HISTORY OF IDEAS - Art

Summary

The script explores the evolving purpose of art throughout history, from its role in advertising religious and political ideologies to the modern concept of 'art for art's sake.' It discusses how art has been used to resonate emotionally with audiences, inspire contemplation, and serve as propaganda. The narrative challenges the modern reluctance to define art's purpose, advocating for its potential to enrich our lives by addressing loneliness, fostering hope, and questioning power structures, ultimately aiming to improve our daily existence.

Takeaways

• 🏛️ Art holds a high status in modern societies, with people visiting museums and art auctions setting record prices, yet there's a reluctance to clearly define art's purpose.
• 🕍 In early Christianity, art was used as a medium to make religious messages more resonant and emotionally appealing, akin to a form of advertising.
• 🗿 In 15th century Thailand, art served a clear purpose, inviting contemplation and inspiration, showing the role of art in supporting religious and philosophical truths.
• 🎨 In the 19th century, art was also used as a tool for political propaganda, as seen in Jacques-Louis David's painting of Napoleon crossing the Alps.
• 📜 The 'art for art's sake' movement, initiated by Théophile Gautier, argued for the independence of art from religious and political agendas, emphasizing its intrinsic value.
• 🚫 Marcel Duchamp's 'Fountain' challenged traditional notions of art, advocating for art that is enigmatic and provocative, separate from mainstream society.
• 🎼 Mark Rothko's abstract color field paintings represented a shift towards art that is about pure aesthetics, appealing to an elite but often puzzling to the general public.
• 🎭 The Venice Biennale showcased the global reach of art, curated by women for the first time, indicating a shift in the art world's power dynamics.
• 💸 Art has become a playground for the super-rich and a tourist destination, reflecting its dual status of reverence and ongoing questioning of its purpose.
• 🛠 Art has historically been tasked with glorifying religion or the state, but modern art sought to break away from these missions to find its own voice.
• 🌟 The script suggests that art should be embraced for its ability to help us cope with emotions, communicate our inner world, question power, and improve political systems, ultimately aiming to enhance our lives.

Q & A

What is the general status of art in modern societies?

Art holds a high status in modern societies, with people frequently visiting museums and art works often selling at record prices.

Why is there a reluctance to clearly define the purpose of art in the modern era?

The reluctance stems from the fact that art's purpose has historically been clear, but in the modern context, it has become more complex and open to interpretation.

What was the role of art in the early days of Christianity?

Art was used by early Christians to make their message more resonant, emotionally attractive, and popularly appealing, essentially serving as a form of advertising for their religious ideas.

How did Christian art evolve over time in Europe?

Christian art evolved from humble beginnings in catacombs to producing extraordinary cathedrals, paintings, and sculptures that celebrated and enhanced the prestige of its messages.

What is the purpose of the Buddha statues created in Southeast Asia?

The purpose of Buddha statues is to inspire viewers to become more like the Buddha, offering an invitation to calm and contemplation.

What was the significance of Jacques-Louis David's painting 'Napoleon crossing the Alps'?

The painting commemorated a significant moment in Napoleon's early military career and served as propaganda for his political cause.

What is the 'art for art's sake' doctrine proposed by Théophile Gautier?

The 'art for art's sake' doctrine argues that art should be free from the agendas of religions and governments and exist solely for its own sake, without trying to influence or represent anything.

What was Marcel Duchamp's stance on the purpose of art?

Duchamp believed that art should be enigmatic, mysteriously provocative, and silent, standing outside the mainstream and defending itself against confusion with advertising, mass media, and propaganda.

What is the significance of Mark Rothko's color field paintings?

Rothko's color field paintings are abstract and are considered by some to be the greatest works of the 20th century, appealing to an elite audience but often puzzling to the wider public.

How has the perception of art changed from being a tool for religious or political purposes to a modern concept?

Modern art is a result of a shift away from art serving religious or political agendas, with a focus on being a sophisticated tool that helps people cope with emotions and improve their lives.

