Kelangkaan Minyak Goreng Kemasan dan Curah Masih Terjadi di Sejumlah Daerah

KOMPASTV

11 Feb 202202:38

Summary

TLDRThe script discusses the ongoing shortage and high prices of packaged and bulk cooking oil in various regions, particularly in West Sulawesi's Polewali Mandar. Vendors complain about limited supplies from distributors, with some orders never arriving. Despite a drop in prices, the scarcity persists, and the issue is not widely covered on social media, where the oil is, however, being sold at higher prices than government-set limits. The Indonesian Consumer Protection Agency (LKM) urges the government to address the shortage and soaring prices, fearing it could lead to further problems. The script also mentions the lack of strong action by the KPU against potential cartel practices or unhealthy competition that could be violating antitrust laws.

Takeaways

📦 Packaging oil scarcity: There is an ongoing scarcity of packaged cooking oil in certain areas, not just due to high prices but also because it's hard to find.
💰 High prices persist: Despite a drop in prices, cooking oil remains expensive, above the maximum retail price set by the government.
🛒 Limited supply from distributors: Vendors in places like Polewali Mandar, West Sulawesi, complain about the limited supply of cooking oil from distributors, with ordered goods not arriving.
📉 Price drop, no product: Even though prices have dropped, there is no product available, indicating a disconnect between price adjustments and actual availability.
📈 Online price gouging: Cooking oil is being sold at high prices on social media, above the government-set prices, suggesting a black market or price manipulation.
🤔 Unseen sources: The origin of the cooking oil being sold online is unclear, as field observations show vendors at the market receive insufficient stock from distributors.
🇮🇩 Consumer pressure: The Indonesian Consumer Protection Agency (LKM) is urging the government to address the scarcity and soaring prices of cooking oil, which is not just a local issue.
🚨 Concerns of unhealthy competition: There are worries that the government's efforts are only addressing surface-level issues and not tackling the root causes of the problem.
🔍 Lack of strong action: The script mentions that the KPU (Election Commission) has tried to address the burden, but there is no strong trigger or initiative to investigate cartel practices or unhealthy competition violating antitrust laws.
📝 Online petition: There is an online petition to pursue suspicions of cartels and unhealthy competition causing the cooking oil scarcity.
📺 Media coverage: The issue of cooking oil scarcity is not widely covered in the media, but it is rampant on social media, indicating a possible lack of public awareness or media attention.

Q & A

What is the main issue discussed in the transcript?
-The main issue discussed is the ongoing shortage of packaged and bulk cooking oil in certain areas, leading to high prices and difficulties in obtaining cooking oil both in traditional markets and modern retail stores.
In which region is the shortage of cooking oil particularly affecting the local population?
-The shortage is particularly affecting the region of Polewali Mandar in West Sulawesi, where local vendors are complaining about limited supply from distributors.
What is the situation regarding the supply of cooking oil from distributors according to the vendors?
-The vendors report that the supply of cooking oil from distributors is insufficient, with ordered goods often not arriving.
How is the price of cooking oil affected by the shortage?
-The price of cooking oil has remained high, even above the maximum retail price set by the government, due to the shortage.
What is the government's maximum retail price for cooking oil?
-The government's maximum retail price for cooking oil is between 16,000 and 18,000 Indonesian Rupiah per liter.
Is the shortage of cooking oil visible on social media platforms?
-Contrary to the shortage in physical markets, cooking oil appears to be widely available for sale on social media platforms, albeit at prices higher than the government-set maximum.
What action has the Indonesian Consumer Protection Agency (LKM) taken in response to the cooking oil shortage?
-The LKM is urging the government to take action to address the shortage and rising prices of cooking oil, which is not just a local issue but a widespread concern.
What concerns does the LKM have regarding the government's efforts to tackle the issue?
-The LKM is concerned that the government's efforts are only addressing the problem at a superficial level and not tackling the root causes, which could lead to further issues.
What measures has the Indonesian Competition Commission (KPU) taken to address the issue?
-The KPU has attempted to investigate the burden caused by the shortage, but there is no strong trigger or initiative to uncover cartel practices or unhealthy competition that could be violating anti-monopoly and unfair competition laws.
What steps are being taken to further investigate the potential cartel practices or unhealthy competition?
-An online petition has been initiated to pursue suspicions of cartel practices and unhealthy competition that may be causing the cooking oil shortage.
Who is conducting the investigation into the cooking oil shortage and potential cartel practices?
-The investigation is being conducted by the Kompas TV team, with Noah Band leading the coverage.

