BB KEET REFORMED VIEW OF SCRIPTURE

IRSA Stellenbosch
9 Jan 202420:17

Summary

TLDRThe video script delves into the Dutch Reformed Church's struggle with scriptural interpretation in the 21st century, highlighting a shift from viewing the Bible as infallible to questioning its factual nature. It discusses the impact of historical criticism and the rise of inclusive theologies, leading to acceptance of same-sex unions and a 'spacious house' approach to accommodate diverse beliefs. The script contrasts this with the traditional reformed view, advocating for a return to sola scriptura and the authority of scripture as the ultimate guide for Christian faith and practice.

Takeaways

  • πŸ“œ The Dutch Reformed Church in South Africa has historically believed in the infallibility of the Bible, but there has been a significant shift in the late 1990s towards a more critical and metaphorical interpretation of scripture.
  • πŸ—£οΈ Some ministers and commissions within the church have made statements suggesting a departure from traditional interpretations, such as viewing facts as subjective and the resurrection narratives as metaphorical.
  • 🌈 The church has also seen a move towards inclusivity, with the acceptance of same-sex unions and a recommendation to the government to scrap the traditional definition of marriage.
  • πŸ” The script discusses the influence of historical criticism and how it has been used to challenge traditional Christian beliefs, leading to a crisis of authority within the church.
  • πŸ‘₯ The paper contrasts the views of theologians like Yan Hayes and Vly Yonka, who opposed the biblical justification of apartheid, with those of Professor Yuri Laru and Ferdinand, who embraced historical criticism and its implications.
  • πŸ“š There is a noted concern about 'genitive theologies' such as feminist, postcolonial, liberationist, and Marxist theologies, which are seen as external influences manipulating the church's interpretation of scripture.
  • πŸ›οΈ The script highlights the struggle within the Dutch Reformed Church between maintaining traditional reformed principles and embracing a more progressive, inclusive approach.
  • 🌟 The paper suggests that the church's current direction is in contrast to the teachings of Professor Benny K, who advocated for a strict interpretation of scripture and rejected the biblical justification of apartheid.
  • πŸ“– The importance of 'sola scriptura' (scripture alone) is emphasized as the guiding principle for interpreting scripture, which stands in opposition to the more relativistic approaches that have gained traction.
  • ✝️ The script concludes with a call to uphold the authority and reliability of scripture, to interpret it within its original context, and to resist the pressures to conform to contemporary societal desires.

Q & A

  • What is the main theme of the paper titled 'Bat and the Reformed View of Scripture Rediscovered'?

    -The main theme of the paper is the struggle within Protestant churches, particularly the Dutch Reformed Church in South Africa, regarding the interpretation of scripture and the impact of historical criticism and other theological shifts on their beliefs and practices.

  • How did the misuse of the Bible for justifying apartheid affect the Dutch Reformed Church?

    -The misuse of the Bible for justifying apartheid led to a dramatic shift in the view of scripture within the Dutch Reformed Church, causing a crisis of faith and a struggle for identity, as well as a reevaluation of their historical stance on the infallibility of the Bible.

  • What significant changes occurred in the Dutch Reformed Church's view of scripture in the late 1990s?

    -In the late 1990s, the Dutch Reformed Church experienced a reversal in its view of scripture, moving away from the belief in the infallibility of the Bible towards a more metaphorical and mythological interpretation, as evidenced by statements from church ministers and commissions.

  • What are the key differences between the theological approaches of Yan Haynes and Professor Yuri Larus?

    -Yan Haynes was concerned about the disintegration of the unity of scripture and the undermining of reformed principles of interpretation, while Professor Yuri Larus and Ferdinand Deist popularized and applied 19th-century radical German historical criticism, which led to a more relativistic view of scripture.

  • How did the Dutch Reformed Church's stance on marriage evolve, as mentioned in the script?

    -The Dutch Reformed Church's stance on marriage evolved to the point where, in 2019, the General Senate approved same-sex unions, and in 2023, the General Secretary recommended to the government the scrapping of marriage between a man and a woman, based on the argument that it is based on binary gender notions.

