How Israel and Palestine Became Enemies | Flashback with Palki Sharma

Summary

The script narrates the history of Zionism and the establishment of Israel, starting with Theodore Herzel's vision for a Jewish homeland in response to anti-Semitism in France. It traces the Jewish diaspora, the struggle for statehood, conflicts with Arabs in Palestine, British involvement, the UN's partition plan, and the wars that led to Israel's expansion. The summary highlights the ongoing conflict, emphasizing the need for a political solution beyond military means for lasting peace.

Takeaways

• 📜 The script narrates the history of Zionism and the establishment of Israel, starting with the experiences of Theodore Herzel in 1891 Paris and his realization of the need for a Jewish homeland.
• 🕋 Herzel's encounter with anti-Semitism in France led him to found the Zionist movement, aiming to create a state where Jews could live free from discrimination.
• 🏛 The script provides a historical background on the Jewish people, tracing their origins to ancient Israelites and the promise of a homeland in present-day Israel.
• 🛡️ It details the series of invasions and the Roman suppression that led to the Jewish diaspora, scattering the Jewish population across different continents.
• 🌍 The 19th and 20th centuries saw a resurgence of Zionism in response to rising anti-Semitism, with Herzel organizing the first World Congress of Zionists in Basel, Switzerland.
• 🏙️ The initial plan for Jewish statehood involved negotiations with the Ottoman Empire, which ultimately rejected Herzel's offer to colonize Palestine in exchange for debt payment.
• 🏘️ Plan B involved Jewish individuals purchasing land in Palestine, leading to the first wave of migration and the establishment of Jewish settlements with European characteristics.
• 🤝 The script describes the support of wealthy Jewish families in America and Europe, particularly the Rothschilds, in funding the land purchases and development in Palestine.
• 📜 The involvement of Britain during World War I is highlighted, with the Balfour Declaration promising a Jewish homeland in Palestine and post-war British control over the region.
• 🛑 The script discusses the tensions and conflicts between the growing Jewish and Arab populations in Palestine, culminating in the British proposal for partition, which was rejected by the Arab side.
• 🏳️ The establishment of Israel in 1948 and the subsequent wars, including the 1948 Arab-Israeli War and the 1967 Six-Day War, are summarized, showing Israel's territorial expansion.
• 🕊️ The current situation is outlined, with Palestine seeking statehood and Israel controlling significant territories, emphasizing the ongoing conflict and the need for a political, not military, solution.

Q & A

Who was Theodore Herzel and what was his significant contribution to the Jewish people?

Theodore Herzel was an Austrian journalist who, after witnessing anti-Semitism in France, became the founder of political Zionism, advocating for the establishment of a Jewish homeland where Jews could live without discrimination.

What was the Dreyfus Affair and how did it influence Herzel's life mission?

The Dreyfus Affair was a military scandal in France where a French Captain, Alfred Dreyfus, was falsely accused of selling military secrets to Germany. Herzel was deeply affected by the anti-Semitism surrounding the case, which led him to his life's mission of finding a homeland for Jews.

Why did Jews leave their ancient homeland in the first place?

Jews left their ancient homeland due to multiple invasions, including those by the Assyrian Empire, Babylonians, Persian Empire, Roman Empire, and Ottomans. The peak of this exodus occurred during the Roman times, following a brutal crackdown on a Jewish revolt.

What was the significance of the World Congress of Zionists and what was decided there?

The World Congress of Zionists, organized by Herzel, was significant as it was the first formal gathering of Zionists. They decided to create a Jewish homeland in Palestine, despite the presence of Arab inhabitants there.

How did the Zionists initially attempt to acquire land in Palestine?

Initially, the Zionists attempted to acquire land in Palestine by proposing to the Ottoman Sultan to pay off foreign debts in exchange for the right to colonize Palestine. However, this offer was rejected.

What was the role of the Haganah in the early 20th century?

The Haganah was a Jewish paramilitary organization founded in 1920 to protect Jewish settlements in Palestine. It played a crucial role in ensuring the safety and security of the growing Jewish population.

Why did the British Empire initially suggest alternatives to Palestine for the Jewish homeland?

The British Empire suggested alternatives like Uganda and Argentina for the Jewish homeland due to the existing Arab population in Palestine and the complexities of establishing a new state in an already inhabited land.