What is the role of art in contemporary society according to the script?

In contemporary society, art is seen as a sophisticated tool that can help us cope with loneliness, fill us with hope, communicate our inner world, question power, and aim to improve political systems.

Outlines

00:00

🎨 The Role of Art in Society and Religion

This paragraph delves into the high status of art in modern societies, with people visiting museums and art pieces selling at record prices. However, it contrasts this with the contemporary reluctance to define the purpose of art. The script takes us back to 290 AD Rome, where early Christians used art to spread their message, making it emotionally appealing and resonant. Art served as a form of advertising for their beliefs, and for centuries, Christian art dominated Europe, creating cathedrals and other works to enhance the prestige of their message. The script also touches on the role of art in the East, such as in Thailand, where it was used to inspire contemplation and emulation of religious figures like Buddha.

05:01

🌐 Art as Propaganda and the 'Art for Art's Sake' Movement

The second paragraph explores the historical use of art as propaganda, exemplified by Jacques-Louis David's painting of Napoleon crossing the Alps, which glorifies Napoleon's military achievements. It then discusses the 19th-century movement led by Théophile Gautier, advocating 'art for art's sake,' suggesting that art should be free from religious and political agendas and exist purely for its own beauty. This idea influenced a new generation of romantic artists who opposed the notion that art should serve any purpose other than itself. The narrative moves to the 20th century with Marcel Duchamp's 'Fountain,' challenging traditional views of art and asserting the artist's role as an enigmatic creator outside the mainstream. The paragraph concludes with a look at the commercialization of art in the 20th century, particularly at the Venice Biennale, where art has become both a playground for the wealthy and a tourist attraction, while also questioning the purpose of modern art and suggesting it should be a tool for better living.

Keywords

💡Art

Art in the video is presented as a multifaceted concept with various roles throughout history. It is defined as a form of human expression that can serve different purposes, such as propaganda, advertisement, or a means of personal expression. The video discusses how art has been used to glorify religion, support political causes, and also as a form of 'art for art's sake', highlighting its evolution and the ongoing debate about its purpose.

💡Mystique

The term 'mystique' refers to a sense of mystery or awe that is often associated with art in modern society. It is related to the video's theme by illustrating the public's confusion and fascination with contemporary art, which can appear enigmatic and provoke a sense of wonder, as exemplified by the reactions to modern works in museums.

💡Christian Art

Christian Art is a specific genre that emerged from the early days of Christianity, as mentioned in the script with the depiction of Jesus healing a bleeding woman. It is used in the video to illustrate how art has historically been employed to propagate religious beliefs and make them more accessible and emotionally appealing to the masses.

💡Propaganda

Propaganda is a form of communication that is aimed at influencing the attitude of a community towards some cause or position. In the context of the video, it is used to describe how art has been used throughout history to promote political ideologies, as seen in Jacques-Louis David's painting of Napoleon crossing the Alps.

💡Art for Art's Sake

The concept of 'art for art's sake', or 'l'art pour l'art', is a philosophy introduced by Théophile Gautier, advocating that art should be created for its own beauty and value, rather than to serve any utilitarian purpose. This idea is central to the video's discussion on the evolution of art's role in society, emphasizing the romantic artists' rebellion against art serving religious or political masters.

💡Modern Art

Modern Art is a period of artistic development characterized by a departure from traditional forms and techniques. The video uses this term to discuss the shift in art's purpose, moving away from serving religious or state agendas to exploring more abstract and personal expressions, as seen in the works of Marcel Duchamp and Mark Rothko.

💡Contemporary Art

Contemporary Art refers to art produced in the present postmodern period, often characterized by its diversity and the use of new media. The video script mentions the viewer's puzzlement when faced with contemporary art, indicating a shift in public perception and the ongoing search for meaning in art.

💡Abstract Art

Abstract Art is a form of art that does not attempt to represent an accurate depiction of a visual reality but instead uses shapes, colors, forms, and gestural marks to achieve its effect. The video uses Mark Rothko's color field paintings as an example of abstract art that has a profound impact on viewers, despite its lack of a clear subject matter.

