Police Unions And The Fight To Reform Law Enforcement
Summary
TLDRThe video script addresses the ongoing debate over police reform in the U.S., sparked by incidents like the death of George Floyd. It discusses the role of police unions in protecting officers from accountability, the challenges of reform due to collective bargaining rights, and the need for changes in contracts and laws to ensure public safety. It also highlights the complexity of the issue due to the decentralized nature of policing and the varying degrees of union influence across different jurisdictions.
Takeaways
- 🔊 Public outcry for police reform intensified after George Floyd's death, with activists demanding changes to address police brutality and racial bias.
- 🏙️ Calls to defund the police, ban chokeholds, and enforce stricter punishments for abusive officers have gained momentum in response to repeated incidents of violence.
- 🛡️ Police unions have historically secured generous benefits for officers and acted as their first line of defense against accusations of brutality and misconduct.
- 🚨 The narrative of police unions often conflicts with public sentiment, as they may perpetuate a false sense of immunity for police officers from legal consequences.
- 📜 Police unions negotiate contracts that can include provisions shielding officers from accountability, which can complicate efforts to address police violence.
- 🤝 The unique nature of police work, involving potential violence, has led to contracts that may protect officers even in cases of misconduct.
- 🛑 There is a push for reforms such as nationwide de-escalation standards and training to improve police conduct and reduce violence.
- 🏛️ The decentralized nature of policing in the U.S., with over 12,000 local departments, complicates the establishment of uniform standards and accountability.
- 🛂 Police unions argue that their protections prevent officers from refraining to act due to legal liability concerns and help maintain hiring rates and attract good candidates.
- 🗳️ The long-term impact of the unrest could influence local and state elections, potentially leading to changes in the power dynamics of police unions.
- 🛡️ Some argue that police unions should not be allowed to bargain for exceptions that place them above the law, as seen in certain state laws and federal interventions.
Q & A
What was the catalyst for the nationwide protests in the U.S.?
-The nationwide protests were sparked by the death of George Floyd in police custody in Minneapolis, which led to activists demanding police reform.
What is the role of police unions in the context of police brutality?
-Police unions often serve as the first line of defense for officers accused of brutality, negotiating contracts that can shield them from accountability.
Why have some people called for defunding the police?
-Calls to defund the police are based on the desire to redirect resources towards community services and to reduce the reliance on police for issues that could be better handled by other professionals.
What is the significance of the term 'de-escalation standard' mentioned in the script?
-A 'de-escalation standard' refers to a set of guidelines or training that encourages officers to resolve situations without resorting to force, aiming to prevent unnecessary violence.
How do police unions differ from other unions in terms of their bargaining power?
-Police unions are unique in that they often bargain for exceptions that allow their members to be above certain laws, which can include provisions that shield officers from accountability for violent incidents.
What is the impact of police unions on the hiring and retention of police officers?
-Police unions have helped make the job of policing more attractive by securing generous benefits, which can contribute to higher hiring rates and the retention of officers.
What are the arguments against the special protections negotiated by police unions?
-Critics argue that these protections can be used to shield officers from complaints involving violent incidents, thereby enabling racial discrimination and abuse of power.
How do the contracts negotiated by police unions affect the ability of departments to enforce discipline?
-The contracts can include provisions that impede the department's ability to enforce accountability and discipline, making it difficult to hold officers accountable for misconduct.
What is the historical context of police unions in the U.S.?
-The initial police unions in the U.S. were founded during the First World War, but they were disbanded after the war and did not reorganize until the 1960s when civilian review boards were introduced.
What is the position of House Republicans regarding police reform?
-House Republicans are planning to put forward a reform legislation proposal aimed at ending racial injustice in law enforcement.
How do police unions respond to criticism and protests against police brutality?
-Police unions have been vocal in defending their actions and their members, often using social media and press conferences to counteract the narrative of police misconduct.
Outlines
🔍 Police Reform and Union Resistance
Following the death of George Floyd, activists called for police reform across the U.S., highlighting the pattern of unarmed African American civilians being killed by officers. Despite a small percentage of officers involved in such incidents, there is a strong call for changes like defunding the police, banning chokeholds, and holding abusive officers accountable. Police unions, which have historically secured benefits and defended officers from scrutiny, are seen as a barrier to reform. These unions negotiate contracts that can shield officers from accountability for violent incidents, and critics argue that this protection perpetuates a false narrative and undermines public safety. Some advocate for reforms that include de-escalation standards and nationwide training, while emphasizing that public safety should be the priority in negotiations with unions.
