Indonesian FM on occupied Palestine and Indonesia democracy path | Talk to Al Jazeera

Al Jazeera English
25 Feb 202427:55

Summary

TLDRIn an interview with Al Jazeera, Indonesian Foreign Minister Retno Marsudi discusses the nation's strong stance on Palestinian rights amidst the escalating Gaza conflict. Marsudi emphasizes Indonesia's commitment to international law and condemns double standards by Western countries. She highlights Indonesia's diplomatic efforts, including active participation in the International Court of Justice and dialogue with global leaders. Marsudi also addresses Indonesia's constitutional mandate for self-determination and defends its foreign policy principles, including economic diplomacy and the protection of Indonesian nationals abroad.

Takeaways

  • 🌍 The world is focusing on the International Court of Justice (ICJ) due to the escalating conflict in Gaza.
  • 🇮🇩 Indonesia is advocating for Palestinian rights and opposing Israel's occupation of Palestinian territories.
  • 🗣️ Indonesia's constitution mandates support for the right to self-determination, influencing its stance on Palestine.
  • 🛑 Indonesia emphasizes the need for consistent implementation of international law without double standards.
  • 🇺🇸 Discussions with the US highlighted the importance of ceasefire and the two-state solution.
  • 🕌 Indonesia, as a prominent Muslim-majority country, feels a responsibility to advocate for Palestinian rights.
  • 🕊️ The ICJ case is seen as a vital step in addressing long-standing issues between Israel and Palestine.
  • ⚖️ Indonesia rejects normalization with Israel without a two-state solution and continues to support Palestine.
  • 💼 Indonesia's accession to the OECD is a significant step, despite challenges posed by Israel.
  • 🔄 Indonesia's foreign policy has shifted towards economic diplomacy and protecting its nationals abroad.

Q & A

  • Why is the case at the International Court of Justice (ICJ) regarding the occupation of Palestinian territories important to Indonesia?

    -Indonesia has a long-standing commitment to supporting Palestinian rights, as mandated by its constitution. The Indonesian government believes it is their duty to advocate for justice and humanity, particularly in response to the atrocities committed against Palestinians over the past 70 years.

  • What is the Indonesian foreign minister's stance on the implementation of international law?

    -The Indonesian foreign minister emphasizes the importance of implementing international law consistently and without double standards. She criticizes the selective application of international law, particularly by Western countries, and calls for a uniform approach.

  • How does the Indonesian foreign minister view the role of the United States in the Palestinian conflict?

    -The Indonesian foreign minister acknowledges the United States' role but expresses concern over its vetoes in the UN Security Council and the perceived double standards in its approach. She urges the U.S. to maintain its position on issues like displacement and the two-state solution.

  • What is Indonesia's position on normalization with Israel in relation to OECD accession?

    -Indonesia's position is clear: the country will not normalize relations with Israel without the establishment of a two-state solution. The accession to the OECD is not conditional on normalization with Israel, and Indonesia remains firm in its stance.

  • How does Indonesia approach the concept of self-determination in the context of Papua and Maluku?

    -The Indonesian foreign minister distinguishes the situation in Papua and Maluku from the Palestinian issue, emphasizing that they are entirely different cases. She implies that the historical and contextual factors make these situations incomparable.

  • Why hasn't Indonesia signed the Genocide Convention, and what is its position on the issue?

    -Indonesia has not signed the Genocide Convention because there is no national consensus on the matter. However, Indonesia supports the moral principles behind the convention and expresses solidarity with countries like South Africa in their efforts to address genocide-related issues.

  • What concerns have been raised about Indonesia's democracy under President Joko Widodo?

    -Concerns include the nomination of the president's son as a vice presidential candidate and the lowering of the age limit by the Constitutional Court, perceived as nepotism. There are worries about potential setbacks in democratic reforms, but the foreign minister insists that democracy is part of Indonesia's DNA.

  • What legacy does the Indonesian foreign minister believe she leaves after ten years in office?

    -The foreign minister highlights the shift in focus towards economic diplomacy, emphasizing economic cooperation and the protection of Indonesian nationals abroad. She also mentions Indonesia's leadership roles in international forums like the G20 and ASEAN during challenging times.

  • How does the Indonesian foreign minister view the future of Indonesia in the global context?

    -The foreign minister hopes that Indonesia will continue to play a bridging role in the global arena, advocating for collaboration and resilience amidst increasing global uncertainties and challenges.

  • How does the foreign minister justify Indonesia's actions at the international level concerning the Palestinian issue?

