DOSEN MINTA KREDIT ARTIKEL JURNAL MAHASISWA

Summary

The transcript discusses a troubling incident where a professor at Unas demands to be credited in student articles, essentially trading academic favors for course leniency. This practice raises ethical concerns about academic integrity and reflects a broader issue in Indonesian higher education, where some professors may exploit students for their publishing requirements. The speaker criticizes this behavior, suggesting it fosters a culture of mediocrity and unprofessionalism among educators. They also note the disparities in university rankings, highlighting the urgent need for reform in the academic landscape to ensure genuine scholarly contributions.

Takeaways

• 😀 Some faculty members in Indonesia are asking students to include their names in academic publications without contributing meaningfully to the work.
• 😀 This practice raises ethical concerns and could reflect a lack of integrity among certain educators.
• 😀 The increasing pressure on lecturers to publish may lead to questionable behaviors, such as exploiting students for credit.
• 😀 There are strict regulations mandating academic publications for university faculty, particularly at higher ranks.
• 😀 In contrast to practices in some Western countries, many Indonesian educators are still adapting to the expectations of academic publishing.
• 😀 Some universities require dissertation examiners to be credited in student publications, raising further ethical questions.
• 😀 The trend of hiring 'article jockeys' indicates a market-driven approach to academic publishing that undermines true scholarship.
• 😀 A disparity exists in publication practices between major universities and those in less urban areas in Indonesia.
• 😀 Academic integrity is jeopardized when faculty prioritize their publication requirements over genuine mentorship.
• 😀 There is a call for universities to reform and uphold ethical standards in academic publication practices.

Q & A

What issue is raised about professors asking to be credited in student articles?

The script discusses a situation where a professor requested to have their name included in a student's scientific article, which raises concerns about academic integrity and exploitation of students.

How does the speaker view the implications of professors requiring their names to be included in student publications?

The speaker perceives this practice as a sign of laziness or incompetence among some professors, suggesting it undermines the educational process and exploits students.

What are the responsibilities of professors regarding publication in Indonesia?

Professors are required to publish a minimum number of scientific articles in accredited journals as part of their academic duties, especially for those holding specific positions.

What comparison is made between academic publication practices in Indonesia and abroad?

The script contrasts the more established practice of publishing research abroad with the ongoing struggles in Indonesia, where many professors still do not regularly engage in scientific writing.

What is the significance of the 'Times Higher Education World University Rankings' mentioned?

The rankings highlight the performance of Indonesian universities on a global scale, showing that despite having notable institutions, they still rank relatively low compared to global standards.

What is implied about the mentalities of some educators in Indonesia?

The script suggests that some educators may exhibit a 'beggar mentality' or engage in practices like gratification by demanding credit for work they did not contribute to.

How does the speaker view the inclusion of dissertation examiners as article contributors?

The speaker questions the fairness of including dissertation examiners as contributors in articles, arguing that they are already compensated for their roles and shouldn't require additional credit.

What is the impact of regulations on the publication requirements for professors?

New regulations have intensified the pressure on professors to publish, leading some to seek shortcuts, such as having their names included in student articles without meaningful contribution.

What is the concern regarding the prevalence of article ghostwriting?

The script expresses concern that the normalization of hiring ghostwriters for academic publications reflects a deeper issue in the academic integrity of Indonesian institutions.

What underlying issues does the speaker believe these practices indicate within Indonesian academia?

The speaker believes these practices point to systemic problems in Indonesian academia, including inadequate training for professors, the pressure to publish, and a lack of commitment to genuine educational values.