General Provisions - Obligations (Part 1)

Glen Ramos
24 Jan 202129:09

Summary

TLDRThis video script delves into the fundamentals of the law on obligations and contracts, focusing on the general provisions of obligations as outlined in the Civil Code of the Philippines. It explains the concept of obligation as a juridical necessity to perform certain actions, distinguishing between 'real' and 'personal' obligations. The script further breaks down the four essential elements of an obligation: the active and passive subjects, precision, and efficient cause. Through examples, it illustrates how these elements operate in unilateral and bilateral obligations, highlighting the difference between civil obligations enforceable by law and natural obligations based on moral principles.

Takeaways

  • πŸ“š The topic of the script is the general provisions of obligations within the context of the law on obligations and contracts.
  • πŸ“– The law on obligations and contracts is a set of rules that govern the nature and sources of obligations and rights, as well as duties arising from agreements and contracts.
  • 🌏 The source of the law on obligations and contracts in the Philippines is the Civil Code of the Philippines, specifically Republic Act No. 386.
  • πŸ“† The Civil Code of the Philippines is rooted in the Spanish Civil Code and took effect in the country on December 7, 18.
  • πŸ” The definition of obligation is found in Article 1156 of the New Civil Code of the Philippines, which describes it as a juridical necessity to give, to do, or not to do something.
  • 🀝 Juridical necessity implies that a court can be asked to order the performance of an obligation if the debtor refuses to perform it.
  • πŸ”‘ There are two types of obligations: real obligation (to give) and personal obligation (to do or not to do).
  • πŸ” The four essential elements of an obligation are the active subject (creditor), passive subject (debtor), precision (object or subject matter of the obligation), and efficient cause (the legal tie that binds parties to an obligation).
  • πŸ“ An example provided in the script illustrates how to determine the passive and active subjects, precision, and efficient cause in a contract of loan.
  • πŸ”„ The script differentiates between unilateral and bilateral obligations, where unilateral obligations require performance by only one party, while bilateral obligations require performance by both parties.
  • πŸ› The Civil Code of the Philippines enforces civil obligations, which are enforceable by court action, as opposed to natural obligations, which are based on natural law and not enforceable by the court.

Q & A

  • What is the main topic of the video script?

    -The main topic of the video script is the general provisions of obligations and contracts, specifically focusing on the law on obligations and contracts as outlined in the Civil Code of the Philippines.

  • What is the source of the law on obligations and contracts in the Philippines?

    -The source of the law on obligations and contracts in the Philippines is the Civil Code of the Philippines, also known as Republic Act No. 386, which is based on the Spanish Civil Code that took effect in the Philippines on December 7, 1880.

  • According to Article 1156 of the New Civil Code of the Philippines, what is an obligation?

    -According to Article 1156 of the New Civil Code of the Philippines, an obligation is a juridical necessity to give, to do, or not to do something, which implies that the court may be asked to order the performance of an obligation if the debtor refuses to perform it.

  • What are the different types of obligations mentioned in the script?

    -The script mentions real obligation (to give) and personal obligation (to do or not to do). Personal obligation is further divided into positive personal obligation (to do) and negative personal obligation (not to do).

  • What are the four requisites or essential elements of an obligation?

    -The four requisites or essential elements of an obligation are: 1) Active subject or creditor or obligee, 2) Passive subject or debtor or obligor, 3) Precision, and 4) Efficient cause.

  • What is the role of the active subject in an obligation?

    -The active subject, also known as the creditor or obligee, is the party who has the right to demand the performance of the obligation from the debtor.

  • What is precision in the context of obligations?

    -Precision refers to the object or subject matter of the obligation. It is not the thing itself but rather the conduct of giving, doing, or not doing something.

  • What is the efficient cause in obligations and what are its possible sources?

    -The efficient cause is the legal or juridical tie that binds the parties to an obligation. It may be any of the five sources of obligation: law, contracts, quasi-contracts, acts or omissions punishable by law, or quasi-delicts.

  • Can you provide an example from the script that illustrates a unilateral obligation?

    -An example of a unilateral obligation from the script is when 'D' is obliged to give 'C' ten thousand pesos with interest at 12% per annum on December 31, 2021, pursuant to a contract of loan.

  • How is a bilateral obligation different from a unilateral obligation?