    -The foreign minister asserts that Indonesia is actively involved in various international forums, advocating for Palestinian rights. She argues that Indonesia's involvement is often behind the scenes but remains significant and visible in diplomatic efforts.

Outlines

00:00

🌍 Focus Shifts to International Court Over Gaza

The global focus is turning to the International Court of Justice as over 50 nations and various international bodies convene to address the Israeli occupation of Palestinian territories. Indonesia, a long-time advocate for Palestinian rights, is actively participating. The Indonesian government is vocal against Israel's actions, demanding a cessation of unlawful activities and policies. The Indonesian Foreign Minister, Retno Marsudi, emphasizes Indonesia's constitutional mandate to support self-determination and explains Indonesia's commitment to the Palestinian cause.

05:00

🇺🇸 US Double Standards on International Law

The Indonesian Foreign Minister criticizes the inconsistency in the application of international law, highlighting the double standards, especially by Western countries. She stresses the need for consistent implementation of international laws and resolutions, particularly those concerning Palestinian rights and the two-state solution. The minister recalls previous ICJ opinions ignored by Israel and emphasizes the importance of upholding international law without bias.

10:01

🇵🇸 Indonesia's Diplomatic Efforts for Palestine

Indonesia's active role in advocating for Palestinian rights at international forums, including meetings with the US Secretary of State, is highlighted. The Indonesian Foreign Minister discusses her conversations with US officials about displacement issues in Gaza and the importance of a two-state solution. Despite US vetoes on resolutions, Indonesia continues to push for a ceasefire and justice for Palestinians, maintaining its stance on supporting Palestinian independence.

15:04

🕊️ Collective Responsibility and Global Response

The Indonesian Foreign Minister underscores the need for collective global responsibility to address the Palestinian issue. She discusses Indonesia's involvement in diplomatic efforts with the Arab League and the Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) to seek solutions. Despite behind-the-scenes work, she insists Indonesia is highly visible in these efforts. The minister calls for consistent international action and questions why other countries do not face similar sanctions for their policies as Israel does.

20:06

📈 Indonesia's Accession to OECD and Israel's Obstruction

Indonesia's bid to join the OECD, with no preconditions despite Israel's attempts to block it, is detailed. The Indonesian Foreign Minister states that normalization with Israel will only occur upon achieving a two-state solution. The accession process is seen as a prestigious step for Indonesia, and the minister remains firm on maintaining Indonesia's foreign policy principles without compromising on the Palestinian issue.

25:06

🇮🇩 Internal Self-Determination and Global Democracy

The Indonesian Foreign Minister addresses questions about self-determination within Indonesia, distinguishing it from the Palestinian issue. She explains the ongoing process of national consensus needed for signing the Genocide Convention, supporting South Africa's case morally despite not being a party. The minister reflects on Indonesia's democratic journey, asserting democracy as part of Indonesia's DNA despite recent political challenges.

🗳️ Indonesia's Democratic Journey and Future Prospects

The discussion covers Indonesia's democratic progress, the recent nomination of the president's son, and concerns about nepotism. The Indonesian Foreign Minister affirms the commitment to democracy despite vulnerabilities and external perceptions. She reflects on her decade-long tenure, emphasizing economic diplomacy and protection of nationals abroad. Looking ahead, she hopes Indonesia continues to play a bridging role in global affairs, fostering resilience and collaboration.

Mindmap

Keywords

💡International Court of Justice (ICJ)

The International Court of Justice (ICJ) is the principal judicial body of the United Nations, tasked with settling legal disputes between states and providing advisory opinions on international legal issues. In the video, the ICJ is a focal point as over 50 nations, including Indonesia, converge to address the Israeli occupation of Palestinian territories.

💡Israeli occupation of Palestinian territories

This refers to Israel's military and administrative control over territories claimed by Palestinians, including the West Bank, East Jerusalem, and Gaza. The video discusses international efforts, led by nations like Indonesia, to address the legality and human rights implications of this occupation at the ICJ.

💡Indonesia

Indonesia is highlighted in the video as a country with a long-standing commitment to advocating for Palestinian rights. The Indonesian government, represented by Foreign Minister Retno Marsudi, speaks out against Israel's occupation and stresses the importance of international law and self-determination.

💡Palestinian rights

The rights of Palestinians, including the right to self-determination and freedom from occupation, are a central theme in the video. Indonesia and other nations argue for the protection and respect of these rights through international legal channels like the ICJ.

