Is Elden Ring Nightreign As Bad As People Say

Summary

In this review of *Night Rain*, the reviewer praises the game's multiplayer functionality but expresses disappointment with its repetitive gameplay and lack of innovation. While enjoying the game with friends, they criticize its weak roguelike elements, lack of build variety, and underwhelming loot drops. The lack of crossplay, communication tools, and creative boss fights is also noted as a drawback. At $40, the reviewer feels the game offers insufficient content, making it feel more like a mod rather than a full-fledged title. Overall, it's described as a fun but flawed experience, with potential if more content is added in the future.

Takeaways

• 😀 The game is considered 'pretty good' but ultimately feels repetitive and lacks depth.
• 😀 Despite the enjoyment of the early gameplay, the experience becomes stale after a few hours.
• 😀 The gameplay loop is very repetitive, with recycled enemies and bosses across all runs.
• 😀 There are serious design flaws, such as no crossplay and no communication tools in multiplayer.
• 😀 The lack of a duos option in multiplayer is seen as a baffling decision.
• 😀 Loot drops are underwhelming, with most randomized drops offering only trivial stat increases.
• 😀 The game lacks meaningful progression and doesn't offer much variety in builds or gameplay.
• 😀 Playing solo is highly recommended against, as it leads to a frustrating experience.
• 😀 Multiplayer works well, but the absence of in-game communication tools hurts coordination, especially in co-op.
• 😀 The game’s price of $40 feels too steep for the limited content and repetitive gameplay offered.
• 😀 The game feels like a mod for *Elden Ring* rather than a new and fresh experience, missing the usual FromSoftware polish.

Q & A

What is the general opinion of the reviewer on the game?

The reviewer feels that the game is not horrible, but it is overhated. They describe it as 'pretty good' but not great, and one of From Software's weakest games.

Why does the reviewer consider the game weak?

The reviewer finds the game repetitive, lacking in variety, and feels the gameplay loop doesn't evolve. They also criticize the underwhelming loot system, trivial upgrades, and the lack of innovation in the roguelike elements.

How does the reviewer feel about the co-op experience?

The reviewer enjoys playing with friends and acknowledges that the game functions smoothly in multiplayer. However, they criticize the lack of communication tools and the inability to play in duos, which limits the co-op experience.

What specific gameplay element does the reviewer find repetitive?

The reviewer finds the gameplay loop repetitive, as the same enemies and bosses are encountered repeatedly, leading to a sense of staleness after a few hours of play.

What are the issues with the game's loot and progression system?

The reviewer describes the loot as underwhelming, with many drops providing insignificant numerical upgrades. The randomized gear does not encourage creative builds, and most buffs feel trivial and not impactful enough to change the gameplay experience.

What is the reviewer's opinion on the Night Lords?

The reviewer expresses disappointment with some of the Night Lords, calling one of them (the fourth Night Lord) one of the worst bosses From Software has created. While some Night Lords are cool, many of them feel tedious and repetitive, particularly those that keep running away from the player.

How does the reviewer feel about the game's price?

The reviewer feels that while the game is priced at $40, it is still too expensive for the experience it offers. They mention that it feels like a mod for Elden Ring rather than a standalone game.

What do they think about the multiplayer functionality?

The reviewer is impressed with how well the game functions in multiplayer, particularly in terms of smoothness and stability, unlike previous From Software titles. However, they note the absence of communication tools, which makes it challenging to coordinate with teammates.

What are the main criticisms regarding the game's build and drop system?

The build and drop system lacks creativity, as most buffs are just small number increases like stamina recovery or health boosts. There is little variety in the builds, and the drops rarely offer any interesting or impactful changes to gameplay.

Would the reviewer recommend the game?

The reviewer would not strongly recommend the game at full price, as they believe it lacks the content and innovation to justify the cost. However, they still find it fun to play with friends but are unlikely to return to it unless significant content updates are added.