Lengkap! Kalimat Menohok Diplomat RI Silvany Pasaribu pada Vanuatu

Summary

The Indonesian representative passionately defends their nation's sovereignty and human rights record in the UN, responding to Vanuatu's criticism. They emphasize Indonesia's commitment to diversity, tolerance, and democratic values, highlighting ratified international conventions. The speaker refutes Vanuatu's stance, urging them to address their own human rights shortcomings and respect Indonesia's territorial integrity, asserting that Papua and West Papua are integral parts of the country.

Takeaways

• 😠 Indonesia expresses strong disapproval of Vanuatu's interference in its internal affairs, calling it 'shameful' and 'unhealthy'.
• 🏛 The Indonesian representative criticizes Vanuatu for not understanding the fundamental principles of the United Nations Charter, particularly non-interference.
• 👉 Indonesia emphasizes the importance of respecting the sovereignty and territorial integrity of all nations, urging Vanuatu to adhere to these principles.
• 📢 The Indonesian President advocates for a 'win-win' approach to international relations, which was echoed by other world leaders.
• 🙅‍♂️ Vanuatu is accused of choosing to instill enmity and division, especially during a time of health crisis and economic adversity.
• 🌐 Indonesia highlights its commitment to human rights, diversity, and tolerance within its multicultural nation of over 17,000 islands.
• 📜 Indonesia has ratified the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination, while Vanuatu has not signed it.
• 🤔 The Indonesian representative questions Vanuatu's sincerity in promoting indigenous rights, given their lack of signature on key human rights instruments.
• 🚫 Vanuatu is also pointed out for not signing and ratifying the Convention Against Torture, raising doubts about their commitment to human rights.
• 🇮🇩 Indonesia asserts that Papuans are Indonesians and play a vital role in the nation's development, including on the island of Papua.
• 🛡️ Indonesia pledges to defend itself against any advocacy of separatism, especially when masked as human rights concerns, and reaffirms the provinces of Papua and West Papua as integral parts of the country.

Q & A

What is the main issue raised by the Indonesian representative in response to Vanuatu's statement?

The main issue raised is Vanuatu's alleged excessive and unhealthy obsession with how Indonesia should govern itself, and the perceived interference in Indonesia's domestic affairs.

What does the Indonesian representative accuse Vanuatu of missing regarding the United Nations Charter?

The Indonesian representative accuses Vanuatu of missing the fundamental principles of non-interference in the domestic affairs and respect for the sovereignty and territorial integrity of other countries as outlined in the United Nations Charter.

What approach does the President of Indonesia advocate for in international relations?

The President of Indonesia advocates for a win-win approach to international relations that is mutually beneficial among states.

How does Indonesia describe its commitment to human rights within its diverse nation?

Indonesia describes its commitment to human rights by valuing diversity, respecting tolerance, and ensuring equal rights for all individuals under the law in its multicultural and multi-ethnic nation.

What international convention has Indonesia ratified that is relevant to the elimination of racial discrimination?

Indonesia has ratified the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination.

Why does the Indonesian representative question Vanuatu's commitment to indigenous rights?

The Indonesian representative questions Vanuatu's commitment to indigenous rights because Vanuatu has not signed the International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights, which is a core human rights instrument.

What human rights convention has Vanuatu been called out for not signing and ratifying?

Vanuatu has been called out for not signing and ratifying the Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment.

What does the Indonesian representative claim about the people of Papua?

The Indonesian representative claims that the people of Papua are Indonesians who play an important role in the development of Indonesia, including on the island of Papua.

What principles does the Indonesian representative emphasize regarding the provinces of Papua and West Papua?

The Indonesian representative emphasizes that the principles of the U.N. Charter, which include respect for sovereignty and territorial integrity, mean that Papua and West Papua are irrevocable parts of Indonesia.

How does the Indonesian representative describe the finality of Papua and West Papua's status within Indonesia?

