Elon Musk: Who's Better? Engineers or Scientists?

Summary

In an interview at the USA Science and Engineering Festival, Elon Musk discusses the symbiotic relationship between science and engineering, emphasizing the importance of engineering in driving scientific discoveries. He highlights the slowing pace of physics due to a lack of engineering advancements, such as particle colliders. Musk also shares his motivations for creating companies like PayPal, Tesla, and SpaceX, aiming to expand human consciousness and understanding of the universe. He encourages aspiring entrepreneurs to overcome the fear of starting companies and to focus on creating compelling prototypes to drive change.

Takeaways

• 🔬 Elon Musk is a proponent of engineering, suggesting that engineers often drive scientific discoveries.
• 🌌 Historical figures like Galileo, Faraday, and Maxwell were great engineers who contributed significantly to science.
• 🚀 The lack of advancements in physics is attributed by Musk to a slowdown in engineering, specifically the development of particle colliders.
• 🧠 Musk believes in expanding the scale and scope of consciousness to improve our understanding of the universe.
• 🤔 He emphasizes the importance of asking the right questions, as highlighted by Douglas Adams in 'The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy'.
• 🚀 Musk's ventures like PayPal, Tesla, and SpaceX aim to change human consciousness and operations significantly.
• 💡 The motivation behind his ventures is to grow the scale of human consciousness and understanding.
• 💼 Starting a company involves studying engineering, designing new things, and creating a compelling prototype.
• 💸 Venture capital can provide funding to help take innovative ideas to the next level.
• 🚀 Fear of starting a company should be managed, as the worst outcomes are not dire, according to Musk.

Q & A

Who is Todd Seer interviewing at the USA science and engineering festival?

Todd Seer is interviewing Elon Musk at the USA science and engineering festival.

What is Elon Musk's educational background according to the transcript?

Elon Musk is classically trained as an engineer and a physicist.

Who does Elon Musk believe wins in the debate between scientists and engineers?

Elon Musk suggests that engineers often win the debate, but also acknowledges that many great scientists were actually great engineers.

Who are some examples of individuals that Elon Musk considers to be both scientists and engineers?

Elon Musk mentions Galileo, Faraday, and Maxwell as examples of individuals who were known for their scientific discoveries but were also great engineers.

What does Elon Musk think drives advancements in physics?

Elon Musk believes that engineering, specifically the development of tools like colliders, drives advancements in physics.

Why does Elon Musk think physics has slowed down in recent years?

Elon Musk thinks physics has slowed down due to the lack of engineering advancements, such as the development of a new collider.

What motivates Elon Musk to create companies like PayPal, Tesla, and SpaceX?

Elon Musk is motivated by the desire to grow the scale and scope of consciousness and improve our understanding of the universe.

What advice does Elon Musk give to people who want to make change?

Elon Musk advises people to study engineering, design new things, create a compelling prototype, and not fear starting a company.

What does Elon Musk think is the key to making a difference in the world?

Elon Musk believes that asking the right questions, as highlighted by Douglas Adams in 'The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy', is the key to making a difference.

What is Elon Musk's perspective on the role of venture capital in starting companies?

Elon Musk sees venture capital as a strong industry that provides funding to take ideas to the next level once a compelling prototype is created.

How does Elon Musk view the potential risks of starting a company?

Elon Musk downplays the risks of starting a company, suggesting that the worst that could happen is not starving or dying of exposure.

Outlines

00:00

🚀 Interview with Elon Musk on Science and Engineering

In this interview at the USA Science and Engineering Festival, Todd Seer sits down with Elon Musk to discuss the roles of science and engineering. Elon, trained as a physicist and engineer, is asked to choose between the two professions, to which he responds that engineering often drives scientific discoveries, citing examples like Galileo, Faraday, and Maxwell. He argues that advancements in physics have slowed due to a lack of engineering progress, specifically mentioning the need for a new particle collider. Elon also discusses his ventures like PayPal, Tesla, and SpaceX, emphasizing the importance of expanding human consciousness and understanding of the universe. He suggests that the real challenge is not the information available but the motivation to act on it.

Keywords

💡Engineer

An engineer is a professional who applies scientific principles to design, build, and maintain structures, machines, devices, systems, materials, and processes. In the video, Elon Musk discusses the importance of engineers in driving scientific discoveries and technological advancements. He suggests that engineering often precedes and enables scientific breakthroughs, as exemplified by the necessity of a collider in advancing physics.

💡Scientist

A scientist is a person engaged in a systematic activity to acquire knowledge about the physical or material world through observation and experimentation. The video script mentions scientists like Galileo and Faraday, who were also great engineers, highlighting the interplay between science and engineering.

💡Physics

Physics is a branch of science concerned with the nature and properties of matter and energy. The video discusses how advancements in physics have slowed due to a lack of engineering progress, specifically referencing the development of a collider, which is a tool used in particle physics.

💡Collider

A collider is a type of particle accelerator used by physicists to study the properties of matter and test the predictions of quantum mechanics. In the transcript, Musk points out that the lack of advancement in building new colliders has hindered progress in physics, emphasizing the role of engineering in scientific research.