💡Self-determination

Self-determination is the principle that a nation has the right to freely choose its sovereignty and international political status without interference. The Indonesian Foreign Minister emphasizes this principle, citing its inclusion in Indonesia's constitution, as a reason for Indonesia's support of Palestinian rights.

💡Two-state solution

The two-state solution is a proposed framework for resolving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict by establishing an independent Palestinian state alongside Israel. The video discusses Indonesia's advocacy for this solution and the challenges posed by Israeli and US positions on the matter.

💡Double standards

Double standards refer to the application of different sets of principles for similar situations. In the video, the Indonesian Foreign Minister criticizes the inconsistent application of international law by Western countries, particularly in the context of the Israeli occupation of Palestinian territories.

💡UN Security Council resolutions

These are decisions made by the UN Security Council, often addressing issues of international peace and security. The video mentions that numerous resolutions regarding the Israeli-Palestinian conflict have been adopted but not implemented, highlighting the need for consistent enforcement.

💡Ceasefire

A ceasefire is a temporary suspension of fighting, typically one that is agreed upon by all parties involved in a conflict. The video stresses the importance of a ceasefire in Gaza to halt ongoing violence and human suffering, as advocated by the Indonesian Foreign Minister.

💡Veto power

Veto power is the ability to unilaterally stop an official action, particularly in the context of the UN Security Council. The video discusses the use of veto power by countries like the United States to block resolutions related to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, complicating efforts to address the situation.

💡OECD accession

The process of becoming a member of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD). The video touches on Indonesia's efforts to join the OECD and the challenges posed by Israel's opposition, reflecting Indonesia's commitment to its principles regarding the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

💡Humanitarian crisis

A humanitarian crisis refers to a singular event or a series of events that are threatening in terms of health, safety, or well-being of a community or large group of people. The video discusses the ongoing humanitarian crisis in Gaza, characterized by daily atrocities and a high death toll, and the need for international intervention.

Highlights

The world is now shifting its focus to the International Court of Justice regarding the Israeli occupation of Palestinian territories.

Indonesia, with a long track record of advocating for Palestinian rights, is at the forefront of the case.

Indonesian Foreign Minister Retno Marsudi emphasizes the country's constitutional mandate to support the right to self-determination.

Marsudi highlights the importance of consistent implementation of international law without double standards.

The minister criticizes Western countries for their inconsistent application of international law.

Marsudi underscores Indonesia's commitment to the two-state solution and the necessity for the US to uphold this stance.

Indonesia will take any possible avenue to defend justice and humanity for the Palestinian people.

Marsudi mentions Indonesia's active role in diplomatic efforts, including visits to the capitals of UN Security Council's permanent members.

Indonesia's involvement in international discussions and meetings emphasizes its visibility and commitment to the Palestinian cause.

The minister discusses the importance of collective responsibility and the role of P5 countries in resolving the issue.

Indonesia's accession to the OECD and the challenges posed by Israel's opposition are addressed.

The principle of a two-state solution remains a benchmark for Indonesia's normalization with Israel.

Marsudi distinguishes between Indonesia's stance on self-determination for Palestine and internal regional issues within Indonesia.

Indonesia's delay in signing the genocide convention is due to the need for national consensus.

The minister reflects on Indonesia's commitment to democracy despite challenges and the evolving political landscape.