The Indonesian representative describes the status of Papua and West Papua as final, irreversible, and permanent parts of Indonesia since 1945, endorsed by the United Nations and the international community.

What is the Indonesian representative's stance on the advocacy of separatism under the guise of human rights concern?

The Indonesian representative's stance is to defend Indonesia against any continuing advocacy of separatism conveyed under the guise of artificial human rights concern.

Outlines

00:00

😤 Indonesia's Rebuke to Vanuatu's Criticisms

The speaker from Indonesia vehemently defends the nation's sovereignty against Vanuatu's criticisms, expressing indignation at the perceived interference in Indonesia's domestic affairs. The speaker emphasizes the importance of respecting the principles of non-interference and territorial integrity, as outlined in the United Nations Charter. They highlight Indonesia's commitment to human rights, diversity, and tolerance, and point out Vanuatu's lack of adherence to key human rights conventions, such as the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination and the International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights. The speaker calls on Vanuatu to focus on its own human rights responsibilities before criticizing others.

05:01

🏛 Asserting Indonesia's Sovereignty Over Papua

In this paragraph, the Indonesian representative reaffirms the provinces of Papua and West Papua as integral parts of Indonesia since 1945, with the endorsement of the United Nations and the international community. The speaker denounces Vanuatu's advocacy for separatism under the pretense of human rights concerns and pledges to defend Indonesia against such advocacy. The paragraph concludes with a firm statement that the status of Papua and West Papua as parts of Indonesia is final, irreversible, and permanent.

Keywords

💡Right of Reply

The 'Right of Reply' is a procedural mechanism in international forums that allows a country to respond to a statement made by another country. In the script, Indonesia is exercising its right of reply to address concerns raised by Vanuatu, showing the importance of dialogue in international relations.

💡Non-interference

Non-interference is a principle of international law that prohibits states from intervening in the internal or domestic affairs of another state. The video emphasizes this principle as Indonesia criticizes Vanuatu for overstepping boundaries by commenting on Indonesia's governance.

💡Sovereignty

Sovereignty refers to the supreme power or authority of a nation to govern itself without any interference from outside sources. The script repeatedly mentions the importance of respecting the sovereignty of nations, particularly in the context of Indonesia's governance of its provinces.

💡Territorial Integrity

Territorial integrity is the concept that a state's territory is intact and not subject to external threats or divisions. In the video, Indonesia asserts the territorial integrity of its provinces, including Papua and West Papua, as an unalterable part of the nation.

💡Human Rights

Human rights are the basic rights and freedoms to which all individuals are entitled without discrimination. The script discusses human rights in the context of Indonesia's commitment to its diverse population and its criticism of Vanuatu's stance on indigenous rights and international covenants.

💡Indigenous People

Indigenous people are the original inhabitants of a land or territory. The video mentions the promotion of indigenous rights, but also criticizes Vanuatu for not signing certain international covenants related to indigenous people's rights.

💡Racial Discrimination

Racial discrimination refers to any distinction, exclusion, restriction, or preference based on race, color, descent, or national or ethnic origin that has the purpose or effect of nullifying or impairing the recognition, enjoyment, or exercise of human rights. Indonesia claims to have ratified an international convention against racial discrimination, contrasting with Vanuatu's lack of action on similar covenants.

💡Economic Adversity

Economic adversity refers to difficult economic conditions or challenges faced by a country or region. The script mentions the current emergency health crisis and economic adversity, suggesting that this is not the time for divisive actions or rhetoric.

💡Separatism

Separatism is the advocacy or practice of political independence for a particular region within a nation. In the video, Indonesia defends itself against any advocacy of separatism, particularly in relation to the provinces of Papua and West Papua.

💡United Nations Charter

The United Nations Charter is the foundational treaty of the United Nations, an intergovernmental organization. The script refers to the principles of the UN Charter, emphasizing the respect for sovereignty and territorial integrity as fundamental to international relations.

