Why are so many seniors in San Diego aging without a home? | NBC 7 San Diego

NBC 7 San Diego
29 Jan 202425:51

Summary

TLDRNBC San Diego reports on the escalating crisis of senior homelessness in California, where the aging population faces unaffordable housing costs and inadequate social security. With a 29% increase in unsheltered seniors from 2017 to 2021, the report highlights the harsh living conditions and the struggle for basic needs, such as food and medicine. The lack of affordable housing and healthcare access is exacerbating the situation, with mental health issues and substance abuse becoming prevalent coping mechanisms. Experts emphasize the urgency of addressing the housing crisis to prevent a worsening of the situation.

Takeaways

  • 🏠 The number of seniors aged 55 and older living on the streets in California has made up a third of the unsheltered population, increasing by 84% between 2017 and 2021.
  • 📈 Seniors are the fastest-growing group among the unhoused population in California, with a significant increase in homelessness among this demographic.
  • 💼 Many seniors experiencing homelessness for the first time are facing tough choices due to fixed incomes and rising living costs.
  • 🚫 Homelessness is not just a result of long-term issues; it's also a consequence of recent life events like illness, job loss, or the death of a partner.
  • 🛌 Homeless seniors often have to live in their vehicles or makeshift shelters, facing harsh living conditions and limited access to basic needs.
  • 🏥 Health issues are exacerbated by homelessness, with seniors experiencing premature aging and a range of illnesses due to the lack of proper care and living conditions.
  • 🤔 The crisis is multifaceted, involving not only housing affordability but also mental health, substance abuse, and the lack of adequate support systems.
  • 🏢 There is a critical shortage of affordable senior housing, with many seniors unable to find suitable and affordable places to live.
  • 💊 Homelessness can lead to a disconnection from the healthcare system, resulting in untreated health conditions and a worsening of mental health.
  • 🔍 The situation is expected to worsen before it improves, with projections indicating a tripling of homelessness among people aged 65 and older by 2030.
  • 🏛️ Solutions involve a focus on housing affordability, increasing subsidies, and creating more housing options to prevent seniors from becoming homeless.

Q & A

  • What is the focus of the NBC San Diego news report?

    -The focus of the NBC San Diego news report is the growing crisis of homelessness among seniors in California, particularly in San Diego, and the challenges they face due to aging without a home.

  • Why are seniors becoming the fastest-growing group among the unhoused population in California?

    -Seniors are becoming the fastest-growing group among the unhoused population in California due to a combination of factors, including the rising cost of housing, fixed incomes that can't keep up with living expenses, and a lack of affordable housing options.

  • What percentage of the unsheltered population in California is made up of people aged 55 and older?

    -People aged 55 and older make up about a third of the unsheltered population in California.

  • How has the number of seniors seeking homelessness services changed between 2017 and 2021 according to California's homeless data integration system?

    -Between 2017 and 2021, the number of seniors aged 55 and over seeking homelessness services increased by 84%.

  • What are the tough choices seniors on a fixed income often have to make due to the high cost of living in San Diego?

    -Seniors on a fixed income often have to make tough choices between food, medicine, and housing due to the high cost of living in San Diego.

  • What is the situation that Chuck Scott, a 69-year-old, finds himself in, and how does he describe his living conditions?

    -Chuck Scott, a 69-year-old, has been living out of his truck for the past two years. He describes his living conditions as inconvenient, needing to shower at people's houses and finding places to eat, and uncomfortable sleeping arrangements.

  • What is the role of Teresa Smith, CEO of Dreams for Change, and what does she say about the senior population in her organization's safe sleeping lots?

    -Teresa Smith is the CEO of Dreams for Change, a nonprofit running San Diego Safe Sleeping, which offers safe legal camping spaces for people experiencing homelessness. She says that at least 45% of the individuals currently housed in their lots are 55 and older.

  • What are the health implications of living on the streets for seniors, according to Dr. Margo Cuselle?

    -According to Dr. Margo Cuselle, living on the streets prematurely ages and sickens people. Seniors in their 50s and 60s who are homeless often have health issues that resemble those of people in their 70s and 80s in the general population, including cognitive decline, mobility problems, and other age-related issues.

  • What is the impact of homelessness on mental health, and how do some seniors cope with it?

    -Homelessness can exacerbate mental health issues, with many experiencing depression, anxiety, and substance abuse as coping mechanisms. Some seniors turn to substances like methamphetamines to stay awake and alcohol to help with anxiety and fear.

  • What does Dr. Margo Cuselle suggest is the fundamental issue leading to homelessness for seniors?

    -Dr. Margo Cuselle suggests that the fundamental issue leading to homelessness for seniors is the inability to pay for housing, which is a direct result of low benefits, low minimum wage, and a lack of pensions for many who have worked their whole lives.

  • What is the projected increase in the number of seniors experiencing homelessness between 2017 and 2030?

    -It is projected that the number of seniors aged 65 and older experiencing homelessness will triple between 2017 and 2030.

