How a Remake Should NOT be Made

Summary

In this critical commentary, L dissects the Silent Hill 2 remake, arguing that nostalgia clouds gamers' judgment and prevents them from recognizing its flaws. The video emphasizes frustrations with the game's combat mechanics, likening them to a poorly designed mini-game that detracts from the horror experience. L contrasts this remake with the successful Dead Space remake, highlighting the need for modern updates that improve upon outdated systems. The host's passionate critique serves as a rallying cry for gamers to demand better from remakes, ultimately questioning the industry's commitment to innovation and player satisfaction.

Takeaways

• 🎮 The remake of Silent Hill 2 is criticized for not meeting the expectations of modern gamers, despite nostalgia.
• 🕹️ The game's audio design and graphics may impress, but the overall gameplay experience falls short.
• 👾 Many gamers are blinded by nostalgia and overlook the game's design flaws.
• 😒 The combat mechanics have been described as frustrating, likening them to a turn-based fighting game.
• 🛠️ The design choices in enemy encounters are seen as poor, leading to a negative gameplay experience.
• 🤷‍♂️ Players defending the game argue that the main character's lack of combat skills is intentional, reflecting desperation.
• ⚔️ Playing on hard mode can lead to extreme frustration, suggesting poor balance in difficulty.
• 📉 A successful remake should improve gameplay mechanics, but this version is said to have worsened them.
• 📊 The script compares Silent Hill 2's remake unfavorably to the well-received Dead Space remake.
• 🤔 Ultimately, gameplay quality is emphasized as paramount in any game's success, including remakes.

Q & A

What is the main criticism of the Silent Hill 2 remake according to the speaker?

The speaker criticizes the Silent Hill 2 remake for not adequately improving upon the original game's combat mechanics and design, suggesting it fails to modernize the gameplay experience.

How does the speaker feel about the nostalgia surrounding the original Silent Hill 2?

The speaker believes that nostalgia blinds fans from recognizing the flaws in the remake, suggesting they are overly protective of the original game.

What comparison does the speaker draw between Silent Hill 2 and other games?

The speaker compares Silent Hill 2's remake unfavorably to the Dead Space remake, praising the latter for effectively modernizing the survival horror genre.

What gameplay mechanic does the speaker specifically criticize in the Silent Hill 2 remake?

The speaker criticizes the combat system, describing it as turn-based and likening it to a mini-game, which detracts from the overall gaming experience.

What does the speaker imply about the game design choices made by the developers?

The speaker implies that the developers' design choices are poor and detrimental to the gameplay experience, particularly regarding enemy encounters and combat mechanics.

What does the speaker say about the challenges presented in Silent Hill 2 remake?

The speaker describes the challenges in the remake as frustrating and unfair, suggesting that they lead to a negative gaming experience.

What emotion does the speaker attribute to the character James Sunderland?

The speaker attributes a sense of desperation to James Sunderland, arguing that this does not justify the gameplay mechanics that make combat feel janky and frustrating.

How does the speaker characterize the game's enemy design?

The speaker characterizes the enemy design as problematic, noting that the enemies' tracking abilities can feel unfair and ruin the overall gaming experience.

What reaction does the speaker anticipate from fans of the Silent Hill 2 remake?

The speaker anticipates that fans of the remake will react defensively, potentially feeling anger or frustration at the criticisms presented.

What is the speaker's overall verdict on the Silent Hill 2 remake?

The speaker concludes that despite its atmospheric qualities, the Silent Hill 2 remake is a prime example of how not to remake a game in the modern gaming era.