different perspective, rather than trying to trump or replace the reality of a situation.

  • Why does the professor caution against the over-reliance on quantification and data?

    -The professor cautions against over-reliance on quantification and data because it can trivialize complex human experiences and issues that cannot be easily distilled into numbers.

  • What does the professor believe attracts him to the Christian faith?

    -The professor is attracted to the Christian faith because it provides answers to questions about human existence, emotions, and relationships that science does not address.

  • How does the professor envision the role of mathematics in the new heaven and the new earth?

    -The professor envisions that mathematics will continue to be relevant in the new heaven and the new earth, as it will be part of a physical world that is an improved version of the current one.

  • What was the unique aspect of the sculpture created by Safi and Devdas and his team for Burning Man?

    -The sculpture was unique because it was shaped like a dodecahedron, had a mirrored interior, and could be unfolded and laid flat, reflecting both mathematical and cosmological concepts.

Outlines

00:00

📐 Mathematics and Its Practical Applications

Safi and Devdas, a professor of mathematics and computer science at the University of San Diego, discusses his passion for studying shapes and their applications in various fields. He explains that mathematics is about recognizing patterns and structures, which can be applied to numbers, functions, and images. He highlights the evolution of 'applied mathematics' from traditional engineering applications to a broader scope in the 21st century, where almost every mathematical concept finds practical use. He also mentions his work in topological data analysis, a field pioneered by Gunnar Carlson, which focuses on understanding the overall shape of data in a fuzzy setting, useful for handling noisy real-world data. An example of this is quickly identifying types of diabetes from patient data.

05:02

🍺 Beer Genetics and the Limitations of Mathematical Modeling

The speaker recounts a project with students where they collaborated with a brew master to understand the characteristics that define different types of beer. They analyzed data from 21 beers and created a 'family tree' to show how these beers are related. This exercise in applying mathematics to real-world problems is contrasted with the brew master's deep knowledge and experience. The speaker emphasizes that while mathematical models can provide new perspectives, they should not be seen as superior to practical knowledge. They also discuss societal perceptions of mathematicians as being highly intelligent and the dangers of overemphasizing the role of mathematics in understanding complex human experiences.

10:03

🌐 The Complexity of Human Experience and the Role of Art

The narrative shifts to the complexity of human experience, which the speaker argues cannot be fully captured by mathematical formulas or scientific data. They compare the simplicity of mathematical problems to the intricacies of human relationships and societal issues like race relations. The speaker also touches on the role of art in expressing the inexpressible and criticizes the obsession with quantification and data in modern society. They argue for a more holistic understanding of truth that includes non-quantifiable aspects of human existence.

15:04

🌟 Faith and the Intersection of Science and Theology

The speaker explores the intersection of faith and science, reflecting on how the Christian faith provides answers to questions about human existence and morality that science does not address. They discuss their personal journey of faith and how it is rooted in historical events rather than abstract philosophical concepts. The speaker also ponders the implications of their faith for their work in mathematics, questioning which mathematical concepts will persist in a future 'new heaven and new earth' and how their mathematical work can have a lasting impact.

20:05

🎨 Making Mathematics Physical Through Art

The speaker shares their desire to make mathematics physical and their collaboration with artists to achieve this. They describe a project that resulted in a two-ton sculpture shaped like a dodecahedron, which was displayed at Burning Man. The sculpture, with its mirrored interior, prompts visitors to contemplate their humanity and the relationship between technology and human identity. The speaker also discusses the mathematical and cosmological significance of the dodecahedron, linking it to unsolved problems in geometry and the potential shape of the universe. They conclude by advocating for a balanced appreciation of both the digital and physical worlds and the importance of human experiences over data and technology.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Mathematics

Mathematics is the abstract science of number, quantity, and space, either as abstract concepts, or by embodying them in physical objects or forms. In the video, mathematics is portrayed as a tool to understand patterns and structures in the world, from prime numbers in encryption to shapes and angles in everyday objects. The speaker, a professor of mathematics, uses it to study and appreciate the beauty of shapes and their deeper complexities.

💡Applied Mathematics

Applied Mathematics involves the use of mathematical methods to solve real-world problems. The term 'applied' in the 20th century was often associated with practical applications in engineering and physics. However, in the 21st century, as mentioned in the video, every area of mathematics has become applied due to its relevance in various fields, including data encryption, prediction analysis, and quantum mechanics.

💡Topology

Topology is a branch of mathematics that deals with the properties of space that are preserved under continuous transformations, such as stretching or bending, but not tearing or gluing. The video describes topology as a way to understand the shape of things when precise measurements are not possible, like seeing the world without glasses. It's used in topological data analysis to understand the overall shape of data, which is often noisy and incomplete.

