RIP Adobe?! Procreate CEO Says NO to Generative AI, Artists CHEER!

Summary

このビデオスクリプトでは、デジタルアートとAI、そしてプロクレートに関する議論が中心です。プロクレートは、生成的AIをプラットフォームに取り入れることを拒否し、アーティストの創造性に対する脅威と位置づけています。AdobeがユーザーのコンテンツをAIモデルのトレーニングに使用するという問題が浮上した後、プロクレートのCEOは生成的AIを製品に導入しないという強い立場を表明しました。デジタルアーティストたちからは広範な支持を受けていますが、AIの適切な利用法が議論の的となっており、創造性と効率のバランスを探求する必要があります。

Takeaways

• 🎨 プロクリートが生成的AIに反対し、製品にその技術を取り入れることを決して誓約している。
• 👨‍🎨 プロクリートのCEO、ジェームズ・クーダは、生成的AIが芸術家たちに与える影響に強い反発を示している。
• 🤖 Adobeは生成的AIを製品に取り入れ、ユーザーのコンテンツをAIモデルのトレーニングに使用するかもしれないという誤解を招いた。
• 🖌️ プロクリートは、生成的AIが人間の創造性に対する脅威であると主張しており、その立場は多くのデジタルアーティストから称賛を受けている。
• 📱 プロクリートはiPad向けのデザインアプリであり、生成的AIを導入しないという方針を公表している。
• 📰 TechCrunchの記事によると、プロクリートは生成的AI技術を製品に取り入れる予定はないという立場を明確にした。
• 🔧 他のデジタルアートアプリが生成的AI技術を採用している中、プロクリートのこの姿勢は特に際立っている。
• 👀 アーティストたちは、自分の作品がAIアート機械のトレーニングに使用されることを避けたいと考えている。
• 🛠️ プロクリートは、生成的AI技術をサポートしないことで、人間の創造性に対する支持を表明している。
• 🔄 プロクリートの立場は、デジタルアート業界におけるAI技術の使用に対する議論をさらに深めている。
• 🔮 プロクリートは、生成的AI技術を製品に取り入れることで顧客の信頼を失うリスクがあると判断している。

Q & A

プロクリートが生成的AIに何故反対するのか説明してください。

プロクリートは、生成的AIが人間の創造性に対して脅威になる可能性があると見做しており、特にアーティストがそのジョブを失う恐れがあると懸念しています。プロクリートは主にアーティストをターゲットにしており、彼らの創造性に対するサポートを重視しています。

Adobeがどのような問題に直面しているのか教えてください。

Adobeは、生成的AIを製品に取り入れることで、ユーザーのコンテンツをAIのトレーニングに使用することができると誤解された新しいサービス条件により、批判を浴びています。後にAdobeは、顧客のコンテンツをAIモデルのトレーニングに使用していないと明確にしました。

プロクリートのCEO、James Cudaはなぜ生成的AIを嫌っているのですか？

James Cudaは、生成的AIがアーティストに対する影響と、それが行業全体に及ぼす影響に不満を持っており、彼は製品が人間の創造性をサポートするべきだと述べています。

デジタルアートアプリが生成的AIを採用することの利点とは何ですか？

生成的AIは、創造的なプロセスをスピードアップさせる助けとなり、煩わしい作業を簡略化することができ、アーティストの生産性を高めることができます。

生成的AIがアート業界でどのような反響を引き起こしているのか説明してください。

多くのアーティストは、生成的AIが彼らの作品を無断で使用してAIアート機械をトレーニングすることに反対しており、それが彼らの生計を脅威としていると感じています。

プロクリートが生成的AIを採用しないという方針はどのようにデジタルアーティストに評価されているのか教えてください。

プロクリートの方針はデジタルアーティストから広く称賛を受けています。彼らは、Adobeのように他のデジタルアートやイラストレーションアプリが技術を採用している一方で、プロクリートがアーティストの仕事を守ると誓っていることに満足しています。

クリエイティブスイートが生成的AIを採用していないかどうか確認するにはどうすればよいですか？

クリエイティブスイートが生成的AIを採用していないかどうかを確認するためには、公式ウェブサイトや関連するニュース記事をチェックすることが重要です。

AIがアニメーション業界でどのように役立つか説明してください。

AIは、アニメーションの間のフレーム生成やその他の煩わしい作業を自動化することで、アニメーションプロセスを効率化する助けとなる可能性があります。

生成的AIの技術が進展する中で、アーティストはどのように適応すべきか教えてください。

アーティストは、生成的AIを単なるツールとして使用し、創造性と効率を高めるために活用することが重要です。技術を拒否することは、彼らのキャリアに悪影響を及ぼす可能性があります。

