猫一杯被全网封杀，这是整肃谣言还是杀鸡骇猴？｜秦朗｜小学生｜猫一杯｜网红｜摆拍｜造谣｜户晨风｜封杀｜王局拍案20240417

Summary

近日，杭州警方宣布破获了一起备受关注的案件，找到了名为秦朗的小学生。秦朗因一位名叫毛一北的网红在巴黎发现其寒假作业而成为全国热搜的对象。毛一北在视频中表示，她在巴黎的洗手间捡到了秦朗的作业，并主动完成了作业。事件迅速在网上引起热议，媒体和公众纷纷加入寻找秦朗的行列。随后，秦朗的“叔叔”出现，提供了关于秦朗的详细信息，但最终被警方揭露为虚构人物。警方进一步调查发现，整个事件是毛一北和另一名网红薛某共同策划的一场炒作。毛一北对此公开道歉，并承认了整个事件是她编造的。事件最终导致毛一北的社交媒体账号被封，其商业价值和影响力受到了严重影响。

Takeaways

• 🔍 杭州警方近日破获了一起备受关注的案件，找到了名为秦朗的小学生。
• 🤔 秦朗的名字在春节期间因为一份丢失在巴黎的寒假作业而在网络上广为流传。
• 📚 网红毛一北在巴黎捡到了这份作业，并在网上发布了帮助秦朗完成作业的视频。
• 👮 经过调查，警方发现整个事件是毛一北和另一人薛某策划的，秦朗这个人物并不存在。
• 🚫 毛一北和薛某因散布谣言受到了行政处罚，毛一北公开道歉。
• 💥 事件引起了广泛讨论，许多人质疑对毛一北的处罚是否过于严厉。
• 📉 毛一北的社交媒体账号和网店受到了影响，她的商业价值和声誉受损。
• 🤷‍♀️ 毛一北自称只是喜剧博主，制作的内容纯属娱乐，并非新闻报道。
• 📰 传统媒体在未经核实的情况下转发了毛一北的视频，对事件的扩散负有责任。
• 🇨🇳 事件中提到的民族主义情绪，如毛一北关于中国人重建巴黎圣母院的视频，虽然是假的，但广受欢迎。
• 🤔 讨论了社会对谣言的态度，以及在健康社会中谣言存在的必然性和处理谣言的正确方式。
• 👨‍✈️ 对于警方在处理此类事件中的角色和效率提出了质疑，尤其是与传统媒体的错误报道相比。