    -A bilateral obligation involves both parties performing particular conduct, whereas a unilateral obligation requires only one party to perform a particular conduct. In the script, an example of a bilateral obligation is when 'D' is obliged to transport 'C's goods and 'C' is obliged to pay transport costs under a contract of carriage.

  • What is the difference between civil obligation and natural obligation as per the script?

    -A civil obligation is enforceable by court action and is based on positive law, as defined in Article 1156 of the New Civil Code of the Philippines. A natural obligation, on the other hand, is based on natural law and is not enforceable by court action.

Outlines

00:00

πŸ“œ Introduction to Obligations and Contracts Law

The video script begins with an introduction to the law on obligations and contracts, which governs the nature and sources of obligations, rights, and duties arising from agreements. It highlights the Civil Code of the Philippines, specifically Republic Act No. 386, as the primary source of this law, which is based on the Spanish Civil Code. The script then delves into defining 'obligation' according to Article 1156 of the new Civil Code, explaining it as a juridical necessity that can be enforced by courts if a debtor refuses to perform it.

05:14

πŸ“ The Essence of Obligations: Juridical Necessity

This paragraph further explains the concept of juridical necessity, emphasizing the court's role in enforcing obligations. It distinguishes between 'real obligation' (to give) and 'personal obligation' (to do or not to do), providing definitions and examples to clarify these types of obligations. The paragraph also discusses the importance of the parties involved, such as the active subject (creditor or obligee) and the passive subject (debtor or obligor), in the context of obligations.

10:14

πŸ” The Requisites of Obligation

The script outlines the four essential elements or requisites of an obligation: the active subject, passive subject, precision, and efficient cause. It describes the roles of the active and passive subjects in demanding and performing obligations, respectively. Precision is defined as the object or subject matter of the obligation, focusing on the conduct rather than the thing itself. The efficient cause is identified as the legal tie binding the parties, which can stem from various sources such as law, contracts, quasi-contracts, acts or omissions punishable by law, or quasi-delict.

15:17

πŸ“ Examples of Obligations and Their Elements

The paragraph provides examples to illustrate the application of the requisites of obligation. It uses a loan contract scenario to identify the passive subject (the debtor), active subject (the creditor), precision (the act of giving money with interest), and efficient cause (the contract itself). The explanation helps to clarify how each element contributes to the formation and understanding of an obligation.

20:20

🚒 Contract of Carriage: A Bilateral Obligation Example

This paragraph presents a contract of carriage as an example of a bilateral obligation, where both parties have specific duties to perform. It distinguishes between the transport of goods and the payment of transport costs, identifying the active and passive subjects, precision, and efficient cause for each. The efficient cause in this case is the contract of carriage, which binds both parties to fulfill their respective obligations.

25:24

πŸ›οΈ Civil vs. Natural Obligations

The final paragraph discusses the distinction between civil and natural obligations. Civil obligations, which are enforceable by court action, are based on positive law, while natural obligations, grounded in natural law, are not enforceable by courts. The script emphasizes that the obligation defined in Article 1156 of the new Civil Code of the Philippines is a civil obligation, highlighting the importance of legal enforceability in the context of obligations.

Mindmap

Keywords

πŸ’‘Law on Obligations and Contracts

The 'Law on Obligations and Contracts' refers to the legal framework that governs the nature and sources of obligations and rights, as well as duties arising from agreements and contracts. It is the main theme of the video, as it sets the stage for discussing the specifics of obligations within the Philippine legal context. The script mentions that this body of law is derived from the Civil Code of the Philippines, specifically Republic Act No. 386.

πŸ’‘Civil Code of the Philippines

The 'Civil Code of the Philippines' is the legal document that provides the rules and principles governing the relations between persons and property. It is mentioned as the source of the law on obligations and contracts in the Philippines, highlighting its foundational role in shaping obligations and contracts within the country's legal system.

πŸ’‘Obligations

In the context of the video, 'Obligations' are defined as juridical necessities to give, do, or not to do something. They are central to the video's theme, as they represent the duties and responsibilities that parties to a contract must fulfill. The script delves into the nature of obligations, distinguishing between 'real obligations' and 'personal obligations'.