Transcripts

play00:00

the

play00:07

world I'ma FAS in the hake as the war on

play00:10

Gaza escalates the world is now shifting

play00:13

its focus to the international court of

play00:15

justice where more than 50 Nations and

play00:18

several International bodies have

play00:20

converged to address the Israeli

play00:22

occupation of Palestinian

play00:24

territories Indonesia a country with a

play00:26

long track record of advocating for

play00:28

Palestinian rights is one of them its

play00:31

government has spoken out against

play00:33

Israel's decades long occupation and

play00:35

called for international law to be

play00:38

respected Israel must cease

play00:42

completely

play00:43

unconditionally and

play00:45

immediately all of its unlawful action

play00:49

and policies in the occupied Palestinian

play00:53

territory as the nation makes its case

play00:55

at the icj the Indonesian foreign

play00:58

minister ratno masudi talks to Al

play01:05

jazer Indonesia's foreign minister rno

play01:07

marui thank you for talking to Al jazer

play01:10

thank you for having me Indonesia is one

play01:12

of the countries on the Forefront of the

play01:14

case at the international court of

play01:15

justice on the legality of the

play01:17

occupation of the Palestinian

play01:19

territories why is this case so

play01:21

important to Indonesia look at what

play01:23

happened in the last 70 years atrocities

play01:28

brutalities killing almost every day

play01:31

especially currently in in in Gaza

play01:36

so the question is can we stay still M

play01:41

observing this very worrying and sad

play01:45

situation it is not and in Indonesia in

play01:49

particular our constitution mandated

play01:52

about it about the right to

play01:56

self-determination so it is mandated in

play01:58

our constitution in Indonesian con

play01:59

Constitution so there is no other way

play02:02

that

play02:03

Indonesia has to be in the Forefront for

play02:06

the Palestinian cause um in this case is

play02:10

before the icj but we have of course

play02:13

seen over the decades that the situation

play02:16

hasn't improved right yeah for the

play02:18

Palestinian people we have had uh an

play02:20

opinion from the icj before 20 years ago

play02:24

Israel has completely ignored it why do

play02:27

you think this time this case will make

play02:30

a

play02:30

difference the situation again number

play02:34

one I want to respond first about the

play02:37

implementation with the of the decision

play02:40

of the UN resolution and I mention it

play02:43

again and again in almost every meetings

play02:47

that I have including during the G20

play02:50

friend ministers meeting I mentioned

play02:53

about please avoid double

play02:56

standard we

play02:58

said we need the international law we

play03:02

need to uphold it and implement it in

play03:06

consistent manner so to who did you say

play03:09

no double standards to all to all of us

play03:12

any anyone in particular maybe the US

play03:14

Secretary of State I say it to all

play03:17

before the G20 meeting and Al also in

play03:20

any meetings because implementing the

play03:24

international law in a consistent manner

play03:27

because you feel it's not happening

play03:29

right now happening as you mentioned

play03:31

there is a rule before of the icj it did

play03:35

not I mean the application is not there

play03:38

and how many un Security Council

play03:42

resolution have already been adopted for

play03:46

the Palestinian including the mentioning

play03:49

of the two-state solution so again the

play03:53

implementation is very important and I

play03:57

mean so many countries saying about the

play04:00

international law international law rule

play04:03

base

play04:04

order say it implement it in a

play04:08

consistent uh Manner and that's what you

play04:11

mean with double standards right you're

play04:12

talking about countries like the United

play04:14

States or what what other countries are

play04:16

you feeling now are having a double

play04:19

standard well

play04:21

uh

play04:23

particularly the Western countries the

play04:26

quite often mention about the

play04:28

international law uh rule based but

play04:31

again it applies to all it applies to

play04:33

all whenever we see it please also do it

play04:37

in a consistent manner but not pick and

play04:40

choose because if it is pick and choose

play04:44

then what happened is on uh on the

play04:47

Palestinian uh people is just one of the

play04:50

very bad example how double standard

play04:54

applies in our uh life but Indonesia has

play04:58

a very close Rel relationship with the

play05:00

United States right you had a meeting

play05:02

also with Anthony blinkin the the US

play05:05

Secretary of State in in Brazil during

play05:07

the G20 meeting what kind of pressure

play05:10

can you put I mean or is it the

play05:13

dependency you have from the United

play05:15

States that also with holds Indonesia

play05:18

back because you're worried about the

play05:21

relationship um I had a very good

play05:23

conversation and very good um

play05:26

communication with Anthony blinkin so we

play05:30

had a good communication I can convey

play05:34

the position of Indonesia and especially

play05:37

