HTMX Sucks

Summary

The video script is a passionate critique of HTM X, a JavaScript library, accusing it of being a poorly designed, single-file mess with a lack of best practices like separation of concerns. It points out HTM X's creator as unprofessional and the framework as outdated, insecure, and not scalable. The speaker also criticizes the lack of job opportunities and community support for HTM X, advocating for established technologies like React instead.

Takeaways

• 😡 The speaker expresses a strong negative opinion about HTM X, suggesting it's of poor quality and not a serious contender in web development.
• 🤔 The speaker questions the sudden seriousness with which HTM X is being taken, noting its popularity on platforms like YouTube.
• 📄 The script criticizes HTM X for its lack of coherent documentation and for the poor quality of its first impression in its introductory materials.
• 💻 The speaker points out that HTM X's codebase is a single, large JavaScript file, which goes against modern practices of modularity and separation of concerns.
• 🛠️ The script mentions the absence of a traditional build step in HTM X, which is seen as a disadvantage compared to other JavaScript frameworks that benefit from such processes.
• 🔗 The speaker highlights HTM X's disregard for established web development practices, such as the use of components and the separation of front-end and back-end code.
• 🤖 The script argues against the idea of full-stack JavaScript development with HTM X, suggesting it's not a scalable or maintainable approach.
• 😖 The speaker laments the lack of job opportunities and community support for HTM X, suggesting it could be detrimental to a developer's career.
• 👎 The script criticizes the HTM X creator's behavior, accusing them of unprofessionalism and questionable ethics in their online presence and interactions.
• 📉 The speaker suggests that HTM X is unlikely to scale well for larger applications, unlike component-based frameworks like React which are designed for maintainability.
• 🏁 The conclusion of the script strongly advises against the use of HTM X for web development, advocating for more established and professional technologies.

Q & A

What is the main criticism of HTM X presented in the script?

The script criticizes HTM X for being a poorly designed framework with a single large JavaScript file, lacking modern JavaScript features, and having an unorganized codebase that disregards the principle of separation of concerns.

What does the script imply about the HTM X community's attitude towards the framework?

The script implies that the HTM X community is overly defensive and blindly supportive, often referred to as 'fanboys', and that this attitude is misguided due to the framework's flaws.

Why does the script's author believe HTM X is not suitable for large-scale applications?

The author argues that HTM X's model breaks down as applications grow larger, leading to a messy and unmanageable codebase, unlike the component-based model of React that remains organized and testable at scale.

What is the script's stance on the use of 'hyper media' in HTM X?

The script criticizes the use of 'hyper media' as a pretentious term for HTML and suggests that it does not offer any innovative approach, but rather reuses existing concepts without improvement.

How does the script evaluate the HTM X job market?

The script states that there are virtually no job opportunities for HTM X developers, with only two job listings found on Indeed, compared to thousands of React jobs, suggesting a lack of industry support for HTM X.

What is the script's opinion on the HTM X creator's behavior?

The script describes the HTM X creator as 'unhinged', accusing him of stealing code, memes, and articles, and behaving in an unprofessional and provocative manner on social media.

What security risks does the script associate with HTM X?

The script identifies cross-site scripting (XSS) vulnerabilities as a significant security risk associated with HTM X, due to its design that encourages embedding behaviors in the page without proper sanitation.

What does the script suggest about the HTM X framework's originality?

The script suggests that HTM X lacks originality, as it is described as a 'shameless fork' of Intercooler, and that it does not contribute any new or innovative solutions to web development.

How does the script view the lack of components in HTM X?

The script criticizes the lack of components in HTM X, stating that developers are left to figure out how to integrate their own components, which is an unnecessary burden compared to established libraries with ready-to-use components.

What is the script's view on the HTM X framework's approach to backend and frontend development?

The script criticizes HTM X for eliminating the split between backend and frontend development, arguing that this approach is not scalable, and that the separation of concerns is essential for effective development.

What does the script suggest about the HTM X framework's scalability?

The script suggests that HTM X is not scalable, as it may work for small applications but will become problematic as applications grow, leading to a lack of maintainability and increased complexity.