Scientific Method (updated)

Beverly Biology
26 Jun 202021:48

Summary

TLDRThis video script delves into the essence of science and the scientific method, emphasizing its objectivity and self-correcting nature. It distinguishes science from non-scientific practices like fortune-telling and astrology. The script outlines the scientific method's steps, from observation to experimentation, using examples like DNA experiments and sleep studies. It highlights the importance of control and experimental groups, independent and dependent variables, and the iterative process of hypothesis testing and validation. The video also discusses how hypotheses can evolve into theories with sufficient evidence, and the potential for theories to change with new information.

Takeaways

  • 🔬 Science is a systematic process that produces information about the natural world, excluding unobservable and untestable phenomena like fortune-telling and astrology.
  • 🧐 Science aims to be objective and self-correcting, with biases and flaws ideally identified and corrected through peer review and repeated experimentation.
  • 🔄 Science is repeatable, meaning an experiment should yield the same results when conducted under the same conditions to ensure validity.
  • 👀 Tools of science include direct observation, such as using microscopes and telescopes, and robotic observations like NASA's Voyager probes.
  • 🧬 Experimentation is a core part of science, as illustrated by Frederick Griffith's discovery of genetic transfer between bacteria through his transformation experiment.
  • 🤔 The scientific method involves a series of steps: identifying a problem, forming a hypothesis, designing and conducting an experiment, analyzing data, drawing conclusions, and repeating the process for verification.
  • 📊 In experiments, the control group receives no special treatment and serves as a comparison to the experimental group, which has one differing factor known as the independent variable.
  • 🛌 An example experiment showed that soft calming music might enhance sleep quality, as measured by an increase in average hours slept when the independent variable (music) was introduced.
  • 📈 Data from experiments, known as the dependent variable, can be analyzed and visualized using graphs and tables to compare outcomes between groups.
  • 🔄 The scientific method is self-correcting; if data does not support a hypothesis, the hypothesis is revised, and the process is repeated.
  • 🌐 Over time, repeated confirmation of hypotheses can lead to the development of scientific theories, which are well-substantiated explanations that are subject to change with new information.

Q & A

  • What is the definition of science according to the script?

    -Science is the process that produces information about the natural world, emphasizing the study of natural phenomena and excluding practices like fortune-telling, card reading, palm reading, and zodiac readings, which are not considered scientific due to their lack of observability and testability.

  • Why is science considered self-correcting?

    -Science is self-correcting because it is a shared process; when biases or flaws in an idea are identified by others, they are scrutinized and corrected, ensuring the integrity and accuracy of scientific findings.

  • What are the key characteristics of a scientific experiment?

    -A scientific experiment should be objective, repeatable, and based on observable and testable phenomena. It often involves direct observation, robotic observations, and experimentation to gather data and information.

  • What is the significance of the scientific method in conducting experiments?

    -The scientific method is a series of steps used to collect information and solve problems. It involves identifying a problem, forming a hypothesis, designing and conducting an experiment, collecting and analyzing data, drawing conclusions, and repeating the process to confirm results or refine hypotheses.

  • What is the role of the control group in an experiment?

    -The control group serves as a baseline for comparison in an experiment. It receives no special treatment and is used to measure the effect of the independent variable by comparing its outcomes to those of the experimental group.

  • Can you explain the difference between an independent variable and a dependent variable?

    -The independent variable is the factor being tested or manipulated in an experiment, while the dependent variable is the outcome or data measured as a result of changes to the independent variable.

  • What is the purpose of repeating an experiment in the scientific method?

    -Repeating an experiment ensures the reliability of the results, confirming that the findings are not due to chance and are consistent under the same conditions.

  • How does a hypothesis differ from a theory in the context of science?

    -A hypothesis is a tentative explanation proposed to explain a phenomenon, while a theory is a well-substantiated explanation that has been repeatedly tested and confirmed through observation and experimentation over time.

  • What does it mean for an experiment to be 'fair' or 'valid' in scientific terms?

    -A fair or valid experiment is one that isolates the independent variable to ensure that any observed effects can be attributed solely to it. It controls for other variables that could potentially influence the outcome and confound the results.

