How the Rebel Fleet Reunited After Hoth
Summary
TLDR「スターウォーズ」の反乱同盟がホス星の秘密基地を作った時、帝国が発見された場合の脱出計画も立てていました。反乱同盟は、グループに分かれて脱出し、事前に決められた宇宙座標で合流し、帝国に追跡されないように複数の座標を経由して最終的に再会する計画でした。この計画は「帝国の逆襲」で描かれましたが、各グループがどのように合流したかは「ロストスターズ」や「特定の視点からの帝国の逆襲」などの書籍、2020年のスターウォーズコミックなどで詳述されています。物語では、ウェッジ・アンチルーズ、モン・モトマ、アドミラル・アクバルが同じ部門から脱出した後、ウェッジが第7部門にいたが、アクバルとモトマは第11部門にいたと語られます。ウェッジが第7部門にいた理由については、帝国が通信を遮断していたため、ウェッジが他の反乱部門を探索するために送り込まれた可能性があると説明しています。また、モトマとアクバルが第7部門を離れて他の反乱艦隊と合流しようとした可能性も提案されています。このように、物語の細部を整理し、整合性を保つ試みが魅力的です。
Takeaways
- 🏰 反乱同盟はホス星に秘密基地を作りました。
- 🚀 帝国が発見された場合の脱出計画も作られました。
- 👥 反乱同盟は第1部隊から第11部隊までのグループに分かれていました。
- 📡 帝国は反乱同盟の通信を解読し、第8部隊を完全に破壊しました。
- 🔍 反乱同盟は通信を遮断し、他の部隊を探そうとしました。
- 🎬 『帝国の逆襲』では脱出計画が描かれていますが、その後の集結は描かれていません。
- 📚 『Lost Stars』や『From a Certain Point of View』などの書籍で脱出後の集結が詳述されています。
- 🚀 ルーク・スカイウォーカーは第4部隊と第7部隊を結集し、帝国から脱出を手伝いました。
- 🛰️ ウェッジ・アンティールズは第7部隊にいたが、後に第11部隊にいました。
- 🤔 ウェッジ・アンティールズが第7部隊から第11部隊に移動した理由は、継続性エラーか、任務によって異なる可能性があります。
- 🧐 ウェッジは他の反乱同盟部隊を探すための偵察任務に派遣された可能性があります。
- 🛰️ モットーマとアクバルは第11部隊にいて、ABダラス星で帝国に襲撃されました。
Q & A
共和国同盟在霍斯星秘密基地建立时,他们制定了什么样的逃脱计划?
-共和国同盟在霍斯星秘密基地建立时,制定了一个逃脱计划,以防被帝国发现。计划中所有叛军将被分成小组离开星球,并在太空中的预定坐标点集合,然后跳入超空间到更多坐标点,以确保他们没有被跟踪。最终,所有小组将再次集合。
在《帝国反击战》电影中,叛军小组是如何被标记的?
-在《帝国反击战》电影中,叛军小组被标记为第一师到至少第11师,可能还有更多,他们被赋予了像“第四师”这样的呼叫信号。
叛军小组在撤离霍斯星后,是如何被帝国追踪的?
-帝国通过黑客攻击叛军的通信系统,能够拦截叛军小组之间发送的传输信号。例如,当第四师试图联系第八师时,帝国能够捕捉到传输并得知两个师的位置,导致第八师被完全摧毁。
《失落的星星》这本书中,蒙·莫斯马和韦德·安蒂列斯在撤离霍斯星后在哪里?
-在《失落的星星》这本书中,蒙·莫斯马和韦德·安蒂列斯在撤离霍斯星后,立即登上了名为“自由号”的船。这意味着蒙·莫斯马和韦德·安蒂列斯在撤离星球时是在同一师。
在《帝国反击战》的某些视角中,韦德·安蒂列斯在撤离霍斯星后在哪里?
-在《帝国反击战》的某些视角中,韦德·安蒂列斯在撤离霍斯星后不久,被发现在“家园一号”上,这是阿克巴上将的指挥舰。
为什么韦德·安蒂列斯在漫画中出现在第七师而不是与蒙·莫斯马在第十一师?
-这可能是一个连续性错误,但根据头炮理论,韦德·安蒂列斯可能被分配了寻找其他叛军舰队的任务,这解释了为什么他在漫画中的舰队与书籍中的不同。
在漫画《星球大战2020》中,卢克·天行者和其他人是如何与第四师团聚的?