  • What does the term 'sola scriptura' mean in the context of the Dutch Reformed Church's theological debates?

    -In the context of the Dutch Reformed Church's theological debates, 'sola scriptura' refers to the principle that the Bible alone is the final and complete authority for a Christian, emphasizing the primacy of scripture over human reason and tradition.

  • What role did historical criticism play in shaping the Dutch Reformed Church's views on scripture?

    -Historical criticism played a significant role in shaping the Dutch Reformed Church's views on scripture by introducing doubt about the divine origin and inspiration of scripture, leading to a questioning of the church's traditional interpretations and a move towards more liberal theological positions.

  • How did the teachings of Professor Benny K influence the Dutch Reformed Church's stance on apartheid and scripture?

    -Professor Benny K, through his teachings, influenced the Dutch Reformed Church by refuting the biblical justification of apartheid and advocating for a return to reformed principles of interpretation, emphasizing the authority and reliability of scripture as originating from God.

  • What are the key principles of scriptural interpretation outlined by Professor Benny K and others in the script?

    -The key principles of scriptural interpretation outlined include the authority and inspiration of scripture originating in God, the role of the Holy Spirit in interpretation, the final authority of scripture over human reason, the importance of the original meaning of the text, the unity of scripture, the necessity of interpreting scripture within its context and genre, and the use of clear texts to explain difficult ones.

  • What warning did Yan Haynes give regarding the impact of historical criticism and genitive theologies on the church?

    -Yan Haynes warned that accepting the so-called incontrovertible results of historical criticism would lead to a dangerous path, undermining the infallibility, clarity, and unity of scripture, and potentially leading the church to abandon the word of God.

Outlines

00:00

πŸ“œ The Crisis in Protestant Churches and the Shift in Biblical Interpretation

This paragraph introduces a crisis within Protestant churches, particularly in South Africa, where there's a struggle between traditional beliefs and a new, more liberal interpretation of the Bible. The Dutch Reformed Church, once staunch in its belief in the Bible as the infallible word of God, is undergoing a dramatic shift in its view of scripture. This change is evident in statements from church ministers and commissions that suggest a move away from historical and factual readings of the Bible towards metaphorical and mythological interpretations. The paragraph also touches on the church's grappling with issues like same-sex unions and the rejection of traditional views on marriage, indicating a broader movement towards inclusivity and diversity in beliefs.

05:01

πŸ” Historical Criticism and Its Impact on Theological Interpretations

The second paragraph delves into the effects of historical criticism on theological interpretations, particularly within the Dutch Reformed Church. It discusses the methodological features of historical criticism, which include the use of human reason as the sole measure of truth, denial of divine inspiration in scripture, and a continuous reevaluation of methodologies. The paragraph highlights the work of theologians and biblical scholars who have either embraced or rejected these critical approaches. It also discusses the influence of historical criticism on the church's stance on apartheid and other social issues, leading to a fragmentation in the church's interpretation of scripture and its application to modern challenges.

10:03

πŸ›οΈ The Legacy of Professor Benny K and Theological Resistance to Apartheid

This paragraph contrasts the theological streams within the Dutch Reformed Church, focusing on the legacy of Professor Benny K, who resisted the biblical justification of apartheid. It discusses how Benny K, along with other theologians, engaged with and refuted the radical aspects of historical criticism and other generative theologies that undermined the authority of scripture. The paragraph also draws a parallel between Benny K's theological stance and that of former Prime Minister Dr. DF Malan, who used Darwin's theory of evolution to justify apartheid. It emphasizes the importance of adhering to reformed principles of interpretation and the divine inspiration of scripture, as opposed to interpretations that serve political purposes.

15:03

🌟 The Principles of Scriptural Interpretation and the Relevance of Professor Benny K's Teachings

The fourth paragraph outlines the principles of scriptural interpretation as advocated by Professor Benny K, emphasizing the divine origin and authority of scripture. It discusses the role of the Holy Spirit in interpreting scripture, the importance of sola scriptura as the final authority, and the necessity of interpreting the original meaning of the text. The paragraph also highlights the unity within the diversity of scripture and the importance of context and genre in interpretation. It concludes with a call to uphold these principles in the face of contemporary challenges and a quote from 2 Timothy, urging ministers to preach the word and endure hardship in their service.