  • Why is it important to maintain a single independent variable in an experiment?

    -Maintaining a single independent variable is crucial to ensure that the experiment's conclusions are clear and not confounded by multiple factors. It allows for a definitive determination of cause and effect.

  • How does the script illustrate the process of testing a hypothesis?

    -The script uses the example of a young lady who hypothesizes that listening to soft calming music improves her sleep. She conducts an experiment with a control and experimental group, collects data on sleep duration, analyzes the data, and draws a conclusion based on whether the hypothesis is supported or rejected by the data.

Outlines

00:00

🔬 Introduction to Science and the Scientific Method

The script introduces the concept of science as a systematic process for understanding the natural world, distinguishing it from non-scientific practices like fortune-telling and astrology. It emphasizes the importance of objectivity, repeatability, and the self-correcting nature of science. The tools of science are explored, including direct observation, robotic observations like NASA's Voyager missions, and experimentation, exemplified by Isaac Newton's apple story and Frederick Griffith's bacterial transformation experiment, which demonstrated the transfer of genetic information.

05:02

🔍 The Scientific Method: Steps and Hypothesis Testing

This paragraph delves into the steps of the scientific method, starting with identifying a problem or making an observation, followed by formulating a hypothesis—a tentative explanation. The method involves designing and conducting experiments, collecting and analyzing data, and drawing conclusions. The self-correcting aspect of science is highlighted through the process of repeating experiments to verify results. A practical example is given involving a young lady who tests the hypothesis that soft calming music improves sleep quality, using a control and experimental group, and employing a fitness tracker to measure sleep duration.

10:04

📊 Data Analysis and Conclusions in Scientific Experiments

The script explains the process of data analysis in scientific experiments, using the sleep study example to illustrate how data from control and experimental groups is compared. The importance of the dependent variable, which is measured during the experiment, is discussed, as well as how graphs can be used to visualize data. The conclusion of the experiment is derived from the data, distinguishing between raw data and the main idea or conclusion. The paragraph also touches on the evolution of hypotheses into theories over time, with Charles Darwin's theory of natural selection as an example, and the potential for new information to update scientific understanding.

15:05

🎯 Identifying Variables in Scientific Scenarios

This section presents several scenarios to practice identifying control and experimental groups, as well as independent and dependent variables within scientific experiments. Examples include a military sleep study, a farmer's fertilizer test, a student's study method comparison, and a city's investigation into the effects of air pollution on physical fitness. The scenarios are designed to reinforce the understanding of experimental design and the role of variables in drawing scientific conclusions.

20:08

🚫 The Importance of Fairness in Scientific Experiments

The final paragraph addresses the concept of fairness in scientific experiments, using a modified sleep study scenario as an example where multiple variables are changed simultaneously. It explains why such an experiment would be considered unfair or invalid because it would be impossible to determine which variable is responsible for the observed results. The paragraph reinforces the need for single-variable manipulation in experiments to ensure that conclusions are clear and attributable to the independent variable being tested.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Science

Science is the systematic study of the natural world through observation and experimentation. It is the process that produces knowledge and understanding of natural phenomena. In the video, science is contrasted with non-scientific practices like fortune-telling and astrology to emphasize its empirical and testable nature. The script highlights that science is objective, self-correcting, and repeatable, which are fundamental to its methodology.

💡Scientific Method

The scientific method is a structured procedure for conducting scientific investigations, consisting of steps such as identifying a problem, forming a hypothesis, designing and conducting an experiment, analyzing data, and drawing conclusions. The video script describes the scientific method as a self-correcting process that involves sharing and peer review to ensure the accuracy and validity of scientific claims.

💡Hypothesis

A hypothesis is a tentative explanation or prediction made to address a scientific problem or question. It is a testable proposition that serves as a starting point for an experiment. In the script, the concept is exemplified by the young lady who hypothesizes that soft calming music improves her sleep, which is then tested through an experiment.

💡Experiment

An experiment is a controlled procedure carried out to validate or refute a hypothesis. It involves manipulating variables and observing the effects to test scientific theories. The video script provides examples of experiments, such as the DNA experiment by Frederick Griffith and the sleep study involving soft calming music, to illustrate how experiments lead to the collection of data and the drawing of conclusions.

