RED VELVET Dance Ranking

Summary

In this video, the creator evaluates the dance abilities of Red Velvet members, focusing on their technical strengths and weaknesses. The analysis covers aspects like rhythm, body control, isolations, and facial expressions. Members like Irene and Yeri are noted for their struggles with hip-hop basics and body control, while Wendy and Joy are recognized for potential but still lack consistent technique. Sulgi stands out for her unique style but could benefit from hip-hop training. Overall, the video highlights the technical gaps in Red Velvet's dancing and the importance of more extensive training in idol choreography.

Takeaways

• 😀 Yerry and Irene are grouped together due to their similar technical weaknesses in dance, including a lack of body control and musical awareness.
• 😀 Irene's facial expressions are a common point of critique, with some suggesting her facial features may reflect personal struggles rather than performance choice.
• 😀 Joy is noted for her potential, particularly in heavy, fluid movements seen in heels choreography, though her timing and facial expressions need improvement.
• 😀 Wendy is praised for her awareness of music, but she often rushes through movements, a common beginner mistake. Her dance potential is evident in her ability to step heavily and maintain rhythm.
• 😀 Wendy's isolations, while inconsistent, are highlighted as a unique strength. However, her technique is hindered by an immature understanding of her own movement.
• 😀 Sulgi's performance of mature concepts is strong, though her cheerful expressions may be lacking due to her natural temperament. She could improve by adjusting her body choices for more convincing cheerfulness.
• 😀 Sulgi's technique is generally clean, but she struggles with stiffness, particularly in her upper chest and footwork, which could benefit from more hip-hop training.
• 😀 Despite their strengths, the Red Velvet members' dance training has been limited, preventing them from moving beyond beginner mimicry and developing a solid technical foundation.
• 😀 The lack of diverse and ambitious training for Red Velvet members is seen as a major issue, as it hinders their ability to develop as serious dancers.
• 😀 Wendy, in particular, is seen as someone with the potential to break out of the beginner mindset and fully explore her artistic expression through dance, especially with hip-hop techniques.

Q & A

Why are Yeri and Irene grouped together in the dance ranking?

Yeri and Irene are grouped together because both share similar technical weaknesses in their dancing. Their proportions and years of performing girl group choreography have led to a lack of body control and musicality, as they often perform with minimal engagement with the music.

What is Irene's main issue when it comes to dancing?

Irene's main issue is her inability to grasp basic hip-hop techniques, such as maintaining rhythm during footwork, isolating body parts, and projecting power. Additionally, her facial expressions are often criticized for lacking variety.

What potential does Joy have in terms of dancing?

Joy shows potential in fluid movement, especially in heels choreography, and has improved her timing over the years. Her main weaknesses include inconsistent facial expressions and occasional timing issues, which would likely improve with more technical development.

What is Wendy's biggest dance issue?

Wendy's biggest issue is rushing to the endpoint of movements, which can cause her to lose the musicality of the piece. This is a common mistake for beginner dancers, as it disrupts the natural flow of movement to match the music.

What makes Wendy's dancing stand out despite her issues?

Wendy's dancing stands out because she is one of the few idols who can step with the heaviness required for well-timed footwork. She also shows great musicality by matching her moves with the beats and lyrics of the music.

How can Wendy improve her dancing?

Wendy could improve by developing a better understanding of her own movement and focusing on increasing the clarity of her lines and isolations. Taking dance more seriously and refining her technique would help her unlock her full potential.

How does Seulgi perform in mature versus cheerful concepts?

Seulgi performs exceptionally in mature concepts, where her facial expressions and overall execution are sharp and expressive. However, in cheerful concepts, she struggles to appear enthusiastic and might need to adjust her artistic choices to convey a more cheerful persona.

What are Seulgi's strengths in dancing?

Seulgi is a clean and relaxed dancer, with her locks being a major strength. These locks allow her to isolate body parts and maintain stillness, even as she changes positions. She also excels at using her hypermobility to create unique wrist angles.

Why does Seulgi struggle with certain hip-hop movements?

Seulgi struggles with hip-hop movements due to stiffness, particularly in her upper chest and footwork. This stiffness may be related to problematic body alignment or the habit of clicking her shoulders into place, which can inhibit smooth movement.

What overall critique is made about SM Entertainment's training of Red Velvet?

The critique suggests that SM Entertainment has provided inadequate dance training for Red Velvet, as many of the members have not been given the technical foundation needed to move past the beginner phase of mimicry. This has hindered the group's ability to develop a more sophisticated dance style, despite individual potential.