20:03

πŸ“’ The Call to Preach and Uphold the Word of God

The final paragraph is a direct call to action for ministers and theologians to preach the word of God with patience and careful instruction. It emphasizes the importance of being prepared to teach and correct, regardless of the season or societal trends. The paragraph warns of a future where people may turn away from sound doctrine in favor of myths that cater to their desires, urging the audience to maintain their commitment to the truth and the teachings of the Bible.

Mindmap

Keywords

πŸ’‘Facts

In the context of the video, 'facts' are presented as subjective constructs rather than objective truths. This challenges the traditional view of facts as indisputable realities. The speaker cites a statement from a Dutch Reformed Church minister suggesting that 'facts don't exist,' implying a shift towards a more interpretative understanding of reality. This challenges the historical and factual reading of religious texts and events, urging a metaphorical and mythological interpretation instead.

πŸ’‘Resurrection narratives

The 'resurrection narratives' refer to the stories of Jesus's resurrection in Christian theology. The video suggests that these should not be taken as historical facts but rather read metaphorically and mythologically. This approach reflects a move away from literalism in religious interpretation, which is a central theme in the video's discussion about the changing views on scripture within the Dutch Reformed Church.

πŸ’‘Metaphor

A 'metaphor' is a figure of speech that describes an object or action in a way that isn't literally true, but helps explain an idea or make a comparison. In the video, the use of metaphor is advocated for interpreting religious texts, suggesting that they should be understood symbolically rather than literally. This is part of a broader critique of literalism and a call for a more nuanced approach to scripture.

πŸ’‘Mythology

In the video, 'mythology' is used to describe the stories and beliefs that form part of a group's cultural or religious tradition. The speaker suggests that religious narratives should be read in a mythological way, emphasizing their symbolic and cultural significance over their historical accuracy. This aligns with the video's theme of reevaluating traditional interpretations of scripture.

πŸ’‘Dutch Reformed Church

The 'Dutch Reformed Church' is a significant denomination in South Africa with a complex history, particularly related to its role in supporting apartheid. The video discusses the church's historical belief in the infallibility of the Bible and the shifts in this view, particularly in the late 1990s and early 21st century. The church's evolution serves as a case study for the broader themes of changing theological perspectives and the impact of historical criticism.

πŸ’‘Apartheid

'Apartheid' was a system of institutionalized racial segregation and discrimination in South Africa that ended in the 1990s. The video discusses how the Bible was misused to justify apartheid, leading to a critical reevaluation of the church's use of scripture. This historical context is crucial for understanding the video's focus on the Dutch Reformed Church's struggle with its past and its theological identity.

πŸ’‘Historical criticism

Historical criticism is a method of biblical interpretation that seeks to understand the historical context and authorship of biblical texts. The video discusses the impact of historical criticism on the Dutch Reformed Church, particularly how it led to a disintegration of the unity of scripture and a questioning of the church's traditional views. This is a key concept in the video's exploration of the church's theological crisis.

πŸ’‘Sola scriptura

Sola scriptura is a principle of Protestant Christianity that asserts the Bible as the ultimate authority in matters of faith and practice. The video contrasts the traditional reformed principle of sola scriptura with the emerging views that challenge the Bible's authority and clarity. This principle is central to the video's argument about maintaining a reformed approach to scripture interpretation.

πŸ’‘Reformed principles

Reformed principles refer to the theological and interpretive guidelines that have historically guided the Dutch Reformed Church. The video discusses how these principles, including the infallibility and clarity of scripture, have been challenged by new theological movements and historical criticism. The reformed principles are a key point of contention in the video's narrative about the church's identity crisis.