💡Observation

Observation is the act of gathering information through the senses or with the aid of scientific instruments. It is a fundamental part of science, as it provides the initial data that leads to questions and hypotheses. The script mentions direct observation, such as using a microscope or telescope, and the famous anecdote about Isaac Newton being inspired by observing a falling apple.

💡Control Group

A control group is a standard part of an experiment that does not receive the experimental treatment, serving as a baseline for comparison with the group that does receive the treatment. In the script, the control group is used in various scenarios, such as the sleep study and the military marksmanship test, to demonstrate the importance of having a comparison group for valid scientific conclusions.

💡Experimental Group

The experimental group is the part of an experiment that receives the treatment or intervention being tested. It is compared against the control group to determine the effect of the independent variable. The script discusses the setup of the experimental group in the sleep study, where the subject listens to soft calming music, contrasting it with the control group's normal conditions.

💡Independent Variable

The independent variable is the element in an experiment that the researcher manipulates to test its effect on the dependent variable. It is the factor that is intentionally changed to observe its impact on the outcome. In the script, the independent variable in the sleep study is the presence of soft calming music, which is varied to see its effect on sleep quality.

💡Dependent Variable

The dependent variable is the outcome or response measured in an experiment, which is expected to change as a result of the manipulation of the independent variable. It is 'dependent' on the independent variable in the sense that its value is influenced by changes to that variable. The script uses the amount of sleep recorded by a fitness tracker as the dependent variable in the sleep study example.

💡Data Analysis

Data analysis involves examining and interpreting the results of an experiment to draw conclusions. It often includes creating graphs and tables to visualize the data. The script describes how the data from the control and experimental groups in the sleep study is analyzed and compared, using a bar graph to illustrate the difference in sleep duration with and without music.

💡Theory

A theory in science is a well-substantiated explanation of some aspect of the natural world, based on a body of facts that have been repeatedly confirmed through observation and experimentation. The script mentions Charles Darwin's theory of natural selection as an example of a hypothesis that, over time and through rigorous testing, has become an accepted scientific theory.

Highlights

Science is a process that produces information about the natural world, excluding unobservable and untestable phenomena like fortune-telling and horoscopes.

Science is objective and self-correcting, with biases and flaws being identified and corrected over time through peer review and repetition.

Science is repeatable, requiring experiments to be consistent and withstand scrutiny to validate claims.

Direct observation, such as using microscopes or telescopes, is a fundamental tool in gathering scientific information.

Robotic observations, like NASA's Voyager probes, extend our ability to observe and collect data from beyond our solar system.

Experimentation, exemplified by Frederick Griffith's discovery of genetic transfer in bacteria, is key to advancing scientific knowledge.

The scientific method involves a series of steps starting with identifying a problem, forming a hypothesis, and designing an experiment.

Hypotheses in science are tentative explanations that can be tested and potentially lead to the formation of theories.

Experiments should have a control group for comparison and an experimental group where the independent variable is manipulated.

The independent variable is the factor being tested in an experiment, while the dependent variable is the measured outcome.

Data analysis involves comparing control and experimental groups, often visualized through graphs and tables.

A conclusion in science is the main idea learned from an experiment, distinguishing it from the raw data collected.

The scientific method concludes with the possibility of repeating experiments to ensure the reliability of results.

Hypotheses and theories can evolve with new information, as demonstrated by shifts in understanding of the Earth's position and shape.

Charles Darwin's theory of natural selection started as a hypothesis and became an accepted scientific theory through repeated confirmation.

Fairness in experiments is crucial, ensuring that only one independent variable is changed to avoid confounding results.

Practice scenarios and problems help solidify understanding of the scientific method and its application in various contexts.