What was the Balfour Declaration and how did it impact the establishment of Israel?

The Balfour Declaration was a letter written by British Foreign Secretary Arthur James Balfour to the Rothschild family, expressing British support for the establishment of a 'national home for the Jewish people' in Palestine. This declaration significantly influenced the eventual creation of the state of Israel.

How did the United Nations propose to resolve the conflict over Palestine in 1947?

The United Nations proposed a plan to partition Palestine into a Jewish state and an Arab state, with Jerusalem being controlled by an international regime. However, this plan was rejected by the Arab side.

What were the outcomes of the 1948 Arab-Israeli War and the 1967 Six-Day War for Israel?

The 1948 Arab-Israeli War resulted in Israel occupying 77% of Palestine, including the West Bank and Gaza, and the displacement of a large number of Palestinians. The 1967 Six-Day War led to Israel capturing additional territories such as the Sinai Peninsula and the Golan Heights.

What are the current positions of Israel and Palestine regarding the establishment of a Palestinian state?

Palestine seeks statehood based on the 1967 borders, including the West Bank, Gaza, and East Jerusalem. Israel, however, argues that it is not possible due to the demographic changes and the expansion of settlements within the West Bank.

Outlines

00:00

📜 The Birth of Zionism and Herzl's Vision

The first paragraph introduces the historical backdrop of Zionism, starting with Theodore Herzl's arrival in Paris in 1891. Herzl, an Austrian journalist, was shocked by the prevalence of anti-Semitism in post-revolution France. The Dreyfus affair, a military scandal involving a Jewish captain falsely accused of treason, further exposed the rampant anti-Jewish sentiment. This led Herzl to a life mission of establishing a homeland for Jews where they could live free from discrimination. Herzl chose Palestine, the ancient homeland of the Jews, as the location for this new state, thus founding the political Zionist movement. The paragraph also delves into the history of Jews as Israelites, their origins around 1000 BC, and the 'Golden Age' of ancient Israel under King David and King Solomon. It explains the series of invasions by various empires that led to the diaspora of Jews across the world, setting the stage for the rise of Zionism in the 19th and 20th centuries.

05:03

🌍 The Struggle for a Jewish Homeland: Zionism and Migration

The second paragraph discusses the early efforts of Zionists to establish a Jewish homeland in Palestine. It details the first wave of migration where Jews began buying land and farming, leading to tensions with the Arab population. The Zionists' actions, such as firing Arab workers and establishing European-style settlements like Tel Aviv, indicated their intent to rule rather than assimilate. Financial support from successful Jewish families in America and Europe facilitated land purchases. The paragraph also covers the political maneuvering of the Zionists, including Herzl's unsuccessful attempt to negotiate with the Ottoman Sultan for colonization rights and the eventual British support for a Jewish homeland in Palestine after World War I. The establishment of the Haganah, a Jewish paramilitary organization, and the subsequent increase in Jewish migration due to Nazi persecution are also highlighted, culminating in the British proposal for partition and the ensuing conflict.

10:04

🕊️ The Quest for Statehood and the Ongoing Conflict

The final paragraph addresses the current state of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. It outlines the Palestinian demand for statehood based on the 1967 borders, encompassing the West Bank, Gaza, and East Jerusalem, while Israel, having built numerous settlements within the West Bank, argues that the demographic situation has changed. The paragraph touches on the Jewish Law of Return, which allows any Jew worldwide to become an Israeli citizen, further complicating the issue. It also briefly recounts the 1967 war, where Israel captured additional territories, and the subsequent return of some lands to neighboring countries. The paragraph concludes by emphasizing that the conflict cannot be resolved militarily and that a political solution is necessary, with the hope that moderates on both sides can work towards a peaceful resolution and future coexistence.

Keywords

💡Theodore Herzel

Theodore Herzel was an Austrian journalist who is considered the founder of political Zionism. The video script describes his arrival in Paris in 1891 and his subsequent realization of the prevalence of anti-Semitism, which led him to the life mission of finding a homeland for the Jewish people. His efforts are central to the narrative of the video, illustrating the origins of the Zionist movement.

💡Anti-Semitism

Anti-Semitism refers to hostility or prejudice against Jewish people. In the script, it is depicted as a pervasive issue in France during Herzel's time and a driving force behind the development of Zionism. The Dreyfus affair is highlighted as a pivotal event that intensified Herzel's commitment to establishing a Jewish homeland.