πŸ’‘LGBTQ+ movement

The 'LGBTQ+ movement' advocates for the rights and acceptance of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, and other sexual and gender minorities. The video mentions the Dutch Reformed Church's embrace of the LGBTQ+ movement as part of a broader shift in theological views. This is used as an example of how the church's traditional stances are being reevaluated in light of contemporary social issues.

πŸ’‘Binary gender notions

The term 'binary gender notions' refers to the idea that there are only two genders, male and female. The video discusses how the Dutch Reformed Church has moved away from these traditional notions, as evidenced by its recommendation to the government to scrap the legal definition of marriage as being between a man and a woman. This reflects a broader theme in the video of challenging and redefining traditional beliefs.

Highlights

The Dutch Reformed Church in South Africa has undergone a significant shift in its view of scripture, moving away from the belief in the Bible as the infallible word of God.

Some ministers and commissions within the church have suggested that facts are subjective and that the resurrection narratives should be read metaphorically.

The church has been grappling with the misuse of the Bible to justify apartheid and the influence of critical theology in academia.

The Dutch Reformed Church has seen a dramatic change in its stance on scripture since the late 1990s, with some leaders questioning the historical and factual nature of biblical accounts.

The church has been challenged by the idea that no single belief system can claim to be the correct way of belief, leading to a more inclusive approach to worship.

The church's General Senate has approved same-sex unions, reflecting a departure from traditional Christian teachings on marriage.

The concept of a 'spacious house' has been introduced, suggesting that the church should accommodate a wide range of viewpoints, even those that are radically different.

The paper discusses the impact of historical criticism and its methodological features on the Dutch Reformed Church's interpretation of scripture.

Theologians like Professor Yuri laru have been influential in promoting a critical approach to scripture, which has been met with resistance by others within the church.

The paper highlights the work of Professor Yan Haynes and vly Yonka, who opposed the biblical justification of apartheid and warned against the dangers of historical criticism.

The influence of genitive theologies, including feminist, postcolonial, and Marxist theologies, has been significant in shaping the church's recent stance on various social issues.

The paper calls for a return to the principles of Sola Scriptura and the reformed interpretation of scripture, as exemplified by theologians like Professor Benny K.

The historical context of apartheid and the role of the Dutch Reformed Church in its justification is explored, with a focus on the theological debates of the time.

The paper concludes with a call to uphold the authority and reliability of scripture, emphasizing the need for the church to return to its reformed roots.

A quote from 2 Timothy 3:16-17 and 4:1-5 is used to emphasize the importance of scripture as God-breathed and useful for teaching and training in righteousness.

