Sederet Respons Pakar Hukum dan Pengamat Soal Desakan Copot Wapres Gibran

Summary

The discussion centers around the legitimacy of Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka, in light of demands from the Forum Purnawirawan TNI for his replacement. Key figures, including Rahmad Muzani and KaSang Pangar, assert that both President Prabowo and Vice President Gibran are constitutionally valid. Legal experts argue that calls for Gibran's removal violate constitutional procedures, suggesting such demands should go through the DPR before the Constitutional Court. Political analysts warn that these calls for resignation could undermine the legitimacy of the elected government and cause unnecessary political tensions.

Takeaways

• 😀 Rahmad Muzani, the Secretary-General of Gerindra, stated that Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka is legitimate according to the constitution.
• 😀 Muzani responded to calls for the replacement of the Vice President, stating he had not fully reviewed the demands from the TNI veterans forum.
• 😀 Muzani affirmed that both President Prabowo Subianto and Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka are valid as per the constitution.
• 😀 The call for a new Vice President arose after the TNI veterans forum presented a proposal with key points, including the demand for the Vice President's replacement.
• 😀 PSI's General Chairperson, KaSang Pangar, also responded, emphasizing that the President and Vice President were elected in accordance with the constitution.
• 😀 According to constitutional expert Aan Eko Widiarto, calls for the Vice President’s removal are unconstitutional and should be submitted by the DPR before being tested by the Constitutional Court.
• 😀 Widiarto criticized the suggestion that the proposal be made to MPR, stating that the impeachment process should follow a defined legal process.
• 😀 Political analyst Agung Baskoro labeled the demand for the Vice President's resignation as excessive, arguing it could undermine political processes and public perception.
• 😀 Baskoro suggested that pushing for impeachment could cause unnecessary political consequences, especially affecting the public's view of the political system.
• 😀 Former TNI soldiers had previously presented their demand to President Prabowo Subianto through Wiranto, his Special Political and Security Advisor, who stated that Prabowo respected the veterans' proposal but recognized his limited authority under the system of checks and balances.

Q & A

What did Rahmad Muzani say about the legitimacy of Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka?

Rahmad Muzani stated that Gibran Rakabuming Raka is the legitimate Vice President according to the constitution, and his position is in accordance with the constitutional law.

How did Muzani respond to the demand for a change in the Vice President from the MPR?

Muzani said he had not thoroughly studied the demands from the Forum Purnawirawan TNI regarding the replacement of the Vice President and mentioned that he had only heard brief information about it.

What is Muzani's view on the process of changing the Vice President?

Muzani expressed confusion over the proposal to change the Vice President through the MPR, stating that it is not in line with the correct procedures as outlined in the constitution.

What does Muzani think about the legitimacy of President Prabowo Subianto and Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka?

Muzani confirmed that both President Prabowo Subianto and Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka are legally elected and are rightful in their positions, as they were directly chosen by the people.

What is the constitutional process for removing the Vice President, according to legal expert Aan Eko Widiarto?

Aan Eko Widiarto explained that any request to remove the Vice President must first be proposed by the DPR (People's Representative Council) and then tested by the Constitutional Court, not directly through the MPR.

How did political analyst Agung Baskoro view the demand for Vice President Gibran's resignation?

Agung Baskoro believed that the demand for Vice President Gibran's resignation was excessive and could undermine the legitimacy of the presidential process. He argued that focusing too much on this issue could have unnecessary political consequences.

What was Wiranto's response to the demand for a change in the Vice President?

Wiranto, the Special Advisor to President Prabowo on Politics and Security, said that President Prabowo respects the demand from the Forum Purnawirawan TNI, but as head of state, he understands the limits of his powers within the trias politica system.

What does the term 'trias politica' refer to in this context?

In this context, 'trias politica' refers to the principle of the separation of powers in government, which divides authority into three branches: executive, legislative, and judicial, limiting the scope of actions that any one branch can take.

What was the primary reason the Forum Purnawirawan TNI called for the replacement of the Vice President?

The Forum Purnawirawan TNI's call for the replacement of the Vice President was part of a broader set of demands, which included concerns about the direction of state policies and the government’s governance.

Why is it significant that the Vice President is directly elected by the people, according to the script?

The fact that the Vice President is directly elected by the people reinforces the legitimacy of the position and makes any attempt to replace the Vice President more complicated, as it must follow constitutional procedures.