💡Zionism

Zionism is a political movement that supports the re-establishment of a Jewish homeland in the historic territory of Israel. The script explains that Herzel founded this movement with the goal of creating a place where Jews could live without discrimination, which is a central theme of the video.

💡Diaspora

The term 'diaspora' refers to the scattering of a population across different countries or regions. In the context of the video, it describes the widespread dispersion of Jewish people across the globe following invasions and persecutions, which set the stage for the desire to return to a unified homeland.

💡World Congress of Zionists

The World Congress of Zionists was an assembly organized by Herzel to discuss and promote the Zionist cause. The script mentions the first congress held in Basel, Switzerland, which decided on creating a Jewish homeland in Palestine, a key event in the establishment of the Zionist movement.

💡Ottoman Empire

The Ottoman Empire was a vast state that once controlled much of Southeast Europe, Western Asia, and North Africa. The script describes Herzel's attempt to negotiate with the Ottoman Sultan for the colonization of Palestine, which was under Ottoman control at the time, illustrating the political complexities of establishing a Jewish homeland.

💡Haganah

Haganah was a Jewish paramilitary organization founded in 1920 to protect Jewish settlements in Palestine. The script highlights its role in providing security for the growing Jewish community and its significance in the early stages of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

💡Partition Plan

The Partition Plan refers to the proposal to divide Palestine into separate Jewish and Arab states. The script discusses the British proposal for partition, which was rejected by the Arab side but accepted by the Jewish side, leading to the 1948 establishment of the State of Israel.

💡Nakba

Nakba, meaning 'catastrophe' in Arabic, is used by Palestinians to describe the displacement and loss of homes that occurred during the establishment of Israel. The script mentions the quarter of a million people displaced, which underscores the human cost of the conflict.

💡Six-Day War

The Six-Day War was a conflict in 1967 between Israel and neighboring Arab states. The script notes Israel's swift victory, which resulted in the capture of additional territories, including the West Bank, Gaza, and the Sinai Peninsula, significantly altering the geopolitical landscape of the region.

💡Jewish Law of Return

The Jewish Law of Return is a law in Israel that grants the right to any Jew to immigrate and obtain citizenship. The script mentions this law as a factor contributing to demographic changes in Israel and the West Bank, complicating the issue of Palestinian statehood.

Highlights

Theodore Herzel's arrival in Paris in 1891 and his subsequent disillusionment with French society due to prevalent anti-Semitism.

Herzel's realization of the need for a Jewish homeland following the Dreyfus affair, which led to the birth of political Zionism.

The historical context of Jews as Israelites with roots in West Asia dating back to around 1000 BC.

The 'Golden Age' of ancient Israel under the rule of Kings David and Solomon and the construction of the first great Temple.

The series of invasions and the Roman crackdown that led to the Jewish diaspora across the world.

The rise of Zionism in the 19th and 20th centuries as a response to increasing anti-Semitism in Europe.

Herzal's attempt to organize the World Congress of Zionists and the decision to establish a Jewish homeland in Palestine.

The initial plan to colonize Palestine by paying off the Ottoman Empire's debt, which was rejected by the Sultan.

The first wave of Jewish migration to Palestine through individual land purchases from Ottoman landlords.

The establishment of Jewish settlements like Tel Aviv and the cultural and economic differences with Arab communities.

The role of external funding, particularly from American and European Jews, in facilitating land purchases in Palestine.

Britain's involvement in the Zionist cause and the Balfour Declaration of 1917 promising a Jewish homeland in Palestine.

The growth of the Haganah, the Jewish paramilitary organization, and its impact on Arab-Jewish relations in Palestine.

The British proposal for partitioning Palestine into separate Jewish and Arab states, which was rejected by Arab leadership.

The United Nations' plan for dividing Palestine and the subsequent declaration of Israel's independence in 1948.

The 1948 Arab-Israeli War and the territorial gains by Israel, including the West Bank, Gaza, and East Jerusalem.

The ongoing conflict and the contrasting positions of Israel and Palestine on statehood and territorial claims.

The 1967 Six-Day War and Israel's capture of additional territories, further complicating the Israeli-Palestinian issue.