πŸ’‘Juridical Necessity

'Juridical Necessity' is a term used to describe the enforceability of an obligation by law. If a debtor refuses to perform an obligation, the court may be asked to order the performance. This concept is integral to understanding how obligations are legally binding and can be pursued through legal channels, as illustrated in the script's discussion of Article 1156.

πŸ’‘Active Subject

The 'Active Subject,' also known as the 'Creditor' or 'Obligee,' is the party who has the right to demand the performance of an obligation. This concept is crucial in the script as it identifies the person with the authority to seek fulfillment of the obligations stipulated in a contract.

πŸ’‘Passive Subject

The 'Passive Subject,' also referred to as the 'Debtor' or 'Obligor,' is the party obliged to perform the obligation. This term is key to understanding who bears the responsibility to act or refrain from acting as per the terms of a contract, as discussed in the script.

πŸ’‘Precision

'Precision' in the script refers to the object or subject matter of the obligation. It is not the thing itself but rather the conduct of giving, doing, or not doing something. This concept is vital for defining the specific actions or inactions that constitute the fulfillment of an obligation.

πŸ’‘Efficient Cause

The 'Efficient Cause' is the legal or juridical tie that binds the parties to an obligation. It can be any of the five sources of obligation, such as contracts, quasi-contracts, acts or omissions punishable by law, or quasi-delicts. This term is central to the script's explanation of what constitutes the basis for an obligation.

πŸ’‘Requisites of Obligation

The 'Requisites of Obligation' are the essential elements that must be present for an obligation to exist. The script outlines four requisites: the active subject, passive subject, precision, and efficient cause. Understanding these requisites is fundamental to grasping the conditions under which obligations are recognized and enforced by law.

πŸ’‘Bilateral Obligation

A 'Bilateral Obligation' is an agreement where both parties are required to perform specific conduct. The script uses the example of a contract of carriage to illustrate this concept, where one party is obliged to transport goods, and the other is obliged to pay for the service, demonstrating mutual responsibilities.

πŸ’‘Civil Obligation

'Civil Obligation' is an enforceable obligation based on positive law, as opposed to 'Natural Obligation,' which is based on natural law and not enforceable by court action. The script distinguishes between the two, emphasizing that civil obligations, as defined in Article 1156 of the New Civil Code of the Philippines, are subject to legal enforcement.

Highlights

Introduction to the law on obligations and contracts, which governs the nature and sources of obligations and rights, and duties arising from agreements and contracts.

The source of the law on obligations and contracts is the Civil Code of the Philippines, Republic Act No. 386, based on the Spanish Civil Code.

Definition of obligation as a juridical necessity to give, to do, or not to do, as stated in Article 1156 of the New Civil Code of the Philippines.

Explanation of 'juridical necessity' meaning the court may order the performance of an obligation if the debtor refuses to perform it.

Differentiation between real obligation (to give) and personal obligation (to do or not to do).

The four requisites of obligation: active subject, passive subject, precision, and efficient cause.

Active subject or creditor is the party who has the right to demand performance of the obligation.

Passive subject or debtor is the party obliged to perform the obligation.

Precision is the object or subject matter of the obligation, focusing on the conduct rather than the thing itself.

Efficient cause is the juridical tie binding parties to an obligation, which may come from various sources like law, contracts, etc.

Example provided to illustrate the determination of passive subject, active subject, precision, and efficient cause in a loan contract.

Unilateral obligation explained, where only one party is required to perform a particular conduct.

Bilateral obligation differentiated from unilateral, where both parties are required to perform particular conducts.

Civil obligation is enforceable by court action, unlike natural obligation which is based on natural law and not enforceable by courts.

The importance of understanding the difference between civil and natural obligations in the context of juridical necessity.

Article 1156 of the New Civil Code of the Philippines emphasized as defining a civil obligation, not a natural one.