Transcripts

play00:00

facts don't exist facts are things you

play00:03

make up for yourself the resurrection

play00:06

narratives should not be understood

play00:08

historical and factual but read

play00:11

metaphorically and

play00:13

mythologically by worshiping together

play00:15

with people of other religions we don't

play00:18

give up the correct way of belief none

play00:21

of us can claim a correct way of

play00:25

belief how did we get here in

play00:28

2023

play00:30

the story behind the story needs to be

play00:34

told also for our International

play00:37

friends friends once again thank you for

play00:40

the

play00:41

privilege my paper title is bat and the

play00:45

reformed view of scripture

play00:48

rediscovered quote the Bible is the

play00:51

product of the fraud of people quote we

play00:56

don't believe in the Bible we believe in

play00:58

God

play01:00

in the second decade of the 21st century

play01:03

Protestant churches around the world are

play01:05

embroiled in a death

play01:07

struggle some are already firmly caught

play01:10

in a strangle hold and eliminated others

play01:12

are still fighting a good

play01:15

fight here in South Africa the struggle

play01:17

emerged dramatically in the wake of the

play01:19

misuse of the Bible for the

play01:22

justification of aparte and the Takeover

play01:25

of critical theology at state

play01:27

universities and mainstream churches

play01:31

the Dutch Reformed Church historically

play01:32

considered the largest reformed

play01:34

denomination in South Africa subscribed

play01:37

since its Inception to the belief that

play01:39

the Bible is the infallible word of God

play01:43

although this confession is still

play01:44

maintained on paper there was

play01:46

undoubtedly a dramatic change in the

play01:49

late 1990s a reversal in the view of

play01:52

scripture striking examples confirming

play01:55

the shift include such statements by

play01:58

Dutch Reformed Church ministers or Comm

play01:59

missions like this quote facts don't

play02:03

exist facts are things you make up for

play02:06

yourself quote the resurrection

play02:08

narratives should not be understood

play02:11

historical and factual but read

play02:13

metaphorically and

play02:15

mythologically quote from the Dutch

play02:17

reform General Senate documents serving

play02:20

tonight quote by worshiping together

play02:23

with people of other religions we don't

play02:26

give up the correct way of belief none

play02:28

of us can claim a correct way of belief

play02:33

even Jesus's teaching on marriage has

play02:35

been abandoned as 2019 General Senate

play02:38

approved same sex unions while the

play02:40

General Secretary of the Dutch Reformed

play02:43

Church in

play02:44

2023 officially recommended to

play02:47

government the scrapping of marriage

play02:49

between a man and a woman as the latter

play02:52

is based on quote binary gender

play02:56

Notions recently a general Senate

play02:59

Commission decided that quote the way

play03:01

complex issues in the church should be

play03:04

dealt with is to hold one another close

play03:07

even though we have different

play03:09

interpretations and opinions the new

play03:12

mantra propagated by

play03:14

moderators is the idea of a spacious

play03:17

house where radically irreconcilable

play03:19

viewpoints may be safely accommodated

play03:23

the inescapable realization took hold

play03:26

there's a impass in the Dutch Reformed

play03:28

Church a recent Moder to admit it an

play03:31

irrevocable fault line not just on

play03:34

secondary issues but on the most basic

play03:37

tenance of the

play03:40

Reformation everyone knows it or should

play03:44

know

play03:45

it but how did this all come

play03:49

about how did we get here in

play03:53

2023 the story behind the story needs to

play03:58

be told also for our International

play04:02

Friends got a few case studies to try

play04:05

and Shine the Light on how this

play04:10

occurred serious concerns on the One

play04:13

Hand by Yan Hayes vly Yonka two students

play04:17

who studied under Burk Hower in the

play04:19

bathing tradition senior leaders in the

play04:21

Dutch Reformed Church systematic

play04:23

theologians uh Pioneers uh who did

play04:27

remarkable work for reconciliation as

play04:30

well vly yuner Yan on the one hand and

play04:33

on the other hand two very well-known

play04:36

historical critical biblical Scholars

play04:38

also in the Dutch Reformed Church

play04:39

tradition the one Ferdinand died uh the

play04:43

other one Professor Yuri laru from

play04:47

ptor Professor Yuan Haynes who taught

play04:49

systematic theology at stalos and ptor

play04:52

was assassinated on the 5th of November

play04:55

1994 probably because of his leadership

play04:59

role against the biblical justification

play05:01

of

play05:02