Outlines

00:00

🏡 Crisis of Homeless Seniors in California

The script opens with a focus on the escalating issue of homelessness among seniors in California. It is highlighted that this vulnerable group is not only the fastest-growing segment of the unhoused population but also faces unique challenges due to their age. The data indicates a significant increase in the number of homeless seniors between 2017 and 2021, with many experiencing homelessness for the first time. The script introduces the audience to individuals like Chuck Scott, who has been living out of his truck, and discusses the difficult choices they must make between basic necessities due to fixed incomes and the high cost of living.

05:01

📈 Rising Homelessness Among Seniors Due to Housing Costs

This paragraph delves into the reasons behind the surge in homelessness among seniors, emphasizing the role of housing affordability. Seniors, many of whom are on fixed incomes, are struggling to keep up with the rising costs of rent and living expenses. The narrative includes personal stories of individuals like Scott, who could no longer afford his rent after it tripled, and Daniel Alfredo, who has been homeless for 20 years and now suffers from various health issues. The lack of affordable senior housing and the impact of inflation are identified as key factors contributing to this crisis.

10:02

🚑 Health Challenges of Homeless Seniors

The third paragraph highlights the health challenges faced by homeless seniors, who often require extra care that most shelters are not equipped to provide. It discusses the premature aging and sickness that result from living on the streets, with research showing that homeless individuals in their 50s and 60s experience health issues typically seen in those 20 to 30 years older. The paragraph also touches on the mental health impacts of homelessness, including anxiety, depression, and substance abuse as coping mechanisms, and the tragic reality that many seniors die on the streets due to untreated health conditions.

15:04

🏘️ The Urgency of Addressing Senior Homelessness

This section underscores the urgency of finding solutions to senior homelessness, with insights from Dr. Margo Cushelle, who points out that the crisis is likely to worsen before it improves. The discussion centers on the need for more affordable housing, subsidies, and the importance of acting now to prevent a larger crisis in the future. The paragraph also addresses the lack of preparedness in the current shelter system to cater to the specific needs of the elderly population and the societal implications of not addressing this issue.

20:06

📊 The Impact of Housing Costs on Senior Homelessness

The focus of this paragraph is on the direct correlation between housing costs and the rise in senior homelessness. It presents data showing that as housing costs increase, so does homelessness, and emphasizes that this issue is not related to substance use or mental health problems, but rather to the inability to afford housing. The paragraph also discusses the lack of federal funding for housing programs and the dire need for more housing units for low-income households, painting a bleak picture of the future if action is not taken.

25:06

🌐 Multi-Layered Solutions to Senior Homelessness

The final paragraph wraps up the discussion by emphasizing that while mental health and substance use are intertwined with homelessness, the core issue is the lack of affordable housing. It calls for a comprehensive approach that includes increasing the availability of housing, improving benefits, raising the minimum wage, and ensuring subsidies for seniors. The paragraph concludes with a call to action, stressing that every solution to homelessness must involve housing and that the most at-risk population, the seniors, must be prioritized.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡Homelessness

Homelessness refers to the condition of people without a regular place to live, often lacking the security of a stable home. In the video, it is the central theme highlighting the plight of the growing senior population without homes in California. The script mentions that seniors are the fastest-growing group among the unhoused population, with many facing the harsh reality of living in their cars or on the streets.

💡Seniors

Seniors are individuals who are typically over the age of 65, often associated with retirement and a time for relaxation and enjoyment of life's fruits. However, the script reveals a crisis where seniors are becoming a significant and rapidly growing part of the homeless population, struggling with inadequate resources and facing the physical and mental challenges of living without a stable home.

💡Unhoused Population

The term 'unhoused population' is used to describe people who do not have a permanent residence, which includes those living on the streets, in temporary shelters, or in vehicles. The script emphasizes that in California, this population is growing, with seniors making up a significant and increasing proportion.

💡Crisis

A crisis is a situation that is thought of as an unstable time of extreme danger or difficulty. The script describes the situation of senior homelessness as a 'crisis within a crisis,' indicating the severity and urgency of the issue, especially in the context of an already existing homelessness problem.

💡Fixed Income

A fixed income refers to a regular, unchanging amount of money that an individual receives, often associated with retirement pensions or social security payments. The video script illustrates the challenge faced by seniors on fixed incomes who cannot afford the rising cost of living and housing, leading to homelessness.

💡Aging Population

The aging population denotes a demographic trend where the proportion of older individuals in society is increasing. The script discusses how California is witnessing an alarming increase in the aging population becoming homeless, with implications for social services and the economy.

💡Affordable Housing

Affordable housing refers to residential units that are priced at a level where they are accessible to individuals and families with a range of incomes. The script highlights a shortage of affordable housing as a key factor contributing to the homelessness of seniors who, despite working for many years, cannot find housing they can afford on their limited incomes.

💡Healthcare

Healthcare is the organized provision of medical services to individuals or communities through various health professionals and allied health fields. The script points out that living on the streets prematurely ages and sickens people, and the lack of access to healthcare exacerbates the health issues faced by homeless seniors.

