SEKILAS TENTANG JAMAAH TABLIG, Nasehat Ustadz Muflih Safitra, M. Sc #ustadzmuflihsafitra

Summary

The video script discusses the practices and beliefs of the Tabligh Jamaat (JT) group, focusing on their unique rituals like khuruj (outreach), their understanding of religious principles, and their connection to Sufi traditions. The speaker reflects on their personal journey with JT, expressing concerns about the group's deviations from orthodox Islamic beliefs, such as the misinterpretation of tauhid and the reliance on weak or fabricated Hadiths. Despite their dedication to prayer and good deeds, the group’s emphasis on specific rituals and practices is critiqued as misguided, leading the speaker to adopt a more orthodox approach based on Sunna.

Takeaways

• 😀 The practice of 'Khuruj' within the Tabligh Jamaat (JT) involves members leaving for short periods to engage in community-focused missionary work, particularly during Ramadan. This practice is seen as a form of spreading the message of Islam.
• 😀 There is a debate surrounding the validity of 'Khuruj' in Islam, with some questioning its alignment with authentic Sunnah and Islamic teachings. While some view it as a form of Dawah (preaching), others criticize its origins.
• 😀 The founder of JT, Muhammad Ilyas Al-Kandahlawi, claimed to have been inspired by a vision to promote missionary work, leading to the establishment of JT. However, some scholars challenge his interpretation and view his methods as deviant.
• 😀 JT’s practices are influenced by Sufi traditions, combining elements from four major Sufi orders: Qadiriyah, Jistiyah, Sarwardiyah, and Naqshbandiyah, which has raised concerns regarding its compatibility with mainstream Islamic beliefs.
• 😀 A significant point of contention is the JT’s understanding of Tawhid, particularly their focus on Rububiyyah (Lordship) and neglect of other essential aspects like Uluhiyyah (Worship) and Asma wa Sifat (Names and Attributes of Allah). This leads to incomplete understanding of Islamic monotheism.
• 😀 JT’s emphasis on Fadhail Amal (virtues of deeds) leads to a focus on the rewards of actions (such as prayer and fasting) without sufficient regard for their alignment with authentic Sunnah, often promoting weak or fabricated hadiths.
• 😀 Despite being criticized for its theological deviations, JT still maintains strong community bonds, and its members are recognized for their sense of camaraderie and mutual support, such as eating and praying together.
• 😀 The JT movement often emphasizes the importance of simplicity and devotion to worship, but some of their practices, such as the veneration of certain scholars, are seen as problematic from a Sunni perspective, especially regarding figures like Ibn Taymiyyah and Ibn Qayyim.
• 😀 A notable concern is the lack of formal education and scholarly rigor within JT's preaching. Some of its leaders, particularly those who have recently converted, may preach without a solid understanding of the core principles of Islam or proper Islamic scholarship.
• 😀 Lastly, JT’s approach to 'Khuruj' involves traveling to different regions, sometimes knocking on doors to invite people to Islam. While well-intentioned, the method may sometimes lead to intrusive encounters, particularly when they approach individuals unprepared for such discussions.

Q & A

What is 'khuruj' in the context of the Tabligh Jamaat?

Khuruj refers to a practice within the Tabligh Jamaat where members travel to spread Islamic teachings. It involves going out for a specific period, such as 3 days or 40 days, to perform dawah (Islamic outreach) in communities.

What is the controversy surrounding the practice of khuruj?

The controversy lies in its theological justification. Some argue that khuruj is based on a dream of the Tabligh Jamaat's founder, Muhammad Ilyas, who believed he was commanded to spread the message like the Prophets. Critics question whether this practice is truly supported by the Quran and Sunnah.

What role does Sufism play in the Tabligh Jamaat?

The Tabligh Jamaat is associated with several Sufi orders, including Naqshbandi, Qadri, Jistiya, and Sarwardi. This integration of Sufi teachings with traditional Islamic practices is a point of contention, as some view it as deviating from a purist interpretation of Islam.

How do critics view the Tabligh Jamaat's interpretation of tauhid?

Critics argue that the Tabligh Jamaat's understanding of tauhid is incomplete. They focus only on 'rububiyah' (the Lordship of Allah) and neglect other aspects like 'uluhiyah' (worship of Allah) and 'asma wa sifat' (the names and attributes of Allah), which are considered central to Islamic belief.

What is meant by the term 'fadil amal' in the context of Tabligh Jamaat?

'Fadil amal' refers to the focus on the virtues of good deeds, such as the importance of certain acts like prayer, fasting, and dhikr (remembrance of Allah). While this emphasis is seen positively, critics argue that the Tabligh Jamaat often overlooks whether these acts align with the Sunnah or are based on weak or fabricated hadiths.

How does the Tabligh Jamaat approach the concept of bid'ah (innovation)?

The Tabligh Jamaat's stance on bid'ah is controversial. Some members view bid'ah as acceptable if it leads to unity among Muslims, while traditionalists argue that bid'ah ultimately divides the ummah (Muslim community) and should be avoided in favor of the Sunnah.

Why do some members of the Tabligh Jamaat consider congregating in India more important than Hajj?

Some extreme members of the Tabligh Jamaat believe that gathering in India for their religious practices is more virtuous than performing Hajj. This view, however, is not universally held within the group.

What are the potential issues with the Tabligh Jamaat's educational approach to Islamic knowledge?

One of the criticisms is that the Tabligh Jamaat sometimes promotes dawah without adequate scholarly knowledge. Members are often encouraged to teach without sufficient understanding of Islamic principles, leading to the spread of unverified or weak information, particularly in their books on 'fadil amal'.

What is the significance of 'ushul sittah' in the Tabligh Jamaat?

'Ushul sittah' refers to the six foundational principles of the Tabligh Jamaat, which include faith in the Kalimah (Shahada), regular prayer, acquiring knowledge, good character, sincerity in actions, and the practice of khuruj. Critics argue that while these principles are important, they do not fully align with the purist Sunnah.

How do members of the Tabligh Jamaat maintain unity among themselves despite theological differences?

The Tabligh Jamaat emphasizes brotherhood and unity, often sharing meals and engaging in communal activities. This creates a strong sense of community among members, though critics argue that this sense of unity should not overshadow the importance of theological correctness in their practices.