💡Topological Data Analysis

Topological Data Analysis (TDA) is a method in mathematics that helps to understand the shape of data. It's like looking at the data in a fuzzy way to get a general idea of its shape rather than precise measurements. In the video, TDA is used as an example of how mathematics can be applied to quickly diagnose medical conditions like diabetes by identifying patterns in data.

💡Patterns

Patterns in mathematics refer to regularity and repetition of numbers, shapes, or structures. The video emphasizes how mathematics helps in making sense of patterns, whether in numbers for encryption or in functions for engineering. Patterns are fundamental to understanding and predicting outcomes in various fields, including the study of beer characteristics mentioned in the script.

💡Beer Genetics

The term 'beer genetics' used in the video is a metaphorical way to describe the characteristics that define different types of beer. The speaker and his students worked with a brew master to identify around 20 characteristics common to all beers. By analyzing these characteristics, they created a 'family tree' of beers to understand how different beers are related, showcasing the application of mathematical tools in an unconventional field.

💡Humanities

Humanities are academic disciplines that study various aspects of human culture, including history, literature, and philosophy. In the video, the speaker discusses the importance of valuing the humanities alongside sciences, arguing against the idea that one is superior to the other. He emphasizes the complexity of human experiences and the limitations of quantifying human emotions and experiences.

💡Christian Faith

Christian Faith in the video is discussed as a belief system that provides answers to existential questions that science might not address. The speaker reflects on how his faith is attracted to the Christian narrative of history and its intersection with human life, rather than scientific explanations. It's presented as a complement to his work in mathematics, offering a different perspective on the human experience.

💡New Heaven and Earth

The concept of a 'new heaven and earth' comes from Christian eschatology, referring to a future, perfect state of existence after the current world ends. In the video, the speaker contemplates what mathematics will be like in this ideal state, suggesting that mathematical truths will persist but be understood in a more profound way, and that the physical world will be experienced as it was meant to be.

💡Sculpture

In the context of the video, a sculpture serves as a physical manifestation of mathematical concepts and a means to explore themes of humanity and existence. The speaker describes creating a dodecahedron-shaped sculpture for Burning Man, which not only represents complex mathematical and cosmological ideas but also provides a space for introspection about being human beyond the digital world.

Highlights

Mathematics is about making sense of patterns and structures.

Applied mathematics in the 21st century involves every aspect of math.

Mathematics is useful in encryption, engineering, and predicting business outcomes.

Topology, a branch of mathematics, helps understand the shape of complex data.

Professor Safi studies pictures and their mathematical properties.

Data analysis can quickly identify medical conditions like diabetes.

Mathematics can reveal patterns in beer characteristics, similar to genetic sequencing.

Mathematics is a tool to partner with the world, not to overshadow reality.

The complexity of human experience is more intricate than mathematical formulas.

Mathematics is not superior to other disciplines; all are valuable in understanding the world.

The spectrum of disciplines reflects the complexity of the questions they address.

Science and quantification are not the ultimate measures of truth in all aspects of life.

The Christian faith provides answers to questions about human existence and purpose.

Mathematics will persist in the new heaven and new earth as described by the Christian faith.

The physical world is essential to human experience and should be valued in academic pursuits.

Collaborating with artists helps make mathematics physical and tangible.

A dodecahedron sculpture represents both mathematical concepts and philosophical questions.

The shape of the universe may be related to the dodecahedron, an unsolved problem in geometry.

Mathematics can be a personal expression of faith without being a proof of God's existence.

The value of human experiences, like enjoying a cup of coffee, surpasses data and quantification.

Transcripts

play00:00

my name is Safi and devdas I'm a

play00:01

professor of mathematics and computer

play00:03

science at the University of San Diego

play00:05

[Music]

