Audi Etron GT v Porsche Taycan 4S v Tesla Model S LRP-Convoy comparison - Efficiency, Range & Review

Summary

This video compares three high-performance electric cars: the Porsche Taycan, Audi e-tron GT, and Tesla Model S. The focus is on their energy efficiency, range, and charging capabilities, with the Tesla excelling in efficiency, offering the best mileage per kWh. The Taycan and e-tron GT, though less efficient, benefit from faster charging due to their 800-volt systems. Comfort-wise, the e-tron GT and Taycan offer a more dynamic driving experience, while the Tesla stands out for superior visibility and spaciousness. Ultimately, the choice between these cars depends on individual preferences for performance, charging speed, and comfort.

Takeaways

• 😀 The Porsche Taycan is more energy-efficient than the Audi e-Tron GT, averaging 317 Wh/mile compared to 344 Wh/mile.
• 😀 The Tesla Model S leads in efficiency, achieving 252 Wh/mile or nearly 4 miles per kWh, which translates to a theoretical range of 341 miles.
• 😀 The Taycan and e-Tron GT, despite being less energy-efficient, still offer competitive ranges of 254 miles and 263 miles, respectively.
• 😀 The Porsche Taycan benefits from a 800V system, enabling faster charging compared to the Tesla, which has a slower charging rate in the UK with CCS chargers.
• 😀 Charging speeds for the Porsche and Audi can be significantly faster, making them better suited for long trips despite the Tesla's lower energy consumption.
• 😀 The Porsche Taycan offers a sharper and more direct steering feel, thanks to its four-wheel steering system, which enhances handling and driving experience.
• 😀 The Audi e-Tron GT is described as having a smoother, more luxurious ride, offering comfort without the harsh impact of road ridges, making it ideal for comfort seekers.
• 😀 The Tesla Model S offers superior visibility, with a more open, airy interior and a higher seating position, making it the best for visibility among the three cars.
• 😀 Despite the e-Tron GT’s lower efficiency, its luxurious ride quality is comparable to that of a high-end luxury saloon car, such as the Mercedes S-Class.
• 😀 While all three vehicles offer excellent performance, the Tesla Model S is considered the benchmark in electric vehicle efficiency, with the others being strong competitors in terms of comfort and charging capabilities.
• 😀 Ultimately, choosing between these vehicles comes down to personal preferences, with the Tesla excelling in efficiency and the Porsche and Audi offering better driving comfort and performance.

Q & A

What is the average energy consumption of the Porsche Taycan on a 150-mile journey?

The Porsche Taycan averaged 317 watt-hours per mile, or 3.15 miles per kilowatt-hour, during the 150-mile journey.

What is the theoretical range of the Porsche Taycan based on the energy used in the 150-mile test?

The Porsche Taycan used 59% of its battery, which gives it a theoretical range of 254 miles from 100% to 0% battery.

How does the energy consumption of the Audi e-tron GT compare to the Porsche Taycan?

The Audi e-tron GT was less efficient, consuming 344 watt-hours per mile (2.9 miles per kilowatt-hour), compared to the Porsche Taycan's 317 watt-hours per mile.

What is the theoretical range of the Audi e-tron GT based on its energy usage?

The Audi e-tron GT used 57% of its battery on the 150-mile journey, giving it a theoretical range of 263 miles.

What is the average energy consumption of the Tesla Model S and how does it compare to the other two cars?

The Tesla Model S averaged 252 watt-hours per mile, or nearly 4 miles per kilowatt-hour, making it significantly more efficient than both the Porsche Taycan and Audi e-tron GT.

How does the range of the Tesla Model S compare to the other cars based on its energy consumption?

The Tesla Model S, with its higher efficiency, has a theoretical range of 341 miles, which is far greater than the Porsche Taycan (254 miles) and Audi e-tron GT (263 miles).

What advantage do the Porsche Taycan and Audi e-tron GT have over the Tesla Model S in terms of charging?

The Porsche Taycan and Audi e-tron GT feature 800-volt systems, allowing them to charge faster than the Tesla Model S, which has charging limitations in some regions due to its CCS charging protocol.

How does the ride comfort of the Porsche Taycan and Audi e-tron GT compare?

The Porsche Taycan offers a sharp, sporty steering feel, especially with its four-wheel steering, while the Audi e-tron GT offers a more comfortable ride, comparable to a luxury saloon like the Mercedes S500.

Which car has the best visibility, and why?

The Tesla Model S offers the best visibility, with a light and open interior design, making it feel less confined compared to the lower-sitting, sportier Porsche Taycan and Audi e-tron GT.

Which car would be the best choice for someone prioritizing driving dynamics?

The Porsche Taycan would be the best choice for someone prioritizing driving dynamics, as it offers sharper steering and a more direct feel, especially with its four-wheel steering system.

How does the Tesla Model S's charging speed compare to the Porsche Taycan and Audi e-tron GT?

While the Porsche Taycan and Audi e-tron GT can charge faster due to their 800-volt systems, the Tesla Model S is still efficient in its energy usage, which means it doesn't need to charge from such a low state, balancing out the difference in charging speed.