Q & A

杭州警方最近破解了一个重要案件，他们找到了谁？

杭州警方找到了秦朗。

秦朗是如何成为全国搜索的焦点的？

秦朗是一名小学生，他之所以成为全国搜索的焦点，是因为一位名叫毛一北的网红在巴黎发现了他的寒假作业，并在网上发布了相关视频，引发了大量关注和讨论。

毛一北在视频中做了什么，为何会引起如此大的关注？

毛一北在视频中声称她在巴黎的洗手间捡到了秦朗的寒假作业，并决定帮他完成作业。视频因其幽默和创意迅速走红，吸引了大量网友的关注。

秦朗的叔叔在事件中扮演了什么角色？

秦朗的叔叔最初声称与秦朗关系很好，并在直播中提供了关于秦朗的详细信息，但后来被警方揭露他其实是在蹭热度，虚构了秦朗叔叔的身份。

警方是如何介入这个事件的？

警方介入是因为这个事件在网络上造成了巨大的影响，并且揭露了整个事件是由毛一北和另一个名叫薛莫莫的人策划的，秦朗这个人物根本不存在。

毛一北在事件后面临了什么后果？

毛一北因为制造和传播虚假信息，被警方处以行政处罚，并且她在各大社交平台的账号被封禁，她的网店也被迫关闭。

为什么说毛一北的视频内容有创意瓶颈？

毛一北的视频内容需要精心策划和创意，如果没有好的点子，观众可能不会买账。而且，如果连续几次让粉丝失望，作为网红的生命周期可能会很短。

毛一北是如何吸引观众注意力的？

毛一北通过制作假内容的视频来吸引观众的注意力，例如她制作了一个关于巴黎圣母院由中国重建的假视频，迎合了中国网民的民族主义情绪。

为什么说传统媒体在这次事件中负有主要责任？

传统媒体在没有核实信息的情况下，就对毛一北的视频进行了大量转发和报道，这在一定程度上助长了虚假信息的传播，因此他们在这次事件中负有主要责任。

为什么说彻底消除谣言是不现实的？

谣言是人类社会的一部分，是人性的一部分。在一个健康的社会中，我们只能努力将谣言造成的伤害减少到可控的程度，而不是期望彻底消除谣言。

为什么说对毛一北的惩罚可能产生寒蝉效应？

对毛一北的惩罚可能会让人们不清楚界限在哪里，可能会导致商业价值一夜之间归零，给个人、公司和员工带来的不确定性和风险远大于谣言对社会的所谓伤害。

为什么说权力是谣言传播的关键因素？

在社会中，不是不允许传播谣言，而是只有那些有权力的人才被允许传播。官方媒体也会传播谣言，但他们很少受到惩罚，这说明了权力在谣言传播中的作用。

Outlines

00:00

🔍 发现秦朗的真实身份

秦朗在今年春节期间成为中国国内互联网上几乎最著名的人物，引发了全网的搜索。此后，有关秦朗可能与失踪的国务委员秦刚有关的谣言满天飞，但最终发现秦朗只是一名小学生。事件中涉及了名为毛依北的网红，她在巴黎意外发现并帮助完成了秦朗的寒假作业，引发了巨大的关注和讨论。事件逐渐扩大，媒体和公众纷纷介入，尝试查找秦朗的真实身份。

05:04

📹 真实与虚假：毛依北的故事

毛依北通过在巴黎帮助一名名为秦朗的小学生完成作业而走红。随着视频在网络上的广泛传播，各种媒体开始报道这一事件。然而，随着事件的发展，毛依北和另一名参与者被发现编造了整个故事，包括秦朗的存在。毛依北因此面临了行政处罚，并公开道歉，认识到自己的错误，并承担了相关后果，如社交平台账号被封禁和在线商店被关闭。

10:07

🌟 网红毛依北的崛起与挑战

毛依北是一位从国际学生转变为网红的年轻女性，她通过制作短视频迅速获得了大量粉丝和商业价值。她的视频涉及幽默和娱乐内容，尽管受到一些观众的喜爱，但也面临创意瓶颈和公众期望的压力。通过制造一些虚构内容，毛依北试图维持观众的关注，但这也导致了问题和争议。

15:10

📰 误导信息与媒体责任

传统媒体在未经核实的情况下传播了关于秦朗的信息，这一行为被批评为缺乏责任心。尽管毛依北制作并传播了虚假信息，主要的问题在于未进行信息验证的媒体机构。此外，还讨论了警方在处理类似情况时的角色和行动，指出在处理虚构内容时存在选择性执法的问题，这可能对短视频创作者产生不合理的影响。

20:10

🤔 社会对谣言的容忍度

在社会中，谣言和虚假信息的存在是不可避免的。本段讨论了毛依北事件引发的广泛关注，并分析了为何人们愿意相信这些信息。同时指出，严厉惩罚传播虚假信息的行为可能会对社会造成更大的冷却效应，而不是有效地减少谣言的传播。作者呼吁对谣言的处理应更具有灵活性和比例感，以减少不必要的社会损害。

Keywords

💡网络红人

网络红人指的是通过互联网平台获得广泛知名度的个人。在视频中，毛一北（Maoyibei）是一位网络红人，她通过在TikTok等平台上发布短视频而获得了约2000万的粉丝。她的内容主要以幽默搞笑为主，这与视频的主题紧密相关，因为视频讲述了她如何通过制作假视频来吸引观众的注意力。

