LIVRO: Heróis e maravilhas da Idade Média, de Jacques Le Goff

Summary

This video discusses a book that explores the Middle Ages, combining historical insights with its influence on modern literature and culture. Despite its compact design with small margins and few images, the book is praised for its accessible language, making it ideal for history enthusiasts and teachers alike. The speaker highlights how the book challenges negative stereotypes of the Middle Ages and emphasizes the historical continuity across time. The video also invites viewers to share their thoughts on the book and offers recommendations for other medieval-themed books.

Takeaways

• 😀 The book reviewed is focused on the Middle Ages, offering a comprehensive yet accessible overview of the period.
• 😀 The small size of the book (pocket-sized) makes it portable and easy to read, with a total of 200 pages excluding the bibliography.
• 😀 The book contains very few images, which is a limitation considering its topic. The reviewer suggests more images would enhance the experience.
• 😀 The book aims to demystify the Middle Ages, often seen as a time of negativity, and explores its richness and complexities.
• 😀 The book is an excellent choice for those interested in the intersection of history and literature, explaining elements that also appear in modern media.
• 😀 It is praised for its engaging language and approachable style, making it a good option for both casual readers and history teachers.
• 😀 The book touches on the concept of 'long duration,' examining how history unfolds through ruptures, continuities, and the evolution of societies over time.
• 😀 It serves as a useful resource for history teachers, with several chapters suitable for student reading to help them better understand historical narratives.
• 😀 The book is criticized for its small text size and limited visual content, which could have enhanced its appeal and accessibility.
• 😀 The speaker mentions a joint reading experience with a fellow history teacher, highlighting the value of collaborative learning and discussion.
• 😀 The reviewer encourages viewers to share their own book recommendations on the Middle Ages and engage with the content through comments, fostering a community of learning.

Q & A

What is the primary focus of the book reviewed in the video?

The book focuses on the Middle Ages and explores various elements that appear in medieval literature, current literature, and popular media such as series and films.

What are the main criticisms mentioned about the book?

The book has very small margins that make reading and note-taking difficult, and while it includes some images, they are few and not colored, which the reviewer feels could have enhanced the book.

How does the reviewer describe the book's format?

The reviewer describes the book as a pocket-sized, inexpensive edition with approximately 200 pages, excluding the bibliography. The chapters are relatively short, especially towards the end.

What positive aspects of the book does the reviewer highlight?

The reviewer appreciates the book's approachable language, its ability to explain medieval elements found in both current and classical literature, and its concise and engaging format, which is perfect for those interested in the Middle Ages.

What does the reviewer think about the book's treatment of the Middle Ages?

The reviewer believes the book challenges the misconception that the Middle Ages was a period of only negative aspects, offering a more nuanced understanding of the era.

What is the significance of the 'long duration' mentioned in the video?

The 'long duration' refers to the way the book presents the Middle Ages, emphasizing the historical changes, ruptures, continuities, and the enduring elements over time, which is crucial for understanding the era.

Who is Bruno Rosa, and what is his contribution to the topic?

Bruno Rosa is a Brazilian medieval historian who runs a YouTube channel called *Clio: History and Literature*, where he discusses medieval topics. He also offers a podcast series and has critiqued the same book discussed in the video.

Why does the reviewer suggest this book for history teachers?

The reviewer suggests the book for history teachers because it offers an accessible and engaging way to teach students about the Middle Ages, with chapters that are short and informative, making it a great resource for class discussions.

How does the reviewer feel about the book’s educational value?

The reviewer sees the book as valuable for both personal enjoyment and educational purposes, particularly for history teachers who can use it to provide students with a deeper understanding of medieval history and literature.

What type of audience does the reviewer think would enjoy the book?

The reviewer believes the book would appeal to anyone interested in the Middle Ages, particularly those with an interest in literature and history, including educators, students, and general readers.