Transcripts

play00:00

okay so today's topic is science and the

play00:04

scientific method so let's go ahead and

play00:06

get started well first of all you know

play00:10

what is science well it's the process

play00:13

that produces information about the

play00:15

natural world and I do want to stress

play00:17

the word the phrase there the natural

play00:20

world you know natural phenomenon so

play00:22

therefore things like you know

play00:24

fortune-telling and you know reading

play00:26

cards to predict your future is not a

play00:29

science nor is palm reading and you know

play00:32

you wouldn't know that by driving around

play00:33

the streets of Los Angeles there's a lot

play00:35

of these businesses in operation but you

play00:39

know none of these are considered

play00:40

scientific and neither is you know

play00:43

zodiac readings you know your horoscope

play00:45

and and and you know trying to live your

play00:49

life by astrological signals and symbols

play00:52

so these while they might be

play00:54

entertaining to some are definitely not

play00:57

within the realm of science they're not

play00:59

observable they're not testable so what

play01:03

is then science well we number one we

play01:05

try to be objective of course that's

play01:08

very very difficult I mean we're humans

play01:09

we are dealing with human flaws and we

play01:11

all have biases that might inadvertently

play01:14

shape our opinions and our ideas and but

play01:17

the great thing about science is that it

play01:20

is self-correcting because as we go

play01:22

through the scientific method science is

play01:25

shared with others and then if there are

play01:28

biases and flaws in an idea they are

play01:31

hopefully identified by others and

play01:33

scrutinized and therefore then self

play01:36

correct science is repeatable I mean if

play01:40

you're doing an experiment and you have

play01:42

this outrageous claim that your product

play01:45

you know changes the world in some

play01:48

revolutionary way that has to be

play01:50

repeatable and you know therefore live

play01:53

up to the scrutiny of science so tools

play01:58

and skills that we use in in science

play02:01

number one is simply direct observation

play02:04

you know in the picture here we have

play02:05

some folks doing simple microscope

play02:08

observations and observing the

play02:09

microscopic world well here we have a

play02:13

couple people

play02:13

making a telescope observation you know

play02:15

looking through a telescope and

play02:17

observing something in the nighttime sky

play02:18

and this observation is again

play02:21

information that that is about the

play02:24

natural world well also we can do

play02:28

robotic observations you know 1977 NASA

play02:32

launched Voyager 1 Voyager tube these

play02:35

probes have been floating around in the

play02:38

solar system and now beyond the solar

play02:41

system since the late 1970s observing

play02:45

measuring and sending information back

play02:48

to you know NASA here for observations

play02:52

and another you know kind of a maybe a

play02:56

tall tale perhaps that point you know

play02:58

Isaac Newton gets bonked on the head

play03:00

with a falling Apple and therefore as a

play03:03

young lad that helped him uncover the

play03:06

secrets of gravity you know did that

play03:08

tall tale actually happen you know I

play03:11

don't know if we have a good answer to

play03:13

that but again an observation of falling

play03:15

objects leading to great leaps of

play03:18

discovery here and let's not forget you

play03:22

know another area of science is simply

play03:25

experimentation you know maybe and like

play03:27

the young lady in this picture doing DNA

play03:30

experimentation trying to read the DNA

play03:33

printout of a DNA molecule you know a

play03:36

kind of a famous experiment done in 1928

play03:40

Frederick Griffith Frederick Griffith

play03:42

excuse me taught us that bacteria can

play03:45

actually transfer genetic information

play03:47

now watch when he did he injected these

play03:51

mice with a harmless bacteria and to no

play03:55

surprise the mice survived then he took

play03:59

a deadly strain of the bacteria injected

play04:02

into the mice and to no surprise the

play04:05

mice died well then he took the deadly

play04:09

bacteria but he heated the bacteria the

play04:11

heat killed the bacteria injected the

play04:15

dead deadly bacteria into the mice and

play04:18

no surprise the mice survived well

play04:20

here's where it got interesting

play04:22

he took the harmless bacteria that were

play04:25

very much alive

play04:27

and mixed them with the dead deadly

play04:30

bacteria the heated bacteria and by

play04:34

doing such he was expecting the mice to

play04:36

survive however they died so in this

play04:38

experiment he learned that bacteria can

play04:41

transfer genetic information from one to

play04:44