💡International Community

The international community refers to the collection of nations and states that interact with one another in the international system. The video mentions the endorsement of Indonesia's territorial claims by the United Nations and the international community, indicating global recognition of its borders.

Highlights

Indonesia exercises its right of reply to Vanuatu's statement

Indonesia criticizes Vanuatu's obsession with Indonesia's governance

Indonesia calls out Vanuatu for missing the fundamental principles of the UN Charter

Indonesia emphasizes the importance of respecting non-interference in domestic affairs

Indonesia stresses the need to respect the sovereignty and territorial integrity of other countries

Indonesia urges Vanuatu to keep its sermon to itself until it respects these principles

Indonesia promotes a win-win approach to international relations

Indonesia highlights its commitment to human rights and diversity

Indonesia points out that it is the third largest democratic country in the world

Indonesia has ratified the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination

Vanuatu has not signed the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights

Vanuatu has not signed and ratified the Convention Against Torture

Indonesia calls on Vanuatu to fulfill its human rights responsibilities

Indonesia accuses Vanuatu of spreading false narratives about human rights in Papua

Indonesia asserts that Papuans are Indonesians and play an important role in the country's development

Indonesia defends its sovereignty and territorial integrity against separatist advocacy

Indonesia declares that the provinces of Papua and West Papua are irrevocable parts of the country

Indonesia's stance on Papua has been endorsed by the UN and the international community

Transcripts

[Music]

[Applause]

madam president

i'm taking the floor to exercise

indonesia's right of reply to the

statement

made by vanuatu

it is shameful that this single country

continues to have excessive

and unhealthy obsession about how

indonesia

should act or govern itself

frankly speaking i'm confused

how could a country tries to teach

others

while missing the point of the whole

fundamental principles

of the united nations charter

let me tell them the following

to do what is right is to respect

the principles of non-interference in

the domestic affairs

of other countries and to do what is

right

it is to respect the sovereignty

and territorial integrity of other

countries

so until you have done so please keep

the sermon

to yourself

madam president the president of

indonesia

stated a few days ago in this great hall

of nations

and i quote we must promote

a win-win approach albedic relations

among state that is mutually beneficial

unquote

indeed such a call was echoed by world

leaders throughout this prominent week

but this ignorant country chooses

the contrary

at times of an emergency health crisis

and great economic adversity

it prefers to instill enmity and so

division by guiding their advocacy for

separatism

with flowery human rights concern

indonesia comprising of more than

hundreds of ethnic groups a diverse

and multicultural nation with thousands

of tribes

and hundreds of local languages

spreading across more than 17 thousands

and 400 islands

is committed to human rights

we value diversity we respect tolerance

and everybody has the same right in this

third

largest democratic country in the world

we have also promoted and protected

human rights

where each individual has the same

rights under the law

furthermore we have ratified the

international convention

on the elimination of all forms of

racial

discrimination well

interestingly vanuatu has not even

signed it

and how could one talk about promoting

the right of indigenous people

when it does not even sign the

international covenant

on economic social and cultural rights

the core human rights instrument

this actually raises the question do

they really care

about indigenous concern

more importantly vanuatu

has not signed and ratified

the convention against torture and other

cruel

inhuman or degrading treatment

or punishment

we call on the government on one of one

watu

to please fulfill your human rights

responsibility

to your people and to the world

madam president the accusation

of human rights is typical

a tall tale that they sell and stage

over the years in the hall

let me tell them you are no

representation

of the people of papua

and stop fantasizing of being one

pap papuans are indonesians

all of us play an important role in the

development of indonesia

including on the island of papua

madam president

the principles of the u.n charter which

vanuatu

clearly does not seem to understand

stipulates the respect for sovereignty

and territorial integrity

indonesia will defend itself against

any continuing advocacy of separatism

conveyed under the guise of artificial

human rights concern

the provinces of papua and west papua

are ever irrevocable parts of indonesia

since 1945.

it has also been firmly endorsed by the

united nations

and the international community decades

ago

it is final irreversible

and permanent i thank you madam

president

you