when I was in

play05:39

Brazil I mentioned about number

play05:42

one why the US FedEd again the

play05:47

resolution number two I mention about

play05:50

how important two issues that should be

play05:54

upheld by the US number one is about

play05:58

displacement

play06:00

because not everybody is worried about

play06:02

the displacement especially on the

play06:04

southern part of Gaza in

play06:07

Raa so and the US uh Administration

play06:11

clearly mentioned against it so I said

play06:14

that please keep it but they have also

play06:17

again veto the resolution just a few

play06:19

days ago the dis I think the the

play06:22

position of the US is very clear so

play06:23

that's why I mentioned about the issue

play06:25

but how do you feel about the V2 uh let

play06:29

me continue on the number two that I

play06:31

mentioned to uh secretary

play06:35

blinkin the importance of us to keep

play06:39

their position on the two-state solution

play06:42

because I'm really worried about this

play06:44

two-state solution and the uh government

play06:48

of the uh the Prime Minister Netanyahu

play06:51

already mentioned that there is no

play06:52

two-state solution there is no

play06:54

Palestinian solution so what about all

play06:58

the decision that we have taken in the

play07:00

UN which we have to respect it so I just

play07:04

want to present this is the resolution

play07:06

this is the decision that we have taken

play07:10

which you involve in it and what we need

play07:14

is to implement it but not to cut it as

play07:18

if that there is nothing there is

play07:20

nothing there is no resolution on the

play07:23

twoed solution so what kind of response

play07:25

do you get if you say this to uh to blol

play07:28

for example secretary B mentioned yes uh

play07:31

the US maintain the position on two

play07:36

issues that I mention that is on the

play07:38

displacement and on the two-state

play07:40

solution but I want to ask you again how

play07:42

do you respond about the veto that again

play07:45

the US has has put down on on a

play07:47

resolution on on a ceasefire because we

play07:50

know that hundreds of people in Gaza are

play07:51

dying every day yeah I convey my

play07:55

position that the ceasefire is very

play07:57

important because ceasefire fire is a

play08:00

Kem changer and I mention it before the

play08:02

T20 meeting ceire is a Kem changer we C

play08:07

fire I'm afraid that this situation will

play08:11

continue but again what uh mentioned uh

play08:14

by secretary blinkin during uh my

play08:17

meeting uh the meeting with me is

play08:19

exactly like the same of the statement

play08:22

by the permanent representative of the

play08:25

US uh at the UN during the UNS meeting

play08:30

when the US V but Indonesia of course is

play08:33

is a very important player it's the

play08:35

largest Muslim country in the world has

play08:38

a very strong cause uh for the

play08:40

Palestinian people how do you feel as a

play08:43

as a minister representing Indonesia in

play08:45

a in this in this Circuit of

play08:47

international leaders who who don't seem

play08:49

to do anything at the moment I always

play08:52

mention that Indonesia will take any

play08:55

possible Avenue to defend

play09:00

Justice to defend humanity and to be

play09:03

with the Palestinian uh uh people

play09:06

because as I mentioned to you it's

play09:08

already over 70 years and I recall what

play09:12

happened in bandom the Asia Africa

play09:15

Summit paltin 19 in

play09:18

1955 Palestine is the only country who

play09:22

did not

play09:24

enjoy Freedom uh Independence yet so we

play09:29

owe to the Palestinian uh uh people and

play09:33

again number two because it is in in

play09:36

Constitution and number three though I

play09:40

always uh mention that the issue of

play09:42

Palestine is nothing to do with the

play09:45

religious issue it is about the

play09:48

principle but I think the voice of

play09:51

Indonesia as the largest Muslim uh

play09:54

population um is very important because

play09:57

you you will get a lot of pressure I

play09:59

know you have a lot of pressure from

play10:01

Islamic organizations in Indonesia to do

play10:03

more right about the situation in Gaza

play10:06

don't you feel it Indonesia is yeah is

play10:09

kind of invisible right now on the world

play10:11

stage if you look at the situation in

play10:13

Gaza should Indonesia not have a more

play10:15

prominent role no Indonesia for this Cas

play10:19

is very feasible it's very feasible and

play10:24

well we don't see much right if you see

play10:26

what's going on between Europe the

play10:27

Middle East the US and and where was no

play10:30

no we are very visible uh I I I'll tell

play10:32

you um during the U the as the summit of

play10:38

uh Arab Leakes and the

play10:40

OIC Indonesia represented by the FR

play10:43

minister is one of the foreign minister

play10:46

that assigned by the leaders of Arab

play10:49

League and also the OIC

play10:52

to make effort to find ways to take uh

play10:58

uh toward the solution of the situation

play11:00

so together with the foreign minister of

play11:02

Arab Saudi Jordan egyp Qatar turkey

play11:06

Nigeria Indonesia and of course

play11:09

Palestine uh we visited capitals of five