play00:12

so I'm a math professor and my work

play00:14

focuses around shape so I love to study

play00:17

how how shape can be framed how shape

play00:20

can be measured how shape can be looked

play00:23

at or shape can be understood and you

play00:25

know when you think of mathematics to me

play00:27

mathematics is all about how do you make

play00:30

sense of patterns and structures of

play00:32

things so you can make patterns and

play00:34

structures of numbers you get prime

play00:35

numbers and the numbers used for

play00:37

encryption and data you can make

play00:38

patterns and structures the functions

play00:40

like sine function and cosine function

play00:42

useful for engineering and a thousand

play00:44

other things or or for money useful for

play00:47

transactions and or you can make

play00:50

patterns and structures of pictures and

play00:53

that's what I do I study pictures so

play00:54

angles and triangles could be very

play00:56

simpler things you might have learned

play00:57

earlier but but even those really simple

play01:00

things turned out to have really deep

play01:02

complicated beautiful things as as we

play01:05

get older so that's what I love now one

play01:07

of the things I'm in love with is not

play01:09

just mathematics my title actually is

play01:11

professor of applied mathematics and

play01:14

that word applied has has two meanings

play01:18

there's the 20th century meaning and

play01:20

20th century meaning is applications has

play01:23

always been what Boeing would want you

play01:25

know let's let's use mathematics for an

play01:27

engineer to to build airplane design or

play01:29

submarine structures or or build

play01:31

buildings so mathematics has been

play01:33

applied using the tools of sines and

play01:37

cosines and functions for engineers and

play01:40

scientists and physicists so Einstein

play01:42

uses the mathematics and it's applied

play01:44

math but you know this amazing shift has

play01:47

happened in the 21st century in 21st

play01:49

century applied mathematics is no longer

play01:51

about subject it's not about

play01:52

differential equations or calculus it

play01:54

turns out every math you could ever

play01:56

imagine is applied math so if you care

play01:59

about numbers turns out that almost

play02:01

everywhere that numbers are multiplied

play02:04

together and factored into pieces is how

play02:06

data is encrypted when you swipe your

play02:07

Visa card so the National Security

play02:09

Agency NSA they hire mostly math PhDs or

play02:13

number theorists number theory turns out

play02:16

to be useful for for people anywhere in

play02:18

the world today if you care about issues

play02:20

of chance and probability like how often

play02:23

do I get heads or tail

play02:24

and a simple coin toss or rolling dice

play02:26

turns out that's the foundation of how

play02:28

you do prediction analysis for business

play02:29

you want to model these things because

play02:32

you have so much data coming in that you

play02:34

can't get anything 100% right

play02:35

so now data is almost going to be

play02:38

approximated you'd be happy to be 95%

play02:40

sure 90% sure something's gonna work

play02:42

because you have terabytes of data

play02:44

coming to you per second so now all of a

play02:46

sudden things that were known for

play02:47

probability turns out to be applied if

play02:48

you care about patterns of how molecules

play02:51

are organized and the structures and

play02:54

shapes of a rubik's cube for example

play02:55

turns out that's the foundation for

play02:57

quantum mechanic issues and foundations

play03:00

for chemistry so terms that almost every

play03:02

mathematical idea that you can think of

play03:04

turns out to be applied even from number

play03:05

theoretical stuff and and what I care

play03:07

about is shape and a revolution happened

play03:10

related recently to the kind of shape I

play03:12

care about which is not geometric shape

play03:14

which talks about spheres and angles but

play03:17

topological shape and topology just

play03:19

means take off your glasses if you take

play03:21

your glasses off how does the world look

play03:22

it looks fuzzy and then you roughly get

play03:25

the idea their shape but you don't get

play03:26

it perfectly and and it turns out

play03:28

there's and at Stanford there's a

play03:31

faculty named professor named Gunnar

play03:32

Carlson who I worked with and he was one

play03:35

of the founders of this field called

play03:36

topological data analysis so what he

play03:39

does is he looks at data and he takes up

play03:41

his glasses and he sees the data

play03:42

approximately in a fuzzy way and he's

play03:44

able to tell you what the overall shape

play03:46

of the data is in a fuzzy setting not on

play03:49

a perfect angular measurement setting

play03:52

but in a fuzzy setting and that helps a

play03:54

lot because most of the data that we get

play03:55

have noise in it all right no data

play03:57

that's coming to us is perfect a lot of

play03:59

people when they fill out their forms

play04:00

and you're watching Netflix and you're

play04:02

giving Netflix data if you're giving

play04:03

data from Amazon or Apple you don't fill

play04:05

out all the all the fields so they don't

play04:08

know everything about you there's all

play04:09

these holes missing and that that data

play04:12

has noise because you might maybe fill

play04:14

one or two things incorrectly so the

play04:15

fact you could take off your glasses and

play04:16

get a rough approximation of what's

play04:18

really going on is beautiful so using

play04:21

topological data analysis you could

play04:22

immediately tell whether you're normal

play04:24

or have type 1 or type 2 diabetes'