another

play04:45

turns out the harmless bacteria was

play04:47

transformed into a deadly version of

play04:50

bacteria because the harmless bacteria

play04:52

picked up pieces of DNA from the dead

play04:56

deadly bacteria kind of an interesting

play04:59

little experiment where we learned a

play05:01

good deal amount of information and so

play05:05

data and information is gathered by what

play05:09

we call the scientific method so let's

play05:11

go ahead and talk about that so the

play05:15

scientific method the series of steps to

play05:17

collect information and solve problems

play05:20

well it begins with identifying a

play05:23

problem or making an observation asking

play05:26

a question something that is curious

play05:29

you're curious about and you're

play05:31

wondering the solution when next comes

play05:34

what you think this solution is you know

play05:36

a little bit of research and you can

play05:37

construct a hypothesis a tentative

play05:40

explanation to your problem and from

play05:44

there you then design the experiment and

play05:46

we're gonna go through an example in a

play05:48

moment and that experiment will lead to

play05:51

data being collected and then we have to

play05:54

of course analyze that data from the

play05:56

data we can of course draw a conclusion

play05:59

and from our conclusion after our

play06:02

conclusion we would then repeat and now

play06:04

here's where it gets kind of interesting

play06:06

because if our hypothesis appears to be

play06:08

supported by the analyzed data well then

play06:13

of course we want to repeat and perform

play06:15

the experiments again to make sure to

play06:17

make certain of our results but if our

play06:20

data indicates that the hypothesis is

play06:24

not supported well then we have to

play06:26

reconstruct a hypothesis and kind of

play06:29

start all over again so this is what I

play06:30

meant earlier when I said that science

play06:32

is self-correcting mistakes are

play06:35

identified and hopefully can therefore

play06:37

then be corrected

play06:40

well let's get into testing an idea

play06:44

again the scientific method begins with

play06:46

a problem or an observation well last

play06:50

night where we have a young lady in our

play06:52

picture she accidentally fell asleep

play06:53

with her headphones on while listening

play06:56

to soft calming music she awoke

play06:58

refreshed and feeling better than she

play07:00

did on most other days well that's an

play07:03

observation her observation in this

play07:06

example might be you know I seem to

play07:08

sleep better when I play soft calming

play07:11

music so now she's gonna create a

play07:14

hypothesis you know our hypothesis is a

play07:17

proposed explanation a tentative

play07:19

explanation what she thinks the reason

play07:23

for her better sleep would be in this

play07:26

example was the soft calming music now

play07:29

notice how I worded my hypothesis as an

play07:31

if-then statement if there is soft

play07:34

calming music plane then I will sleep

play07:37

better that would be an example of a

play07:39

hypothesis okay so now let's go on and

play07:43

actually perform an experiment well

play07:46

first thing I want to mention is in an

play07:48

experiment there are two groups of test

play07:50

subjects we call the one group the

play07:53

control group and the other group the

play07:55

experimental group well let's focus on

play07:58

what the control group is first so let's

play08:01

focus on our control group you know this

play08:03

is the part of the experiment that

play08:05

receives no special treatment we use the

play08:10

control group as a comparison we're

play08:12

going to compare the control group

play08:13

eventually to the experimental group so

play08:17

here we have our test subjects sleeping

play08:20

in a nice warm comfortable environment

play08:22

and you know during the day she's eating

play08:24

healthy meals during the day she's doing

play08:27

proper exercise and she decides you know

play08:30

what she's gonna measure her amount of

play08:32

sleep for seven days and she's gonna use

play08:35

her fitness tracker to record her sleep

play08:37

you know if you have a Fitbit or a Apple

play08:40

watch you know a lot of fitness trackers

play08:43

have tools on them to record how much

play08:46

and how well you sleep every night so

play08:49

she's gonna wear a fitness tracker to

play08:50

record her sleep

play08:53

well now let's turn our attention to the

play08:56

experimental group we're gonna set this

play08:59

up the same as the control group but

play09:01

with one difference now before we talk

play09:03

about the difference let's focus on

play09:05

setting it up as the same as the control

play09:07

group so our our young lady here is

play09:10

gonna sleep in a warm comfortable

play09:12

environment she's gonna have healthy

play09:15

meals during the day she's gonna perform

