Why Are Redstoners Mad?

Summary

The video script discusses Mojang's controversial updates in a Minecraft snapshot, focusing on Redstone and Minecart changes. Redstone's new randomness and removal of locational mechanics have upset the community, potentially breaking many existing contraptions. The script praises the new Redstone torch texture but criticizes the reduction of block updates, which affects the functionality of various Redstone components. Meanwhile, Minecarts have been reworked with a new physics system, introducing exciting features like arching and high-speed motion, but also causing issues with stacking and rail alignment, impacting storage technologies. The script calls for Mojang to listen to community feedback to avoid repeating past mistakes.

Takeaways

• 🔧 Mojang's snapshot update aimed to address the Redstone community's concerns but ended up causing frustration instead.
• 🔄 The Redstone torch received a texture change that was well-received by the community.
• 🎰 Mojang introduced randomness to Redstone to eliminate locational and directional behavior, which was met with mixed reactions.
• 🔄 The update attempts to standardize Redstone behavior, which could potentially break existing contraptions and contraptions that rely on locational Redstone.
• 🚂 Minecarts underwent a significant rework, including changes to their physics and a new game rule for maximum speed.
• 🔄 The introduction of randomness in Minecart behavior could affect builds that were previously stable and consistent.
• 🛠 The removal of Minecart stacking and changes to how they align with rails may break existing storage technology and other contraptions.
• 🛑 Redstone Dust updates were reduced, affecting the functionality of many Redstone contraptions that rely on block updates for powering components.
• 🔌 The change in Redstone Dust updates could potentially eliminate Quick Connect (QC) properties from Pistons, Droppers, and Dispensers.
• 👷‍♂️ The community's response to the changes has been varied, with some suggesting that Mojang should listen to the feedback of experienced Redstone players.
• 📢 A call to action for Mojang to consider the impact of their changes on the Redstone community and to avoid repeating past mistakes with updates.

Q & A

What was Mojang's original intention for the snapshot update?

Mojang originally intended the snapshot update to focus on the bundle feature, but it ended up causing dissatisfaction among the Redstone community.

What changes did Mojang make to the Redstone torch in the snapshot?

Mojang updated the texture of the Redstone torch, which the speaker in the script found to be an improvement over the old texture.

How did Mojang attempt to address the issues of locational and directional Redstone behavior?

Mojang introduced randomness to Redstone behavior, allowing for certain actions to be random when activated from different levers, in an attempt to eliminate the need for locational and directional dependencies.

What is the impact of the new randomness in Redstone on builds that were previously locational?

The new randomness could potentially break builds that relied on locational Redstone behavior, as they may now behave inconsistently or not at all.

What is the controversy surrounding the Minecart changes in the snapshot?

The controversy lies in the removal of Minecart stacking and changes to how Minecarts snap to rails and align, which could break existing mechanisms and storage technologies.

What is the default and maximum speed setting for Minecarts as introduced in the snapshot?

The default Minecart speed is set to 8 blocks per second, with a maximum speed of 1000 blocks per second.

Why are Redstone experts concerned about the changes to Redstone Dust updates in the snapshot?

The changes reduce the number of block updates Redstone Dust provides, which could break many Redstone contraptions that rely on these updates for functionality.

What is the role of the copper bulb in the new Redstone system?

The copper bulb acts as a transparent updater, which can be used in some situations to replace setups that previously relied on slabs or other transparent blocks for updates.

What are the common responses from Mojang and the community regarding the Redstone changes?

The common responses include telling Redstone experts to fix their contraptions, claiming the changes make Redstone easier and more accessible, and asserting that Mojang knows better.

What is the speaker's call to action for Mojang regarding the Redstone feedback?

The speaker urges Mojang to listen to the feedback from the Redstone community, learn from past experiences with the copper bulb, and avoid repeating history with disappointment.