GJ 117 | DPR, MK,MA MILIK KELUARGA MANA?
Summary
TLDRThe video discusses the growing trend of Indonesians migrating abroad, especially to Singapore, due to perceived better living conditions and healthcare. The speaker criticizes Indonesia's systemic issues, including corruption, elitism, and inefficiency in public services, which lead to high medical costs and slow legal processes. The video highlights the dissatisfaction with the current state of governance in Indonesia and questions the effectiveness of the political system, suggesting that the country's leaders prioritize their interests over those of the general population.
Takeaways
- 🇮🇩 Many Indonesians are moving abroad, particularly to Singapore, with around 1,000 people moving annually.
- 😌 The reason for this migration is that living abroad, especially in Singapore, is perceived as more pleasant and accommodating.
- 🧑⚕️ There is a trend of Indonesians seeking medical treatment abroad due to lower costs and less invasive procedures compared to Indonesia.
- 💊 The high cost of medical care in Indonesia is attributed to corruption and unethical practices between doctors and pharmaceutical companies.
- 🛑 The script criticizes the Indonesian government for neglecting its citizens and only catering to the elite class.
- 🚔 Issues such as land disputes, crimes, and zoning problems are reportedly ignored by the authorities, leading to a lack of justice for the common people.
- 💼 The speaker argues that laws in Indonesia are primarily designed to serve the interests of the elite, not the general population.
- 👨⚖️ Attempts to challenge environmental damage or other major issues through legal channels are often futile and slow.
- 📱 Efforts to expose injustices through viral campaigns are met with harsh penalties under various restrictive laws.
- 🤷 The script questions the legitimacy of political representation, claiming that the political system is controlled by the elite, making it difficult for ordinary people to bring about change.
Q & A
Why do many Indonesian citizens choose to move abroad, especially to Singapore?
-According to the script, many Indonesians move abroad, particularly to Singapore, because they find it more enjoyable and less restrictive compared to Indonesia. They feel they can maintain their Indonesian identity without facing discrimination.
What are some specific examples of discrimination faced by Indonesians within their own country?
-The script mentions that in Indonesia, individuals might be questioned about their religion if they have slightly Chinese features or about their cosmetics if they have darker skin, indicating a form of racial or social discrimination.
What trend among Indonesians is mentioned as a precursor to the trend of moving abroad?
-The script mentions that there has been a trend of Indonesians seeking medical treatment abroad, as it is often cheaper and comes with fewer unnecessary procedures compared to treatment in Indonesia.
What is the reason given for the high cost of medical treatment in Indonesia?
-The high cost of medical treatment in Indonesia is attributed to a hidden phenomenon of corruption, where doctors and pharmacists are involved in unethical practices, leading to inflated medical expenses.
What criticism does the speaker have about the way the Indonesian government handles the country's problems?
-The speaker criticizes the Indonesian government for neglecting the needs of the general population and only focusing on the interests of the elite. Problems like crime and land disputes are often ignored or unresolved.
What does the speaker imply about the Indonesian legal and political system?
-The speaker implies that the Indonesian legal and political systems are biased towards the elite. Legal processes for the elite's benefit are expedited, while issues concerning ordinary citizens are delayed or ignored.
How does the speaker describe the government's response to public grievances or protests?
-The government, according to the speaker, responds to public grievances or protests with legislation that suppresses freedom of speech and public expression, such as internet access restrictions and the criminalization of viral content.
What is the role of the DPR (Indonesian House of Representatives) according to the speaker, and how does it relate to public interest?
-The speaker argues that the DPR, which claims to represent the people, actually serves the interests of the elite, not the general public. Laws are made to protect the elite from criticism and maintain their power.
What alternatives does the speaker suggest for those disillusioned with the current state of Indonesia?
-While the speaker contemplates the idea of moving abroad, they also suggest that instead of changing nationality, it might be more impactful to strive for significant political change from within the country, possibly even aiming to become the president.
What is the speaker's final stance on changing nationality versus staying and fighting for change in Indonesia?
-The speaker expresses a preference for staying in Indonesia and attempting to make a difference, rather than changing nationality. They believe in the potential to enact change through political involvement and leadership.
