#НеДляБыдла - Прибытие (Гениальный ШЕДЕВР для Гениальных Гениев)

Summary

The video script discusses the importance of language in film, emphasizing that movies are best enjoyed in their original language to grasp the full depth of dialogue and character. It critiques the film 'Arrival' for its portrayal of linguistics and time perception, suggesting the movie fails to live up to its intellectual ambitions. The script also compares 'Arrival' to 'Annihilation', highlighting the latter's more effective use of science to explore human nature and its themes.

Takeaways

• 🌐 The film 'Arrival' is deeply connected to linguistics and emphasizes the importance of watching movies in their original language to fully grasp the intended experience.
• 🗣️ The manner of speech in 'Arrival' is a significant aspect, almost acting as a separate character, which is lost in dubbed versions, altering the film's perception.
• 🎓 The online English school Skyeng is highlighted as a service where one can learn English to enjoy content in its original language, with customizable lessons and interactive homework.
• 🔗 The speaker discusses the promotional offer of Skyeng, mentioning a free trial lesson and additional lessons with a promo code, showing transparency in advertising.
• 🎬 The speaker expresses a personal belief in consuming content in its original language, having learned English through games, books, and films, advocating for language learning through immersion.
• 🚀 'Arrival' is critiqued as a film with high ambitions but accused of being pretentious, with the speaker arguing that it does not live up to the intellectual depth it purports to have.
• 🕵️‍♂️ The film's plot revolves around deciphering an alien language, which is central to its narrative, yet the speaker criticizes its execution as lacking depth and clarity.
• 🔄 The concept of time and its non-linear perception by the aliens in 'Arrival' is a key theme, but the speaker finds the film's exploration of this concept unconvincing.
• 🎼 The use of music in 'Close Encounters of the Third Kind' is praised for effectively conveying the progression of communication with aliens, contrasting with 'Arrival's' approach.
• 🌌 'Annihilation' is recommended as an alternative film that, despite its flaws, is considered to be more effective in exploring deep themes about humanity and communication with an alien presence.
• 🔮 The speaker suggests that 'Arrival' leaves much of the heavy lifting to the viewer, requiring them to fill in gaps and think deeply about the implications of the story, which can be seen as both a strength and a weakness.

Q & A

What is the main theme discussed in the video script related to films?

The main theme discussed in the video script is the importance of language in films, emphasizing that films are best enjoyed in their original language to fully capture the nuances and intentionality of the dialogue.

What is the relationship between the film 'Arrival' and linguistics as mentioned in the script?

The film 'Arrival' is closely tied to linguistics as it explores the concept of language and its importance in communication, particularly in the context of establishing contact with extraterrestrial beings.

What is the significance of the scene where Amy Adams' character teaches her daughter in the film 'Arrival'?

The scene signifies the personal connection and emotional depth of Amy Adams' character, setting a somber tone for the story and foreshadowing the importance of familial relationships and loss.

What is the role of Forest Whitaker's character in the film 'Arrival'?

Forest Whitaker's character, Colonel Weber, is a military figure who initially hires another linguist but then turns to Amy Adams' character for help in communicating with the aliens due to her expertise in linguistics.

What is the significance of the 'Circle of Life' in the film 'Arrival'?

The 'Circle of Life' is a metaphor used to describe the non-linear perception of time by the aliens, which contrasts with the human linear perception and is central to understanding their language and intentions.

How does the video script describe the use of subtitles in learning languages?

The script mentions 'smart subtitles' as a tool that helps in learning English by providing interactive lessons and allowing viewers to learn the language while watching their favorite films and series.

What is the promotional offer mentioned in the script for the Skyeng online English school?

The promotional offer mentioned is that the first lesson can be tried absolutely free, and by using a promo code, two additional lessons can be obtained as a gift.

What is the script's opinion on the film 'Arrival' being considered a masterpiece by critics?

The script challenges the critics' view of 'Arrival' as a masterpiece, suggesting that the film may be overrated and that its intellectual and philosophical themes are not as profound as they are presented to be.

What is the criticism of the film 'Arrival' in terms of its narrative structure?

The criticism is that 'Arrival' pretends to be a smart and deep story but instead uses the laziest method of storytelling, often explaining its themes verbally without delving into the complexities of the subject matter.

What is the script's view on the use of the 'Sapir-Whorf Hypothesis' in the film 'Arrival'?

The script suggests that while the film plays with the idea of linguistic relativity, it does not fully explore the concept in a meaningful way and instead uses it as a plot device without much depth.

What is the script's opinion on the film 'Arrival's' handling of the concept of time?

The script criticizes the film for its handling of the concept of time, stating that the idea of perceiving time non-linearly is not convincingly portrayed and lacks scientific grounding.