Adobeのサブスクリプションモデルに対する批判とはどのようなものですか？

Adobeのサブスクリプションモデルは、永遠に月額料金を支払う必要があるという点で非効率的であり、さらにユーザーのコンテンツがAIモデルのトレーニングに使用される可能性があるという懸念があります。

プロクリートの立場が変わることがある場合、どのように対応するべきか教えてください。

企業の立場は市場や技術の変化により変わることがあります。プロクリートが立場を変える場合でも、顧客に対して透明性を持ってコミュニケーションを取り、変更の理由と方針を説明することが重要です。

Outlines

00:00

🖌️ プロクレートが生成的AIに反対表明

プロクレートは生成的AIを採用しないという立場を表明しました。この決定は、アーティストが生成的AIによって仕事を失う恐れがあるという懸念があるユーザーの声に応えるものであり、Adobeが同様の技術を導入したことで批判を受けた直後に行われました。プロクレートは、生成的AIが現在のプラットフォームにとって不適切であると主張し、アーティストのジョブを守ることを重要視しています。

05:01

🤖 プロクレートCEOの生成的AIへの強い反対

プロクレートのCEO、ジェームズ・クーダは、生成的AIが業界全体に及ぼす影響とアーティストに対する影響に強い反対を表明しました。彼は生成的AIを製品に導入しないという意思決定を支持し、人間中心の創造性に対する脅威と見なしています。この姿勢はデジタルアーティストの間で広く支持されています。

10:02

🎨 AIの役割：ツールか代替者か

生成的AIが創造的な職種を置き換える可能性があるという懸念の中で、プロクレートはAIをツールとしてのみ使用し、創造性に貢献するものと位置づけています。一方で、AdobeはユーザーのコンテンツをAIモデルのトレーニングに使用する可能性を示唆した更新された利用規約で批判を浴びていました。AIは創造的なプロセスを補助するツールとして役立つ可能性があるが、職位を排除することは避けたいという業界の声もあります。

15:03

🔄 技術の進歩と創造性の仕事

技術の進歩は常に創造的な業界に影響を与えており、プロクレートの決定は、AIがどのように使用されるかについての議論をさらに深めることでしょう。AIは創造的なプロセスを補助するツールとして役立つ一方で、職位を排除する可能性があると同時に、新しいタイプの創造性と表現方法を生み出すかもしれません。

Keywords

💡デジタルアート

デジタルアートとは、デジタル技術を用いて作成されるアートのことを指します。このビデオでは、デジタルアートがAI技術とどのように関連しているかが議論されています。ビデオでは、プロクリーエイトが生成的AIとどのように対処しているかについて触れられています。

💡プロクリーエイト

プロクリーエイトは、iPadで使用される人気デジタルアートアプリケーションです。ビデオでは、このアプリケーションが生成的AIをどのように拒否し、アーティストの創造性を保護する立場を取っているかが説明されています。

💡生成的AI

生成的AIとは、機械学習を用いて新しいコンテンツを生成する技術です。ビデオでは、生成的AIがアーティストの仕事にどのように脅威となる可能性があるか、そしてプロクリーエイトがこれを拒否する理由について議論されています。

💡Adobe

Adobeは、広く使われるデザインやイラストレーションソフトウェアを提供する企業です。ビデオでは、Adobeが生成的AIを導入し、それがどのようにアーティストの間で反発を引き起こしたかが触れられています。

💡アーティスト

アーティストは、ビデオの主題に密接に関係しており、生成的AIが彼らの仕事をどのように影響するかが問題となっています。ビデオでは、プロクリーエイトがアーティストの創造性と仕事を保護することを誓約していることが強調されています。

💡AIアシスト

AIアシストとは、アーティストの創造プロセスを支援するAI技術のことです。ビデオでは、AIアシストがどのように創造性に役立つか、そしてそれが生成的AIとどのように異なるかが議論されています。

💡テクノロジーの進歩

テクノロジーの進歩は、ビデオの重要なテーマの一つであり、それがアーティストのキャリアにどのように影響を与えるかが問題となっています。ビデオでは、テクノロジーが進歩する中で、アーティストがどのように適応するかが議論されています。

💡クリエイティブスイート

クリエイティブスイートは、Adobeが提供する一連のデザインツールです。ビデオでは、Adobeが生成的AIをこれらのツールにどのように取り入れ、それがアーティストにどのような影響を与えるかが説明されています。

💡ユーザーの反発

ユーザーの反発は、ビデオで強調されている重要なポイントで、それがAdobeの生成的AIに対する反応を示しています。ビデオでは、ユーザーが生成的AIが彼らの作品をどのように使用するかについて懸念していることが触れられています。

💡NFT

NFTとは、非代替性トークンの略で、デジタルアートなどの一意のコンテンツを所有権を証明するデジタル資産です。ビデオでは、Adobeがユーザーの作品をNFTに変換する可能性があるという懸念が示されています。

Highlights

Procreate has taken a stand against generative AI, in response to concerns from artists about job security.