Outlines
🇸🇬 **Indonesians Moving Abroad**
This paragraph discusses the increasing trend of Indonesians migrating abroad, particularly to Singapore. The main reasons for this trend include better opportunities and a more inclusive environment abroad compared to Indonesia, where discrimination based on appearance or religion is common. The author highlights that while Indonesia is vast, it feels restrictive, whereas Singapore, despite its small size, offers greater freedom. This migration trend is likened to the earlier trend of Indonesians seeking medical treatment abroad due to lower costs and better services in countries like Singapore and Malaysia. The paragraph concludes by criticizing the high cost of healthcare in Indonesia, attributed to corruption and unethical practices among doctors and pharmaceutical companies.
⚖️ **Systemic Injustices in Indonesia**
The second paragraph delves into the systemic failures and corruption in Indonesia, arguing that the country is not truly serving its people but rather its elite. The author criticizes the inefficiency and indifference of the government, citing examples of how reports of crimes or injustices often go unaddressed for years. The author asserts that laws and government actions primarily serve the interests of the elite, with rapid responses to their needs while the public’s concerns are neglected. This is highlighted by the quick legal changes that benefit the elite, contrasted with the long delays for issues affecting ordinary citizens. The paragraph also touches on the perpetuation of power within elite families, where multiple members hold significant political roles.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Migration
💡Identity
💡Discrimination
💡Healthcare
💡Corruption
💡Elite
💡Justice
💡Social Media
💡ITE Law
💡Political Power
Highlights
Thousands of Indonesians are moving abroad each year, with Singapore being a popular destination due to its perceived advantages over Indonesia.
Many Indonesians find life abroad more comfortable and less restrictive compared to their experiences in Indonesia.
In Singapore, Indonesians can maintain their national identity without facing discrimination, a contrast to the experiences of some in Indonesia.
There is a growing trend of Indonesians seeking medical treatment abroad, often due to lower costs and better service compared to domestic healthcare.
The high cost of medical treatment in Indonesia is linked to corruption within the healthcare system, including unethical practices between doctors and pharmaceutical companies.
The Indonesian government is criticized for neglecting the needs of its citizens, focusing instead on serving the interests of the elite.
Reports of crimes or grievances in Indonesia often go unaddressed, leading to widespread frustration among the populace.
The speaker argues that the legal system in Indonesia is biased towards the elite, with laws being quickly adapted to benefit those in power while ignoring the needs of the general population.
The speaker suggests that viral campaigns or public pressure are sometimes the only ways to achieve justice, but these actions are increasingly being criminalized under new laws.
New laws in Indonesia are seen as tools to silence dissent and prevent the public from holding the powerful accountable.
There is a growing disillusionment with the political system in Indonesia, as political parties and coalitions are perceived to be in league with the elite.
The speaker expresses skepticism about the possibility of achieving political change through traditional means, given the current state of the political system.
The speaker criticizes the political process, suggesting that elections are manipulated to ensure the elite maintain control.
Despite the challenges, the speaker concludes by stating a preference for staying in Indonesia and striving for change from within rather than seeking foreign citizenship.
The final statement is a bold declaration of intent to aim for the presidency as a means of making a real difference in Indonesia.