Transcripts

play00:00

hello and good day

play00:04

for today our topic is general

play00:07

provisions

play00:08

of obligations

play00:12

but before i discuss the general

play00:14

provisions of obligations

play00:16

let me give you a brief introduction

play00:20

to the law on obligations and

play00:23

contracts the law

play00:26

on obligations and contracts is the body

play00:30

of rules

play00:31

which deals with the nature and sources

play00:34

of obligations and rights

play00:38

and duties arising from agreements

play00:42

and contracts

play00:45

in other words in law on obligations and

play00:49

constructs

play00:50

we will study relevant articles

play00:54

of law governing the obligations

play00:59

and contracts especially

play01:03

the nature and sources of obligations

play01:06

and the right and duties of

play01:09

the parties involved in an

play01:12

obligation and conscience

play01:18

now the question is if we will study

play01:22

relevant articles of law governing the

play01:26

obligations and constructs

play01:32

articles of law nyan

play01:36

in order to answer that question

play01:40

we need to know the source

play01:44

and the source of the law on obligations

play01:48

and contracts

play01:49

is the civil code of the philippines

play01:53

or the republic act number

play01:57

386

play02:00

uncivil code of the philippines or ra

play02:03

number

play02:04

386 an

play02:18

1950

play02:21

actually the civil code of the

play02:24

philippines

play02:25

is based on the civil code of spain

play02:29

which took effect in the philippines on

play02:32

december 7 18

play02:41

let us now start by defining obligation

play02:48

[Music]

play02:49

what is the meaning of obligation

play02:54

actually the definition of obligation

play02:58

can be found in article 1156

play03:02

of the new civil code of the philippines

play03:07

article 1156 of the new civil code of

play03:11

the philippines

play03:12

states that an obligation

play03:16

is a juridical necessity to give

play03:19

to do or not to do

play03:24

sabes so article 1156

play03:27

an obligation dao i juridical

play03:30

necessity what does it mean by

play03:33

juridical necessity juridical necessity

play03:38

means

play03:39

that the court may be asked to order

play03:42

the performance of an obligation if the

play03:46

debtor

play03:46

refuses to perform it

play03:52

young parties or the lawang

play03:56

persons involved sam

play04:14

[Music]

play04:29

to demand the performance of

play04:32

the obligation

play04:36

in other words side or

play04:40

sha

play05:13

[Music]

play05:34

article 1156 an obligation

play05:38

is a juridical necessity to give to do

play05:41

or not to do that means

play05:45

merong obligation to give

play05:48

admiral obligation to do and

play05:52

not to do the obligation to give

play05:57

is called real obligation

play06:01

and the obligation to do and not to do

play06:05

is called personal obligation

play06:10

of course your obligation to do

play06:13

and not to do puerto panatin yang hati

play06:17

we have obligation to do and

play06:20

obligation not to do

play06:23

your obligation to do antagon positive

play06:27

personal obligation at your obligation

play06:31

not to do antagon

play06:33

negative personal obligation

play06:40

definitions article 1156

play06:44

meron long to give to do or not to do

play06:48

pero along not to give

play06:52

ang not to give

play06:55

is that included

play06:59

not to do

play07:36

that is the reason why kumbhak walang

play07:38

obligation

play07:39

not to give

play07:44

let us now proceed to the requisites

play07:47

of obligation or

play07:50

essential elements of an obligation

play07:59

receipts of obligation or essential

play08:03

elements of an obligation

play08:06

we actually have four requisites of

play08:10

obligation or four essential elements

play08:13

of an obligation

play08:18

requisites or essential elements

play08:24

i

play08:37

essential elements all of

play08:41

the four essential elements or

play08:44

four requisites must be there

play08:48

in order to have an obligation

play08:51

that is the meaning of requisites of

play08:54

obligation

play08:55

or essential elements of an obligation

play09:00

we have four requisites of obligation

play09:04

and they are first active subject

play09:08

or creditor or obligee

play09:11

second passive subject or

play09:14

debtor or obligor third

play09:18

precision and fourth efficient

play09:22

cause the active subject

play09:27

or creditor or obligee

play09:30

is the party who has the right to demand

play09:33

performance of the obligation

play09:37

in other words ito young person or

play09:41

italian party

play09:42

na meron right to demand

play09:46

compliance of the obligation

play09:50

to give to do or not

play09:53

to do young merong

play09:56

right demand

play09:59

fulfillment obligation

play10:04

the passive subject or that or

play10:07

or obligor is the party

play10:11

who is obliged to perform

play10:14

the obligation meaning to say or in

play10:17

other words he is the person

play10:21

who has the obligation to give to do

play10:25

or not to do

play10:30

performed

play11:00

obligation

play11:01

[Music]

play11:09

[Music]

play11:11

right to demand

play11:15

next precision precision

play11:20

is the object or subject matter

play11:23

of the obligation it may consist

play11:27

of giving doing or not

play11:30

doing something

play11:34

therefore a precision

play11:37

[Music]