💡假视频

假视频是指为了吸引观众而故意制造的虚假内容。在视频中，毛一北制作了一个关于巴黎圣母院由中国重建的假视频，这迎合了中国网民的民族主义情绪。假视频在视频中是一个关键概念，因为它涉及到信息真实性的问题，并且是引发公众讨论和警方介入的原因。

💡社会资源

社会资源指的是在社会中可以被利用以满足人们需求的各种资源。视频中提到，毛一北的假视频事件消耗了大量的社会资源，包括警方的调查和媒体的关注。这与视频的主题相关，因为它探讨了假视频对社会资源的影响和滥用。

💡传统媒体

传统媒体是指相对于互联网媒体而言，如电视、广播和报纸等更为传统的信息传播渠道。视频中提到，传统媒体在未经核实的情况下传播了关于秦朗（Qin Lang）的信息，这表明了它们在假新闻传播中的作用。这与视频的主题紧密相关，因为它讨论了媒体责任和信息验证的重要性。

💡法律责任

法律责任是指个人或组织在法律上应承担的义务或应负的责任。在视频中，毛一北因为制作和传播假视频而面临法律责任，警方对其进行了调查和处罚。这个概念与视频的主题相关，因为它涉及到个人行为与法律后果之间的关系。

💡民族主义情绪

民族主义情绪是指人们对自己国家的强烈忠诚和热爱，有时会导致对外部信息的盲目接受，尤其是那些迎合民族自豪感的信息。视频中提到，毛一北的假视频之所以能够广泛传播，部分原因是它迎合了中国网民的民族主义情绪。这个概念与视频的主题相关，因为它解释了为什么某些假信息能够迅速传播并被广泛接受。

💡谣言

谣言是指未经证实的信息，通常在人群中传播。在视频中，毛一北的假视频被视为谣言，因为它未经证实就广泛传播。这个概念与视频的主题相关，因为它讨论了谣言在社会中的作用以及对谣言的处理方式。

💡内容创作

内容创作是指创作者制作和分享各种形式的内容，如视频、文章、音乐等。在视频中，毛一北作为内容创作者，通过制作和发布短视频来吸引粉丝。这个概念与视频的主题相关，因为它探讨了内容创作者如何通过创造性的方式来吸引观众，即使这些方式可能涉及制作假内容。

💡商业价值

商业价值是指某物或某项活动在商业上的潜在盈利能力。在视频中，毛一北作为网络红人，她的内容具有巨大的商业价值，她的视频广告价格高达数十万元人民币。这个概念与视频的主题相关，因为它解释了为什么内容创作者可能会采取各种手段，包括制作假视频，来增加自己的知名度和商业价值。

💡信息核实

信息核实是指对信息的真实性进行检查和确认的过程。在视频中，传统媒体在未经核实的情况下传播了关于秦朗的信息，导致了假新闻的传播。这个概念与视频的主题相关，因为它强调了在信息传播过程中核实信息的重要性。

💡社会责任

社会责任是指个人或组织在行为上对社会福祉应承担的责任。在视频中，讨论了内容创作者和传统媒体在传播信息时应承担的社会责任，特别是在核实信息真实性方面的职责。这个概念与视频的主题相关，因为它涉及到社会对信息真实性的需求以及媒体和创作者在满足这一需求中的作用。

Highlights

杭州警方近日破获了一起重大案件，找到了秦朗。

秦朗在春节期间成为中国国内互联网上几乎最著名的人物。

媒体如阳光网、法制网都在寻找秦朗，引发了全国性的关注。

Transcripts

Ladies and gentlemen, the Hangzhou police have just cracked a major case a few days ago.

They have located Qin Lang. Who is this Qin Lang?

Qin Lang was almost the most famous person on China's domestic internet during this year's Spring Festival.

At that time, the whole internet was searching for Qin Lang, not just the self-media but also the major media.

Media like Yangguang Network, Legal Network were all searching.