play09:17

regular fitness activities during the

play09:19

day she's gonna conduct the experimental

play09:22

group for seven days and she's gonna use

play09:24

her fitness tracker to record how much

play09:27

sleep she gets every night but now let's

play09:30

talk about the one factor we call this

play09:33

one factor that differs we call it the

play09:35

independent variable this is the factor

play09:39

that we are testing and in this case we

play09:43

are testing whether or not sleep the

play09:45

soft calming music has an impact on her

play09:50

ability to sleep every night and so that

play09:53

would make it the independent variable

play09:55

so the independent variable is the one

play09:58

factor that differs between the control

play10:00

group and the experimental group now

play10:03

during the experiment remember we're

play10:05

gonna use our fitness tracker to record

play10:07

how much she sleeps every night let's

play10:10

pretend during the cut the seven days of

play10:12

the control group she averages six and a

play10:15

half hours of sleep per night and during

play10:17

the seven days of the experimental group

play10:19

she averages eight hours of sleep per

play10:23

night this data that we gathered we call

play10:26

the data that is measured during the

play10:28

experiment we call this the dependent

play10:31

variable and I hope you see why it's

play10:33

called the dependent variable because

play10:35

the sleep depended upon the independent

play10:40

variable the sleep the amount of sleep

play10:42

depended upon whether or not she was

play10:44

listening to music that was the

play10:47

independent variable so in this case the

play10:50

dependent variable is the amount asleep

play10:54

that was recorded every night by her

play10:56

fitness tracker so whatever data you are

play11:00

measuring in a science experiment that

play11:02

is the dependent there

play11:07

well now let's talk about analyzing the

play11:10

data we already know the control group

play11:12

and during the control group she

play11:14

averaged six and a half hours of sleep

play11:16

per night and during the experimental

play11:17

group eight hours of sleep per night so

play11:20

data from the control group is going to

play11:23

be compared to the experimental group

play11:25

and we can do that often via by making

play11:28

tables and graphs and in this case I've

play11:31

created a graph for you where it's a bar

play11:33

graph which shows the amount of sleep

play11:37

during the seven days without music six

play11:40

and a half hours of sleep and the seven

play11:43

days of sleep with music eight hours of

play11:46

sleep per night so you can clearly see

play11:48

that with the soft calming music plane

play11:51

she averages more sleep and so graphs

play11:54

are a great way to visualize your data

play11:56

and now based on this data we can

play12:00

determine whether or not our hypothesis

play12:02

was supported or rejected remember her

play12:06

earlier hypothesis was if I play soft

play12:09

calming music through the night then I

play12:12

will sleep better right now the data

play12:15

sure seems to support her hypothesis and

play12:20

so now comes to our conclusion this is

play12:23

the main idea that we have learned now

play12:26

let me ask you I'm going to give you two

play12:28

choices which of these choices would be

play12:30

the conclusion think of it like a

play12:32

multiple choice choice one soft calming

play12:35

music enhances the ability to sleep or

play12:38

how about this soft calming music

play12:41

averaged eight hours of sleep versus six

play12:44

and a half hours when not listening to

play12:46

music which of these is the conclusion I

play12:49

hope you realize it's the first one the

play12:53

second choice that just disappeared

play12:56

that's not the conclusion that was the

play12:58

data that you actually gathered there's

play13:00

a difference between the data gathered

play13:02

in the main idea that we have learned or

play13:05

the conclusion and in this case soft

play13:07

calming music seems to enhance her

play13:10

ability to sleep that would be a

play13:12

conclusion so as we wrap up the

play13:16

scientific method our final step really

play13:17

is to repeat you know our findings can

play13:19

be shared and repeated by others you

play13:21

know to repeat this sleep experiment the

play13:23

second time a third time would be a

play13:25

really good idea just to make sure that

play13:27

our results are true and not due to

play13:29

chance well as time passes

play13:31

perhaps with new experimentations and

play13:34

new observations from other scientists

play13:35

perhaps hypotheses may grow into what's

play13:38

called a theory you might recognize the

play13:40

picture of Charles Darwin here well

play13:41

today Darwin's idea of natural selection

play13:44

is an accepted scientific theory but in

play13:47

1859 when he published his book the