-在漫画《星球大战2020》中,卢克·天行者和其他人在寻找其他分散的叛军小组时,发现了第七师并参与了救援行动,随后与韦德·安蒂列斯团聚,并一起领导红色中队抵抗帝国。
在漫画中,蒙·莫斯马和阿克巴上将为何不在第四师和第七师一起逃离?
-在漫画的结尾,揭示了阿克巴和蒙·莫斯马实际上失踪了,他们不在第四师和第七师中,而是在“家园一号”上,属于第十一师,并且在星球奥巴达兰被帝国伏击。
韦德·安蒂列斯为何最终没有与蒙·莫斯马在同一个师?
-一个可能的解释是,韦德·安蒂列斯被指派去作为侦察员寻找其他叛军师,而蒙·莫斯马和其他叛军领导人则留在了第十一师。
为什么叛军会避免在不同师之间开启通信?
-叛军避免在不同师之间开启通信是因为他们发现帝国能够追踪他们的通信,一旦通信被截获,就会暴露他们的位置,增加被帝国发现和攻击的风险。
在叛军撤离过程中,帝国如何利用叛军的通信弱点?
-帝国通过黑客技术截获了叛军师之间的通信,从而得知了他们的位置,利用这个弱点,帝国能够对叛军进行有效的追踪和攻击。
在《星球大战》的故事中,叛军是如何重新集结的?
-在《星球大战》的故事中,叛军通过各种方式重新集结,包括使用老式的侦察方法寻找其他师,以及在不同的漫画和书籍中描述的救援和团聚行动。
为什么作者喜欢将所有事件都纳入一个整洁的时间线?
-作者喜欢将所有事件纳入一个整洁的时间线,因为这样可以提供额外的洞察力,澄清所需的信息,并且使故事更加连贯,便于读者理解和导航。
Outlines
🌌 ホスの秘密基地からの脱出計画
共和国復活同盟がホス星に秘密基地を作った時、帝国が発見した際の脱出計画も立てていました。反乱勢力はグループに分かれて脱出し、事前に決められた宇宙座標で合流し、その後、さらにいくつかの座標へジャンプして帝国の追跡を防ぐ予定でした。第4部隊のように各グループには呼称があり、デルタ3などの座標で合流しました。反乱勢力は第1部隊から少なくとも第11部隊まで番号が振られました。帝国は基地が完成されてから1か月で発見し、「帝国の逆襲」で脱出計画が描かれていますが、本書や漫画では、脱出後の集結が描かれています。特に「Lost Stars」や「From a Certain Point of View: The Empire Strikes Back」という本、そして2020年のスターウォーズ漫画では、脱出後の集結と統一が詳述されています。ルーク・スカイウォーカーやミレニアム・ファルコンのクルーが第4部隊と合流し、他の散らばった反乱勢力を探していました。第7部隊が帝国に襲撃され、ルークと第4部隊が救助に向かい、ウェッジ・アンチルズと再会し、共にレッド・スクワッドを率いて帝国を撃退しました。しかし、その後、モトhmaとアクバル将軍は第11部隊に所属しており、オバ・ダルタス星で帝国に奇襲されたと分かります。ウェッジ・アンチルズが第7部隊にいた理由は、帝国が通信を解読し、部隊間の連絡を遮断していたため、通信を避ける方法で他の部隊を探す必要がありました。
🛰️ ウェッジ・アンチルズの部隊転属について
ウェッジ・アンチルズが第7部隊にいた理由と、なぜモトhmaと同じ船にいたにもかかわらず第11部隊に属していなかったのかについて、説明を試みます。継続性エラーの一例ですが、物語を整理し、タイムラインに収まるように整理し、見解を提供します。ウェッジは第11部隊にいたが、他の反乱勢力部隊を見つけるために任務に派遣されました。第7部隊が帝国に襲撃され、ウェッジは通信を再確立できず、第11部隊とは接触を失いました。もしくは、モトhmaとアクバルが第7部隊を離れて他の反乱勢力部隊と接触しようとし、第11部隊に遭遇し、その後オバ・ダルタス星で帝国に奇襲されました。ウェッジが第7部隊にいたのは、星戦機で他の失われ反乱勢力を探していたからだと個人的に考えています。これは、アライアンス最高司令部を載せたクルーザーよりも星戦機を送ることのほうが合理的だと感じる理由からです。物語を整理し、連続性に沿って収まるようにするのが好きです。
Mindmap
Keywords
💡アリアンス
💡脱出計画
💡ホス星
💡帝国
💡レンデズボスポイント
💡ハイパースペース
💡第四師団
💡ルーク・スカイウォーカー
💡ウィッジ・アンチルーズ
💡アドミラル・アクバル
💡ホメオネ
Highlights
The Rebel Alliance had a secret base on the planet Hoth and an escape plan in case of discovery by the Empire.