💡Mental Health

Mental health refers to the state of an individual's psychological and emotional well-being. The video script discusses how the stress of homelessness can lead to increased rates of depression, anxiety, and substance abuse among the unhoused senior population, indicating the interconnectedness of housing stability and mental health.

💡Substance Abuse

Substance abuse is the excessive and harmful use of substances such as alcohol or drugs. The script mentions substance abuse as a coping mechanism among homeless individuals, including seniors, who may turn to substances like methamphetamines or alcohol to deal with the stress and anxiety of living on the streets.

💡Housing Subsidies

Housing subsidies are financial assistance provided to individuals or families to reduce the cost of housing. The script suggests that increasing housing subsidies is a potential solution to help seniors and others on fixed incomes afford housing, emphasizing the need for policy interventions to address the affordability crisis.

Highlights

California's rising unhoused population includes a growing number of seniors, with people aged 55 and older making up a third of the unsheltered population.

Homelessness among seniors is increasing at a faster rate than other age groups, with an 84% increase from 2017 to 2021 compared to a 43% increase across all ages.

Many seniors experiencing homelessness for the first time face tough choices between food, medicine, and shelter due to fixed incomes and rising living costs.

Seniors living in their vehicles or on the streets face harsh living conditions and struggle to access necessary help and resources.

The lack of affordable housing and the high cost of living are pushing seniors into homelessness, with many unable to find or afford housing after job loss or retirement.

Local activists and nonprofit organizations are working to provide safe sleeping spaces and support for homeless seniors, but the demand far exceeds the available resources.

Health issues are exacerbated for homeless seniors, with many dealing with chronic illnesses and lack of access to healthcare.

Homelessness prematurely ages and sickens people, with those in their 50s experiencing health declines similar to those in their 70s and 80s in the general population.

Mental health concerns such as depression and anxiety are prevalent among homeless seniors, with some turning to substance abuse as a coping mechanism.

The crisis of senior homelessness is expected to worsen before it improves, with the number of homeless seniors projected to triple by 2030.

Efforts to address senior homelessness must focus on increasing affordable housing, lowering housing costs, and increasing housing subsidies.

The lack of connection to the healthcare system for homeless seniors leads to worsening health conditions and untreated chronic illnesses.

Homeless seniors often face violence, exposure to the elements, and sleep deprivation, which significantly impact their mental health.

Substance use among homeless seniors is increasing as a means to cope with the immediate challenges of living on the streets.

The urgency of addressing senior homelessness is highlighted by the fact that a quarter of California's residents are expected to be 60 or older by 2030.

The public must recognize that homelessness is primarily a housing problem, and solutions must focus on creating and preserving affordable housing for seniors.

