Barnett Pearce on Coordinated Management of Meaning

Summary

In this dialogue, Barnett explores the Coordinated Management of Meaning (CMM) theory, emphasizing the concept of 'persons-in-conversation' and the dynamic interplay between stories told and lived. He argues that certainty in communication arises from understanding processes rather than fixed truths. The discussion touches on the importance of cosmopolitan communication, particularly in bridging divides on contentious issues, and highlights that effective communication can be learned and taught. Ultimately, the conversation advocates for an engaged approach to understanding and improving our social realities.

Takeaways

• 😀 CMM focuses on 'persons-in-conversation' as the fundamental unit of communication.
• 😀 The process of communication involves creating shared meanings over time, informed by past experiences and future possibilities.
• 😀 There are inherent tensions between the stories we tell and the lives we live, highlighting the complexity of human interaction.
• 😀 CMM encourages a shift from seeking absolute truths to understanding the processes behind assertions and beliefs.
• 😀 Beliefs and narratives shape our social realities, and recognizing this allows for potential transformation.
• 😀 Engaging in 'cosmopolitan communication' fosters meaningful dialogues across differing perspectives.
• 😀 The Public Conversations Project exemplifies effective facilitation in discussions on contentious issues like abortion.
• 😀 Communication skills for engaging across differences are not innate but can be learned and taught.
• 😀 Emphasizing process over certainty allows individuals to navigate complex social interactions more effectively.
• 😀 The pursuit of understanding and improving the world through communication is a central theme in CMM.

Q & A

What is Coordinated Management of Meaning (CMM)?

CMM is a communication theory that focuses on the interactions between persons-in-conversation, emphasizing the co-construction of meaning and understanding.

Why is the term 'persons-in-conversation' hyphenated?

The hyphenation emphasizes the reciprocal nature of communication, highlighting that understanding occurs through the ongoing interaction between individuals.

What are the two types of stories discussed in CMM?

The two types of stories are 'stories told' (the narratives we communicate) and 'stories lived' (the actual experiences we have), which may not always align.

How does CMM approach the idea of certainty?

CMM suggests that certainty is not merely a binary choice between certainty and uncertainty, but involves understanding the processes of communication and the content of the stories involved.

What role does assertion play in communication according to the speaker?

An assertion is seen as an active part of conversation that carries implications about belief and the desired influence on others, rather than a simple statement of fact.

Can belief in grand narratives coexist with CMM?

Yes, one can believe in grand narratives while practicing CMM, but the way those narratives are advocated might change, potentially leading to more constructive outcomes.

What is 'Cosmopolitan Communication'?

Cosmopolitan Communication refers to a form of dialogue that promotes understanding across differing perspectives, often addressing deeply contentious issues through structured facilitation.

What is an example of Cosmopolitan Communication provided in the transcript?

An example is the Public Conversations Project, which brings together individuals with opposing views, such as pro-life and pro-choice advocates, to foster understanding.

Is the ability to engage in Cosmopolitan Communication innate or learned?

It is learned and teachable; people can develop these skills through practice and structured learning environments.

How can individuals start learning about Cosmopolitan Communication?

While listening to discussions on the topic can spark interest, the skills are best developed through practical engagement and real-life application.