They were saying, "Qin Lang, where are you? Please come out."

I was skeptical when I saw this news.

At that time, I wondered if this Qin Lang was Qin Gang's illegitimate child.

Everyone knows that Qin Gang has been missing for over half a year, a state councilor.

He just disappeared mysteriously, and nobody knew where he went, not even the police investigated.

But everyone was rumored that Qin Gang was not in the USA

Having an illegitimate child with a woman there, jeopardizing national security.

If Qin Gang could not be found, finding Qin Gang's child

would mean Qin Gang's case could also be half solved.

I thought maybe this Qin Lang is Qin Gang's child, but it turns out he's not.

Then who is Qin Lang? Qin Lang is just a primary school student.

But how did this primary school student become such a focal point in a nationwide search?

It's a bit of a long story, originally there was an internet celebrity in China called Maoyibei.

Maoyibei went to Paris during the Spring Festival.

Something strange happened, today I was actually on the streets of Paris

when a French person handed me winter vacation homework.

XX Primary School, Class 1 Grade 8, Qin Lang, Class 1 Grade 8, Qin Lang

Your winter vacation homework fell into the Paris restroom.

Don't blame me, it's not that I don't want to help you,

it was the French person who asked me to return it to you.

Let's take a look at the completion progress - not done at all.

Went next door and bought a pencil.

She saw that not a single word was written on the homework.

She must have thought, it's not easy for this primary student, traveling to France with his parents,

and still having to carry this homework notebook, and then there was no time to do it.

What to do? Quietly, she just threw the homework into the toilet.

Then Maoyibei is a young girl,

seeing this scene must have felt moved, a maternal instinct suddenly arose.

So she decided to buy a pen and do the homework for this primary student.

Use your imagination to complete the sentences, that simple.

Full marks for self-expression, add a few more.

This is all I can help you with, have a pleasant holiday.

After finishing, she said at the airport when she was returning home,

"I've brought the homework notebook back for you, I'll give it to you after I return to the country."

Now at Paris Charles de Gaulle, ready to fly back home, I've brought your winter vacation homework.

Finished in one evening, no need to thank.

After returning home, this video was uploaded online.

Maoyibei is now a contemporary internet celebrity.

She has around 20 million followers across various platforms online,

mainly on TikTok.

So when her video went online, it immediately sparked a huge discussion across the web.

Many people were saying, "Where exactly is this Qin Lang?"

This Maoyibei, she's brought your homework notebook back.

Following this, various media started re-sharing, and during this process, everyone was looking for who this Qin Lang is.

But at that time, the clues were too scarce,

because at that time Maoyibei only mentioned Qin Lang from Class 1 Grade 8.

Then quickly, a clue came on February 17 of this year; Qin Lang's uncle showed up.

Stop rushing me; I'll show you what's next when I wake up.

Qin Lang's uncle said he has a very good relationship with his nephew,

his mother seems to not be very strict with the child,

so as an uncle, he felt quite embarrassed,

so when he saw his nephew's homework book lost in Paris,

he felt particularly remorseful and specifically went to a bookstore to buy several new homework books for his nephew,

and these didn't require many questions to be answered or many words to be written, they could be done in a few minutes, too easy.

Following that, the next day he hosted a live stream online.

His uncle's appearance provided a very detailed piece of information.

He said his nephew Qin Lang attends Xichang Elementary School (misspoke)

His own IP is from Jiangsu, so think about it, that gets specific.

As a result, Xichang Elementary School in Jiangsu (misspoke) there were only two such schools

People quickly called these two Xichang Middle Schools to verify with the media

Qin Lang does not belong to our school

There are only four classes per grade, right?

Yes

Online it says he's in Class 8, so we don't have a Class 8, do we?

