Winx Reboot Transformations Review

Summary

In this video, the creator reviews the new transformations and designs in the rebooted season of *Winx Club*. They express mixed feelings about the music, animation, and character designs, particularly for Flora, Musa, Stella, and Aisha. The creator appreciates the effort in some areas, like Flora's acrobatic elements and the dynamic backgrounds, but critiques the overuse of American theater kid mannerisms and the lack of innovation in some transformations. They discuss the impact of AI on animation quality and share nostalgic thoughts about the original designs, while also examining the modern, more kid-friendly approach to the characters.

Takeaways

• 😀 The speaker expresses mixed feelings about the transformations in the remake/reboot of 'W.I.T.C.H.', citing nostalgia for the original designs while acknowledging updates.
• 🎶 The speaker is not a fan of the new transformation song, describing it as outdated and not innovative, although it serves its purpose in the context of the show.
• 💃 The speaker appreciates the acrobatic elements in Flora's transformation, but finds the overall design and execution lacking in originality compared to the previous series.
• 🤷‍♀️ The speaker criticizes the use of exaggerated American theater kid mannerisms in the characters' movements, which contrasts with the European origins of the show.
• 👗 The speaker points out that Flora's new outfit lacks the unique spark of the original but is likely aimed at appealing to a younger, modern audience.
• 🔊 The voice acting during the transformations is noted as not sounding natural, raising questions about how the voiceovers were recorded and executed.
• 👠 The speaker compares Tecna's new outfit to her original one, stating that the updated design is likely more accessible to children but less distinctive and futuristic.
• 🎥 The speaker enjoys the camera work during some transformations, such as Flora's, particularly the shot where she adjusts the camera, showing creativity in the direction.
• 🌑 The speaker is excited about the potential return of Stella's powers related to both the sun and moon, feeling it adds depth to her character.
• 💧 Aisha's transformation is a favorite of the speaker, although there are concerns about the use of teal in her outfit and the loss of her original Morphix powers in favor of water-based effects.
• 🌊 The speaker critiques the animation's use of AI, expressing concerns over how it impacts the uniqueness and diversity in animation, particularly in the hair movement and overall fluidity of the transformations.

Q & A

What is the general sentiment towards the new song introduced in the reboot?

The reviewer expresses that they are not particularly fond of the new song, describing it as outdated and not very innovative. They mention that it's somewhat typical of 2016 music and feels just 'there' rather than standing out.

How does the reviewer feel about Flora's transformation in the reboot?

The reviewer appreciates that Flora's transformation uses familiar elements from magical girl shows, such as acrobatic work, but notes that the overall design lacks attention-grabbing aspects, particularly with the wings. They also mention the transformation is not as unique as the original.

What is the issue with the character mannerisms in the animation, according to the reviewer?

The reviewer criticizes the 'American theater kid' mannerisms that are overly prominent in the characters' movements, which they feel doesn't align with the European origins of the show. They explain that these mannerisms are becoming more common globally due to American media influence but detract from the original feel of the characters.

How does the reviewer feel about Techna's new outfit in the reboot?

The reviewer finds Techna's new outfit less unique than the original, though they understand the reasoning behind it. They feel that the redesign may appeal more to younger audiences and is more accessible but still believe the original design was more innovative and suited Techna's character better.

What is the reviewer's opinion on the overall quality of the animation?

The reviewer finds some aspects of the animation, such as the physics of certain movements (like the hair or character poses), to be problematic. They describe certain moments as feeling unnatural, with static or unrealistic movement, which detracts from the quality of the transformation sequences.

What does the reviewer think about the inclusion of AI-generated elements in the animation?

The reviewer is critical of the use of AI in the animation process, particularly regarding the hair design. They express concern about how AI may be affecting diversity and character in animation, feeling that 3D animation and AI may be sucking the uniqueness and charm from the industry.

How does the reviewer feel about the new designs for Musa's transformation?

The reviewer is generally positive about Musa's transformation, describing her wings and overall look as cute. However, they note that the animation's physics, especially during certain dance movements, look off, which affects the fluidity of the transformation.

What is the reviewer's stance on Aisha's transformation and outfit?

The reviewer appreciates Aisha's transformation, particularly the inclusion of water and waves in the sequence, but they express disappointment that the color scheme is heavily teal, as they feel Aisha's powers should be more associated with green and Morphix, which was a unique aspect of her original design.

What specific element does the reviewer feel was overlooked in Stella's transformation?

The reviewer points out that Stella's wings look better in context than in the trailer but still wish they had a glassy appearance rather than a foiled material. They also express a preference for a more nuanced use of the sun and moon powers in the transformation, as Stella's powers were originally seen as more mystical and complex.

How does the reviewer view the overall impact of the reboot on fans, particularly younger audiences?

The reviewer believes the reboot may be trying to appeal more to younger fans, with designs and transformations being more toned down and accessible. However, they also feel that some of the original character traits and attitudes, especially with Flora, have been softened to make the characters more relatable to a broader, younger audience.