play04:26

really quickly you can quickly see that

play04:28

there are these three branches going on

play04:30

you're gonna fit in one of those things

play04:31

you don't need to know the exact

play04:32

geometry but that rough topology is

play04:34

really good so everything is applied

play04:36

that's why I love it

play04:37

you know so one thing that I did with my

play04:39

students recently is I wanted to find

play04:43

patterns and structures in beer so San

play04:46

Diego where I'm at in my theory of San

play04:47

Diego is really known for their for

play04:51

their beer it's one of the number one

play04:53

craft brewery markets in the world I

play04:55

think they're about 160 different

play04:57

Brewers here and so we went to one of

play04:59

the oldest Brewers here it's the San

play05:02

Diego Brewing Company and we talked to

play05:03

the brew master and we said can you tell

play05:06

us what makes a beer a beer instead of

play05:08

the labels of Pilsner or IPA or or ales

play05:13

what is it that makes beer special and

play05:16

the brew master said actually you know

play05:19

if you take any beer in the world if you

play05:20

rip the label off you basically have

play05:22

about 15 to 25 characteristics of what

play05:26

makes a beer a beer including things

play05:28

like things like original gravity final

play05:33

gravity pounds of hops temperature that

play05:36

goes in temperature coming out and he

play05:39

gave me a list about 20 and he said any

play05:41

beer in the world can be broken up into

play05:42

these 20 pieces and they have different

play05:44

weights

play05:44

sometimes the alcohol content actually

play05:46

matters a lot sometimes it doesn't

play05:48

and so what we did was we took the data

play05:51

of 21 different beers that they had they

play05:54

gave me the data for each of their

play05:55

pieces this is called basically the beer

play05:57

genetics of what appears and we put it

play05:59

in in some sense - like a gene

play06:01

sequencing machine and it spit out a

play06:03

family tree of how these 21 beers are

play06:05

related to one another

play06:06

and so to me that's how I think of

play06:08

applying mathematics you take real world

play06:10

problems real world interesting

play06:13

questions that are out there and how

play06:14

things can be related to one another may

play06:16

be through the lens of biology and

play06:18

genetics and then you use the

play06:19

mathematical tools to extract that and

play06:21

say here's something else you can do

play06:23

with it now a word of warning for me is

play06:26

that this genetic tree of how the beer

play06:28

is are related to one another it is not

play06:31

more powerful or more amazing than

play06:33

anything the brew master already knows

play06:34

so I want to be really clear that math

play06:36

is not here to trump what the reality is

play06:38

about it's just here to partner with the

play06:40

world to talk with them about it it

play06:42

might be a different way of framing

play06:44

something that people haven't seen

play06:45

before but to say that somehow math now

play06:47

with this beer genetic tree is the

play06:49

ultimate

play06:50

with a capital T is something that's

play06:52

very worrisome and II have to be careful

play06:54

I think if you think about almost any

play06:56

other discipline they struggle with

play06:58

their own notions of truth and notions

play06:59

of what it means to be right and math

play07:01

just comes along and shares its

play07:02

perspective you know one of the things

play07:04

that found over the years when every

play07:07

time I travel is people are are honored

play07:13

to be with me because I'm a

play07:15

mathematician somehow they think I'm

play07:16

smarter than them because of the fact

play07:18

that I have a math credential this is

play07:20

really interesting to me if I'm in a

play07:22

plane and somebody's sitting in the

play07:23

middle and I'm sitting on one side of

play07:25

them as a mathematician and you know the

play07:27

world's greatest Nobel Laura poets who's

play07:31

on the other side or or one of the most

play07:33

amazing artists who exists in the world

play07:36

today sitting on the other side people

play07:37

usually it feels like turns to them and

play07:40

say oh you're an artist it's great but

play07:41

this is a mathematician you know he

play07:43

really understands what it means to be

play07:44

smart no matter how smart you are he

play07:47

really gets it and they use smart like

play07:49

with a capital S right you know somehow

play07:51

I have the full truth with a capital T

play07:53

in my hand and and I find that really

play07:56

dangerous I think you know having grown

play07:58

up in India there's a spectrum of how

play08:01

smart somebody is and I thought it was

play08:02

an Indian thing until I came to the

play08:03

States and I realized it's the same

play08:05

thing everywhere you know on one side as

play08:06

a mathematician and then the next of

play08:08

them are the physicists and the

play08:10

biologists and the chemists and and then

play08:12

over here the sort of a social scientist

play08:14

right there science

play08:16

you know economists psychology and and

play08:21

then you get into historians and and