play13:50

Origin of Species he really started out

play13:52

as his hypothesis and over the years his

play13:55

hypothesis has been confirmed

play13:57

time after time at the time by other

play13:59

scientists and so today we call natural

play14:01

selection a theory which means it's a

play14:04

well substantiated explanation acquired

play14:07

through the scientific method and

play14:08

repeatedly tested and confirmed through

play14:11

observation and experimentation but I do

play14:14

want to mention that you know hypotheses

play14:16

and theories can always change based on

play14:19

new information you know there was a

play14:20

time when the earth was believed to be

play14:23

stationary the center of the universe

play14:25

and not only that but also flat well

play14:29

that was because of based on the

play14:30

information we had at a time that

play14:32

appeared to be most accurate of course

play14:35

as time passed we eventually learned

play14:36

that hey the earth is round and it's

play14:39

really the earth that is in rotation

play14:41

around throughout the universe so new

play14:44

information can update hypotheses and

play14:48

theories

play14:51

well you know here are the notes before

play14:53

I want to give you a scenario and then a

play14:55

few practice problems so in this

play14:57

scenario the military wants to know of

play15:00

soldiers with only four hours of sleep

play15:01

can operate at the same level as those

play15:03

who normally get seven hours of sleep

play15:05

100 soldiers are allowed to sleep for

play15:07

four hours a night and another hundred

play15:09

are allowed to sleep for seven hours a

play15:11

night the soldiers are then tested for

play15:13

marksmanship and the firing range based

play15:15

on this story I think you should be able

play15:17

to answer these four questions pause the

play15:20

video because I'm gonna go over the

play15:21

answers in three two one so first of all

play15:25

name the control group in this

play15:26

experiment or those are the soldiers

play15:28

with seven hours asleep because the

play15:30

control group is the group that receives

play15:32

no special treatment and to get seven

play15:35

hours of sleep is the normal situation

play15:37

the next part name the experimental

play15:40

group of those are the soldiers would

play15:41

ever receive four hours of sleep because

play15:43

we're manipulating this experimental

play15:45

group name the independent variable that

play15:48

would be the amount of sleep the

play15:49

definition of the independent variable

play15:51

it's the fact that we are testing we are

play15:53

testing seven hours of sleep versus four

play15:56

hours of sleep and then name the in

play15:59

excuse me name the dependent variable

play16:01

well that would be their score on the

play16:03

firing range their marksmanship because

play16:05

we can measure that and the data that is

play16:07

gathered is the dependent variable let's

play16:10

do another one of these practice

play16:11

scenarios

play16:14

okay here's another scenario a farmer

play16:17

wants to test the new fertilizer for his

play16:19

crops he sections off two large areas of

play16:22

his field and in section a he waters his

play16:24

crops as usual and uses his normal

play16:26

fertilizer called grow right in Section

play16:29

B he waters his crops as usual but adds

play16:31

ever grow fertilizer after one growing

play16:34

season he records the growth of the

play16:36

crops based on this story I think you

play16:38

should be able to answer these four

play16:39

questions answer the questions and I'm

play16:41

gonna and pause the video because I'm

play16:43

gonna go over the answers now in three

play16:45

two one

play16:46

so name the control group I hope you

play16:49

said that's Section A because again the

play16:51

control group is the part of the

play16:52

experiment that receives no special

play16:54

treatment section a gets water as usual

play16:57

and the normal fertilizer name the

play17:00

experimental group that's Section B we

play17:02

are manipulating the the the factors of

play17:06

section B by giving them a new

play17:08

fertilizer number three name the

play17:11

independent variable well that would be

play17:13

the type of fertilizer again the

play17:14

independent variable is the factor we

play17:16

are testing and we're testing the type

play17:18

of fertilizer and then name the

play17:20

dependent variable what are we actually

play17:22

measuring the growth of the crops let's

play17:25

do another scenario

play17:29

here we have a student and he wants to

play17:31

know if his new study method is more

play17:33

successful than his traditional study

play17:34

method so for one month he studies for

play17:37

his classes using his traditional study

play17:39

method and a next month he studies for

play17:41

his classes using his new study method

play17:44