Transcripts
video ini dibuat bersamaan dengan ribuan
warga negara Indonesia yang pindah ke
luar negeri jadi warga negara asing e
rata-ratanya Menurut data yang ada itu
sekitar 1000 orang warga negara
Indonesia pindah ke Singapura Singapura
saja itu sekitar 1000 orang setiap
tahunnya kenapa bisa seperti itu ya
alasan sederhananya adalah karena di
sana lebih menyenangkan sedangkan di
sini lebih menyempitkan kalau misalkan
Baraya pindah ke Singapura Baraya tetap
bisa mempertahankan identitas
keindonesiaan tanpa harus dirasisin
sedangkan kalau di Indonesia Baraya
sipit sedikit aja ditanya Agamanya apa
Baraya hitam sedikit aja ditanyain
kosmetiknya Apa itu kondisi di Indonesia
kan seperti itu maka bisa disimpulkan
bahwa 5 juta km per wilayah nusantara
ini wilayah Indonesia ini ternyata
menyempitkan sedangkan Singapura yang
wilayahnya hanya segede Jakarta itu
ternyata sangat-sangat melapangkan luar
biasa tren kepindahan warga negara
Indonesia ke luar negeri ini adalah
kelanjutan dari tren berobat ke luar
negeri jadi sejak beberapa tahun yang
lalu itu memang ada tren berobat ke luar
negeri karena apa karena jauh lebih
murah Jadi kalau misalkan Baraya
sekarang Baraya ngaku sakit aja sakit
berat kanker misalkan datang ke
dokter-dokter di Indonesia maka ada
potensi Baraya diporotin duit sampai
ratusan juta rupiah tapi dengan keluhan
yang sama silakan Baraya datang ke
Singapura datang ke Malaysia Baraya
tidak akan diapa-apain Baraya mungkin
hanya dicek diajak ngobrol kemudian
kalaupun harus berobat biayanya hanya
puluhan juta atau bahkan lebih murah
daripada itu dan tidak ada prosedur
operasi begini dan begitu biasa aja
bahkan kadang-kadang juga enggak dikasih
obat hanya dikasih konsultasi begini dan
begitu cek kalau tidak percaya kenapa
bisa seperti itu ya karena di Indonesia
ada sebuah fenomena di balik gunung es
yaitu suap jadi dokter-dokter di
Indonesia dengan tukang Farmasi itu
biasanya terlibat pada rangkaian
prostitusi aneh di situ yang menyebabkan
harga berobat di Indonesia menjadi
sangat mahal nah fenomena dari banyaknya
warga negara Indonesia yang pindah ke
luar negeri dan banyak warga negara
Indonesia yang harus berobat ke luar
negeri adalah karena negara ini
sebenarnya tidak diurus jadi setiap ada
penyimpangan setiap ada kejelekan setiap
ada kezaliman setiap ada kejahatan itu
akan diabaikan Kenapa karena negara ini
memang bukan ngurusin hal-hal yang
seperti itu negara ini ngurusin kalangan
elit saja
ngaku enggak jadi Coba silakan Baraya
buktikan apakah pernyataan saya Ini
salah atau tidak Baraya sekarang lapor
kepada polisi misalkan Pak anak saya
dicabuli tunggu 1 tahun Apa yang akan
terjadi saya menduga tidak akan terjadi
apa-apa Baraya coba lapor ke tukang
Pertanahan di Indonesia Pak tanah saya
diserobot sama orang tidak dikenal
Tunggu 10 tahun apakah laporan Baraya
itu akan ditanggapi atau tidak Baraya
sekarang lapor kepada pemerintah Pak
anak saya jadi korban zonasi di
sekolahnya nya Coba tunggu seumur hidup
Baraya Apakah Baraya akan ditanggapi
laporannya Atau tidak Silakan cek
sekarang karena apa negara kita Ternyata
bukan untuk rakyatnya negara kita bukan
untuk
270 juta penduduknya negara ini hanya
untuk kalangan elit elit saja laporan
Baraya yang menumpuk itu hanya akan
terabaikan hanya akan mengendap dan
akhirnya terkubur di dalam genangan
lumpur tangisan Baraya
sendiri bahkan undang-undang yang ada
itu disinyalir bukan untuk mengakomodasi
kepentingan-kepentingan kita tapi
mengakomodasi kepentingan-kepentingan si
elit dan si paling elit dan
keluarga-keluarganya
misal kita menggugat ke MK atau ke ma
atau ke yang gitu-gitulah misalkan
tentang kerusakan lingkungan akibat
pertambangan masalah-masalah di Papua
Baraya silakan ajukan ke ma Baraya
silakan ajukan ke MK Butuh waktu lama
sekali untuk rapat untuk begini dan
begitu Itu pun kalau jadi kemudian
Baraya silakan ajukan masalah-masalah
soal ormas itu juga bakal diabaikan
Baraya membutuhkan masalahmasalah ini