💡Venice Biennale

The Venice Biennale is an international contemporary art exhibition held every two years in Venice, Italy. The video script references this event to illustrate the current status of art as a playground for the super-rich and a destination for tourists, highlighting the commercial and social aspects of modern art.

💡Sophisticated Tool

In the video, art is described as a 'sophisticated tool' that has the potential to help us cope with complex emotions and societal issues. This term encapsulates the video's message that art should be more than just an object of aesthetic appreciation; it should serve practical purposes in our daily lives, such as providing hope or questioning power structures.

💡Leading Better Lives

The phrase 'leading better lives' is used in the video to suggest the highest purpose of art, which is to contribute positively to the quality of human life. It is tied to the video's theme by advocating for a more functional role of art, beyond mere decoration or investment, to improve our emotional and social well-being.

Highlights

Art holds a high status in modern societies, with people visiting museums and art works selling for record prices.

There is a reluctance in modern times to clearly define the purpose of art, unlike in most of history.

In 290 AD Rome, early Christians used art to resonate their message and gain followers, similar to advertising.

Christian art dominated Europe for a millennium, producing cathedrals and enhancing the prestige of its messages.

In the 15th century Thailand, Buddhist art served as an inspiration for contemplation and personal growth.

Art in both East and West has historically supported religious truths and made ideas more digestible.

Jacques-Louis David's 'Napoleon crossing the Alps' is an example of art as political propaganda.

Théophile Gautier's 'art for art's sake' movement argued for art's independence from religious and political agendas.

Marcel Duchamp's 'Fountain' challenged traditional notions of what art should be, promoting enigmatic and provocative works.

Mark Rothko's abstract color field paintings became highly valued, representing an obscure direction in 20th-century art.

The Venice Biennale in 2005 showcased art as a playground for the super-rich and a destination for tourists.

Art's purpose has historically been to glorify religion or speak well of the state, but modern art diverged from these agendas.

Art should overcome its hesitation to state its purpose and be recognized as a sophisticated tool for various human needs.

Art can help us cope with loneliness, fill us with hope, communicate our inner world, question power, and improve political systems.

The highest honor we can give to art is to use it as a tool to lead better lives.

The transcript also promotes The School of Life's shop for thoughtful books, games, and stationery.

Transcripts

Art has a very high status in modern societies:

People flock to museums

and art works fetch record prices.

But our age is also oddly reluctant to say in clear terms what art might actually be for.

An odd mystique surrounds it, epitomized by the puzzlement many of us feel

as we look at yet another odd looking, modern work of art in a contemporary museum.

We're often left quietly and politely wondering what is it all meant to be about.

For most of history, this kind of question didn't arise, because it was abundantly clear what art was for.

The question mark over the purpose of art is really a modern one, so let's go back in time

and find out about a wider range of options that we might be able to draw on fruitfully today.

Rome, 290 AD

Deep below the imperial Roman city, the faithful secretly gather in catacombs,

or burial chambers, to celebrate new religious figure, Jesus Christ.

Christianity, though still in its infancy and ruthlessly persecuted by the Roman authorities, is rapidly gaining ground.

Like so many religions before it and since, Christianity has become involved with the making of art.

Here, an unnamed and not especially talented artists represents Jesus healing of a bleeding woman,

an incident recorded in the New Testament.

Like all religions, Christianity is using art for a clear and understandable purpose:

to make its message more resonant, emotionally attractive, and popularly appealing.

Art is like a kind of advertising for its ideas.

Soon Christian artists are going to dominate Europe.

For almost a thousand years almost all art produced in Europe will simply be Christian art.

From humble beginnings in a subterranean prayer room,

Christian art will go on to produce extraordinary cathedrals, paintings

sculptures and celebrating and enhancing the prestige of its messages.

Thailand, 15th century

An unknown craftsman finishes a statue of the Buddha.

