مراجعة وتقييم Assassin's Creed Mirage

Abdullah Reviews

4 Oct 202314:22

Summary

TLDRThe video script discusses a player's journey from a novice to a professional in a game set in Baghdad during the Abbasid era and the 9th century. The game features a visually stunning representation of Baghdad as the center of civilization and science, with a diverse population including Arabs, Jews, and Christians. Despite the Islamic dominance and Arabic language, the game offers an immersive experience with detailed environments, engaging dialogues, and a rich historical setting. However, the player criticizes the game's repetitive and shallow gameplay, lack of story depth, and outdated mechanics, which fail to utilize the full potential of the game's setting and characters. The review ends with a mixed assessment, acknowledging the game's visual and cultural appeal but expressing disappointment in its execution and lack of innovation.

Takeaways

🕌 The game is set in Baghdad during the Abbasid period and the 9th century, a time when Baghdad was a hub of civilization and science.
🌍 The city of Baghdad was diverse, with inhabitants from various ethnicities including Jews, Christians, and different Arab tribes, all coexisting.
🎨 The game's visual style is praised for its detailed representation of Baghdad's architecture, marketplaces, and palaces, reflecting the rich Arab history and culture.
🗣 The player can immerse themselves in the Arabic language and the daily life of the city's inhabitants, engaging in conversations and blending with the crowd.
🔍 The game offers a vast open world with many hidden details and secrets for players to discover, enhancing the exploration experience.
🗡 The assassination missions are a highlight, providing a thrilling experience with a sense of satisfaction when executed successfully.
🔄 The gameplay has been criticized for its repetitive nature and lack of depth, with missions and side quests feeling superficial and monotonous.
🎮 The game mechanics are considered outdated, with combat and stealth elements being basic and lacking innovation compared to modern standards.
🛹 The traversal of the game world using a horse is enjoyable and adds to the immersion, but the overall gameplay feels shallow and forgettable after extended play.
🔄 The game's progression system is seen as strange and not fully engaging, with abilities and skills being unlocked in a way that feels delayed and disconnected.
📦 The side content and collectibles in the game are abundant but ultimately feel unimportant and not engaging, lacking the depth to keep players interested.

Q & A

What is the main theme of the video script discussing?
-The main theme of the video script is a critique and discussion of a video game, focusing on its storyline, gameplay, and historical representation of Baghdad during the Abbasid era.
What is the game's setting and time period?
-The game is set in Baghdad during the Abbasid era and the 9th millennium, a time when Baghdad was considered the center of civilization and science.
How does the game represent the cultural diversity of Baghdad during the Abbasid era?
-The game represents the cultural diversity by including characters from various ethnicities such as Jews, Christians, and different Arab ethnic groups, all coexisting in Baghdad.
What are the narrator's initial impressions of the game's visual and artistic style?
-The narrator is initially impressed by the game's visual and artistic style, appreciating the detailed representation of Baghdad, the use of colors, and the lighting effects.
How does the game's narrative structure affect the player's experience according to the narrator?
-The game's narrative structure is criticized for being repetitive and lacking depth, which negatively affects the player's experience and makes the gameplay feel shallow.
What is the narrator's opinion on the game's side missions and their impact on the overall story?
-The narrator feels that the side missions do not add much value to the overall story and are mostly repetitive, which detracts from the game's appeal.
How does the game's combat system fare according to the critique?
-The combat system is described as basic and unsatisfying, with the player only needing to press a button to perform attacks, lacking depth and challenge.
What is the narrator's view on the game's stealth mechanics?
-The stealth mechanics are considered superficial and not well-developed, with the AI being easily outsmarted, which makes the stealth aspect of the game less engaging.
How does the game's progression system affect the gameplay experience?
-The progression system is criticized for being delayed and not impactful enough, making the gameplay less enjoyable until the player unlocks more abilities and equipment.
What are the narrator's thoughts on the game's replayability and long-term appeal?
-The narrator believes that the game lacks replayability and becomes mundane over time due to its repetitive nature and lack of depth in gameplay mechanics.
What is the final rating given by the narrator for the game?
-The final rating given by the narrator is a 6 out of 10, indicating that while the game has enjoyable elements, it falls short in several areas such as story depth and gameplay mechanics.

Outlines

00:00

🎮 Mixed Feelings on the Gaming Experience

The speaker expresses their complex feelings about a game that revolves around the character Miraj, who has an intriguing backstory set in Baghdad during the Abbasid period. Despite the game's beautiful depiction of Baghdad and its rich historical context, the speaker finds the gameplay repetitive and lacking in depth. They criticize the game's narrative for being too focused on Miraj's assassinations and not enough on the broader story and character development. The speaker also mentions the game's technical aspects, such as the color choices and lighting, which they find impressive, but ultimately feels that the game fails to utilize its full potential, leaving them with a sense of unfulfillment.

05:02

😐 Disappointment in Gameplay and Narrative

The speaker continues to elaborate on their dissatisfaction with the game's mechanics and storyline. They feel that the game's open-world concept, while giving players freedom, also contributes to the loss of narrative focus. The speaker is critical of the game's repetitive tasks and the lack of depth in the side missions, which they find to be a missed opportunity to enrich the player's experience. They also discuss the game's combat system, describing it as basic and lacking challenge, and express disappointment with the stealth mechanics, which they find to be too simplistic. The speaker wishes for a more engaging and innovative approach to the game's design.