play08:23

eventually you get into linguistic

play08:25

scholars and languages and the way over

play08:28

on the other side of the artists and

play08:29

most students think oh I'm not a

play08:32

scientist I don't think this way I'm not

play08:33

the smart so I'm actually going to be on

play08:35

the art side I think that spectrum is

play08:39

universal but at the same time the

play08:41

spectrum hides something it hides the

play08:43

level of complexity I think to me the

play08:46

mathematician is really productive and

play08:48

it's really good and it has great output

play08:51

is because she is dealing with something

play08:53

that's not complicated

play08:54

you know the fact that you have

play08:56

something called the quadratic formula

play08:58

means that a formula can answer whatever

play09:02

you're thinking about I mean it's

play09:03

right if I'm talking to my wife and I

play09:06

realized that she's not happy with how I

play09:08

acted the day before there's no wife

play09:10

formula to plug in because to hang out

play09:13

with another human to deal with them as

play09:15

a person to love them to forgive them to

play09:17

take care of them as a human is far more

play09:20

complicated than an formula or an

play09:22

equation so what do we do is math right

play09:24

we just you take an idea beer

play09:25

complicated as it could be about the

play09:27

smell of a beer about the taste it would

play09:29

be about the social construct of what it

play09:31

means to be human and drink a beer and

play09:32

we boil it down into about 20 variables

play09:36

and then we say oh here's the family

play09:38

tree of beer but that's a pathetically

play09:41

silly slice of the complication of what

play09:43

beer really is I think what happens is

play09:45

you move down the spectrum is you're

play09:47

dealing with things that get more and

play09:49

more complicated and thus you can't say

play09:51

that much about it a historian is

play09:53

dealing with a far harder question than

play09:55

a mathematician they can't answer it in

play09:58

the easy way because the question is

play09:59

harder right they can't they can't nail

play10:01

it down as simple as we can because

play10:03

there's no formula for it they have

play10:04

their own tools of measuring truth and

play10:06

their own tools of method measuring

play10:08

smartness but but the thing they're

play10:10

asking is a complicated thing and an

play10:13

artist is actually trying to describe

play10:15

things that can't even be expressed in

play10:17

words in fact they need images to even

play10:19

get to the kind of things that we can

play10:22

speak in English and I'm at the physics

play10:25

we can speak it in formulas so that's

play10:26

triviality you know I always say that we

play10:28

can put somebody on the moon because

play10:30

putting somebody on the moon is easy we

play10:32

can't solve race relations not because

play10:34

the people who study race are not smart

play10:36

but but studying race relations was

play10:39

incredibly hard it's really hard to talk

play10:41

about equality of men and women in the

play10:42

world today and and me too movement

play10:45

that's pushing ahead because those are

play10:46

incredibly hard questions for us to

play10:48

wrestle with and how do you bring

play10:49

justice in the world today that people

play10:51

are struggling with the currency in the

play10:53

world today is science right is

play10:54

quantification and data a friend of mine

play10:56

studies black pastors in the south and

play11:01

he's not a Christian he's not a believer

play11:03

but he's been interviewing the the

play11:06

transformation of the lives of these

play11:08

black pastors in the south for about 20

play11:11

years and he's a sociologist and he

play11:14

wants to know what does it mean to be

play11:16

wrestling with issues of race and faith

play11:19

at the same time one of the biggest

play11:22

narratives as a pastor is this Exodus

play11:24

that God will one day set you free and

play11:26

it really resonates with the

play11:27

african-american community but what

play11:29

happens if now the pastor of this church

play11:30

is now driving a Lexus you know does

play11:33

that mean that they've already achieved

play11:35

it clearly that's not what the world

play11:36

says so that's the kind of really deep

play11:39

sophisticated in-depth question he's

play11:41

dealing with but most of the journals

play11:43

that he's submitting his work to keep

play11:44

saying to him where's the data and he's

play11:47

saying this is the data I mean what it

play11:49

means to be a human is to talk to them

play11:51

and to understand with them you can't

play11:52

quantify and distill this into a bunch

play11:54

of numbers that's trivia trivializing

play11:56

the work so the world is obsessed with

play11:59

truth based on data and and it's

play12:03

dangerous because it's wrong that's the

play12:04

simple stuff the thing is I think that

play12:06

absolutely makes sense if you're in the

play12:08

science world I mean you should be

play12:10

judged right by data and of the sciences

play12:12

but the problem is when you start

play12:15

leaving the world and using the same set

play12:18

of tools what one of my favorite people