🏛 The Complexities of Police Unions and Reform
Police unions, such as the Fraternal Order of Police, are under scrutiny for bargaining rights that seem to place them above the law in some instances. Connecticut state law, for example, allows union contracts to supersede state law, which can complicate federal interventions in cases of civil rights violations. While House Republicans propose reform legislation to address racial injustice in law enforcement, the decentralized nature of U.S. police departments adds to the challenge of establishing clear guidelines. Critics argue that unions should not shield members from legal accountability or allow dishonesty. Success stories like Camden, New Jersey, show that breaking away from union contracts and rehiring officers as county employees can lead to significant improvements in safety and reductions in complaints. The debate over the power of police unions is tied to broader discussions about racial animosity and the role of law enforcement in society, with some arguing that their exceptional status as public sector workers does not justify the protection of bad actors within their ranks.
Mindmap
Keywords
💡Police Reform
💡Police Brutality
Highlights
Activists across the U.S. demand police reform following George Floyd's death.
A pattern of officers killing unarmed African American civilians is often ignored.
There's a very small percentage of bad police officers, according to the transcript.
Calls for defunding the police, banning chokeholds, and punishing abusive officers.
Police unions have historically fought for generous benefits and protection for officers.
Police unions often serve as the first line of defense for officers accused of brutality.
The unique nature of police work and its associated violence is highlighted in union contracts.
Critics argue that collective agreements protect officers from accountability for violent incidents.
Police unions claim protections prevent officers from refraining to act due to legal liability concerns.
Proposed reforms include a nationwide de-escalation standard and training.
Local governments should prioritize public safety over wage bills in union negotiations.
There are over 12,000 local police departments in the U.S., complicating uniform guidelines.
Police unions have the same rights and obligations as other unions, but a different history.
The creation of most police unions was triggered by the introduction of civilian review boards.
Connecticut state law allows union contracts to supersede state law in some instances.
House Republicans plan to put forward a reform legislation proposal addressing racial injustice.
Police departments have been criticized for heavy-handed crowd control tactics during protests.
Police unions have defended their actions and criticized the 'soft touch' approach to criminals.
The ability to bargain for exceptions above the law should be outlawed, according to critics.
Camden, New Jersey, saw a significant reduction in crime and complaints after leaving the police union.
Police unions are one of the last bastions of direct racial animosity in American society.
Local and state governments have the power to curtail police union power through elections.
Police unions argue they deserve special treatment as heroes who put themselves in harm's way.
Transcripts
after the death of George Floyd in
police custody in Minneapolis activists
across the u.s. took to the streets to
demand police reform I know you are
local and state police and four thousand
members of the National Guard took a
stand there's a repeated pattern of
officers killing unarmed African
American civilians and people protesting
and oftentimes that being ignored too
often some of that violence has come
from folks who we're supposed to be
serving and protecting nobody is more
opposed to the small number of bad
police officers and you have them
they're very tiny I use the word tiny
it's a very small percentage there's
been calls to defund the police band
chokeholds and to more effectively
punish officers who abuse their power or
show racial bias but before any proposed
policing reforms can actually go into
effect lawmakers and Department Chiefs
would first have to get past police
unions over the course of decades police
unions have fought to secure generous
benefits for rank-and-file officers and
helped make the dangerous job of police
work more attractive to hundreds of
thousands of officers but when their
members come under scrutiny for police
brutality and heavy-handed tactics it's
the Union that often serves as their
first line of defense perpetuated a
false narrative an anti police rhetoric
but everybody needs to remember police
officers are here to help these seniors
are not above the law in the same way
police are not above the law
there's no exception to the rule here
that should be applicable for police
union leadership
a police union represents the officers
of a given department and negotiates
employment contracts specific with the
city or town that funds the department
the union also represents officers in
labor disputes such as wrongful
termination complaints or discrimination
accusations how do you know it's
collective agreements lead to changes in
behavior most of the problems that we
have when it comes to police violence
could be changed if we were able to find
ways to eliminate the deals that police
unions have implemented to protect
police officers from accountability
police unions are different than other
unions because police work carries the
possibility of violence during the
normal course of duties this means that
protections negotiated into police
contracts can end up shielding officers
from complaints that involve violent
incidents we want to protect the safety
of the products that are made in the
u.s. we don't allow an organization that
represents the people who make those
products to be in charge of setting the
standards and enforcing them
implementing accountability discipline
and that's what we've done with these
police unions in many instances it looks
like collective agreements are being
used to protect the ability of officers
to discriminate in their use of force
police unions say that protections they
advocate for help prevent police from
refraining to act due to concerns over
legal liability and they also prevent
frivolous lawsuits and maintain hiring
rates and attract good candidates I'm
hopeful that we can come to an agreement
on some common-sense reforms including a
de-escalation standard and training that
is nationwide a lot of cities already do
this my main advice actually is to
employers is the local governments and