apartate not long before that during his

play05:05

farewell address at the University of

play05:07

Pretoria he expressed his grave concern

play05:11

about the socalled incontrovertible

play05:15

results of historical criticism which

play05:18

included such conclusions as one the

play05:21

disintegration of the unity of scripture

play05:24

number two the settled thinking patterns

play05:27

of the Christian faith must be abandoned

play05:29

and thirdly the church can no longer

play05:32

express its views with

play05:35

authority as background usually

play05:38

historical criticism involved uh the

play05:41

following methodological features going

play05:43

back to rarus lesing Strauss bolman and

play05:46

so forth number one human reason is the

play05:48

sole measuring stick for truth and

play05:50

interpretation number two the divine

play05:52

origin wonders and inspiration of

play05:54

scripture is denied number three the

play05:56

distance between the text and today is

play06:00

problematized and fourthly continuous

play06:02

methodological adjustments all the time

play06:04

just four basic

play06:06

principles Yan addressed his concerns

play06:10

about this to his Old Testament

play06:12

colleague Professor Yuri laru who not

play06:15

only contemptuously rejected in public

play06:18

Dr Bayer's nudus theological protest

play06:21

against aparte but also once described

play06:24

the Bible as the product of the fraud of

play06:27

people professor L and ferand Di in

play06:31

particular after the death of Professor

play06:33

Beni K in 1974 popularized and applied

play06:37

19th century radical German historical

play06:40

criticism in a surprisingly effective

play06:43

way in South

play06:44

Africa where Benny K Yan Haynes and vly

play06:48

Yonka who by the way all rejected the

play06:51

biblical justification of a party took

play06:53

German critical scholarship very

play06:56

seriously but rejected its relativistic

play06:59

and unchristian implications laru and

play07:01

Di's eulogy for historical criticism

play07:05

undermined our reformed use of scripture

play07:08

and gradually infiltrated siners and

play07:11

eventually hijacked

play07:14

them the infallibility the clarity and

play07:18

the unity of scripture and tested

play07:20

reformed principles of interpretation

play07:23

were in

play07:25

tatters a new generation of pastors were

play07:28

pouring into to the church with this

play07:30

socalled more responsible use of

play07:34

scripture in harmony with our precious

play07:36

reformed Heritage as represented by

play07:39

among others Calvin baon K Yona Hayes

play07:43

had the courage to protest in response

play07:46

to laru and diced propaganda for the

play07:48

so-called incontrovertible results of

play07:50

historical criticism hes prophetically

play07:53

warned quote if accepting the so-called

play07:58

incontrovertible results of historical

play08:00

criticism lead one and obliges the

play08:03

Theologian to adopt such views it is in

play08:06

my judgment a dangerous path to follow

play08:11

not long after that he was

play08:13

assassinated but haes was not yet

play08:16

finished in his farewell address Haynes

play08:19

who along with yoner and K as we said

play08:21

stood up against the biblical

play08:23

justification of a part it warned

play08:25

further of the socalled genitive

play08:28

theology including feminist postcolonial

play08:31

liberationist and Marxist theologies H

play08:34

pointed out that these theologies

play08:37

including the biblical justification of

play08:39

apartate do not operate from the Bible

play08:43

itself but from outside and therefore

play08:46

also manipulate it for a particular

play08:49

political purpose such approaches has

play08:52

led the dut Reformed Church in recent

play08:54

times to embrace the lgbtq plus movement

play08:57

producing for some quote a dangerously

play09:01

kind Jesus that is certainly queer and

play09:04

not fixed that's from a ordained Dutch

play09:06

Reformed Church Professor down the road

play09:09

here Yan Haynes did not

play09:13

exaggerate in 1993 as did vona when he

play09:18

warned that the genitive theologies

play09:20

quote are nothing less than a radical

play09:24

overthrow of the rudder of the ship of

play09:28

the Christian

play09:31

Church in front of a hall packed with

play09:33

theologians and academics Yan Haynes

play09:36

concluded his professional and

play09:38

ecclesiastical career highlighting

play09:40

concerns about a dangerous New

play09:44

Direction threatening scripture and our

play09:47

confessions as well as influences from

play09:50

outside of the Bible that will

play09:53

manipulate the church to abandon the

play09:56

word of God

play09:59

this takes us to Prof Ben Kat a

play10:02

generation before haes and Yona Benny

play10:06

kit here who taught round the it's about

play10:08

a kilometer or so from