Rebels were divided into groups to escape and then rendezvous at pre-designated coordinates in space.
The escape plan was executed after the Empire discovered the base on Hoth.
The movie 'Empire Strikes Back' depicted the escape plan, but not the full reunion of the scattered groups.
Books and comics like 'Lost Stars' and 'From a Certain Point of View' provide more details on the reunion of the Rebel groups.
Mon Mothma and Wedge Antilles were on the ship called Liberty after the evacuation from Hoth.
Wedge Antilles was seen on Admiral Akbar's Command Ship, the Home One, shortly after the evacuation.
The Empire had hacked into Rebel communications, intercepting transmissions between divisions.
The Rebels ceased contact between divisions to avoid detection and sought alternative ways to reunite.
The Star Wars 2020 comic run covers the reunification of the scattered Rebel groups after the escape from Bespin.
Luke Skywalker and the Millennium Falcon's crew found the seventh division under attack and helped them escape.
Mon Mothma and Admiral Akbar were revealed to be part of the 11th Division and were ambushed on the planet Ob Dallas.
Wedge Antilles was tasked with finding other Rebel divisions, which explains his presence in the seventh division.
Mon Mothma and Admiral Akbar's absence from the fourth and seventh divisions suggests they were attempting to link up with other divisions themselves.
The discrepancy in Wedge Antilles' division could be a continuity error, but headcanon explanations have been proposed to maintain a coherent timeline.
One headcanon explanation is that Wedge was acting as a scout to find other Rebel divisions, which is a practical approach given his role and skills.
Another headcanon explanation is that Mon Mothma and Admiral Akbar left the seventh division to find other fleets and were later ambushed.
The video discusses the importance of continuity and the enjoyment of fitting the Star Wars narrative into a coherent timeline.
Transcripts
when the alliance to restore the
Republic built their secret base on the
planet Hoth they also created an escape
plan should they ever be discovered by
the empire
all of the rebels would be divided into
groups and leave the planet and then
rendezvous at a pre-designated
coordinate in space they would all
arrive at the scattered Rendezvous
points and then jump to hyperspace to
several more coordinates to ensure that
they weren't followed or tracked then
they would all eventually meet up
together once again
for example one of these groups was
given the call sign fourth Division and
their initial Rendezvous point was
called Delta 3. the groups that the
rebels divided into were labeled the
first division all the way through to at
least the 11th division there may have
been more it didn't take long for the
Rebel Alliance to utilize this escape
plan because the Empire discovered the
rebel base on Hoth only a month after
its construction was finalized of course
we saw this Escape Plan take shape in
the movie Empire Strikes Back what we
didn't see was all of the scattered
Rebel groups meeting up at the
Rendezvous points instead you can read
about that in several Books and Comics
notably the Lost Stars book by Claudia
gray and in a few chapters of the from a
certain point of view Empire Strikes
Back book which is an anthology book
written from the perspective of several
different characters in the movie all
with different author others
Additionally the Star Wars 2020 comic
book run covers the reunification of the
scattered Rebel groups once the crew of
the Millennium Falcon escapes from
vespin
some interesting things to notice when
reading all of these are the locations
of mon mothma and wedge Antilles the
book Lost Stars places Mon mothma and
wedge Antilles on board the ship called
Liberty immediately following the
evacuation from Hoff this would mean
that Mon mothma and wedge Antilles were
in the same division when they evacuated
the planet
furthermore the book from a certain
point of view Empire Strikes Back places
wedge until he's on the ship home one
Admiral akbar's Command Ship also
shortly after the evacuation from Hoff
this would mean that for wedge to travel
between these two ships the liberty and
the home one they had to have been part
of the same division that escaped from
Hoff
so to summarize wedge Antilles Mon
mothma and Admiral Akbar were part of
the same division after they escaped the
reason that the rebels would be
restricted to their respective divisions
is because the Empire had hacked into
their Communications specifically the
Empire had discovered a way to intercept
Transmissions that the rebel divisions
sent to one another for example when the
fourth division attempted to contact the
eighth division after they'd each made
it to their respective Rendezvous points
the empire was able to pick up the
transmission and learn the location of
both divisions as a result the Empire
tracked and completely destroyed the
eighth division the rebels soon learned