Outlines

00:00

💰 Oil Shortage and High Prices in Indonesia

The script discusses the ongoing issue of oil shortages and high prices in Indonesia, particularly in areas like Polewali Mandar, West Sulawesi. Traditional markets and modern retail stores are struggling to find oil, and sellers are complaining about limited supplies from distributors. Despite the government's efforts to stabilize prices, the scarcity and high costs persist. The situation is not limited to the physical markets, as even online platforms are flooded with oil being sold at prices higher than the government's regulated rates, ranging from Rp16,000 to Rp18,000 per liter. The Indonesian Consumer Protection Agency (LKM) is urging the government to address these issues, which are not just limited to the distribution but also involve broader economic and regulatory challenges. The script also mentions the lack of strong action by the Indonesian Competition Commission (KPU) to tackle potential cartel practices or unhealthy competition that could be violating anti-monopoly laws.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Shortage

Shortage refers to a situation where the supply of a commodity is less than the demand. In the video script, it is mentioned that there is a shortage of packaged and bulk cooking oil, making it difficult to find in both traditional markets and modern retail stores. This shortage is a central issue discussed throughout the video.

💡Cooking Oil

Cooking oil is a common household item used for cooking and food preparation. The video script discusses the scarcity of cooking oil, highlighting its importance in daily life and the impact of its unavailability on consumers.

💡Price Control

Price control is a government regulation that sets a maximum price for goods or services. The script mentions the highest retail price set by the government for cooking oil, which is still considered expensive, indicating the government's attempt to manage the market price of this essential commodity.

💡Retailers

Retailers are businesses that sell goods directly to consumers for personal use. The script describes the complaints of retailers in Polewali Mandar, West Sulawesi, about the limited supply of cooking oil from distributors, illustrating the challenges faced by businesses in sourcing essential goods.

💡Distributors

Distributors are intermediaries that supply goods to retailers. The script indicates that retailers are facing difficulties due to the limited supply from distributors, which is a key factor contributing to the shortage of cooking oil.

💡Social Media

Social media platforms are used for various purposes, including selling goods. The script notes that cooking oil is being sold at high prices on social media, above the government-set prices, suggesting a parallel market where price controls may not be effective.

💡Consumer Complaints

Consumer complaints are expressions of dissatisfaction or grievances about products or services. The script mentions that consumers are complaining about the high prices and unavailability of cooking oil, which is a driving force behind the discussions on the issue.

💡Government Efforts

Government efforts refer to the actions taken by the state to address specific issues. The script discusses the government's attempts to tackle the shortage and high prices of cooking oil, emphasizing the need for more effective measures.

💡Anti-Monopoly Law

Anti-monopoly laws are regulations designed to prevent the abuse of market power and promote fair competition. The script refers to the lack of strong action by the KPU (presumably a regulatory body) to investigate potential cartel practices or unhealthy competition that could be violating anti-monopoly laws.

💡Petition

A petition is a formal request, often from many people, addressed to an authority or decision-maker. The script mentions an online petition to pursue suspicions of cartels and unhealthy competition, showing the public's initiative to address the issue through legal means.

💡Investigation

Investigation is the act of looking into and examining something in detail. The script suggests that there is a need for a thorough investigation into the causes of the cooking oil shortage, including potential violations of competition laws.

Highlights

Shortage of packaged cooking oil and bulk cooking oil continues in some areas.

Cooking oil is not only scarce but also expensive, above the highest retail price set by the government.

In Polewali Mandar, West Sulawesi, traders complain about limited supply of cooking oil from distributors.

Malaysia's mudslide has affected the availability of cooking oil.

Despite the price drop, there is no supply of cooking oil.

The shortage of cooking oil is not visible in social media, but it is widely sold online at high prices above government-set prices.

The price range of cooking oil sold online starts from Rp16,000 to Rp18,000 per liter.

Indonesia's Consumer Protection Agency (LKM) urges the government to address the shortage and soaring prices of cooking oil.

The government's efforts to tackle the issue seem to be limited to downstream issues, not addressing the root cause.

There is a concern that the current situation will create problems and has been proven to be so.

KPU (General Elections Commission) has tried to address the burden, but there is no strong trigger or spirit to dismantle cartel practices or unhealthy competition.

There is a potential violation of anti-monopoly and unfair competition laws.

An online petition has been created to pursue suspicions of cartels and unhealthy competition causing the cooking oil shortage.

Kompas TV's investigative team, Noah Band, has been covering the issue.

Traders in the market are seen to receive less supply from distributors.

The government's practical actions are only addressing downstream issues, not the broader problem.

There is a need for stronger measures to address the root causes of the cooking oil shortage.