play11:13

permanent members of the UN Security

play11:16

Council and then when was that uh it was

play11:19

in November it was in November so we

play11:21

visited every capital of P5 countries

play11:26

and we also had a meeting with with uh

play11:30

Norway in Oslo I could not make uh make

play11:33

it at that time but the rest of the

play11:36

group faced Oslo met the foreign

play11:38

minister of Norway not only Norway but

play11:40

also with the NAIC countries plus with

play11:43

the banalu but have you been able to

play11:45

make a difference during that visit yeah

play11:48

at least for example during the

play11:50

conversation and I just met also the uh

play11:53

new foreign minister of of France so we

play11:55

tried to compare not and we tried to

play11:58

under line the importance of their

play12:02

contribution to solve the issue because

play12:06

we thought their contribution the

play12:08

situation will go nowhere so in terms of

play12:12

pales uh Palestinian issue Indonesia is

play12:15

almost everywhere e but not very visible

play12:19

maybe behind the scenes but we don't

play12:20

really see it in the Forefront maybe you

play12:23

too Focus you're too focus on on the uh

play12:26

surrounding countries but in every

play12:28

meeting

play12:29

about Palestine Indonesia is always in

play12:32

the Forefront in your speech uh you said

play12:35

that all the countries all the states

play12:37

are responsible they have an obligation

play12:40

shouldn't the world Step Up much more in

play12:41

that

play12:42

direction I think the word should sh

play12:46

shall Step Up um you mentioned about the

play12:49

collective responsibility the collective

play12:52

Duty it's true we need that we need that

play12:57

especially especially once again the P5

play13:00

the member of Security Council they have

play13:03

their responsibility they have their

play13:05

duty to end the

play13:09

atrocities and but they use the veto

play13:11

every time and again yeah well that is

play13:13

the issue that is the issue so once

play13:17

again without Collective

play13:20

responsibility it's very difficult and

play13:22

you mentioned about

play13:24

sanction um in a conversation with a

play13:27

number of colleagues

play13:29

I mentioned about if this kind of Acts

play13:35

this kind of

play13:37

policies does by other

play13:41

countries what will be can you imagine

play13:43

what will be the reaction of the word

play13:46

what I can imagine is list of sanction

play13:50

may be kicking off the country from many

play13:53

organization will happen but what about

play13:56

this it's quite OB obious it's it

play14:00

happens every day but I mean it's unimag

play14:06

unimaginable why we cannot solve the

play14:10

issue because again the responsibility

play14:15

should be ours all of us has the

play14:18

responsibility uh your country Indonesia

play14:20

has started accession uh discussions

play14:23

with the oecd the uh Organization for

play14:25

economic development and cooperation as

play14:27

the first country in soueast Asia it's a

play14:30

very prestigious thing but there were

play14:33

some reports that Israel who is also a

play14:35

member was trying to block your

play14:38

accession have you have you been forced

play14:40

to make some compromises there no no no

play14:43

I mean um I make my statement very clear

play14:47

since the the very beginning of course

play14:49

the accession is there there is a

play14:51

discussion the Dynamics I I fully uh

play14:55

monitor the situation I had a very good

play14:58

conversation communication with the

play15:00

Secretary General of the OIC oecd and I

play15:03

talk before the decision I talk to

play15:07

almost all European Union foreign

play15:10

ministers in they supported you

play15:14

everybody support but Israel was trying

play15:16

to block it and I mention that if the

play15:21

trade off is between accession and

play15:27

normalization with Israel now the answer

play15:33

is simple

play15:36

no so so finally they decide to um to

play15:42

accept the accession of

play15:44

Indonesia this is just a beginning IU

play15:48

this is just a beginning so there was no

play15:49

precondition from there's no

play15:51

precondition we will see because some

play15:54

country needs about five years some

play15:56

countries even need eight years

play15:59

if I mentioned the Benchmark for

play16:02

Indonesia to normalize the relation with

play16:05

Israel actually is very simple and we do

play16:08

not create new element in it that is the

play16:11

two-state solution it's already

play16:13

mentioned everywhere so The Benchmark

play16:16

Remains the two-state solution If Today

play16:19

Palestine got the independence there is

play16:21

a two State solution then immediately

play16:25

tomorrow normalization will be there

play16:27

asize that but it's a prestigious thing

play16:30

as I said right it means a lot for

play16:31

Indonesia this this uh membership would

play16:34

you make that choice really on principal

play16:36

grounds to not become a member because

play16:40

Israel is there and is trying to to

play16:42

block it once again the process just

play16:45

started so I don't want to give the

play16:48

hypothetical uh answer or it let us see

play16:52

