DNB vs MD/MS - The TRUTH (NEET PG 2024)

Summary

In this video, Dr. Ric duer addresses common concerns regarding the DNB (Diplomate of National Board) program, particularly for medical students unsure whether to pursue an MD or DNB at their rank. He discusses the importance of choosing the right branch over the college's reputation, the dilemma of whether to retake exams or accept a DNB position, and provides insights on making an informed decision about the hospital for DNB training. Dr. duer also shares his personal experience and offers advice on factors to consider when selecting a DNB hospital, emphasizing the need for hands-on experience and infrastructure.

Takeaways

• 😌 The speaker has been receiving many questions about DNB (Diplomate of National Board), especially regarding whether to pursue MD or DNB at certain ranks.
• 🏥 The speaker advises visiting hospitals to decide on a DNB hospital, emphasizing the importance of firsthand experience.
• 📈 With a rank of 5,700, the speaker was initially unsure about pursuing MD Medicine but eventually chose DNB after discussions with seniors and research.
• 🌟 The speaker stresses that the branch of study should be the top priority when choosing between MD and DNB, as it impacts one's career long-term.
• 🤔 The decision to take a drop (retake the exam) is personal and depends on individual circumstances and confidence in improving the rank.
• 🚫 The speaker warns against compromising on the branch for the sake of getting into a 'good' medical college.
• 🏆 For those who rank within 5K, it's advised to take the DNB in their first choice of branch, even if it's a first attempt.
• 🔄 If the rank is between 5K to 10K and it's the first attempt, considering a drop might be reasonable if there's strong motivation to improve.
• 🚑 For high-end branches like Medicine, DM, and Radio, if the rank is above 10K, the speaker suggests considering a drop if the goal is a prestigious institute.
• 📉 The passing percentage for DNB is lower and considered tougher than MD, but the speaker believes primary DNB candidates are well-prepared.
• 🏥 The speaker suggests visiting potential DNB hospitals to understand their offerings and not just rely on previous year's trends or rankings.

Q & A

What are the common doubts and questions regarding DNB that the speaker has been receiving?

The speaker has been receiving doubts and questions about DNB, particularly whether to pursue MD or DNB at certain ranks, the difficulty level and pass percentage of DNB, and details about the course curriculum including academics, rounds, and hands-on experience.

What is the speaker's advice for selecting a DNB hospital?

The speaker advises visiting the hospitals you are considering, especially those within your rank range, to get a firsthand experience and understand what each hospital offers.

Why was the speaker initially confused about their rank of 5,700?

The speaker was initially confused because they wanted to pursue medicine, but with a rank of 5,700, they realized they wouldn't get into MD medicine at a decent hospital, which led to the consideration of other options like MD Pediatrics or taking a drop.

What was the speaker's final decision regarding pursuing DNB or taking a drop after their internship?

After considering their options and discussing with seniors, the speaker decided to pursue DNB instead of taking a drop, as they felt it was the right decision at the time.

What is the most important factor to consider while approaching DNB counseling, according to the speaker?

The most important factor to consider while approaching DNB counseling is the branch of study, as it will stay with you for your lifetime and is more important than the city or the type of college.

What is the speaker's opinion on taking a drop after not getting a desired rank in the first attempt?

The speaker believes that taking a drop is a personal decision and depends on individual circumstances. They suggest considering factors like the rank, the branch, and personal motivation before deciding.

How does the speaker feel about the pass percentage for DNB exams?

The speaker acknowledges that the pass percentage for DNB exams is lower and it is tougher to pass compared to MD, but they also mention that primary DNB students prepare for it seriously as it is their degree exam.

What are the key points the speaker suggests considering when deciding to take DNB or MD in high-end branches?

The speaker suggests considering factors like the desire to practice or pursue super speciality (DM), the quality of the hospital and its facilities, and the potential for learning and exposure in the chosen branch.

Why does the speaker recommend visiting hospitals before deciding on a DNB program?

The speaker recommends visiting hospitals to get a clear understanding of what each hospital offers, as different hospitals have different pros and cons, and to make an informed decision based on personal priorities.

What is the speaker's advice for those who are considering DNB in branches like medicine, dermatology, or radio diagnosis?

For high-end branches like medicine, dermatology, or radio diagnosis, the speaker advises considering a drop if the rank is above 10K and the desired branch is not available, or taking DNB from a good city and institute if the rank is between 5 to 10K.