Transcripts

play00:01

you're watching NBC San Diego news it's

play00:03

a crisis within a crisis hidden among

play00:06

California's Rising unhoused population

play00:09

is a growing number of seniors aging

play00:12

without a home in the next half hour

play00:14

you'll meet members of this vulnerable

play00:16

group see their living conditions and

play00:18

witness the challenges they face when

play00:21

trying to find

play00:22

help thanks for joining us I'm Monica

play00:25

Dean when we think about homelessness

play00:27

seniors aren't typically the people who

play00:29

come to mind

play00:30

but data show they are the fastest

play00:32

growing group among the unhoused

play00:34

population recently a new study shows

play00:36

people 55 in older living on the streets

play00:39

make up a third of the unsheltered

play00:42

population here in California these are

play00:44

not just people who have been homeless

play00:46

for a long time many of them are

play00:48

experiencing this for the first time as

play00:50

seniors according to the California's

play00:52

homeless data integration system between

play00:55

2017 and 2021 the number of people 55 in

play01:00

over who sought homelessness Services

play01:02

increased

play01:04

84% by comparison people across all ages

play01:07

accessing homeless Services increased by

play01:10

43% those seniors are having to face

play01:13

tough choices food medicine or roof with

play01:17

many of them on a fixed income and the

play01:19

ever growing cost of living here in

play01:21

America's Finest City seniors are faced

play01:24

with harsh living conditions and some

play01:26

very tough choices joining me now is NBC

play01:29

San Diego goes Amber Fus who has been

play01:31

researching and Reporting on this topic

play01:33

and Amber you recently spent a few days

play01:35

meeting members of this vulnerable

play01:37

population and learning about how they

play01:39

fell into homelessness in the first

play01:41

place yeah that's right Monica you know

play01:43

we often hear that our homeless

play01:45

population just keeps growing so I

play01:47

wanted to go out there see why that is

play01:49

and who these people are the ones who

play01:51

are ending up on our streets and in

play01:52

speaking with Advocates and just being

play01:54

out there you know I came to realize

play01:56

these people are a lot older than what

play01:58

we sometimes assume they are yes it's

play02:00

interesting to see the face of a topic

play02:02

that we certainly often generalize up

play02:05

close and they are one of the most

play02:07

vulnerable populations and Amber they're

play02:08

facing a harsh new reality yeah that

play02:11

reality is that working your whole life

play02:13

does not guarantee you'll have a roof

play02:14

over your head most of the people I

play02:16

spoke with simply cannot afford housing

play02:18

cost in the city the majority had in one

play02:21

way or another either struggled to keep

play02:24

up with Rising rent costs or are simply

play02:26

unable to find places to live due to

play02:28

their limited Financial Resources forces

play02:30

as a result as you pointed out at the

play02:32

top data shows seniors are indeed the

play02:35

fastest growing group among the Hopeless

play02:37

population and with the help of one

play02:39

local activist I got to spend some time

play02:41

with this growing Community to better

play02:43

understand their living conditions and

play02:45

the challenges they face every

play02:47

day on a recent morning in the rich viw

play02:50

Webster neighborhood of Eastern San

play02:52

Diego Chuck Scott stopped by to check on

play02:55

his truck he was with a healthcare

play02:57

worker from a local Rehabilitation

play02:59

Center where he was staying was a

play03:01

discharge me in the hospital on

play03:03

Saturday what were you in the hospital

play03:05

for I fell down right here the stay at

play03:07

the center is only temporary this is

play03:10

what Scott calls home the 69-year-old

play03:13

has been living out of his truck for the

play03:15

past two years well it's definitely

play03:18

inconvenient you know because you got to

play03:21

go and take showers to people's houses

play03:22

and inconvenience them you know and uh

play03:26

it's not really need to find places to

play03:28

eat and uh it's s very comfortable

play03:32

sleeping Scott hardly stands out from

play03:34

the many people living in their cars at

play03:37

this same parking lot as far as a

play03:39

sleeping Arrangement I'll sleep right

play03:41

here and try to move my seat as far back

play03:44

as I can so my legs will stretch up a

play03:46

lot of times it doesn't work that way

play03:48

and same with Irene she'll try to do the

play03:50

same thing Frank who prefer to only go

play03:52

by his first name and his partner Irene

play03:55

randone have called their truck home for

play03:57

6

play03:58

months believe really hard real hard to

play04:01

get help I thought I was on a waiting

play04:02

list for 6 months and I'm not even on a

play04:04

list and I thought I had done the

play04:05

footwork and I just thought the the

play04:08

government was going to help homeless

play04:10

people you know I mean why we have to

play04:11

jump through all these hoops to get

play04:13

housing they want us off the street and

play04:15

stuff and it's really hard the group all

play04:17

above the age of 55 find themselves in

play04:20

the middle of a growing crisis aging

play04:23

without a home torture California