No, we don't

So Qin Lang was not found at Xichang Middle School in Jiangsu

Expanded the search nationwide, including Xichang Middle Schools in Luoyang, Henan, and Beihai, Guangxi

These two cities also have Xichang Middle Schools

These two Xichang Middle Schools were searched, but Qin Lang, the primary school student, was not found

So everyone was suspicious at that time

Just then, on February 19th, the police arrested Qin Lang's uncle

Saying that Qin Lang's uncle was spreading rumors

Qin Lang's uncle admitted on the same day, saying he was actually just riding the wave of popularity

It's not fake, I told you, it was just for clout

Click to report, yes, yes, yes, good brothers, click to report

He saw Maoyibei's video was viral online

Then, the topic of finding primary school student Qin Lang was very popular on all websites

He just wanted to ride the popularity wave, pretending to be Qin Lang's uncle

Honestly, nowadays on the domestic internet, as long as there is a hot topic

There will always be various people coming out to ride the wave

You see this everywhere on TikTok's short video platform now

Then, on the same day, a teacher of Qin Lang appeared, saying Qin Lang's homework was indeed lost

Then, Maoyibei also communicated with his teacher a bit

Saying, "I have already done the homework for him."

So on February 19th, Qin Lang's uncle was not arrested, right?

Following that day, Maoyibei also released a video

Everyone was watching the video of me picking up the winter vacation homework in Paris

First of all, I want to clarify that I really did not expect so many people to watch

It was written on the notebook, the school and class, he is not from Xichang Elementary School

I didn't say which school he was from, you just said it was Xichang Elementary School

Not Xichang Elementary School, what Xichang Elementary School

His school, can't say ah can't say this is someone's privacy can't say

Don't self-identify in the comments section, even if I can't say, I have been messaging back one by one

I have already contacted the other party's mother, so no need to look further

After communicating, the other party does not want to appear on camera, so we shouldn't disturb their life

So with this, we consider the matter satisfactorily resolved

Why does she emphasize that what she filmed is real

Because after this event, there was a bunch of debate online

Then some people said, "This Maoyibei, her video is fake."

Then at that time, some fans of Maoyibei immediately came out and said

What Maoyibei films is all real

And on February 19th, Red Star News even specifically interviewed

The MCN company that Maoyibei is associated with

That MCN company also specifically stated that what Maoyibei filmed is all real

There's nothing fake, it's all real

So then Maoyibei came out and said, what we filmed is all real

Found Qin Lang's mother and returned the homework notebook to him

She thought that with this, the matter was basically over

Unexpectedly, two months later, the Hangzhou police came out and said

The entire event was all orchestrated by Maoyibei

And someone named Xue Momo, the two of them planned it together

The video was entirely staged by themselves, Qin Lang doesn't exist at all

Then, due to the significant impact caused

Therefore, administrative penalties were imposed on Maoyibei and Xue Momo

On the same day, Maoyibei came out specifically to apologize to the netizens

Hello everyone, I am Maoyibei, I previously posted a video online

About a primary student, Qin Lang, losing his winter vacation homework in Paris

This entire incident was fabricated by me, I apologize to everyone here.

I deeply regret and apologize for this.

At the same time, all the public platforms where Maoyibei was active,

such as TikTok, Bilibili, and Xiaohongshu,

her accounts were all blown up, she enjoyed the same treatment as me.

At the same time, Maoyibei’s online store was also blown up.

Maoyibei also has a platform on YouTube, I see she already has 389,000 followers.

After this incident, they changed their name,

but her TikTok is still active.

The whole story of this event is just as described.

So when this story got out internationally, many people were baffled,

saying it was just a small matter, and Maoyibei was completely banned online for it.

Her online store was shut down, and the MCN company was dealt with, was that necessary?

So today, I’m here to share my views on this matter.

First, let’s introduce Maoyibei.

Maoyibei is a girl from Guangzhou, she studied in France.

Last year, because of the pandemic, she couldn’t go back, so she stayed in Guangzhou.

While stuck in Guangzhou, she started making short videos.

Everyone knows now is the era when anyone can be a short video blogger.

Maoyibei is quite pretty, and initially online, she mainly complained about France.