when you sit down at the bargaining
table you should be putting public
safety first right so their priority
shouldn't be for example minimizing the
wage bill it should be making sure that
civilians are safe
I like the concept of more training the
house does it we do it I like the fact
that we're looking for a way to van
choke holes we we do it by taking money
from from different departments they do
it in a different fashion but we're
about 90 percent they're more than
twelve thousand local police departments
were operating in the United States
during 2016 policing is a state local
issue and oftentimes it boils down to
what's in the contract and there can be
any number of provisions in there that
will impede the department's ability to
enforce accountability and discipline
police what unions have the same rights
and obligations as other unions their
history is really really different
though you know the initial police
unions in the u.s. were founded during
the First World War not an easy time to
form a union - what happened after the
war the US government kind of forced
those unions out and then they didn't
organize for a long time but what
actually triggered the creation of most
police unions in the US and the ACLU
launched a campaign in the 60s
introduced what are called civilian
review boards right so to have oversight
of policing by regular people and that
actually is what triggered police
officers to start forming unions to
prevent that civilian oversight of
policing police unions are public sector
unions similar to unions around the
country for public school teachers
firefighters and sanitation workers the
Fraternal Order of Police for example
claims to represent more than three
hundred and thirty thousand police
officers across the u.s. police unions
are an outlier in one major way it's
very unique for any union to bargain for
an exception that allows them to be
above the law Connecticut state law
actually has a provision that allows a
union contract to supersede the state
law and there are some instances where
that can even happen when the federal
government does stepping into
problematic police departments when
there have been civil rights violations
oftentimes provisions could supersede
what's been done on the federal level
House Republicans will be putting
forward a reform legislation proposal
let's talk about ending injustice racial
injustice in our law enforcement
[Music]
collective bargaining rights aren't just
set their bargaining rights police
officers work like you and I and they
should have access to that
representation if they choose to have it
so when we have reform it's a two-sided
three across the u.s. that our local
police state police Federal Police and
County Sheriff's Department's this adds
to the complication of providing clear
guidelines on officer conduct and use of
force I support unions as a rule but we
don't let everybody form a union in this
country particularly if there are bad
acts being done with that power of
unionization like protecting people from
accountability for acts of violence as
demonstrations over police brutality
intensified following Freud's death
police departments across the country
drew more criticism for heavy-handed
crowd control tactics such as using tear
gas pepper spray rubber bullets and
physical force police unions have been
vocal on social media net press
conferences defending themselves and
their actions that are being protested
nationwide there's been a message not
only from our City Hall but from the
State House that says there will be a
soft touch and the criminals know it and
while folks were protesting they were
breaking down doors climbing in windows
pulling out their weapons they're not
afraid to carry their no unions that
seek to shield their members from the
law in a basic fundamental way or seeks
to allow their members to lie to their
bosses or lied to it to others in public
on a consistent basis about when they've
killed people that it's not acceptable
to engage in that type of behavior and
that should be outlawed the ability to
bargain Forks to be above the law should
be outlawed
just like 2.21 City Camden New Jersey
who has seen a turnaround in its police
force and also in the level of safety in
the city and what they did is took a
comprehensive look at
and part of that included basically
getting out of the Union and out of the
contract and rehiring those workers as
county employees and they were able to
transform their police force and the
changes that they put in place resulted
in a two-thirds reduction in homicides
rate and a ninety five percent reduction
in a number of complaints against
officers because of the decentralized
nature of police departments in the u.s.
broad overreaching federal actions are
unlikely to have a near-term impact on
the ability of police unions to defend
bad actors within police departments
from being disciplined or terminated by
their departments police units have been
one of the last bastions of direct
racial animosity in American society if
you look at some of the statements made
by police unions in the aftermath of
these killings a lot of them are
incredulous telling you next to believe
you're lying eyes based on what you saw
in the video and a lot of them have been
very blatantly making very derogatory
statements about the african-american
community I think a lot of the biggest
changes though are up to local
governments and off to state governments
because now we have a lot of the worst
elements of collective agreements have
been put into state law and what are
called law enforcement officer builds of
Rights
Anabelle for example make it such an
officer needs to agree to the timing and
the location of their of their
investigation or interrogation after
after killing a civilian the long-term
effects of recent unrest could affect
local and state elections which could
move to curtail the power of police
unions in certain towns in cities police
unions make the argument that they are
exceptionally deserving of this
treatment because they are heroes who
put themselves in harm's way for our
safety these are not the only public
sector workers who put themselves in the
way of direct physical harm for our
benefit you know is this really the
argument does not square up with reality
you
Посмотреть больше похожих видео
Who Is Behind Police Unions? | NowThis
A brief history of police impunity in Black deaths
Red card for macho Spain | ARTE.tv Documentary
Kolkata doctor case has SERIOUS problems | Abhi and Niyu
What happened when protesters questioned a Black Toronto police inspector's loyalty to her community
The origins of policing in America | Perspective
5.0 / 5 (0 votes)