play04:25

accounts for about a third of the

play04:27

nation's homeless population and among

play04:30

this population seniors are the fastest

play04:32

growing Group in San Diego people 55 and

play04:36

older living in the streets make up at

play04:38

least 29% of the unsheltered population

play04:42

with 80% of them becoming homeless in

play04:44

their own Hometown these are people that

play04:46

you know lived and worked here in San

play04:48

Diego their entire lives who have just

play04:51

been priced out of the system and unable

play04:53

to you know finish you know in Ence in

play04:55

the homes that they had Teresa Smith is

play04:58

the CEO of dreams for a nonprofit

play05:00

running San Diego safe sleeping s the

play05:03

two designated Lots offer safe legal

play05:05

camping space for people experiencing

play05:08

homelessness hundreds of individuals are

play05:10

currently housed and Smith says at least

play05:13

45% of them are 55 and older um I think

play05:17

it's happening more rapidly now yes

play05:18

because of the cost inflation and the

play05:20

cost of litty um it's really is pushing

play05:23

them out of those housing situations and

play05:25

there's nothing to jump back into and we

play05:27

have such a shortage of literally senior

play05:30

housing so even as they start to

play05:31

approach those senior ages where they

play05:33

may need a little bit more of that

play05:35

support as any other senior would be

play05:37

there's nowhere that it's affordable for

play05:39

them to even go that's exactly what

play05:41

happened to Scott who at one point was

play05:43

living inside his very own one-bedroom

play05:45

apartment my rent went from $800 to

play05:49

$1,600 and I couldn't afford to move

play05:51

back in after they

play05:53

modeled so um you know they said they

play05:55

give me first choice to move back in but

play05:57

I can't I only get $1,000 a month those

play06:00

security how can I afford to pay $1600 a

play06:02

month I can't stories like Scots are

play06:05

common especially among the older

play06:08

populations living on the streets how

play06:10

often do you see people you know of

play06:11

older age like seniors like 60 70 coming

play06:14

into the shelter you see a lot of them

play06:17

you know a lot of them that need medical

play06:18

attention and stuff like that and a lot

play06:20

of that shouldn't even be here should be

play06:21

somewhere else like Tom like Tom Liss at

play06:23

home or something you know and and it's

play06:25

sad you know I surprised I ain't got

play06:28

like you know kids I want to take care

play06:30

of them some people are stuck in their

play06:31

old ways of like not trying to get help

play06:33

for themselves like you know being

play06:35

stubborn like that's how I am you know I

play06:38

won't call an ambulance come to help me

play06:40

I I'll lay there and die I don't care

play06:42

that's just me Daniel Alfredo is

play06:44

currently living at one of San Diego

play06:46

safe sleeping sites he managed being on

play06:49

the streets for the past 20 years until

play06:51

life started catching up to him now at

play06:54

51 years old loffredo suffers from a

play06:57

wide range of illnesses and deal with uh

play07:00

stic nerve damage on my right leg I got

play07:03

cellulitis um other other issues you

play07:06

know I don't want to get into research

play07:08

shows that living on the streets

play07:10

prematurely ages and sickens people when

play07:13

talking about homelessness 50 is the new

play07:15

75 Margo cushelle director of UC San

play07:19

Francisco's Benny off homeless and

play07:21

Housing Initiative has been studying

play07:22

senior homelessness for the past decade

play07:25

whether it be measures of cognitive

play07:28

decline

play07:30

Mobility problems problems with function

play07:33

falling all of the things that we

play07:35

usually think of happening to people in

play07:37

late life just happened to people 20 or

play07:40

30 years earlier cushelle says their

play07:43

situation can also trigger anxiety

play07:45

depression and substance abuse we heard

play07:48

from so many people who experienced

play07:50

homelessness who told us that they use

play07:52

substances as a coping mechanism using

play07:55

things like methamphetamines to stay

play07:57

awake using things like um alcohol to

play08:00

help them cope with the anxiety the fear

play08:04

the um the difficulty falling asleep

play08:07

those things driving down the streets of

play08:09

downtown San Diego the amount of

play08:11

unhoused seniors stands out I'm going to

play08:14

go over to 16th in commercial area 14th

play08:17

and Commercial I have a lot of seniors

play08:19

that have

play08:20

cancer I've just been discharged it's

play08:22

kind of like the pool where they drop

play08:25

everyone we took a ride with Heather

play08:27

newart a homeless advocate who spends

play08:29

her days helping the unhoused let me get

play08:32

you some so you can at least give it out

play08:33

I had a lady that was on this street is

play08:36

the honest God truth she had was stage

play08:39

four cancer and she was propped up right

play08:42

here and she was on a chair with two

play08:47

crates and that was her bed I lost count

play08:50

of how

play08:51

many

play08:53

new

play08:56

Diversified individuals or seniors or I

play08:59

I've lost

play09:00

count most of the seniors I know that

play09:03

are on the streets are definitely

play09:04

handicapped one way or another and are