about this and ceased contact with the
other Fleet divisions instead they
attempted to find each other in a
different way so as not to alert the
Empire this undertaking can be seen in
the Star Wars 2020 comic run
when Luke Skywalker and to the rest of
the Millennium Falcons crew reunited
with the fourth division they looked for
a way to find the other scattered Rebel
groups the first division that they
found after this was the seventh
division which was already under attack
from the Empire Luke and the rest of the
fourth division sprung into action to
save the seventh and when they did Luke
was reunited with wedge Antilles
together they LED red Squadron in
holding off the Empire so they could
escape this would seemingly answer the
question of which division wedge
Antilles monrothma and Admiral Akbar
were part of it would seem that they
were a part of the seventh division
however when the dust settled and the
fourth and seventh divisions flee to
safety it is revealed that Akbar and mon
mothma are not there and are actually
considered missing apparently mothma's
division has disappeared this is strange
because wedge was definitely on the same
ship as mon mothma during this
transitionary period for the rebel
alliance we find out later that Mon
mothma and Admiral Akbar are on board
the ship home one and were a part of the
11th Division and had been ambushed by
the Empire on the planet OB Dallas
Luke wedge and several other Pilots were
responsible for saving them and
reuniting them with the rest of the
Rebel Fleet
so why was wedge Antilles in the seventh
Division and not in the 11th division
with mon mothma when he was already seen
on the same ship as her in previous Star
Wars content
the boring answer to this question is
it's a continuity error but this channel
is in the business of headcanon and
continuity errors so that everything can
fit into a neat timeline a knot that
that's mandatory or anything I'd just
like to do that so let's head Canon an
explanation for how wedge Antilles got
separated from the 11th Division and
ended up in the seventh Division I think
a quick answer for this is he was given
an assignment to find other rebel Fleet
divisions the rebels in the 11th
division where wedge initially had been
and where Mon mothma and other members
of the Rebel High command had been as
well very likely discovered that the
Empire had found a way to trace their
Communications
having recently been promoted after Hoth
it wouldn't be surprising if they had
tasked wedge Antilles and the rest of
his recently reformed red Squadron to
find and contact other rebel divisions
the old-fashioned way by scouting for
them if this was the case wedge
eventually found the seventh division
but was unable to re-establish contact
between them and the 11th division
because they were then attacked by the
Empire this would explain why wedge was
not seen with the same Fleet in the
comics as he was in the books
basically because Mon mothma and the
other rebel leaders did not want to risk
opening Communications and revealing the
locations of them or anyone else they
sent wedge and red Squadron to fly
around in space and try to find the
other rebel divisions on their own
another possible answer to this
discrepancy is that Mal and mothma took
it upon herself to try to link up with
the other rebel divisions
she and Admiral Akbar left the seventh
division in the home one and tried to
find other rebel fleets at the
Rendezvous points themselves in this
case they found the 11th Division and
then were discovered by the Empire and
subsequently ambushed on the planet AB
Dallas this would also explain why wedge
Mon and Akbar were not in the same
division in the comic
those are my current head cannons for
this minor discrepancy the one that I
personally lean toward is wedge acting
as a scout to find other rebel divisions
because from what I feel is a
utilitarianist stance it makes more
sense to send starfighters to look for
other lost Rebel fleets rather than a
cruiser filled with Alliance High
command but that's how I'm headcanoning
I know it's not that big of an issue but
again as I've mentioned several times in
my other videos I enjoy fitting
everything into a neat timeline I like
it when the continuity lines up that
will do it for this video though
apologies if this was confusing I feel
like I said the word division way too
many times for this video to make sense
but that's all I have to talk about for
this one I hope you enjoyed it and I
hope to see you in the next video have a
good one
Browse More Related Video
ジョージアはロシアと欧州どちらに向かうのか 「スパイ法」を解説
“Inoue MUST SEE Tank” - Virgil Hunter REACTS to Naoya Inoue KO’ing Luis Nery & facing Gervonta Davis
Mary Evelyn Tucker 0203 A Communion Of Subjects, Not A Collection Of Objects
Mary Evelyn Tucker 0101 - To See The Universe Not Just As A Place, But As A Story
税金の闇を暴いてたら、政府から嫌がらせが始まりました。消されるかもしれません。
Hong Kong convicts 14 democracy activists in biggest national security case | BBC News
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)