Talking about how there’s no air conditioning in the rooms in France.

At the time, many people found it very strange,

saying such a developed country and yet the rooms don’t have air conditioning.

Then she got a bit of fame.

And then she made a video that suddenly went viral,

where she was eating lettuce leaves, her actions looked very much like a guinea pig.

This video brought her millions of likes and millions of followers overnight.

Suddenly, she went from an ordinary international student

to an internet celebrity, think about it, millions of followers.

Then she started her own company,

and began working as a professional short video blogger.

Her growth was quite rapid.

I saw that her videos are mainly humorous,

all sorts of comedic content. To be honest, I watched her comedic videos,

and I didn’t find them very funny, her jokes are not that sophisticated.

They are basically the kind that try to make you laugh forcibly.

But such content is quite popular on the domestic internet.

So in about a year, she amassed about 10 million followers,

and together with other platforms, that’s about 20 to 30 million followers, a major internet celebrity.

The commercial interest and value of a major internet celebrity are immense.

Now, the advertising price for one of her videos is 400,000 RMB,

with smaller TikTok videos priced at 150,000, and about 100,000 on Xiaohongshu.

Think about that, the commercial value is enormous.

When I saw these prices, to be honest, I felt a bit envious,

think about us making YouTube shows,

every episode carefully crafted with scripts, and then comparing information,

actually, the ad revenue share for one episode is just about 10-20,000 RMB.

Think about it, they make a short video of one or two minutes,

a girl just from ad fees can get 450,000, over 400,000.

This truly makes my heart ache,

If I could be such a short video blogger, I wouldn’t want to be doing this tough job.

Such a labor-intensive and thankless job.

Everyone knows that short video creation has its bottlenecks,

like how do you keep producing content continuously?

Maoyibei has talked about this in other communications,

saying she doesn’t really have any bottleneck anxiety, just needs to keep thinking creatively.

Many people ask me, you update so frequently, don’t you have a creative bottleneck?

Don’t you feel anxious?

Whenever I can't think of content,

I share my previous videos and reflect on the mindset.

You would see, wow, this girl is so talented, how does she think of these?

I definitely want to create content similar to what she thought of.

When you're feeling down and find there are still videos by Maoyibei,

or videos by other funny bloggers, I can just open and watch.

She makes me feel like I can throw away all my unhappiness for today.

I think that's enough.

She positions herself quite accurately,

basically saying, I'm just here to make you laugh after work.

So, she actually doesn’t feel much of this so-called bottleneck anxiety.

But frankly, in my opinion, she still does.

Think about the current short video platforms,

what she does has strictly scripted content.

You can’t produce it without a script.

These scripts require very clever planning and ideas.

If you don't have good planning and ideas, no one will watch what you film.

Moreover, if you’ve reached a certain level of traffic and your audience becomes disappointed,

honestly, the lifespan of internet celebrities is quite short.

If you can’t continuously attract netizens and disappoint them several times in a row,

then slowly your status as an internet celebrity might not hold.

So Maoyibei’s ability to create hype or such content is actually quite strong.

Gradually, she started to attract the audience’s attention by making fake content videos.

One of the most famous fake videos she made was about

claiming that Notre Dame de Paris was rebuilt by the Chinese.

She said online, "Have you seen Notre Dame being repaired?

It’s because we Chinese went over to help them fix it, that's why it got done."

This catered to the nationalist sentiment of Chinese netizens,

touting the Chinese as construction giants who can build anything, not just bridges

but also help restore the heritage like Notre Dame left by their ancestors.

But later, when someone checked, there was no such thing at all.

No Chinese company was involved in any of the construction units of Notre Dame.

But the video she spread at that time made many people believe it was true.

So this time, she really overstepped the bounds.

She made it look particularly like a news report,

and especially egregious was that

when Red Star News went to verify this information, they denied it,

still claiming it was true.

So from my personal perspective,

I think Maoyibei making this kind of funny staged video without clarifying online

is indeed a bit problematic.