play09:06

still waiting for their affordable

play09:08

housing for their section8 or whatever

play09:10

or Senior Living housing they don't have

play09:11

enough spots for them Michael Anderson

play09:14

also lives at a city safe sleeping site

play09:16

but he spent years on the streets after

play09:18

losing his job I had a backpack a

play09:21

sleeping bag and some cardboard every

play09:23

night and waking up at 4:30 in the

play09:25

morning every day to make sure you're

play09:27

packed up and ready to go before the cop

play09:29

get there is not fun especially when I

play09:31

started

play09:32

Living with around other people and we

play09:35

would have to pack up our tents and

play09:37

everything um and being slightly

play09:40

physical disabled it sucked for me but

play09:42

it was really really hard on the older

play09:44

people that around us at just 48 years

play09:47

old Anderson now also deals with a

play09:50

variety of health issues this becomes

play09:52

even more tragic when people have these

play09:55

aging related health problems cancer

play09:57

heart disease diabetes things that we

play10:00

really can't treat effectively when

play10:02

people are homeless and we have no place

play10:04

for them to go the health needs of

play10:06

seniors can require Extra Care and most

play10:08

shelters are not prepared to serve this

play10:11

growing population the services now are

play10:14

not quite caught up to those these quite

play10:16

yet I think it's happening much faster

play10:17

than we can really even start thinking

play10:19

about what are those specific Services

play10:21

we need to first of all solve our

play10:23

housing crisis we need to have every

play10:25

effort on creating more housing lowering

play10:28

the cost of housing increasing housing

play10:31

subsidies so that being an older adult

play10:34

living on a fixed income doesn't cons

play10:36

doesn't you know mean that you have to

play10:38

be homeless with a quarter of the

play10:39

state's residents expected to be 60 or

play10:42

older by 2030 cushelle says the time to

play10:45

act is now we think this is going to get

play10:48

worse before it gets better and The Time

play10:50

Is Now for us to start addressing it

play10:53

unless we're ready as a society to have

play10:56

huge numbers of seniors live living and

play10:59

dying on our streets Frank feels the

play11:02

urgency expressing determination in his

play11:05

attempts to find a place to call his own

play11:07

my plan is to um go and talk to these

play11:12

people about the shelter um and get on

play11:15

the list with them so I can get on the

play11:18

housing list you know and hopefully

play11:20

that's moved quickly you know as as long

play11:23

as I stand on that list and um you know

play11:27

and that's all I can do is just keep my

play11:29

head up and and keep going tring along

play11:32

highlighting the ongoing struggles and

play11:34

hopes of those living on the streets

play11:37

open to get housing you know um I car

play11:40

past and um they're supposed to get

play11:43

bagged with me you

play11:44

know I wish I could help I I wish I

play11:47

could win the lottery build a building

play11:50

downtown or buy a building downtown kick

play11:51

all rich rich folks on the streets and

play11:54

move all the poor people in and all

play11:56

their way out I'd hand them tent in a s

play11:57

bag here you go have fun but for now

play12:00

Michael and others continue to wait for

play12:03

permanent Housing Solutions to get them

play12:05

out of the tents or the cars they are

play12:08

currently living in Amber Fus n

play12:12

bc7 wow Amber this is a heartbreaking

play12:14

but really powerful look at the reality

play12:17

of our homeless crisis I mean we talk

play12:19

about the problem in generalities so

play12:21

often but when you hear those individual

play12:23

stories of the people who are impacted

play12:26

and this is their daily lives and

play12:27

routines it really paints a very

play12:30

personal picture yeah Monica and it was

play12:32

really heartbreaking to hear all these

play12:33

stories because the reality is that most

play12:36

of the people if not all of them

play12:37

especially the ones that we spoke to

play12:39

they all told us they wanted shelter

play12:41

they wanted a place of their own and it

play12:44

was either because they couldn't afford

play12:45

it like the first man who we heard from

play12:47

he just didn't have enough money his

play12:49

Social Security was only enough for to

play12:52

barely even cover shelter or they had

play12:54

trouble navigating the shelter system in

play12:56

our County but it was just heartbreaking

play12:58

to know the place they're in it is it

play13:00

was um powerful to hear from them for

play13:02

sure and we're going to continue this

play13:04

discussion still ahead how has the

play13:06

enforcement of the encampment ban

play13:08

impacted on house

play13:10

seniors how do they want us to go into

play13:13

shelters and there's no rooms in the

play13:14

shelters how do they want to reinforce

play13:17

us to have an options to go somewhere

play13:19

else better if they don't have the the

play13:22

Necessities or the

play13:23

spot plus Dr Margo kelle professor of

play13:26

medicine and division Chief at the

play13:28

division of vulnerable populations at

play13:30

Zuckerberg San Francisco General

play13:32

Hospital goes in depth with us about the

play13:34

problem and potential

play13:36

[Music]