The current stalemate in the conflict, with Israel's continued control over the West Bank and the blockade of Gaza.

The call for a political solution rather than a military one, emphasizing the need for dialogue and compromise.

The historical role of Europe in the conflict, from driving Jews out to supporting their settlement in Palestine.

Transcripts

[Music]

the year was 1891 an Austrian journalist

arrived in Paris he worked for a

newspaper in Vienna and Paris was his

new assignment his name was Theodore

Herzel France back then was the land of

the Revolution Herzel expected equality

and free thought well he was in for a

surprise because as it turned out

anti-Semitism was everywhere in France

as a Jew Herzel knew all about it in

fact it was a way of life in his

homeland but in post-revolution France

Herzel expected better and then came a

famous military Scandal the draus affair

a French Captain was accused of selling

military secrets to Germany he too was a

Jew the conviction later turned out to

be false but her Herzel had seen enough

there was a massive outpouring of

anti-Semitism Jews were being targeted

and abused this episode made Herzel

realized his life's Mission he needed to

find a country for Jews a place they

could call home a place where they could

live without discrimination the only

question was where Herzel settled on the

ancient homeland of Jews

Palestine thus he founded a new movement

for Jewish statehood what is often

called Zionism Herzel himself is called

the founder of political Zionism but he

died before Israel was

created let me tell you the story of

what happened in between also why Jews

left their ancient Homeland in the first

place and how they came in conflict with

the Arabs time for a

flashback we'll start with a simple

question who are Jews today we know them

as followers of a religion the religion

of Judaism but Jews never called

themselves that in ancient times they

called themselves Israelites not

Israelis

Israelites these people originated

around 1,000 BC and where did they live

in West Asia roughly the same place as

modern day Israel Jews Trace their

ancestry to three people Abraham his son

Isaac and his grandson Jacob they belied

God made a promise to Abraham the

promise of a Homeland in present day

Israel you may have heard Israeli

leaders talk about the promised land

well this is what they mean a land

promised to them by God and Jews did

live here many call it the Golden Age of

ancient Israel two kings ruled over the

Jews King David who founded Jerusalem

and King Solomon who built the first

great Temple now the obvious question is

this why did the Jews leave because of

multiple invasions first came the

Assyrian Empire then the Babylonians

then the Persian Empire then the Roman

Empire and finally the Ottomans each

round of invasion led to Jews leaving

their Homeland the peak was probably

during the Roman times Jews had tried to

revolt against Rome the response was a

brutal Crackdown Roman generals bed

Jerusalem they massacred the population

and destroyed the Jewish temple those

who survived

fled now our story makes a Time jump to

the 19th and 20th centuries the Jews

have fled their Homeland only a few

thousand remain in West Asia the rest

are now spread across countries and

continents we're talking about a large

diaspora Poland had around 3 million

Jews Russia 2 and a half million Britain

300,000 and Germany half a million as

anti-Semitism increased there Zionism

emerged the call for a separate Jewish

country the likes of Theodore Herzel led

the call he decided to organize a World

Congress of zionists herdel wanted

Munich to host it but when Jews there

rejected it he settled on basil in

Switzerland around 200 zionists attended

this Congress plus hundreds of onlookers

and they decided on creating a Jewish

homeland in Palestine just one problem

though Palestine was not just vacant

land it was home to tens of thousands of

Arab people so how would Jews make it

their

Homeland hudel and Company had a plan

back then Palestine was controlled by

the Ottoman Empire so in

1896 Herzel went to Constantinople

that's modern day stanbul and he stayed

there for 11 days but he could not meet

the sultan nonetheless he pushed on

Herzel relayed an offer to the ottoman

Sultan we will pay our foreign debt in

return let us colonize Palestine it was

basically an attempt to buy the land

Herzel thought it was a Godfather sort

of offer one the sultan could not refuse

but the ottoman Sultan did just that he

rejected it so colonization was a dead

end that's when zionists turned to to

plan B individual purchases Jews could

buy land from ottoman landlords in

Palestine one piece of land at a time

this was the first wave of migration

Jews bought the land and began farming

but to the Arab population one thing was

clear the Jews were not there to

assimilate they were there to rule

because after buying lands they fired

Arab workers and Farmers they also set

up their own towns and centers like Tel

Aviv in

19009 and these settlements did not look

like Arab once they looked out of place

to put it simply they looked European

most of this was funded from outside