The move is seen as a direct response to Adobe's incorporation of generative AI, which has caused controversy.

Procreate's stance is to reassure its primary customer base, artists, that their jobs are not at risk from AI.

The host expresses a balanced view on generative AI, seeing its value in disposable content but concerns for permanent works.

Adobe is criticized for potentially using user content to train its AI without clear consent.

Procreate's CEO, James Cuda, released a strong statement against generative AI, emphasizing support for human creativity.

The company's stance has been praised by digital artists who are wary of AI's impact on their industry.

Clip Studio Paint faced backlash and walked back plans for an image generator tool, showing sensitivity to user concerns.

The discussion highlights the potential of AI to speed up tedious tasks in digital art, such as tweening in animation.

The host suggests AI could be a useful tool in the creative process, but not a replacement for artists.

Adobe's updated terms of service caused concern among users about the potential misuse of their content for AI training.

Procreate's clear position against generative AI stands in contrast to other platforms embracing the technology.

The host predicts a generation of artists will become accustomed to AI tools, similar to the transition from traditional to digital painting.

There is a call for finding the right balance in using AI, to avoid creating sterile and bland art.

The host reflects on the impact of technological advancements on the job market in creative industries, drawing parallels with past transitions.

AI's role as an assistant in the creative workflow is endorsed, rather than as a replacement for human artists.

The host expresses concern about artists who may refuse to use AI tools, potentially hindering their productivity and relevance.

Procreate's commitment to not using generative AI provides assurance to its users about the security of their content.

The host criticizes Adobe's subscription model and the uncertainty around its use of user content for AI development.

The video concludes with a call to subscribe for more discussions on pop culture, reflecting the channel's broader focus.