play12:19

is Richard Dawkins I like him because

play12:21

he's truly passionate of how about what

play12:24

he believes in and I'd rather have

play12:26

somebody who's passionate and against

play12:28

you know against faith or against God

play12:30

that's great I'm glad he's putting

play12:32

strips on the table but the reason I

play12:33

struggle with him is because he's not

play12:35

trained as a philosopher he's not

play12:37

trained as a theologian he's trained as

play12:39

a as a biologist as as an evolutionary

play12:42

biologist he's brilliant at what he does

play12:44

but you can't take those same set of

play12:46

tools and say now I have enough tools to

play12:48

answer any questions Stephen Hawking did

play12:51

the same thing when he talked about

play12:53

philosophy being dead and he said

play12:55

philosophy is now dead well that

play12:57

statement is a philosophical statement

play12:59

so he's using philosophy to talk about

play13:00

philosophy being dead and I mean he's a

play13:02

brilliant cosmologists he's a brilliant

play13:05

physicist one of the greatest who's ever

play13:06

existed but to say that those weapons

play13:08

and physics can now be used to shoot

play13:10

down other arguments in history and in

play13:12

science and in history and political

play13:14

science and full of philosophy is as

play13:18

dangerous and wrong I guess what

play13:21

attracts me and what pulls me and makes

play13:23

me think of the Christian faith is not

play13:26

things from a scientific lens you know

play13:29

if I think back to what

play13:30

means to be a mathematician when I was

play13:33

in undergrad or grad school I don't

play13:35

remember any lectures from a professor

play13:38

if I was amazing I had an amazing

play13:39

professors but I remember oh my gosh

play13:41

that lecture on triple integrals was

play13:44

just incredible

play13:45

I don't read any of that stuff I just

play13:47

you know I usually remember things like

play13:48

hey the the pizza party we had that

play13:50

night or the night we played euchre or

play13:54

the way the girls smelled next to me or

play13:56

the dance like how am I getting I never

play13:58

want to dance but you know you know you

play14:00

know what I'm saying

play14:01

but all of those things is what it means

play14:03

to be humans is what attracts me and

play14:05

gives me these memories so the reason

play14:08

I'm attracted to the Christian faith is

play14:09

not because of some scientific slam dunk

play14:11

argument of course if there's a tension

play14:13

if there's a huge tension between what

play14:16

the Christian faith says and the way the

play14:18

world is framed according to the

play14:19

Christian perspective versus the

play14:21

scientific data we have then yeah then

play14:24

we're in trouble but I don't see that

play14:25

tension at all in fact if I'm reading

play14:27

through scripture or listening to how

play14:29

it's been interpreted it's usually that

play14:32

that the scripture is not really

play14:33

interested in science it's not making

play14:35

questions of science it's answering

play14:36

questions of who we are why we're here

play14:38

why do we feel anger when we watch a

play14:42

movie like 12 years of slave you know

play14:43

when we want justice to happen in this

play14:46

world what does it mean to forgive what

play14:48

does it mean to retaliate you know those

play14:49

bigger questions what does it mean to

play14:52

have a great relationship but it's mean

play14:53

to enjoy food those are the kind of

play14:55

questions that science doesn't answer

play14:56

but the Christian faith does and most

play14:59

faith to do the reason I'm attracted to

play15:02

the Christian faith in particular is it

play15:04

actually is rooted in history so unlike

play15:07

a theoretical or an abstract

play15:09

philosophical faith it actually says God

play15:12

intersected the world in certain places

play15:14

in certain times and here's how it

play15:15

actually happened it's not God does this

play15:17

and the world runs this way they

play15:19

actually meet and because of that you

play15:20

could actually measure the meeting you

play15:22

can actually say well if Jesus lived

play15:24

then here's what it should look like if

play15:26

Jesus resurrected then here's what it

play15:28

should look like and that actually makes

play15:30

sense to me the fact I can actually

play15:31

measure through historical lens as to

play15:34

what's going on that's attractive the

play15:37

question I started asking maybe five to

play15:39

ten years ago in a very serious way

play15:42

which had

play15:44

echoes of it beforehand was what does it

play15:47

mean to be human and if you start asking

play15:50

that question I wanted to ask that

play15:51

question through the lens of a

play15:52

mathematician what does it mean to be

play15:53

human as a mathematician and so the

play15:56

Christian faith says actually that this

play15:59

world though amazing and beautiful and

play16:02

gorgeous and attractive is still broken

play16:04

they're parts of it they just don't fit

play16:06

and they're echoes of of glory in the

play16:09

background that it's pointing to

play16:12

something more amazing than what we have

play16:14