untuk diajukan kepada MK dan Ma dan
sebagainya Itu juga mungkin saja Baraya
akan diabaikan setidaknya dalam beberapa
puluh tahun undang-undang perampasan
aset misalkan itu mengandap sama selama
berapa tahun berapa puluh tahun gitu
Tapi ketika Si paling elit itu ngomong
bahwa anak saya pengin jadi Pejabat itu
dalam 2 hari dalam 3 hari dalam sehari
itu MK dan Ma bisa langsung
mengabulkannya anak saya pengin jadi ini
itu bisa langsung cepat langsung
undang-undangnya langsung berubah gitu
mk-nya langsung berubah apanya langsung
berubah gitu itu di Indonesia itu
kejadiannya seperti itu mau ngebantah ya
kan itu faktanya memang terjadi seperti
itu makanya si elit dan si paling elit
itu
anaknya kakeknya cucunya buyutnya
semuanya jadi pejabat bahkan ada yang si
paling elit itu punya anak tiga
tiga-tiganya jadi pejabat tiga-tiganya
jadi ketua partai politik tiga-tiganya
jadi apa ya semuanya Kayak gitulah
enggak tahu itu di Indonesia apa di
negara yang lain tapi nah gimana kalau
kita melawan misalkan Kok bisa seperti
itu negara ini kenapa kayak gitu terus
Ya udah kalau misalkan negara gini
begitu terus maka kita akan melawan
dengan cara memviralkannya no viral no
Justice misalkan gitu ya Lalu apa yang
terjadi ya muncul undang-undang ite
Siapa yang mau memviralkan bakal masuk
penjara muncul undang-undang penyiaran
Siapa yang melakukan investigasi bakal
masuk penjara Kemudian muncul RUU Polri
Siapa yang bikin onar di memviralkan dan
lain-lain akses internetnya akan dicabut
gitu ya kayak gitu akhirnya jadi rakyat
enggak bisa ngapa-ngapain rakyat mau
ngeluh rakyat mau apa juga ya akhirnya
bisa aja kena undang-undang Ute apa
segala rupa langsung eh ite langsung
dihilangin dan sebagainya pertanyaan
saya adalah itu yang bikin undang-undang
itu kan dan merangkai rancangan
undang-undang itu kan adalah orang-orang
DPR DPR itu ngakunya kan Perwakilan
Rakyat perwakilan kita-kita ini katanya
ya tapi Mana buktinya coba saya misalkan
tanyakan rakyat golongan mana yang minta
agar setiap rakyat Indonesia tidak boleh
melakukan investigasi terhadap hal-hal
yang mencurigakan di Indonesia di mana
rakyat Indonesia golongan mana yang
menghendaki agar kalau misalkan ada
rakyat yang protes yang komplain dan
sebagainya kemudian ee internetnya bisa
dicabut secara sepihak gitu siapa rakyat
yang menghendaki itu ya tidak ada ini
sebenarnya adalah dari kelompok-kelompok
tertentu saja dari elit-elit dari si
paling elit dan keluarga-keluarganya
saja yang tidak mau dikritik yang
penginnya disembah apa segala rupa Jadi
mereka tetap ingin belanggeng berkuasa
ya sedangkan kita-kita Ya hanya
digunakan suaranya saja menjelang
Pilkada nah pilkadanya juga diobok-obok
biar suara-suara kita itu bisa masuk ke
corong mereka dengan sangat
sebaik-baiknya gitu ah kalau misalkan
seperti itu Saya mau berjuang melalui
politik karena dengan jadi partai
politik maka saya bisa ini ya Enggak
bisa juga Baraya karena partai politik
sekarang sudah jadi milik mereka semua
itu kan koalisinya besar ya jadi
partai-partai itu juga pada akhirnya
terlibat aja dalam konspirasi-konspirasi
besar yang kita tidak ketahui
juntrungannya apa ya Semoga aja mereka
punya itikad baik kan kita mah enggak
tahu cuman bisa menduga-duga cuman bisa
berburuk sangka gitu ya lalu Jadi
bagaimana dong Apakah Baraya
mempertimbangkan untuk pindah ke warga
neegaraan kalau saya sih
tidak saya berpikirnya dari daripada
Saya pindah ke warga negaraan Mendingan
jadi presiden
浏览更多相关视频
Banyak Masyarakat Indonesia Memilih Berobat ke Luar Negeri, Kenapa? | 60 Menit Special Report
EXPOSED: Truth Behind MBBS Admissions & Paper Leaks | NEET Scam
VIDEO CONTOH PEMBELAJARAN ANEKDOT (STAND UP COMEDY)
Hidup di Luar Negeri Jauh Lebih Enak Daripada di Indonesia!
Stand Up Comedy Akbar: Menjelaskan, Kenapa Korupsi di Indonesia Susah Dihilangkan?
Soal WNI Pindah WN Singapura, Dirjen Imigrasi: Ini Jadi Alarm
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)