what is happening now the processes are

play16:55

starting but they understand the

play16:58

principle of the Indonesia uh foreign

play17:00

policy it's very clear you talked a lot

play17:04

about

play17:04

self-determination right in your speech

play17:07

at the icj Indonesia had of course also

play17:09

in the past some groups within the

play17:11

country asking for self-determination

play17:13

the papan people in the East and you

play17:15

have people in in the malas there were

play17:18

even some people protesting what do you

play17:20

tell them about

play17:21

self-determination do you think that the

play17:24

case is

play17:26

similar I'm asking you

play17:29

I don't think I mean

play17:31

comparing the issue that you mentioned

play17:33

with Palestine issue is completely

play17:37

completely different things that is what

play17:39

I can see and can you explain

play17:42

why uh well I mean if you look at from

play17:46

all the angles all the reason it's I

play17:49

mean without thought explaining in

play17:51

details a different it's quite it's

play17:54

quite uh it's quite clear that comparing

play17:58

uh I mean we don't have to compare or we

play18:00

cannot compare to be more exact we

play18:02

cannot compare those two cases but you

play18:05

can't explain a bit further why two our

play18:08

viewers who want to know because I I

play18:10

think they might not know I just I just

play18:12

give one example the historical

play18:15

background that's

play18:17

it so Indonesia was also considering to

play18:20

support the case of uh South Africa at

play18:23

the genocide case right at the icj but

play18:27

then uh that's impossible because

play18:29

Indonesia hasn't signed the genocide

play18:32

convention why is that why we are not

play18:35

there yet yeah yeah well the process is

play18:38

not is not uh re uh uh does not reach

play18:41

the final states of course to be a party

play18:45

of a convention it is time it takes time

play18:50

and we are not yet to reach the

play18:54

consensus within the country about uh uh

play18:58

being a party of the genocide um

play19:01

convention but I talk with um South

play19:05

Africa forign minister in uh Brazil and

play19:08

we discussed about it and I mentioned to

play19:10

her clearly though Indonesia is not in

play19:16

the convention is not a party of the

play19:19

convention but we give the moral support

play19:22

what South Africa is doing uh right now

play19:25

because the vast majority of countries

play19:27

is is a signatory to the genocide

play19:29

convention I think it's only like 40

play19:31

countries who haven't ratified it right

play19:33

and Indonesia is one of them is it has

play19:36

it to do with the past with with what

play19:37

happened

play19:38

nation5 the national consensus is needed

play19:41

in every convention that we will uh

play19:46

choose to be uh a party a state party

play19:50

and every countries of of course every

play19:52

country has a a different view but every

play19:55

country needs also their national uh

play19:58

consensus like Indonesia but does it

play20:00

does it have to do with things that

play20:01

happened like more than 50 years ago

play20:03

like in 1965 when there was a lot of

play20:05

different regime right totally different

play20:07

but there been as I mentioned to you I

play20:10

mean the national consensus is not there

play20:14

yet Indonesia has been uh called a

play20:17

success story if you look at the democra

play20:20

democratization right I was a witness

play20:22

myself I've been in Indonesia for a long

play20:24

time uh and from an authoritarian regime

play20:27

to democracy

play20:28

Indonesia was seen as an example uh

play20:31

under this current president joku Doo

play20:33

It's been sad that there is been some

play20:36

setbacks on uh democracy and one of the

play20:39

examples is what happened with the

play20:41

nomination of his own son as a vice

play20:43

presidential candidate and there was a

play20:45

change uh in the Constitutional Court to

play20:48

lower the age limit for a vice

play20:50

presidential candidate which was

play20:52

accepted by the court and the the the

play20:54

ruling judge happens to be the

play20:56

brother-in-law of the president

play20:58

himself this doesn't sound like the

play21:01

Reformation the reforms that I witnessed

play21:04

in Indonesia in all those years do you

play21:06

see this also as a setback and how do

play21:08

you explain this to to colleagues for

play21:10

example around the world well every

play21:15

democracy um

play21:18

has has always encountered Dynamics or

play21:22

challenges but rest assured rest assured

play21:27

that democracy is already being of the

play21:31

DNA of

play21:34

Indonesia how if you mention if you

play21:36

mention about the up and down you

play21:39

mention about it up and

play21:42

down as long as the DNA is there in our

play21:47

blood I mean but isn't it vulnerable if

play21:49

you look around the world democracy is

play21:51

on decline not only in Indonesia but in

play21:53

other countries too it's a vulnerable

play21:55

thing it's vulnerable thing it's

play21:57

vulnerable thing and democracy is not

play22:01

falling from the sky but we have to

play22:04

nurture it and I think Indonesian