play10:10

here from 1920 to

play10:15

1959 and what I want to do is as I

play10:17

compared yanes vko with d and laru these

play10:22

two different theological streams I want

play10:24

to compare B yet briefly with a former

play10:29

prime minister of South Africa Dr DF

play10:32

malan against the background that I've

play10:36

just painted it is remarkable that

play10:38

Professor Benny KET who in stalos took a

play10:42

courageous stand against the biblical

play10:44

justification of apartate Thoroughly

play10:47

wrestled through the radicali of

play10:49

historical criticism in Europe and kept

play10:52

up to dat on a variety of genitive

play10:54

theologies including Marxism feminism

play10:57

refuting its unbiblical foundations and

play11:01

rejection of reformed principles of

play11:04

interpretation basically everything Yan

play11:08

and vly Yonka warned against Benny K

play11:11

already knew intimately and rejected a

play11:13

generation

play11:16

earlier this particular reform

play11:18

theological stream with roots going back

play11:20

to Haron baren in the Netherlands

play11:22

counters the general perception in South

play11:25

Africa and the world that basically the

play11:28

whole Dutch Reformed Church believe in

play11:31

the divine inspiration of scripture and

play11:33

with that lens constructed the

play11:36

theological truth of apartate through

play11:40

scripture over and over biblical

play11:43

Scholars like Professor Farin and who

play11:45

was also for a while in stalos painted

play11:48

the latter picture for us trying to

play11:51

argue that it was biblical Scholars who

play11:54

practiced historical criticism like

play11:56

himself who stood up against the UN

play11:59

biblical justification of a

play12:01

parate often the latter is used as

play12:04

argument for why historical criticism

play12:06

and genitive theologies must be embraced

play12:09

today which we know destroyed the

play12:13

authority of scripture and our precious

play12:16

reformed

play12:17

confessions friends so briefly be before

play12:20

I say a few things about Benny KET I

play12:22

want to say something about uh a

play12:25

theologian and a politician that I think

play12:28

the world probably has never never

play12:31

understood or

play12:33

appreciated unknown to a generation of

play12:35

African speaking Christians in South

play12:38

Africa is that Dr DF malan the architect

play12:41

of most aparte laws implemented between

play12:45

1948 and 1952 was a disciple of Charles

play12:51

Darwin and his theory of the survival of

play12:54

the fittest this theory was malan's

play12:57

foundation for a parted Milan was also a

play13:01

theological liberal Dutch Reformed

play13:04

Church Minister who practiced historical

play13:07

criticism in ut for his doctrate before

play13:10

he went into politics interestingly

play13:13

Benny Kia took over from DF Milan at a

play13:16

very distinguished Church KET when Milan

play13:20

went into politics K was there for a few

play13:22

years before he was called to become

play13:25

professor in stalos now this brings us

play13:27

to Benny K who interest in L took over

play13:29

as I said from DF Milan as Pastor from

play13:31

the famous re Church where the Andrew

play13:35

murus and family also were famous

play13:38

pastors G

play13:40

argued already in

play13:44

1949 in A Brave series of articles in

play13:47

the official Church newspaper that the

play13:50

biblical justification of apartate was

play13:52

false and

play13:55

unscriptural responding to a Dutch

play13:57

reform church Commission on the this

play13:59

matter KET said the following quote one

play14:02

feels like throwing your hands up in the

play14:04

air in frustration and say where does

play14:07

the commission come up with such an

play14:09

explanation and view of scripture I

play14:11

noticed that some of the commission

play14:13

members are my former students I can

play14:16

only solemnly declare here that they

play14:19

certainly did not learn such a view of

play14:21

scripture at the Seminary nor will they

play14:23

find it anywhere else in the Christian

play14:26

church 1949

play14:30

next quote if we want to understand the

play14:33

message of the scriptures we must turn

play14:36

directly to scripture without

play14:38

reservation and then in accordance with

play14:40

the whole thrust of the scriptures try

play14:42

to find out what is being said to us in

play14:45

a particular place so that what happens

play14:47

in practice can be brought into line

play14:50

with it and the scriptures are not bound

play14:52

to what happens in practice the

play14:55

authority of God's word demands this

play14:58

from us

play14:59

otherwise we will reduce his word to the

play15:03

demands of what we consider essential

play15:09

friends how did Professor Benny kit in

play15:12