play11:38

hindi young

play11:42

thing itself we are not talking about

play11:46

the thing itself but rather the conduct

play11:50

of giving something

play11:54

doing something or not doing

play11:58

something take note

play12:02

thing but rather young conduct

play12:06

of giving something

play12:09

doing something or not doing

play12:12

something

play12:18

[Music]

play12:25

next efficient cause

play12:29

efficient cause is the vinculum

play12:33

or the legal or juridical day

play12:37

you juridical tie which binds

play12:40

the parties to an obligation

play12:43

the efficient cause of an obligation

play12:47

may be any of the five sources of

play12:51

obligation the five sources of

play12:54

obligation are law

play12:58

contracts quasi-contracts

play13:02

acts or omissions punishable by

play13:18

sources of obligation

play13:22

but for now focus on efficient

play13:26

costs pakistan

play13:31

that or at

play13:37

and the efficient cause is either

play13:41

any of the five sources of the

play13:45

obligation

play13:55

contracts acts or omissions punishable

play13:58

by law

play14:00

or quasi delics ang magigin

play14:03

sagot nino

play14:08

in order for you to better understand

play14:12

the requisites of obligation

play14:16

i will give you examples

play14:19

example number one

play14:22

d is obliged to give c

play14:26

ten thousand pesos with interest

play14:30

at 12 per annum on december

play14:34

31 2021

play14:39

pursuant to a contract

play14:42

of loan determine

play14:46

the passive subject the active subject

play14:52

the precision and the efficient

play14:56

costs let's determine

play14:59

first the passive subject

play15:03

and passive subject

play15:06

or obligor

play15:09

perform non obligation

play15:14

in this example perform

play15:17

obligation is cd

play15:20

because

play15:23

10 000 pesos sky c

play15:26

with interest

play15:30

therefore d is the passive

play15:33

subject next determinant

play15:39

active subject

play15:43

an active subject

play15:47

or obligee

play15:51

and the active subject is

play15:54

the party who has the right to

play15:57

demand the performance of the obligation

play16:01

therefore c is

play16:04

the active subject

play16:23

this is not the thing itself but rather

play16:26

the conduct

play16:27

of giving a thing doing a thing

play16:30

or not doing a thing

play16:35

therefore the giving of

play16:38

ten thousand pesos with twelve

play16:41

percent interest is the

play16:45

precision take note

play16:52

10 000 pesos with

play16:55

12 interest

play16:59

you are already wrong because you are

play17:03

talking about

play17:04

the thing itself na ten thousand pesos

play17:09

with 12 interest

play17:12

the pakistation it is

play17:15

the giving of a thing

play17:19

doing a thing or not doing

play17:22

a thing okay yeah angry station not in

play17:25

detail is

play17:26

the giving of 10 000 pesos

play17:30

with 12 interest

play17:34

next how about the efficient cause

play17:41

an efficient cause

play17:53

an efficient cause is either long

play17:57

conscious quasi-contract

play18:00

acts or emissions punishable by law or

play18:07

quasi-delex

play18:09

therefore in this problem

play18:11

[Music]

play18:13

the contract of loan is the

play18:16

efficient cause or the juridical

play18:19

or legal i

play18:23

in this example the obligation here

play18:28

is uni

play18:34

i won so

play18:39

unilateral obligation is that

play18:42

only one party is required to perform

play18:47

a particular conduct

play18:54

on

play19:06

next example number two

play19:10

d is obliged to transport the goods of

play19:13

sea

play19:14

from manila to cebu

play19:17

and c is obliged to pay thee

play19:20

one thousand pesos as transport costs

play19:24

under a contract of carriage

play19:29

determine the passive subject

play19:33

active subject precision and

play19:36

efficient costs

play19:42

object active subject

play19:46

precision at efficient costs

play19:53

as regards the transport of the goods

play19:56

and as regards

play19:59

the payment of transport

play20:03

costs

play20:07

as regards the transport

play20:10

of goods as regards

play20:14

the transport of the goods sino and

play20:20

subject sino and passive subject

play20:24

no impression at an

play20:27

efficient cause as regards

play20:30

the transport of the goods an active

play20:34

subject

play20:35

i see see

play20:39

why because cc and merron right

play20:42

to demand the fulfillment or the

play20:46

transport

play20:47

of the goods from the

play20:51

right to demand

play20:54

as regards the transport of the goods

play20:58

and passive subject i

play21:05

[Music]