Transcripts

hey guys welcome back to clownfish TV

this is neon I'm not here with geeky

Sparkles I'm going to talk about digital

art and Ai and procreate and I have to

give a hat tip to our friend Sarah who

who sent this over I did not

realize that there was so much drama

going on with so many of these uh

digital illustration apps now and

procreate has apparently taken a stand

against generative AI it's actually a

very good time I guess to take a stand

against generative AI if you are

catering primarily to artists who are

afraid of losing their jobs to

generative Ai and uh you know we've got

Adobe blowing themselves up we've

covered that and this seems to be a

direct response to the Adobe situation

that procreate is not going to use

generative AI now look I'm not and I've

said before obvious obviously obviously

if you've seen some of our thumbnails

I'm not completely against generative AI

however you know our thumbnails are

disposable right it's a very disposable

thing it's like okay I don't want to use

a copyrighted image and I need to get an

idea across and you know whatever like

people watch our videos and you know a

day or two later that nobody's watching

it it's disposable it's like a like a

newspaper right that's that's kind of

our our content the majority of our

content um so you know for me I like I

don't feel any uh particular guilt over

that because it's not like I was going

to go hire an artist or you know I'm

certainly not going to spend you know 10

hours drawing an illustration myself for

a video that's going to be viable for

like a day or two um but as far as like

more permanent things I think uh

generative AI is definitely becoming

more more of an issue especially if it's

scraping content now I don't think

there's any avoiding it I think it's

it's here you know it's here uh for

better for worse but I think artists are

trying to delay it as long as as

possible and they certainly don't want

their stuff scraped uh to be used to

train AI art machines and that is what's

going on that's what adobe's come under

Fire for is basically sneaking terms of

service into uh its uh most recent

version of of the

language that says that you basically

give them right to Snoop around in your

f and that they can you know use your

use your stuff to train their generative

AI which is so weird like we're we're

selling applications primarily to

creatives and we're basically selling

them an application that can now do all

the painting and the photo work itself

yeah it's just a very weird thing but uh

let's talk about procreate anyway uh I

do have procreate I don't use it very

much I do have a very large iPad I

actually find it harder especially for

work like this detailed I find it hard

harder to work on an iPad than I do to

work on a big ass XP pen tablet which is

mostly what I use is like a 27in tablet

because I'm blind as a bat and it's also

about the size of a drawing board but

there are a lot of people out there that

that swear by procreate so let's let's

talk about this and see what they have

to say about it they're they're uh

trying to tap into that market as is

Affinity uh Creative Suite they're not

using generative AI to the best of my

knowledge now I think if people want to

add a plugin that maybe does some AI

stuff and they're cool with it and the

terms of service are clear I think

that's okay right um but let's let's uh

look at this article this come from Tech

crunch before we get into it any further

Please Subscribe for more pop culture

news views and rants guys you'll get a

WooHoo for me woohoo no my woohoo are

not as good as geeki and I'm not going

to replace her with generative AI so

don't worry about that um yeah this is

coming from Tech crunch procreate takes

a stand against generative AI vows to

never incorporate the tech into its

products they vow never to do that so

guys if 5 years from now they're like

hey procreate AI is is on the way you

can point point this out and say hey

yeah you said you weren't going to do

that popular iPad design at procreate

it's coming out against generative AI

they said and it has vowed to never

introduce generative AI features into

its products the company said on its

website that although machine learning

is a compelling technology with a lot of

Merit the current path that generative

AI is on is on is wrong for its platform

um yeah there's been a lot of backlash

to Adobe and Adobe was kind of the

canary in at coal Min like hey what

happens if if we just have you know the

this software suite that we've been

selling to creatives what if it just

creates its own content and we don't

even need the artists anymore it's like

well who are you selling this to then

you know so it's just good business to

be like yeah we're going to protect

artists jobs because that literally is

our client base that's literally our

customer base procreate goes on to say

it's not chasing a technology that is a

threat to human creativity even though

this may make the company seem at risk

of being left behind procreate CEO James

Cuda released an even stronger statement

against the technology on X on Monday I

think he swears let's let's uh let's

listen to this are we rolling there you

go you've been asking us about AI you

know I usually don't like getting in

front of the camera I prefer that

products speak for themselves I really

[ __ ] hate journey of AI I don't like

what's happening in the industry I don't

like what it's doing to artists we're

not going to be introducing any

generative AI into our products okay our

products are always designed and

developed with the idea that a human

will be creating something you know we

don't exactly know where this story is

going to go or How It Ends but we

believe that we're on the right path

supporting human

creativity all right well I think I

think that's a I think that's a pretty

uh a pretty good statement coming from

someone who literally creates a

product that is sold to creatives to be

like hey guys yeah we're not going to

replace you uh if for no other reason

regardless of of whether or not he

actually believes it if for no other

reason it's not good business right it's

not good business to create a product to

eliminate your customer

paase uh the company stance has

attracted widespread praise from digital

artists online many of whom are unhappy

with the way other digital art and

illustration apps have embraced the

technology that would be again Adobe

David Tunes here says if you're

wondering whether to use Photoshop or

procreate remember this Adobe overpriced

monthly subscription generative AI

features you can't remove procreate

onetime purchase and the CEO said I

really effing hate generative AI uh back

let's see in 2022 clip Studio paint

walked back its plans to release an

image generator tool after facing

backlash from its user base yeah so clip

Studio that's another one your your user

base it's all artists It's All Digital

artists right now I can see some value

in maybe AI apps optional AI apps that

speed up some of the more tedious stuff

especially like an

animation uh you know some kind of like

in you know in-betweener program like

doing some tweening or something like

that that would be like you could just

do the key frames and it would generate

the in between frames for you hopefully

not add a bunch of extra fingers in the

process you know what I'm saying