Jews had done well for themselves in

America and Europe like the roel family

arguably the most powerful European

banking

Dynasty with their help Jews bought land

in Palestine still it was a trickle

things would pick up after the British

got involved remember this was before

the first world war so Britain was still

the superpower the Zionist asked London

for help the response was not quite as

enthusiastic Britain suggested

alternatives to Palestine like Uganda

and Argentina but the Zionist said no

they wanted their ancient Homeland in

West Asia then came the world war

suddenly Britain needed the support of

Jews so in 1917 they offered complete

support the British foreign secretary

Arthur James balur wrote a letter to the

roel family he said Jews would have a

homeland in Palestine he said Britain

was committed to it and after the war

they had the chance to do just that the

Ottomans were defeated Britain was given

control of Palestine by now Jewish

migration had picked up they were still

a minority in Palestine but they had

their strengths more organization more

money and more support an example of

this was the hagana it was a Jewish

paramilitary organization founded in

1920 its job to protect Jewish

settlements in Palestine the Arabs were

no match for it the hagana had better

intelligence also better training than

thanks to the British in the 1930s

Jewish migration picked up again the

reason was Nazi Germany this time Hitler

targeted and massacred Jews by the

thousands so those who could fled as the

Jewish population exploded Palestinians

revolted Jewish settlements and trains

were attacked so the British did what

they do best they said let's partition a

Jewish State for the Jews an Arab State

for the Palestinians but the Arab side

rejected this much like today their

leadership was divided so even when the

proposals were favorable they could not

capitalize and this back and forth

continued through the second world war

and soon Britain was fed up they were

financially and politically drained so

what did they do well they packed up and

left they told the United Nations it is

now your problem so the US came up with

a plan and listen to this

closely the Jewish state would get 55%

of Palestine including the neev

desert this state would have 500,000

Jews and 400,000 Arabs so a Jewish

majority the Arab state would get 44% of

this land and this state would have

around 10,000 Jews its areas would

include the West Bank in Gaza I know the

math does not add up 55 + 44 is 99 so

what happened to the remaining

1% well that was Jerusalem the city

would be controlled by an international

regime basically the United

Nations Palestinians rejected the plan

but the Jews said okay we are now

independent in 1948 they declared the

state of Israel and almost immediately

Arab countries attacked them namely five

of them Egypt Syria Jordan Iraq Lebanon

but Wars are not fought on numbers alone

the Arab leadership was divided each

country had a different objective also

their supply lines were stretched Israel

on the other hand was motivated they

were fighting for their existence and in

1949 they won the

war Israel now occupied 77% of

Palestine so after the war you had three

different parts the state of Israel the

West Bank controlled by Jordan and Gaza

controlled by Egypt and the

Palestinians it was a nightmare for them

a quarter of a million people were

displaced from their Homeland the Arabs

called it the

nakba the maps were not settled just yet

in 1967 another war broke out again Arab

States versus Israel this time Israel

won an even more comprehensive victory

in six days they captured three

important territories the West Bank Gaza

and the Sinai Peninsula and the Golan

Heights basically all of Palestine and

more later on Israel returned Sinai to

Egypt they also formalized the border

with Jordan but the question of

Palestine remains Israel still controls

the West Bank they often build

settlements and eat into Palestinian

land over in Gaza it's a full blockade

and right now a full-blown

War so where do both sides stand right

now Palestine wants statehood based on

three 1967 borders meaning the whole of

West Bank Gaza and East Jerusalem Israel

says it's not possible they have built

dozens of settlements inside West Bank

so Israel says the demography has

changed plus the country is always

expanding any Jew anywhere in the world

can become an Israeli citizen it's

called the Jewish law of

return so resolution looks far

away I know we call this a regional

conflict a West Asian conflict but it's

also an exported one Europe

discriminated against Jews the Ottomans

and Palestinians never did Europe drove

them out and Europe asked them to stay

in Palestine but when the plan looked

tough they bolted classic Colonial

attitude it's amply clear that there is

no military solution to this problem the

question of Palestine cannot be answered

with weapons it requires

Politics the only hope is that moderates

on both sides can chart a course and

remember statehood is not the end it's

just the beginning because after that

comes neighborhood the challenge of

building friendship between the two

[Music]

states