play21:09

which is to transport the goods

play21:13

of sea from manila to

play21:17

cebu that's why

play21:20

cd and passive subject

play21:24

d is the passive subject and c

play21:28

is the active subject

play21:32

d is the detour and c

play21:35

is the creditor

play21:38

d is the obligor and

play21:41

c is the obligee

play21:45

as regards the transport of the goods

play22:03

as regards the transport of the goods i

play22:08

young transport of the goods

play22:12

the transport of the goods is

play22:16

the precision

play22:19

and last i know an efficient cause

play22:23

an efficient cause course

play22:27

that or at creditor

play22:32

an efficient cause i

play22:35

wedding long contracts

play22:39

quasi-contracts quasi-delegates

play22:43

or acts or omissions punishable

play22:47

by law therefore

play22:51

as regards the transport of the goods

play22:56

an efficient cause i young contract

play22:59

of carriage

play23:04

next puntana mantayosa as regards the

play23:07

payment

play23:08

of transport costs

play23:12

sino ang active subject

play23:15

sino and passive subject

play23:19

i know an efficient cause at ano ang

play23:22

prestation as regards

play23:26

the payment of transport costs

play23:30

an active subject i cd

play23:35

why because

play23:38

cd and magda demand

play23:42

1000 pesos the transport cost

play23:45

chi c

play23:50

[Music]

play23:57

why why see the passive subject

play24:01

because si si

play24:16

kai

play24:20

next as regards

play24:23

the payment of transport costs

play24:26

and no on prestition

play24:30

and precision i own payment

play24:33

of transport costs

play24:38

i transport costs

play24:41

because we are not talking about the

play24:43

thing but rather the

play24:46

conduct which is the payment of

play24:49

transport costs

play24:53

how about the efficient costs

play24:56

as regard as regards the payment

play25:00

of transport costs and efficient cause

play25:03

i contract off

play25:06

carriage paren because

play25:10

the contract of carriage binds the

play25:14

debtor

play25:14

and the creditor to the obligation

play25:19

here in this example

play25:23

an efficient cost i contract

play25:27

of carriage

play25:31

in this example the obligation

play25:35

is bilateral

play25:39

first example your obligation is

play25:42

unilateral an obligation

play25:46

is bilateral

play25:50

meaning to say parties

play25:54

i na mag perform non-particular

play25:59

conduct

play26:06

both d and c are required to

play26:10

perform a particular conduct

play26:25

transport costs kai di

play26:30

therefore the law asylum magpu perform

play26:33

non

play26:33

particular conduct

play26:37

hence the obligation here is

play26:40

bilateral

play26:44

always remember perform

play26:48

nonparticular conduct unilateral

play26:51

obligation

play26:55

perform non-obligation that means

play26:58

each party okay

play27:02

and tawak's obligation i bilateral

play27:06

obligation uni means

play27:09

one and by means to

play27:14

next let's distinguish civil obligation

play27:18

from natural obligation

play27:23

and civil obligation natural

play27:27

obligation and civil obligation

play27:30

this is based on positive

play27:34

law at a natural obligation

play27:38

this is based on natural

play27:41

law therefore congruency will obligation

play27:49

it is enforceable by

play27:52

a court action

play27:57

in a civil obligation merong juridical

play28:01

necessity the creditor can

play28:04

go to court to demand the performance of

play28:08

the obligation from the debtor

play28:13

perros a natural obligation since

play28:17

it is based on natural law this

play28:20

is not enforceable by

play28:23

court action there is no

play28:27

juridical necessity in

play28:30

natural obligation

play28:34

take note

play28:37

article 1156 new

play28:40

civil code of the philippines

play28:44

i civil obligation

play28:49

the obligation that is defined

play28:52

in article 1156

play28:55

of the new civil code of the philippines

play28:58

is

play28:59

a civil obligation and not

play29:03

a natural obligation

Rate This
β˜…
β˜…
β˜…
β˜…
β˜…

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

Related Tags
ObligationsContractsCivil CodeLegal RightsJuridical NecessityCreditorDebtorPerformanceLawful DutiesFilipino Law