1949 come to this interpretation of

play15:16

scripture through historical

play15:18

criticism through Marxism through

play15:22

feminism through the lgbtq plus

play15:26

Movement by saying that the Bible is the

play15:29

fraud of

play15:31

people by worshiping together with other

play15:35

religions by abandoning Jesus's teaching

play15:37

on

play15:39

marriage by saying we can never discover

play15:41

an eternal or universal truth as the

play15:44

Dutch reform church General sinate wants

play15:45

to say

play15:49

tonight on the

play15:52

contrary he got there through Sola

play15:55

scriptura and our Irreplaceable and

play15:59

tested reformed principles of

play16:01

interpreting scripture going back to

play16:04

barfun and celvin and the apostles and

play16:07

to Jesus Christ

play16:09

himself I think if Professor bit could

play16:12

have been here today and would have

play16:14

given us advice how do we interpret

play16:16

scripture and how he interpreted

play16:18

scripture in

play16:20

1949 and if you would have given us

play16:22

advice on what to do about marriage and

play16:24

about the uniqueness of Christ I think

play16:27

he would have given us these principles

play16:28

I'm just quickly going to mention them

play16:30

after being in k for a number of years

play16:33

nine number one The Authority the

play16:36

reliability and the inspiration of

play16:38

scripture have its origin in God himself

play16:42

number two it is guaranteed by the

play16:44

internal witness of the holy spirit in

play16:47

Believers number three it is not against

play16:50

human reason or evidence but due to sin

play16:54

Humanity can never correctly interpret

play16:57

scripture without the illum mination of

play16:59

the Holy Spirit number four scripture

play17:02

alone solar

play17:05

scriptura is the final and complete

play17:08

Authority for a Christian confronting

play17:11

and interpreting those who bow and

play17:13

submit under the authority of scripture

play17:16

number five the original meaning of the

play17:20

text and not how contemporary Society in

play17:24

1949 or 2023 want to reinterpret it is

play17:28

the essential and correct interpretation

play17:31

number six within the diversity of

play17:34

scripture there is also a remarkable

play17:37

Unity that the Holy Spirit provides

play17:39

running like a golden thread through all

play17:42

the books binding them together number

play17:45

seven scripture should always be

play17:48

compared and interpreted with scripture

play17:51

and human methods must never change its

play17:55

original purpose and intent number eight

play17:59

difficult texts and they are of course

play18:01

difficult texts must always be explained

play18:05

in light of what is clear and may never

play18:07

be used to abuse or obscure what is

play18:11

clear and the last one texts must always

play18:14

be interpreted in context and according

play18:17

to its unique genre and how a theme is

play18:21

understood throughout scripture friends

play18:23

can we finish can I quote from

play18:26

scripture I read Prof Bob

play18:29

pastoral uh commentary on the 1 and 2

play18:32

Timothy and I just want to quote Paul

play18:37

writing to one of his theological

play18:39

students a junior pastor and I think

play18:42

Prof Ben K and pro Yona uh and others

play18:45

would agree with us to conclude a paper

play18:48

uh on this topic with this piece of

play18:50

scripture 2 Timothy 3 verse 1617 and 4:1

play18:54

to5 all scripture is God breathed and is

play18:57

useful for teaching rebuking correcting

play19:00

and training in righteousness so that

play19:03

the servant of God may be thoroughly

play19:05

equipped for every good work in the

play19:08

presence of God and of Christ Jesus who

play19:12

will judge the living and the dead and

play19:14

in view of his appearing and his kingdom

play19:16

I give you this charge preach the

play19:20

word be prepared in season and out of

play19:23

season correct rebuke and encourage with

play19:26

great patience and careful

play19:30

instruction for the time will

play19:33

come when people will not put up with

play19:36

sound Doctrine instead to suo their own

play19:39

desires they will gather around them a

play19:41

great number of teachers to say what

play19:43

their itching ears want to hear they

play19:46

will turn their ears away from the truth

play19:49

and turn aside to

play19:52

myths but for you keep your head in all

play19:59

situations endure hardship do the work

play20:03

of a

play20:04

evangelist discharge all the

play20:07

duties of your

play20:09

ministry I thank

play20:16

you

Rate This
β˜…
β˜…
β˜…
β˜…
β˜…

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Related Tags
Biblical InterpretationReformed TheologyApartheid CritiqueSouth AfricaScripture DebateHistorical CriticismReligious DiversityTheological ShiftChurch StruggleFaith and Society