10:03

😞 Lack of Innovation and Familiarity

In the final paragraph, the speaker reflects on the overall experience of playing the game, noting a sense of déjà vu and a lack of originality. They compare the game unfavorably to other titles, feeling that it relies too heavily on old design principles without sufficient innovation. The speaker also discusses the game's side activities, which they find to be quickly completed and lacking substance. They express a desire for a more immersive and challenging experience, one that would better utilize the rich historical setting of Baghdad and the potential of the game's narrative. The speaker concludes by expressing their hope for a better return to the game's roots in future installments, one that would be more in line with modern gaming standards.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Assassin's Creed

Assassin's Creed is a popular video game series known for its historical settings and the ability to explore open-world environments. In the context of the video, the speaker is discussing their experience playing the latest installment of the series, which is set in Baghdad during the Abbasid era. The game's narrative and gameplay mechanics are central to the video's theme of historical immersion and entertainment.

💡Baghdad

Baghdad is the capital of Iraq and historically was the center of the Islamic Golden Age. In the video, the speaker mentions Baghdad's significance during the Abbasid era, highlighting its role as a melting pot of cultures and religions. The city's depiction in the game is a key element of the video's discussion on historical representation and the player's experience of exploring a culturally rich environment.

💡Abbasid era

The Abbasid era refers to a period in Islamic history when the Abbasid Caliphate ruled. The video's theme revolves around the game's setting in Baghdad during this era, which is characterized by cultural and scientific advancements. The speaker's experience of the game is deeply tied to the historical context of the Abbasid era and its impact on the game's world-building.

💡Open-world game

An open-world game is one where players can freely roam and explore a virtual world without being constrained to a specific path or set of objectives. The video discusses the speaker's experience with the game's open-world design, which allows them to immerse themselves in the historical setting of Baghdad and engage with the game's narrative at their own pace.

💡Gameplay mechanics

Gameplay mechanics refer to the rules and systems that govern how a game is played. The video critiques certain aspects of the game's mechanics, such as stealth and combat, which the speaker finds repetitive and lacking depth. These mechanics are integral to the player's interaction with the game world and contribute to the overall experience discussed in the video.

💡Stealth gameplay

Stealth gameplay involves the player character avoiding detection by enemies, often using hiding spots and silent takedowns. The speaker in the video mentions the simplicity and repetitiveness of the stealth mechanics in the game, which they find disappointing compared to their expectations for a more engaging and complex system.

💡Combat system

The combat system in a game defines how characters engage in fights and battles. The video script criticizes the combat as being too basic and lacking challenge, with the speaker expressing a desire for a more dynamic and strategic combat experience that would enhance the game's overall appeal.

💡Side missions

Side missions are optional tasks or quests in a game that are not directly related to the main storyline. The video discusses the side missions in the game, with the speaker finding them to be repetitive and not adding much value to the overall experience. However, they also mention that these missions could be more engaging if they were better integrated into the game's world and narrative.

💡Historical immersion

Historical immersion refers to the experience of being deeply engaged in a game's historical setting and narrative. The video's theme is heavily focused on the speaker's experience of historical immersion in the game, which is both a strength and a point of critique. The speaker appreciates the detailed representation of Baghdad but also criticizes the game for not fully utilizing this setting to create a more compelling experience.

💡Game development

Game development encompasses the entire process of creating a video game, from design to programming and art. The video script contains criticism of the game's development, particularly regarding the reuse of old game mechanics and the lack of innovation. The speaker expresses a desire for the developers to take more risks and create a more unique and engaging experience.

💡Narrative

In the context of video games, narrative refers to the story that unfolds as the player progresses through the game. The speaker in the video criticizes the game's narrative for being repetitive and lacking depth, with a focus on the beginning and end of the story rather than a more evenly developed plot. This critique is central to the video's discussion of the game's overall quality and player engagement.

Highlights

The game's true identity is not clear, and it feels like a game within a game.

The story revolves around a character named Bashar, who goes through a journey from a thief to a professional.

Events take place in Baghdad during the Abbasid period and the 9th century AD, a time when Baghdad was the center of civilization and science.

Despite Islam being the dominant religion and Arabic the base language, Baghdad was diverse with Jews, Christians, and various ethnicities.

The game portrays Baghdad in a magnificent way, with every play revealing more of its beauty and history.

The artistic style and the city's design are very attractive, with excellent use of colors, nature, and lighting.

The game features creative touches of Arabic elements such as carpets, fountains, and palm trees, shaping the Arab historical imprint.

The city is full of life, with people walking in the streets, speaking Arabic, and discussing various topics.

The player can immerse themselves in the city, listening to conversations and blending with the crowd.

The game's mission of assassination initially causes hesitation and fear for disturbing the peace and stability of Baghdad.

The game's story starts well but quickly becomes repetitive and lacks depth.

Despite having 15 hours of content, the story and its development are underutilized, lacking in providing a meaningful experience.

The game's side missions are more engaging than the main storyline, featuring interesting events and character development.

The game's combat style is very basic and lacks depth, with repetitive actions and no real challenge.

The stealth mechanics are shallow, with artificial intelligence that can be easily exploited.

The game's world design is beautifully crafted, allowing for good synchronization with the player and various activities to engage in.

The game's progression system is strange and not clearly defined, with abilities and skills being developed in a delayed manner.

The game ends abruptly, leaving the player questioning the value of their efforts throughout the game.

The game's side content is limited and not very engaging, with contracts being the only notable side activity.

The game feels old, with outdated mission designs and gameplay mechanics that seem to be from the early days of the PlayStation 3.

The game's return to its roots is not well-executed, as it seems to simply copy and paste old mechanics into the new part without adapting to the current generation.

The game could have benefited from a more thoughtful approach, using the original as a base and adding different elements to suit the current time.

The game's final rating is a 6 out of 10, indicating it is an enjoyable but flawed experience.