💡Consciousness

Consciousness refers to an individual's awareness or perception of their thoughts, feelings, and surroundings. Musk mentions growing the 'scale and scope of consciousness' as a motivation for his ventures, suggesting that by expanding our understanding and capabilities, we can better comprehend the universe.

💡PayPal

PayPal is an online payment system that enables users to make transactions electronically. In the video, PayPal is mentioned as one of Musk's ventures that has significantly changed the way people conduct financial transactions.

💡Tesla

Tesla is an electric vehicle and clean energy company. The video script references Tesla as an example of Musk's efforts to change the way humans operate by promoting sustainable transportation.

💡SpaceX

SpaceX is a private aerospace manufacturer and space transportation company. The transcript mentions SpaceX in the context of space exploration and the commercialization of space travel, indicating Musk's ambition to make space travel more accessible.

💡Venture Capital

Venture capital refers to the financial capital provided to early-stage, high-potential businesses in exchange for equity or a stake in the company. In the video, Musk talks about the importance of venture capital in funding innovative startups, like his own, to help them grow and develop new technologies.

💡Prototype

A prototype is an early sample or model of a product built to test a concept or process. Musk advises that starting a company involves creating a compelling prototype as soon as possible to demonstrate the viability of an idea, which is a key step in securing funding and moving a project forward.

💡Apathy

Apathy is a lack of interest, enthusiasm, or concern. The video script discusses overcoming apathy as a challenge, encouraging individuals to not just be passive consumers of information but to actively engage and contribute to making changes in the world.

Highlights

Elon Musk believes that engineering often drives scientific discoveries.

Historic figures like Galileo, Faraday, and Maxwell were great engineers.

Physics advancements have slowed due to a lack of engineering progress in particle colliders.

Engineering advancements are crucial for driving physics discoveries.

Elon Musk's ventures aim to grow the scale and scope of human consciousness.

Improving our understanding of the universe is a key motivation for Musk.

The importance of asking the right questions rather than just having answers.

Musk discusses overcoming apathy and taking action on the information we have.

Starting a company is easier if you study engineering and design new things.

Creating a compelling prototype is crucial for starting a company.

Venture capital can provide funding to take ideas to the next level.

Musk encourages people not to fear starting a company.

The worst-case scenario of starting a company is not as bad as one might think.

Musk's discussion on space exploration and the commercialization of space travel.

The interview took place at the USA Science and Engineering Festival.

Musk's ventures like PayPal, Tesla, and SpaceX are changing human operations.

Transcripts

[Music]

so my name is Todd Seer we are here at

the USA science and engineering festival

and I'm sitting down with Elon Musk to

talk about science engineering and the

generations to come now Elon you're

you're classically trained as an

engineer as a physicist is physicist

here's the question then what's better a

scientist or an engineer who wins

engineer every time uh well I wouldn't

say every time and a lot of people that

sort of um are known for their

scientific discoveries are actually

really great Engineers like Galileo for

example okay okay very good or Faraday

or really Maxwell or anyone I mean I I

think you know it is an interesting

debate as to sort of does Engineering

Drive discoveries in physics or just

physics you know just drive discoveries

in engineering I think actually it's

mostly engineering um and I think for

example in in recent years um if you

look at how how much physics has slowed

down because the lack of really um

Engineering in the form of a collider so

everybody's just sitting around waiting

for a bloody collider so I'd say if if

physics was really driving things why

aren't the advancements being made uh

and and it's I think it's it's clearly

uh the engineering of of the collider is

what drives the advancements interesting

now you've with between PayPal and more

than just these things of course but

you've got PayPal Tesla and SpaceX all

three of these things are huge

challenges huge ways basically changing

the way people think what drives you to

try to find these opportunities but not

in a economic way but these ways to kind

of change the way human beings

operate I think it's good to grow the

scale and cons the scale scope and scale

of

Consciousness um and uh and thus improve

our understanding of the universe and um

and and the sort of and and in fact to

improve the sort of questions that we we

we would ask you know as sort of as

dougas Adam said said in TR guide of the

Galaxy the real trick is the question

not the answer there's so much

information but the need to kind of get

over the apathy of having the

information to doing something about it

now not all of us are going to start

space exploration companies and electric

vehicle

companies this the scale changes but

what can people do or what what

motivations do people need to harness to

try to make change as opposed to just

reading about

change

um and that's not supposed to be an easy

question I don't oh it's it's this well

um like I said I think um if if you if

you study engineering and and you figure

out how to design new things um then um

It's relatively easy to start a company

um you just need to get a few

like-minded people um with you and and

then focus on creating a prototype a

compelling prototype as soon as possible

um and then that you know there's

there's a there's a strong Venture uh

Capital industry in this in this country

that will give you funding to take

things to the next level um and that

that's all there is to it um and you

might if you know tried a few times you

might may or may not succeed but um I

think sometimes people fear fear

starting a company too much um you know

they have to say really what's worst

that could go wrong you're not going to

starve to death you're not going to die

of exposure um what's the worst that

could go wrong you

know so I've been speaking with Elon

Musk here at the USA science and

engineering Festival uh in our next

video you can learn more about what Elon

has done with space exploration and the

commercialization of space

[Music]

travel