But if you look at her genre, if you watch her programs,

watching a few more videos, you’ll know she's just a comedy blogger.

She's purely a comedy blogger, and you wouldn't mistake her for a news agency.

So in my view, this incident with Maoyibei causing such a big reaction this time,

many people thought Qin Lang really existed and started looking for him,

the main reason is not because Maoyibei released this video,

but because those media that shared it did not verify the information at the time.

You should know our traditional media are also on short video platforms

and on social media with various accounts; they actually also suffer from traffic anxiety.

Because serious news can't compete with these comedic bloggers for traffic,

so sometimes these media also piggyback on the traffic of short video bloggers.

Seeing which topics by bloggers are high in traffic, they also try to ride on that.

So look at that Yangguang Network,

Who is Yangguang Network? It’s the official CCTV state broadcaster, with Shen Haixiong as the president.

And they shared this information at the time without any verification.

They were also looking for Qin Lang.

So the spread of this news turning this incident into a fabricated news story,

the main responsibility actually lies with those so-called traditional media,

not with the comedy blogger Maoyibei.

So if you're talking about who is the biggest culprit for misusing social resources,

it's not Maoyibei, but those traditional media outlets.

They failed to fulfill their duty of verification.

Even if this was real, could this be called news? Does this have anything to do with news?

One or two media outlets sharing it is one thing, but countless media sharing it?

Can this be called news? Is this journalism?

Is there no real news left to report? If there's no real news, they might as well be laid off early.

Don't waste the resources of the news media, right? Post something valuable.

To put it bluntly, just change the name of these media outlets.

If The New York Times reported a story

about an American kid losing his American winter homework in a Chinese restaurant,

what would you think? Would you think The New York Times is a major media outlet?

Would you think The New York Times is authoritative?

You would think it's just a tabloid.

The second point about this Maoyibei incident

is that she spread false information, but did she infringe on anyone’s rights?

Or if she did infringe, who should claim their rights?

Now the police have stepped in, they have detained Maoyibei for interrogation,

Maoyibei admitted, and then they penalized them.

In my view, if there are victims, it would just be Xichang Middle School.

But the problem is Xichang Middle School was not mentioned by Maoyibei.

It was mentioned by "Qin Lang's uncle", in quotes, Qin Lang’s uncle.

Qin Lang’s uncle is fake.

So Qin Lang's uncle might have actually infringed on some rights of Xichang Middle School.

Anyway, if Xichang Middle School feels its rights were violated,

the one who should claim rights should be Xichang Middle School.

We always talk about criminal law, including the police,

they should ideally play a more passive role in society.

So if the police step into such disputes,

using such a massive force over such matters,

everyone noticed, after the news was released, Hangzhou police almost set up a special team.

We also checked relevant records of elementary students matching Qin Lang's age who might have left the country.

From what we found, there was no matching record of Qin Lang, the elementary student, leaving the country.

This further strengthened our belief that the video involved internet fabrication.

They checked immigration records and investigated Xichang Middle Schools across the country.

Is that necessary? Too proactive.

If Xichang Middle School feels its rights were harmed, then let it sue Maoyibei.

If Maoyibei were sued for one or two million,

maybe then Maoyibei would think twice before doing such things.

If Maoyibei had to pay a fine of one or two million,

maybe then she would hesitate to repeat such actions.

The problem in China now is that issues like Maoyibei’s,

which should be resolved through civil remedies, find the civil channels not smooth and hard to navigate,

and then eventually the police come out and clarify the situation.

In the end, the individuals involved are punished, this is the Chinese approach to solving problems.

But this approach can be very harmful.

Firstly, I want to ask, is this approach really effective?

Can it truly prevent these short video bloggers

from making such staged videos? I don't think it can.

Why? Now, if you look at Bilibili, if you look at TikTok,

the use of scripts to stage tragic events, and all sorts of bizarre plots,

are plentiful in such videos.