right now and so that more amazing world

play16:17

is the new heaven and the new earth when

play16:18

things will all be set right so being a

play16:21

mathematician I'm I got curious what

play16:23

will math be like in the new heaven and

play16:25

the new earth right like how much of

play16:27

this math is gonna last you know because

play16:28

you always want to make a lasting impact

play16:30

than whatever you do and how much of the

play16:31

math is gonna fade and if it's gonna

play16:33

fade why am i spending time on that

play16:34

stuff and if it's gonna last I'm gonna

play16:35

spend a lot more energy there so you

play16:38

know true with any friendships we have

play16:40

right we have a thousand friends and out

play16:42

of that we're gonna pour our energies

play16:43

into just a few of them who become

play16:44

really close friends because we want

play16:46

those friends to last throughout our

play16:48

lives we can turn to them in the worst

play16:49

and the best of times and so I wanted to

play16:53

know in mathematics what will last and I

play16:56

came to the conclusion that everything

play16:57

does that's the cool thing about math is

play16:59

everything is gonna last the new world's

play17:01

gonna take the mathematics we do and

play17:02

you're gonna see it in a much better way

play17:04

but more importantly though this new

play17:07

world is going to be a physical world

play17:09

just like this one so in other words

play17:11

it's not the physical world maybe as

play17:13

Buddhism or maybe Hinduism says is kind

play17:15

of this temporary place where you can't

play17:18

wait to get out of it and to become

play17:20

disembodied and purely spirit it's

play17:23

actually the physical world rocks it's

play17:24

amazing it's in the new earth this new

play17:27

heaven and the new earth where God and

play17:29

his people are gonna be together it's a

play17:31

place where the physical world is going

play17:33

to be there except you're gonna see it

play17:35

the way it was meant to be seen the

play17:36

photograph you hold in your hand will

play17:38

now become the real place instead of a

play17:39

photograph of the Grand Canyon we're

play17:41

gonna be at the Grand Canyon it's gonna

play17:42

be amazing and so how can we make that

play17:46

come to the world today how can we make

play17:49

the future be like that in the world

play17:50

today and so what I wanted to start

play17:53

asking this like how do you make math

play17:54

physical that's the question I really

play17:56

wanted to ask if the new world's going

play17:57

to be physical

play17:57

math physical it turns out if you think

play18:00

about the academic life academia is the

play18:03

most ivory tower of every discipline

play18:05

right you could be a plumber a carpenter

play18:07

you could be a CEO you can be a data

play18:09

analyst at least touching the keyboard

play18:11

you know knock it away but an academic

play18:13

is like sitting literally thinking

play18:16

without actually interacting there's

play18:18

this notion of just literally thinking

play18:19

in the ivory tower about thoughts and

play18:21

the most whitest of the white collar is

play18:24

a mathematician because a chemist is

play18:26

actually doing chemical things and and a

play18:27

physicist doing physical things and a

play18:29

linguist is thinking about literature

play18:30

over time and the change of words but a

play18:32

mathematician man we're just inner

play18:34

thoughts these abstract ideas so what I

play18:37

want is how do you make math physical

play18:38

and I started working with artists over

play18:41

the years because artists actually are

play18:43

deeply embedded in physical things and I

play18:46

as a mathematician who cares about shape

play18:48

thought men who else but an artist whose

play18:50

thought about physical things and images

play18:53

to collaborate with so I started working

play18:56

with artists that you know we've we've

play18:58

done struggles with unsolved problems on

play19:01

on spaces of trees and genetics we have

play19:04

paintings that we did work with artists

play19:07

in lots of different ways but but the

play19:09

most recent one that is kind of exciting

play19:10

is is a collaborator and I Diane Hoffa

play19:14

she's another mathematician she and I

play19:15

got together formed a team of faculty

play19:18

and students and alum and community

play19:20

members and we raised about $50,000 and

play19:23

we built a two-ton sculpture that we

play19:25

took to Burning Man and the sculpture is

play19:28

remarkable for several things one the

play19:30

outside of the sculpture is shaped like

play19:32

a dodecahedron but the hinges of the

play19:34

pentagonal hinge is open and you can

play19:36

actually get in and the outside looks

play19:38

like the matrix icon icon agraphia where

play19:41

that where the lights kind of look like

play19:42

these matrix flow which ask the question

play19:45

of what does it mean to be human in

play19:48

terms of a computer controlling you and

play19:50

the inside once you go inside the

play19:52

dodecahedron it's lined with about

play19:54

10-foot tall mirrors it's a mirrored

play19:56

room of a dodecahedron and it's

play19:58

basically reflecting you all around so

play20:00