play13:40

Solutions welcome back we're talking

play13:42

about why seniors have become the

play13:44

fastest growing population within the

play13:46

unhoused community and we're here with

play13:48

NBC San Diego reporter Amber Fus who has

play13:51

been extensively reporting on this topic

play13:53

and Amber one of the key issues that

play13:55

just keeps coming up among the general

play13:56

homeless population is is the rising

play13:59

cost of housing here in San Diego now

play14:01

you spent a lot of time on the streets

play14:04

talking with seniors I have to imagine

play14:06

this is something you heard a lot about

play14:08

yeah it really is Monica and it it's

play14:10

especially true for this population

play14:11

because a lot of these people are

play14:14

depending on their social security and a

play14:17

lot of times if not all the times

play14:19

whatever they get is not enough to be

play14:22

able to afford rent here in San Diego

play14:25

yeah I'm sure you heard that time and

play14:26

time again in fact I think we have some

play14:28

sound from some people that Amber spoke

play14:30

with take a listen we've got a lot of

play14:33

seniors that are out on these streets

play14:35

now because the economy their social

play14:38

security doesn't pay them enough there's

play14:41

not affordable housing for

play14:44

them they become ill and it's they have

play14:48

their choice between their medication or

play14:51

food or their homes at one point I was

play14:54

living in a studio that didn't even have

play14:56

a kitchen um and it had a shared

play14:59

bathroom and it was costing me 11,100 a

play15:02

month joining our discussion now is Dr

play15:04

Margot celle director of the UCSF Benny

play15:07

off homelessness and Housing Initiative

play15:10

Dr celle thanks for being with us

play15:12

affordability of housing is so critical

play15:15

for any vulnerable group especially

play15:16

seniors what are you seeing across

play15:19

California we are seeing Rising numbers

play15:22

of seniors falling into homelessness um

play15:26

we know now that almost half of single

play15:28

adults are 50 and older and almost half

play15:31

of those first became homeless after the

play15:34

age of 50 these are people who are

play15:37

working poor who've been working their

play15:39

whole Lives who are barely hanging on

play15:42

and sometime after the age of 50

play15:45

Something Happens they get sick their

play15:47

spouse gets sick their marriage breaks

play15:49

up their spouse or partner dies

play15:51

something happens and they have no

play15:53

cushion and they wind up on our streets

play15:57

you know you said something in Amber's

play15:59

report and Amber spent an extensive

play16:00

amount of time on the streets talking

play16:02

with people about this and people who

play16:04

have been impacted by this you said when

play16:06

talking about homelessness 50 is the new

play16:09

75 it's

play16:12

startling yeah you know the experience

play16:15

of homelessness is so harrowing and um

play16:18

people who fall into homelessness are

play16:20

often people who've been working hard

play16:22

their whole lives not getting great

play16:23

access to health care and then they

play16:26

become homeless and everything falls

play16:28

apart

play16:29

and so we've done extensive Health

play16:31

testing on people who experience

play16:34

homelessness in older age and what we

play16:36

find is people who are homeless who are

play16:39

in their 50s and 60s they really look

play16:42

much more like people in their 70s and

play16:45

80s in the general population they have

play16:48

high rates of cognitive impairment of

play16:51

Mobility impairments difficulty walking

play16:53

of all sorts of age related problems but

play16:57

we're just seeing them 20 or 30 years

play16:59

earlier than we would in the

play17:01

non-homeless population Amber in your

play17:03

experience out there reporting on this

play17:05

did you notice that I really did you

play17:07

know I the first man in my report that

play17:10

we spoke to he was in his 70s but from

play17:13

his appearance he looked much older and

play17:15

he was also very sick and then Dr

play17:18

cushelle we also spoke about the part

play17:20

that these are people who are on the

play17:21

street so they don't really have access

play17:23

to Medical Care which I'm sure just

play17:26

makes it so much worse absolutely I mean

play17:29

there are many reasons why Things Fall

play17:31

Apart even worse when people become

play17:33

homeless you know part of it is the

play17:34

non-stop violence they're exposed to the

play17:36

exposure to the elements that lack of

play17:38

sleep but another big part is that

play17:40

people really lose connection to the

play17:43

Health Care System I'm a primary care

play17:45

physician I love doing what I do and

play17:48

what I do is to help people live their

play17:50

best lives to manage chronic illnesses

play17:53

to engage in healthcare prevention so

play17:55

that were they to develop a cancer we

play17:57

catch it early or we catch it before it

play18:00

starts when people become homeless they

play18:02

lose their connection to that so they

play18:04

lose their medicines for their chronic

play18:05

health problems they lose their ability

play18:07

to get their vaccines their health care

play18:09

screening and so this really causes

play18:12

everything that to really get worse yeah

play18:15

and you know another point that was made

play18:17

within the piece that you did Amber was

play18:20

that someone said it was going to get

play18:21

worse before it would get better do you

play18:23

believe that's the case and what

play18:25

contributes to that I do I really really

play18:28

am concerned um about this problem we

play18:31

know that the people born in the second

play18:33

half of the Baby Bo from so about 1955

play18:36

to 1965 have been at an increased risk

play18:38

of homelessness their whole lives it's

play18:40

obviously a very large population we

play18:43

know that homelessness is really related

play18:46

to housing costs so people often blame

play18:49

things like substance use or mental

play18:50

health problems on um the rising rates

play18:53

of homelessness but it really has

play18:55

nothing to do with that what we see is

play18:57

when housing costs go up homelessness

play18:59

goes up as um we continue to have a

play19:04

really severe housing crisis in

play19:07

California we know that this very large

play19:10

group of older adults is going to get

play19:13

larger we know that across the country

play19:15

it is renters 50 and older who are more

play19:18

likely to be what's called rent burden

play19:20

paying more than a third of their income

play19:22

on rent um this group is continuing and

play19:25

we're really not doing enough to stop it

play19:28

we um don't uh the federal government

play19:30

does not really fund um programs like

play19:33

they should only one in four households

play19:35

who qualify for housing subsidies get

play19:37

them we know the cost of housing in

play19:40

California is out of control we know

play19:43

that we have in California only 24 units

play19:45