One of many hundreds of thousands of such statues produced over the

centuries in Southeast Asia.

The purpose of such art is extremely clear:

You're meant to look at the Buddha and take inspiration, becoming a little more as he is.

The sculpture is an invitation to calm and contemplation.

In the East as in the West arts function is evident:

to support the truths set down by religions,

to make ideas more easily digestible.

Paris, January 1801

The French artist Jacques-Louis David finishes "Napoleon crossing the Alps".

It commemorates a moment when a couple of years before, Napoleon still in his

twenties launched a lightning raid on the North Italian states, winning a series of astonishing victories.

In the picture, Napoleon masters a white warhorse

though he actually cross the mountains on a more serviceable mule.

Here, art is doing something it has done throughout history as well:

acting as propaganda for a political cause.

Napoleon is looking back to the example of Louis XIV of France who

did a lot of propagandizing with art.

It was a habit he got into throughout his rule.

Paris, 1833

The poet, novelist and critique Théophile Gautier publishes an essay about art,

which argues that art must free itself from the poisonous agendas of religions and governments.

The point of good art is always to be just for its own sake

as he put it in French, "l'art pour l'art", art for art's sake.

This doctrine of art for art's sake becomes the motto of the new generation of romantic artists

who set themselves against the old ideal that art should serve religion or powerful rulers or nations.

Nonsense, says Gautier, true art must serve nothing at all.

it is an end in itself and doesn't try to change or do or speak about anything.

Artists set themselves apart from the bourgeois commercial society growing up all around,

which is always trying to sell people things.

Art should try to inhabit a loftier, more abstract realm.

New York, 1917

The artist Marcel Duchamp prepares to exhibit his latest work at a show by the Society of Independent Artists.

It is surprisingly a urinal titled simply Fountain.

Duchamp is a rebellion against many notions of what art is,

that it should be easy to understand, that it should make sense, that it should promote something.

The true artist, argues Duchamp must defend himself against any confusion

with advertising, mass media, government propaganda or religious indoctrination,

that true purpose of the artist is to stand outside the mainstream and create

works that are enigmatic, mysteriously provocative and rather silent.

New York, 1949

A russian émigré artist, Marcus Ravkovic who has renamed himself Mark Rothko to escape anti-semitism

exhibits a new range of works at the Betty Parsons gallery in Manhattan.

They are a revelation, in that they seem not to be about anything.

They are about pure color fields and are as abstract as music.

For some, they are the greatest works of the 20th century and soon fetch enormous prices.

The Museum of Modern Art acquires a major set of Rothko's as do other national museums around the world.

Rothko becomes representative of the more obscure direction of 20th century art,

highly appealing to an elite who will often pay enormous incomprehensible prices for works

but puzzling for the wider public.

Venice, June 2005

The world's most prestigious art fair, The Venice Biennale opens at the newly restored spaces of the Arsenale.

It has been curated for the first time by two women, María de Corral and Rosa Martinez.

41 artist's are shown from all over the world.

The nearby Marco Polo airport is filled with the private jets of the world's billionaires,

many of whom profess to love art.

Elaborate cocktail parties are held late into the night.

Art has become a playground for the super rich

as well as an obligatory tourist destination for weary travelers.

Art is both hugely revered and yet somehow still in question.

For most of its history art has been saddled with a mission:

to glorify religion or to speak well of the state.

Modern art was the result of a swerve away from these agendas for extremely understandable reasons.

Yet if art is to regain its true centerality

it should overcome it hesitation about stating what it's really for and is trying to do.

It is really and has always been a sophisticated tool,

a tool that can help us to cope with things like loneliness,

that can fill us with hope,

that can help us to communicate our inner world,

that questions power and aims to improve political systems.

It is never an insult to ask art to do things for us,

to be a practical part of our daily lives.

We honor art most when we give it the highest task of all:

to help us to lead better lives.

If you like our films take a look at our shop.

theschooloflife.com/shop

You'll find lots of thoughtful books, games, stationery and more.