now all of a sudden you're absolutely

play20:01

human you're not this outside

play20:03

environment and it asked the question

play20:04

now that you've kind of gone past

play20:06

technology what does it mean to be human

play20:07

in the middle of all this so that's the

play20:10

that's the artistic framework of how we

play20:12

thought of it but in terms of the object

play20:15

itself it turns out that a mere

play20:17

dodecahedron is a really close example

play20:20

of what our current shape of our

play20:21

universe could be you know the shape of

play20:23

the earth is a sphere but what's the

play20:25

shape of the universe it turns out that

play20:27

the plonker a dodecahedral sphere which

play20:29

is a version of the dodecahedron where

play20:32

he can kind of pass through walls and do

play20:33

these cool tricks then the mirror

play20:35

dodecahedron comes comes to scratch that

play20:38

itch of what the shape of our universe

play20:40

could be so that's really cool it's an

play20:41

unsolved problem of what the universe is

play20:42

and also the there's an unsolved math

play20:44

problem which is can you take any

play20:47

polyhedron and cut along the edges and

play20:50

unfold and lay it flat so albert durer

play20:52

500 years old

play20:54

500 years ago asked this question is it

play20:56

true that any polyhedron can be laid

play20:58

laid flat by cutting along the edges and

play21:01

it's still an unsolved problem today

play21:02

it's the biggest unsolved problem in

play21:03

geometry that I know of and so it turns

play21:06

out the dodecahedron actually unfolds

play21:08

that you can get in just like the way

play21:10

dirt imagined and then you could fold

play21:12

back in and get into the shape of this

play21:13

universe so deals with these unsolved

play21:15

questions of mathematics unsolved

play21:16

questions of physics and cosmology and

play21:18

yet it's a physical object that people

play21:21

can interact with and think about what

play21:23

it means to be human in terms of math as

play21:26

an evidence for my faith I don't see it

play21:28

so in other words I could look at a

play21:30

beautiful theorem and I can say lots of

play21:32

gorgeous theorem it could be an absolute

play21:34

atheist not believe in anything beyond

play21:36

the world that I see in some sense and

play21:38

say this is pretty right the Gauss Bonet

play21:40

theorem is one of the prettiest limbs in

play21:41

the world period or I can believe that

play21:44

there's a creator out there who designed

play21:47

the world and has partnered with us to

play21:49

create with him and I could also look at

play21:50

the gospel in a theorem and say this is

play21:52

pretty this is gorgeous and I could just

play21:54

add the words Wow thank God

play21:56

that he thought of these beautiful

play21:58

things and has allowed me to see his

play21:59

creation so either way Gauss Bonet is

play22:02

Gauss Bonet and so this is just this

play22:05

external viewpoint of how I view the

play22:07

world looking at mathematics but the

play22:09

math itself isn't I don't see it as a

play22:12

pointer to God in other words it is a

play22:14

pointer to God but it's not enough to

play22:16

convince me it's not enough to push my

play22:18

chips into the bucket of faith just

play22:20

because mathematics makes sense

play22:23

not for me if I can have one dream it

play22:26

would be two pieces of thread that would

play22:28

fit together nicely and the first thread

play22:30

is to say we should be careful with the

play22:32

Enlightenment which shatters our

play22:35

disciplines into pieces and so some

play22:37

might be better than others to say that

play22:39

math is better than the humanities which

play22:42

could be better than the arts I think we

play22:43

should value all of them and put her

play22:45

back as this tapestry and the second

play22:47

part is to push back not just against

play22:49

the Enlightenment but against the

play22:50

Industrial Revolution to say that this

play22:53

mass production of things makes us

play22:56

better humans I think we have to be

play22:57

really careful of what it means to live

play22:59

in a world that's physical that as we

play23:01

think more about the digital world that

play23:03

we become disembody we forget what is

play23:06

important to smell and touch and we keep

play23:09

thinking data and the prolific ation and

play23:11

the quantification of data is valuable

play23:13

it is but not compared to being human a

play23:15

great cup of coffee is better than a

play23:17

thousand data analysts and their code

play23:19

that they can write a great conversation

play23:21

over a good meal made at home is more

play23:24

remarkable than climbing the highest

play23:26

tower you could imagine in New York so

play23:28

as long as we value what it means to

play23:31

live a blue-collar life with those who

play23:33

use their hands well and honor them as

play23:34

much as those who might honor the white

play23:36

collar world and at the same time honor

play23:38

these different disciplines I'd love it

play23:45

you

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Ähnliche Tags
MathematicsReal-worldFaithArtScienceTechnologyHumanityPatternsStructuresEducation
Benötigen Sie eine Zusammenfassung auf Englisch?