of housing for every 100 extremely

play19:48

low-income household what you see on the

play19:50

streets is really just the tip of the

play19:52

iceburg it's projected that people 65

play19:55

and older experiencing homelessness

play19:58

their numbers were going to Triple

play19:59

between 2017 to 2030 so we have not seen

play20:03

the worst of this crisis and so the

play20:06

question is what do we do because as you

play20:08

mentioned it often feels kind of like

play20:10

we're putting a Band-Aid on this gaping

play20:12

wound is it putting more money toward

play20:15

housing affordability and then we talk

play20:17

about the the comple complex factors of

play20:20

substance abuse and mental health

play20:22

concerns what do you feel are our

play20:25

greatest needs here you know every

play20:28

Avenue towards ending this crisis of

play20:30

homelessness run through housing there's

play20:33

no question that many people who

play20:35

experience homelessness struggle with

play20:37

substance use and mental health problems

play20:39

and there's no question that we need to

play20:41

get the treatment that they need to

play20:43

thrive but we also know that that

play20:45

treatment without housing just doesn't

play20:48

work and we know that the fundamental

play20:50

underlying disconnect that is leading to

play20:53

so much housing is the inability of

play20:55

people toay that's leading to so much

play20:58

homelessness I'm sorry is the

play20:59

fundamental inability for people to pay

play21:01

for their housing the state is moving in

play21:04

the right direction with creating

play21:07

affordable housing but it is achingly

play21:09

slow a few years ago we had only 21

play21:11

units for every 100 extremely low-income

play21:13

household now we're up to 24 that's a

play21:16

good start but we need to do everything

play21:19

in our power to create housing to

play21:22

preserve housing and to Advocate with

play21:25

our full force for that housing to be a

play21:28

affordable some of housing affordability

play21:30

is just in terms of how much housing we

play21:32

have the more you have the cheaper it is

play21:35

that's where the market works but we

play21:37

need to recognize that as long as we

play21:39

have benefits set so low as long as we

play21:41

have the minimum wage be so low as long

play21:44

as we have so many seniors who don't

play21:47

have pensions who work their whole lives

play21:49

and jobs that didn't give them pensions

play21:51

we need to make sure that we have the

play21:53

subsidies so that our seniors that

play21:56

people who are a Californians can live

play21:59

out their old age in dignity and safety

play22:03

and Amber I think your report shed light

play22:05

on something interesting too when

play22:07

talking about first the housing

play22:08

affordability and these seniors who were

play22:10

left on the streets it seemed like the

play22:13

incidence of mental health concerns

play22:16

depression anxiety escalated and in some

play22:19

cases and I don't know how many maybe Dr

play22:21

cushelle could shed some light on that

play22:23

we're turning to substances to try to

play22:26

suppress some of the anxieties of living

play22:28

on the streets yeah as you can imagine

play22:31

being on the streets it's tough having

play22:32

to live out of your car you know is

play22:34

tough and having to figure out where to

play22:36

go to the bathroom where to get food so

play22:38

a lot of these people were dealing with

play22:40

you know just struggling with their

play22:42

mental health yeah and trying to live

play22:43

day today Dr celle I I imagine that's

play22:46

something that you've looked into as

play22:47

well absolutely we know about 2third of

play22:51

people experiencing homelessness have um

play22:54

relatively significant mental health

play22:56

symptoms but that's mostly driven by

play22:59

depression and anxiety about half each

play23:01

have significant depression and

play23:03

significant anxiety and when you um talk

play23:06

to folks they talk about it as both

play23:08

cause and effect of their homelessness

play23:11

sometimes people were struggling with

play23:12

mental health concerns that made it hard

play23:15

to keep up the two jobs that they needed

play23:17

to you know keep let's say to keep a

play23:19

roof over their head but what people say

play23:21

is they become homeless and everything

play23:25

gets worse they're I can't um

play23:28

overestimate the amount of violence that

play23:30

people are exposed to um that people

play23:33

have you know incredibly High rates of

play23:36

being physically and sexually assaulted

play23:38

people are sleep deprived they're

play23:40

anxious they're terrified they're

play23:42

ashamed this really r reaps havocs with

play23:45

people's mental health and as you said

play23:48

you know the substance use can both um

play23:50

spur people into homelessness it can tip

play23:53

people into homelessness but what we're

play23:55

seeing again and again is a substance

play23:57

who's getting worse people talk about

play23:59

turning to alcohol to um to help ease

play24:02

their symptoms of anxiety obviously not

play24:05

a good long-term solution for anxiety

play24:07

but in the moment it feels like it helps

play24:10

we're also seeing increasing numbers of

play24:12

people turning to methamphetamines

play24:14

because it keeps them awake and alert it

play24:17

it qus their hunger and it seems to sort

play24:20

of solve in a in obviously a not

play24:23

effective way but it seems to address

play24:25

some of their most urgent needs and so

play24:27

we itely see that people turning to or

play24:30

increasing substance use when they

play24:32

become homeless this is such a

play24:34

multi-layered issue but if you were to

play24:36

boil it down and and have one takeaway

play24:38

that you'd want the public to know about

play24:40

it what would that

play24:42

be I think the most important thing is

play24:45

that homelessness is a housing problem

play24:48

we know that when we compare regions

play24:50

with high and low rates of homelessness

play24:53

it is a straight line relationship

play24:55

between the availability of housing for

play24:57

the lowest cost households and therefore

play25:01

every solution to this problem runs

play25:03

through housing it's not that that it

play25:06

isn't also related to mental health and

play25:08

substance use problems of course it is

play25:11

but we can't solve this problem without

play25:14

really addressing our critical shortage

play25:16

of Housing and people have to recognize

play25:19

that it is our seniors who are at most

play25:21

risk we certainly appreciate Dr kelle's

play25:24

valuable insight into this most

play25:26

important issue and Amber we appreciate

play25:28

your research and Reporting on this

play25:30

evolving problem we of course will

play25:33

continue to follow this topic here on

play25:35

NBC San Diego news for now I'm Monica

play25:37

Dean thanks for

play25:47

[Music]

play25:50

watching

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Related Tags
HomelessnessSeniorsCaliforniaCrisisHousingAffordabilityHealthcareMental HealthSocial IssuesUrban Living