and at the end he compares his grades

play17:46

well here are the four questions pause

play17:48

the video try to answer these I'm going

play17:50

to go over the answers in three two one

play17:53

so name the control group I hope you

play17:56

said well that's the one month of

play17:58

traditional studying name the

play18:00

experimental group well that's the one

play18:02

month of this new experimental study

play18:04

method whatever it may be named

play18:07

independent variable that's the study

play18:10

method and name the dependent variable

play18:13

that data being gathered is the greater

play18:16

are the grades one more of these

play18:18

practice problems

play18:21

okay in this final scenario the city of

play18:24

Los Angeles wants to know if there is a

play18:26

connection between physical fitness and

play18:28

air pollution in Group A the volunteers

play18:30

ride a stationary bike for one hour in a

play18:32

pollution-free air timbre in Group B the

play18:34

volunteers ride a stationary bike for

play18:36

one hour and a chamber filled with air

play18:39

pollutants common to Los Angeles and

play18:40

their heart rates are monitored

play18:42

throughout the rides well here are the

play18:44

four questions pause the video try to

play18:46

answer them I'm gonna go over the

play18:48

answers in three two one

play18:50

so name the control group I hope you

play18:52

said hey that's Group B because again

play18:54

the control group receives no special

play18:56

treatment

play18:57

Group B they are riding a bike in the

play19:00

chamber filled with air pollutions air

play19:03

pollutants common to Los Angeles named

play19:06

the experimental group now I hope you

play19:07

said that's group a because we're

play19:09

manipulating this group or removing all

play19:12

the air pollution whatsoever and so

play19:14

we're manipulating group a named the

play19:17

independent variable that would be the

play19:19

quality of the air and what about the

play19:22

dependent variable that would be their

play19:24

heart rates so I hope you get the idea

play19:26

of how these scenarios work

play19:30

well let me pose this question to you

play19:34

would it be fair to do this

play19:36

remember our sleep experiment would it

play19:38

be fair let's say we have our warm

play19:41

comfortable environment in the control

play19:43

and experimental group and member and

play19:45

the experimental group our young lady

play19:47

here is listening to soft calming music

play19:50

but during the day she's doing different

play19:53

exercise programs during the day she's

play19:55

eating different meals she's still gonna

play19:57

use her fitness tracker to record her

play20:00

sleep and she's still gonna do this for

play20:02

a total of seven days is this a fair

play20:04

experiment and let's pretend she

play20:07

averages again let's keep the numbers

play20:09

the same pretend she averages six and a

play20:10

half hours of sleep per night in the

play20:12

control group and eight hours of sleep

play20:15

per night in the experimental group I

play20:17

hope you realize no this is not a fair

play20:20

experiment this experiment would not be

play20:22

viewed as a valid scientific experiment

play20:24

and I hope you see why if I were to ask

play20:27

you how many independent variables are

play20:29

in this experiment I hope you realize

play20:31

there's three one of them being whether

play20:35

or not she listens to music another a

play20:38

second being the exercise program she

play20:41

performs during the day and a third

play20:43

being the meals she eats during the day

play20:46

well why why is this a big deal but I

play20:49

hope you realize well maybe that extra

play20:52

amount of sleep was caused by the

play20:54

calming music but maybe that extra sleep

play20:57

was caused by the change in exercise

play20:59

habits but maybe that extra sleep was

play21:02

caused by the change of the eating

play21:03

habits and maybe that extra sleep was

play21:06

caused by a combination of these factors

play21:08

and that's the point we can't narrow it

play21:12

down a science experiment is supposed to

play21:15

allow you to come to a single conclusion

play21:17

and in this case we just can't do that

play21:20

there's too many possible explanations

play21:23

to explain why she averaged more sleep

play21:27

in the experimental group this

play21:29

experiment would need to be recreated

play21:33

okay so as I wrap up this video I want

play21:37

to thank you for watching you know

play21:38

here's a little practice quiz for you to

play21:40

try and if you're in my class I'm happy

play21:43

to check your answers before or after

play21:45

school one day thanks for watching

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Related Tags
Scientific MethodObservationExperimentationHypothesis TestingData AnalysisNatural WorldCritical ThinkingSelf-CorrectingResearch MethodologyEducational ContentScience Education