And these videos do not declare themselves as staged or fictional.

Some even subtly suggest they are real, they are numerous.

If you applied the same standard,

then maybe 80% of the bloggers on Bilibili and TikTok would have to be arrested.

Have you achieved that? No, you haven’t, so it’s selective enforcement.

And selective enforcement, especially since such videos

have a huge market and people are willing to watch, they become popular and then

once you're popular, there's also a great commercial value.

In such a case, if you're not punishing everyone equally,

you'll never completely eradicate this phenomenon.

Although the police claim to be fighting internet rumors and rectifying online culture,

trying to set an example, in my view, it's unachievable. That's the second point.

Thirdly, in a healthy society, it's not a rumor-free society.

I believe rumors are part of society.

Rumors are inherent to human nature; the readiness to believe certain statements is the soil in which rumors thrive.

In any healthy society, it's nearly impossible to be free of rumors.

So why did this incident capture so many people's attention?

Isn't it analyzed that it's because of the current push to reduce burdens, involving children,

and her actions made it seem like the government's measures weren't being implemented?

Ultimately, it's when people are willing to believe certain information that rumors have the potential to spread.

Including the rumor Maoyibei spread that Notre Dame was rebuilt by the Chinese.

Why did it become a widely spread rumor?

Because many Chinese were willing to believe in the narrative of 'Amazing China'.

If one day someone said the White House's maintenance was done by the Chinese,

it would likely spread even wider, catering to a certain psychological need.

To expect to completely eliminate rumors is unrealistic.

In our society, we can only aim to reduce the harm caused by rumors to a manageable extent.

For instance, the so-called false rumors spread by Maoyibei, if we classify them as rumors,

their societal harm is quite minimal.

Is it necessary to deploy the police for such severe punishment?

At least in my view, it's completely unnecessary.

If the police were to penalize such behavior,

for these so-called unreal statements, it would only cause a chilling effect.

Because people don't know where the boundaries are; overnight, the commercial value could drop to zero.

All the effort, her company, her employees,

all their hard work could just vanish.

The uncertainty and the risk it brings are far greater

than the so-called harm a rumor could do to society.

And moreover, don't those official media spread rumors themselves?

Aren't their fake news broadcasts plentiful?

Were they punished? No.

But you harshly penalize a young girl, a private media creator,

for spreading such unverified information, is it just because she lacks power?

At the end of the day, isn't it because when you spread rumors, you have power?

The distinction here isn't about the rumor, it's about power.

If this logic is clearly understood,

everyone will realize that in such a society, it's not that you can't spread rumors,

it's that only those with power are allowed to spread them.

You don't believe me? Now, if the Hangzhou police could find Qin Gang for me,

if they could find out where he is, then I'd say they're capable. What's finding Qin Lang worth?

Alright, I'll end here today, thank you everyone.

If this kind of logic is seen through,

everyone will understand that in such a society, it's not that you aren't allowed to spread rumors,

it's that only those with power are allowed to spread them.

If you think the Hangzhou police can find Qin Gang,

and if they manage to find him, then I'll admit they're effective. What skill is there in finding Qin Lang?

Alright, I'll stop here today, thank you all.

That's all for today, thank you.

Class 1-8, Qin Lang, you left your winter homework in a Paris restroom.

Now at Charles de Gaulle Airport ready to return to China, winter homework.

Can this be called news? Is this related to journalism?

One or two media sharing it is one thing,

but countless media sharing it, can this be called news? Is this journalism?

We also checked for elementary students matching Qin Lang's age group

to see if any had left the country.

From what we found, there was no matching record

of Qin Lang, the elementary student, leaving the country.

What do you want to say? I want to ask if you think Xi is a dictator?

This person seriously violates live streaming standards.

This person seriously violates live streaming standards, I'll disconnect him immediately.

Is this person crazy? This person,

is he crazy? My goodness, this person,

this person is too dangerous, this person.

This person will definitely have someone looking for him, this person will definitely have someone looking for him.