something like that be useful um

flatting Comics I think would be useful

uh you know stuff like that you know I

mean artists have already been using uh

you know perspective tools and stuff

like that which I know some people were

like well that's cheating using

perspective tools that's cheating uh

using like halone buildings and stuff

like but like that's been going on for a

long time in comics and manga and it

does save time I mean you can either

drop in a building I mean if if you've

got you've got something happening in

like New York City it's easier to just

like Drop in a New York skyline that is

the actual New York skyline and do like

a half te pattern or something than it

is to like draw the entire New York City

skyline like in the amount of time it

would take you you could draw like two

or three more comic Pages you know what

I'm saying so little things like that

like I I don't have I personally don't

have a problem with um artists have been

using references for a while I know

there's a whole big discussion now on

whether or not artists should use any 3D

assets or whatever but this is actually

very common in manga uh especially when

you're dealing with real world vehicles

or technology or something like that but

you you do have to make it convincing it

should be used as reference and not just

be like d I don't think it should be

dropped right into the the page or

whatever because it it really takes

people out of it if it's a totally

different style but that's not AI either

but that is an assist and I think I

think that is the place for AI in the

workflow is as an

assistant uh you know something helpful

to help you speed up your creativity

your productivity not replacing entire

art departments you know because some

bean counter is like well I can just you

know plug in some prompts and get

whatever I want it's like n you still

need somebody dead to oversee it

right uh this is Adobe which arguably

has the most popular Suite of design

tools has released several generative AI

features into its products in addition

Adobe recently came under Fire after its

updated terms of service seem to imply

that it would train AI models on users

content the company later had to clarify

it doesn't train AI models on customers

content yeah a time when digital art

platforms are embracing AI Elum right

it's interesting to see a popular app go

against the crowd again it's in their

own best interests I mean I'm not saying

he doesn't believe it I believe he does

believe it but it is in your own best

interest as a company that literally

sells a product to digital

creatives and we know where they're at

with this right now you know this is not

a good time to say hey guys we're just

going to let yeah procreate yeah it's

just going to it's just gonna draw by

itself doesn't even need you it's gonna

it's gonna uh mine Bitcoin or something

when you you put your iPad to sleep it's

going to mint mint all of your work into

nfts without your knowledge or some

crazy [ __ ] you know but um yeah it's

it's going to be really interesting to

see the push back on this and if it has

any effect because I mean we've been

talking about the uh uh the animation

industry and the unions and one of their

their big Hang-Ups is AI I think they're

afraid of being replaced by AI but I

think AI does become

a tool and that's where I'm at with it

where I think there is a difference

between using it as a tool and I think

it has Merit and value as a tool but it

should not be a replacement

for actual creatives um unfortunately in

it being a tool it actually does

eliminate some positions you know again

I was talking about you know in between

animators well they get gone because you

don't need them any more right uh

flatters and Comics well they get gone

because you don't need them anymore uh

because you know it can it can handle

that can do that work for you uh but the

same thing happened

with you know letters in comics and in a

lot of cases traditional inkor in comics

um in animation look at what happened

when we made the transition from 2D

animation to 3D animation so many people

got displaced and I

remember there was a a very different

feeling back then when the 2D an

animators got replaced and we had a lot

of 3D

animators you know picking up gigs

because everybody was doing 3D animation

I mean it happened almost overnight it

was so weird it was like we had a couple

of Pixar movies come out and then all of

a sudden everybody's like yeah you know

what everything's going to be 3D from

here on out every major theatrical

release is going to be 3D and that was

just how it was going to be and so many

of these guys got displaced and they

were called Old heads they were called

old school they were Antiquated they

were ancient and then Disney does the

Mary Poppins

Sequel and they had to call these guys

out a retirement because nobody at

Disney knew how to draw 2D animation

anymore and they wanted it to to be

authentic and I think this is very

similar to that I think we're going to

have a whole generation of artists um

that are used to AI tools just like so

many artists now are used to painting

digitally are used to you know rendering

with under or whatever and it's just we

haven't figured out exactly what the

right combination is I don't think

replacing people completely is is the

answer but saying you're never going to

touch the technology at all and knows he

said generative AI he didn't say AI

assist he didn't he said generative AI

creating images whole cloth from uh

using AI uh you know I think it's here

to stay I just think we have to figure

out the right ratio of like you know

what what can we use this for you know

without completely displacing people

because then we're going to have a lot

of really sterile and we're seeing it

now like social media like all these

these posts they show you kind of this

like AI generated hellscape of bland syy

weird ass nightmare fuel

stuff

and you know we're never going to get

out of that if if we rely too heavily on

it and so I don't know it's going to be

really interesting to watch I mean I'm

open to new things I I have one foot in

the tech world I I you know I did work

as a Cartoonist for a while but I also

worked as a web developer and uh you

know I've kind of res resigned myself to

the fact that technology marches on but

I'm very curious to

see which artists actually make the leap

and which ones don't cuz I think some

people are so against AI in any

form any form whatsoever that even if it

would help them maybe double or triple

their own workload they will not use

it uh and those people will get left

behind

so I don't know but it is good at least

with with procreate that you know where

the company stands for now until they

sell or something but you know where

they stand you know if you buy procreate

they're not using generative AI you know

they're not going to swipe your stuff so

that's good you can't say the same about

Adobe right now and I I'm actually

trying to migrate all of our computers

over to Affinity because just for so

many reasons I have a problem with Adobe

now and I think it's yeah just a

subscription model I think is ridiculous

60 bucks a month or whatever for from

now until the end of time and they might

scrape your content I mean how

ridiculous is that I'm going to wrap it

up please subscribe we'll talk later

[Music]