play22:08

people remains committed to nurture to

play22:14

build

play22:15

democracy because again after being a

play22:18

democratic country more than how many

play22:21

years more than 20 25 25 years I mean

play22:25

being a democratic country for 25 years

play22:27

is very young it is but 25 years is

play22:31

enough for us to said that democracy is

play22:35

being one of the DNA of Indonesia but

play22:38

would you then condemn what happened at

play22:39

the Constitutional

play22:42

Court people call it nepotism what I can

play22:46

say is that whatever happened democracy

play22:50

is part of the DNA of Indonesia the

play22:52

other problem is with democracy might be

play22:55

the the election of Pabo subbiano as the

play22:58

new uh president of Indonesia uh he is

play23:01

known as someone who has a a dark past

play23:04

human rights abuses in the past and also

play23:07

was banned by the United States for 20

play23:09

years and he's now elected and very

play23:11

possibly will be the next president of

play23:14

Indonesia how worried are you with him

play23:16

as the president about

play23:19

democracy again IU I mentioned already

play23:21

mention about the Democracy but I think

play23:24

as you mentioned um during uh before the

play23:29

conversation that this interview will be

play23:32

focused on the Palestinian issue so I

play23:36

think I'm enough conveying my message

play23:39

about democracy that democracy is

play23:42

already part of the Indonesian DNA and

play23:44

we have the commitment to strengthen

play23:48

democracy whatever the situation is so

play23:51

you would be part of the new government

play23:54

as the foreign

play23:56

minister uh it is very difficult uh

play24:00

question uh for me IU I've been in my

play24:04

position for 10 years so I think it's

play24:06

long enough really yes it is long enough

play24:09

to be a friend Minister for 10 years in

play24:12

those 10 years A lot has changed right

play24:14

in the world if you look back because I

play24:17

mean it's been a very turbulent time I

play24:20

think worldwide we just been discussing

play24:22

also the changing World Order uh also uh

play24:26

double standard credibility of the West

play24:30

how do you see after 10 years where the

play24:32

world is going more uncertain more

play24:36

instable that is what I what what I see

play24:39

right now I'm a bit worried about the

play24:42

situation if there is no commitment from

play24:46

all of us to make it better but I try

play24:50

also to see from the other side of the

play24:53

coin in any challenge in any Dynamic

play24:57

situ

play24:58

situation there is a sense of resilience

play25:02

there is a sense of collaboration like

play25:06

in Co during the pandemic of

play25:09

covid-19 so let us together nurture that

play25:13

sense of

play25:14

collaboration I've seen a lot on your uh

play25:17

Instagram how active you are as a

play25:19

foreign minister you you have this very

play25:22

cool videos I have to say so so if you

play25:25

look at your career for those 10 years

play25:28

what is the Legacy you leave as a

play25:31

minister it's again it's very difficult

play25:33

because I mean I don't judge myself

play25:37

whether

play25:39

I what sort of Legacy that uh I live uh

play25:43

but during the uh 10

play25:46

years uh it's very obvious there is a

play25:49

change of mindset from the Indonesian uh

play25:53

Diplomat because in the past uh we talk

play25:57

more on politics but now in any in every

play26:01

meeting meeting with any countries the

play26:05

politics is is important as always but

play26:09

economic cooperation becomes more

play26:12

important why economic diplomacy is very

play26:16

important because it reflects the

play26:19

interest of the uh the people and we

play26:23

know that the foreign

play26:25

policy should reflect the national uh

play26:28

interest so that's why the economic

play26:31

diplomacy is very dominant during the

play26:34

last uh 10 years number two is about

play26:37

protection of Indonesian National abroad

play26:40

it becomes more stronger and stronger

play26:43

and I'm so glad that during the 10 years

play26:47

I got the opportunity or Indonesia got

play26:49

the opportunity to lead the ch20 in 2022

play26:53

as well as in asan in

play26:56

2023 both the years are difficult years

play27:00

and sometimes I said that it's like

play27:03

nightmare when we were there but thanks

play27:06

God alhamdulillah that we are able

play27:08

Indonesia is able to pass through that

play27:12

presidency the chairmanship in a good

play27:15

way so where do you want to see

play27:16

Indonesia in 10 years from now what I

play27:19

want to see is Indonesia keep playing as

play27:22

the preaching uh uh to play a preaching

play27:26

role in

play27:28

the in the word which is I can

play27:31

anticipate it that the Gap the

play27:33

differences in the future remains and

play27:36

even maybe sharpen than now Indonesia's

play27:40

foreign minister rno marui thank you for

play27:42

talking to aler thank you very much

play27:45

thank

play27:52

[Music]

play27:53

you

Rate This

5.0 / 5 (0 votes)

関連タグ
ICJIsraelPalestineIndonesiaInternational LawGaza ConflictUN ResolutionsDiplomacyHuman RightsForeign Policy
英語で要約が必要ですか?